Monday, December 19, 2016

The Lost Great New York Aquarium - 1331 Broadway

A postcard depicted a crowd waiting to gain entrance to the exhibition.

Largely forgotten now, William Cameron Coup was among the foremost of American showmen--those brash impresarios who spoke in superlatives and offered audiences the biggest, the rarest and the most thrilling.  Born in 1837, he partnered with Dan Castello in 1869 and formed a "boat circus" which traveled the Great Lakes.  In 1870 they persuaded P. T. Barnum to merge his exhibition with their circus, resulting in "P. T. Barnum's Museum, Menagerie, Caravan and Hippodrome."

In 1876, Coup took on a new partner, Charles Reiche, for an ambitious and seemingly impossible project.  The latest European fad was public aquariums--essentially large museums of living fish.  The men acquired the northwest corner of Broadway and 35th Street where the Colosseum Theatre had recently been demolished.

Coup's two-story structure was faced in red brick and trimmed in limestone.  The unremarkable architecture of the exterior belied the engineering challenges inside.  The first floor contained the expansive exhibition hall and tanks, while below street level were the engine rooms and reservoirs.  The "naturalists' apartments" were on the second floor.

Maintaining environments for sea and fresh water animals required an intricate system of pumps, drains, and reservoirs of salt and fresh water.  The larger fish--ranging from six- to ten-feet in length--were kept in a darkened section lit by skylights.  The arrangement not only gave patrons a more naturalistic view and supposedly kept the fish from seeing the people, it reduced the amount of algae.

Frank Leslie's Sunday Magazine depicted the below-the-scenes engines and reservoirs.  (copyright expired)

Coup included an innovative marketing scheme in his building plans for the new venture.  "A very fine restaurant will be connected with the Aquarium, but it will differ from all others in the peculiarity that the fare it will offer will be only fish, which will be kept alive in a large tank where they may be viewed and selected by the hungry customer, who may enjoy the additional zest of catching his fish before eating it," wrote The New York Times.

In Barnum-like fashion, the showman knew that in order to draw visitors to his aquarium he needed something big, something sensational.  Nothing was bigger than a whale.  But keeping a confined whale alive in 1876 was problematic.  The Chicago Tribune held little optimism, saying the chances that a "whale will live long or not is somewhat doubtful.  His perils are five in number."  The newspaper listed the temperature of the water, the confinement, the "atmosphere of the aquarium," the purity of the water (2,400 gallons of sea water were pumped from the East River every 24 hours to refresh the tank), and keeping the mammal fed.  The article noted that a bushel and a half of live eels would be fed to the whale daily.  "As the animal is too epicurean in his tastes to like dead fish, each particular eel in his diurnal bushel and a half must be alive and squirming."

The tanks were constructed using English plate glass.  The half-inch thick sheets were considered the strongest of their type and able to withstand the pressure of hundreds of gallons of water.  But even this strong glass would be challenged by the immense whale tank--25-feet in diameter and about 6-1/2 feet deep.  The New York Times reported that it held "when full from 60,000 to 65,000 gallons."

To maintain suspense and mystery, the two whales which arrived during the first week of July 1876 were delivered under cover of night.  For two weeks the tank was only half-filled with water, just enough to keep the mammals alive.  Then, on June 24, the process of filling began.

Just before noon, when the water was about six inches from the top and orders were given to shut off the flow, the glass exploded.  The New York Times reported, "One of the workmen, who was in the act of turning off a waste-cock at the base of the wall where the break occurred, was struck with the fragments and thrown violently forward, receiving serious injuries."  Two other workmen were sent to the hospital and others were slightly hurt.  Both whales died.

A month later, The New York Times, in reporting that the Great New York Aquarium was nearly completed, advised, "A specially organized whaling expedition is now cruising off the coast of Labrador in search of whales to replace those that died at the aquarium recently, and Mr. Coup has offered $5,000 for the capture, alive, of the famous mammoth seal Ben Butler, which for years past has frequented the bay of San Francisco and the watering-places on the Pacific Coast."

The frustrating problem of the glass tanks continued.  On August 29 The New York Times reported, "At 7 o'clock yesterday morning, four more tanks bursted [sic] at the New-York Aquarium...These accidents are causing a delay in the opening of the Aquarium, but as a new glass of greater thickness will be used hereafter, it is hoped that no more delays will be caused."

That same day, in another section of the newspaper, a one-line article mentioned, "Three more young seals from the Bay of Biscay arrived yesterday, and are imprisoned in their respective tanks at the New-York Aquarium."

William Coup's replacement headliner arrived just in time for the Great New York Aquarium's opening.  On October 10, the New York Evening Post noted, "The expected whale has arrived at the Aquarium on Thirty-fifth street, after a week's journey from the St. Lawrence to Quebec by schooner, and thence to this city by rail.  He is white, frisky, and weighs 1,500 pounds."

The Great New York Aquarium opened the next day.  Frank Leslie's Sunday Magazine said it rivaled "in size and beauty any of its European contemporaries."  Coup's advertisement in The New York Herald called it, "the Finest Aquarium in the World!" and "A Place of Never-Ceasing Pleasure, Interest and Study."  The ad regaled: "The great living white whale devouring live eels, half a barrel per day! The thousand other divertissements! The Sharks! Sea Lion! Sturgeons! Seals! Sticklebacks! Sea Ravens! Winged Fishes of the Ocean!"  It reminded patrons, "while the visitors are examining the contents of the great iron and glass tanks Dodworth's popular orchestra discourses the most entertaining music."

Readers who snipped out that advertisement and sent it with 50 cents to W. C. Coup, would receive "a beautifully executed chromo-lithograph, size 30x40 inches, of the interior beauty and attractions."  It was a brilliant marketing ploy by Coup which not only helped him track the effectiveness of his advertising; but provided nearly free publicity when the posters were tacked up in homes and businesses.


For 50 cents this poster "in eleven colors, by Greyson, one of the best living chromo artists" could be had. Next to the whale tank can be seen the seal enclosure.  from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

Biologist Frank Butler worked for the Aquarium, explaining in Popular Science magazine in July 1899, "I supervised fish culture, and when not otherwise engaged made collections of fishes and invertebrates in Bermuda and in other parts."  Butler revealed how Coup managed to keep a whale alive in such confinement.  He didn't.

"We had many white whales at different times, for the management would keep whales penned up on the St. Lawrence River to replace those which died, and would never show more than two at a time, claiming that they were rare animals and only to be had at 'enormous' expense...It would never do to have the public know that they were common during the summer in the St. Lawrence, and when one was getting weak another would be sent down, and the public supposed that the same pair was on exhibition all the time."

Some visitors to the Aquarium felt they were being duped by the former circus proprietor.  Butler remembered overhearing a tourist couple's conversation.

"Oh, I'm so glad we came here, and can tell the folks that we've seen a real live whale!"

"Lucy, this city if full of all kinds of cheats, an' I don't believe that thing is alive more'n Methuselah is; it's some indy-rubber contraption with clock-work in it that makes it go round and puff in that way."

Sadly, the whales were not clock-work and their life expectancy once delivered to the Aquarium was about three months.


Well-dressed patrons, having paid their admission of 50 cents, strolled through the exhibits.  Frank Leslie's Sunday Magazine 1876 (copyright expired)

In addition to the whale tank, there were three floor pools devoted to seals and alligators, and about 150 various-sized tanks.  The Great New York Aquarium was an instant hit and was brought in about $200 per day--more than $4,500 in today's terms.  "But," according to The Green Book Magazine in July 1914, "before long the novelty wore off and receipts fell even lower than expenses."  Theater historian Thomas Allston Brown, in his 1903 A History of the New York Stage, said that receipts dropped "to five dollars on at least one occasion." 

Coup was a businessman, not a scientist, and he scrambled to draw audiences.  A small stage was set up and live entertainments were presented.  On September 8, 1877, The New York Times reported, "There will be given on the afternoon and evening of Sunday next at the Aquarium the first of a series of grand sacred concerts with an orchestra of 20 pieces.  These concerts will be continued every Sunday."

Dr. H. Dorner took over when Coup withdrew from the struggling enterprise.  The respected Great New York Aquarium suffered the humiliation of becoming a sideshow to a vaudeville theater.  On December 30, 1878, Oscar's performing horses appeared and juggler Charles Seeley made his American debut.  A pigeon show opened on February 4, 1879 and Little Red Riding Hood was staged for children on February 10.  Other attractions that year included Angie Schott, the "female magician," a tribe of Native Americans in April, and Professor Parker's trained dogs.

The Great New York Aquarium limped along for two years, before Dorner finally gave up.  Forest and Stream magazine reported on May 5, 1881, "On the 26th of April the New York Aquarium presented a sorrowful spectacle to those who had know it in its days of grandeur.  The great tanks were torn down, and piles of brick and mortar only remained to mark their location."  That day an auctioneer sold off the contents.

The panes of plate glass from the disassembled tanks, about 1,000 square feet in total, were sold, along with decorations and fixtures.  "Next he offered a lot of statuary of life and heroic size, including the Venus of Milo, the Dancing Fawn and the Laccoon, which were bought by Mr. George Busnell, of museum fame.  A small Octopus, which had once been in alcohol, a big pile of chairs, a stuffed Sloth and the table-tanks went to as many different bidders, the dime museums getting their share."

The magazine lamented the loss of a quality institution.  "Farewell 'The Great New York Aquarium.'...The greed of present gain permitted all kinds of shows to invade it, and the class which once supported it in good style left it."

Thomas Allston Brown wrote, "During the fall of 1882 the Aquarium was used as an Indian camp, and entertainments were given.  The building was soon torn down."  In fact, only part of the structure was demolished.  

The front, 35th Street section was remodeled by architect John Sexton and converted to the New Park Theatre, which opened on October 15, 1883.  Most of the equipment--chairs, scenery, stage machinery, for example--came from Booth's Theatre on 23rd Street, which had closed in 1881.

The New Park Theatre used only the front-most section of the Aquarium building.  from the collection of the New York Public Library.

In 1894, architects Rose & Stone remodeled the building again for actor and producer Charles E. Evans who renamed it the Herald Square Theatre.  Much of the interior details were brought in from the former Booth's Theatre on West 23rd Street.  
It opened with the premiere American production of George Bernard Shaw's Arms and the Man.  The theater was taken over by the Shubert Brothers in 1900, and by 1907, when actor Lew Fields operated it, the building had been electrified.


The facade glowed in electric lights in 1907.  The New York Times, April 9, 1907 (copyright expired)

After being rebuilt after a fire in 1911, the Herald Square Theatre opened as reportedly Manhattan's first silent motion picture house.  Then, in 1914, it was demolished for an office building that survives.


many thanks to Paul Anater for suggesting this post

Saturday, December 17, 2016

The R. J. Horner Factory -- Nos. 109-111 West 24th Street





In 1886 Robert J. Horner opened his new furniture store at Nos. 61-65 West 23rd Street.  The block between Fifth and Sixth Avenues would include several of the leading furniture dealers by the end of the century, including George C. Flint and Geiger & Braverman.  Horner, who targeted both middle- and upper-class buyers, launched an innovative technique to attract customers: he installed bedrooms, dining rooms and parlors in the upper floors where furniture could be displayed in room settings.

Despite the Financial Panic of 1893, Horner’s success continued.  In the fall of 1899 he purchased two old buildings on the north side of West 24th Street between Seventh and Eighth Avenues from “a Mr. Barber.”  On November 5 the Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide reported that “R. J. Horner & Co., the furniture firm…will built a 6-story storage house for their own use.”  The Guide pointed out that the firm had paid “$50,000 cash” for the 50-foot wide property at Nos. 109-111—in the neighborhood of $1.47 million in 2016.

R. J. Horner commissioned the architectural firm of George Edward Harding & Gooch (which often went simply by “Harding & Gooch”) to design its new building.  By the time that a contractor was hired six months later in May 1900, the plans had changed to seven stories.

The completed edifice smacked of a greatly expanded commercial stables building.  The extra-high two story base was clad in stone and featured wide truck bays.  Harding & Gooch used buff-colored brick on the upper floors, laid to resemble rusticated stone.  Here the five-story pilasters, the splayed lintels with their double keystones, and the stepped brackets of the sills were executed in brick.  Above it all a peaked pediment, similar to those routinely found on stables, completed the design.


Horner’s fleet of vehicles was stored and maintained on the lower section, while the upper floors were used both for storing the latest in furniture models and for manufacturing them.  During the day the building would have been a hive of activity as horse-drawn drays came and went, clattering along West 24th Street with their heavy deliveries of bedroom suites and dining room furniture.

There were about 48 workers in the building on Saturday, morning March 19, 1904; all but four of them working in the factory and warehouse portions on the upper floors.  Suddenly, at around 10:30 a “loud report” was heard on the second floor.  A container of benzine had exploded. 

American Cabinet Maker and Upholsterer reported “Within a few moments great tongues of flame were licking the inflammable material stored on every floor, roaring up the stairs and shafts, and dense smoke rose on every side.”  Most of the employees were able to rush down the stairs before being cut off by flames; but about a dozen fled by jumping to the roofs of neighboring buildings.  One, however, had to be rescued after being paralyzed with fear.  “A young woman who had become hysterical when she saw that the stairs were blazing was dropped about ten feet by rescuers.”

Although firefighters responded quickly, the water pressure from the hydrants was nearly useless.  The trade journal explained “It was fully twenty minutes after the arrival of the first engines before a stream of any size could be sent into the building, and even then the pressure was not great enough to be effective.”

The water shortage resulted in four fire alarms.  The situation was compounded when two responding companies, Engines No. 18 and No. 72, collided at Sixth Avenue and 12th Street.  “There was a terrific shock, and all the horses were thrown.  Both of the poles of No. 18 snapped short, one of them piercing one of the horses of No. 72 and cutting him so that he had to be killed.”  Only Engine 72 could continue on to fight the blaze.

For two hours traffic on Sixth Avenue was held up and crowds of female shoppers—estimated in the thousands--poured from the emporiums on “The Ladies’ Mile” south of 23rd Street to witness the firefight.   American Cabinet Maker reported “The police had some difficulty in handling the crowds and in keeping them back until five mounted men were obtained from Fifth avenue.  Those who would pay no attention to the policemen afoot promptly retreated before the horses and kept at proper distance.”

The Police Department gained an important lesson in crowd control that day.  “It was the first time that mounted police were used at a fire in the heart of the city, and they demonstrated their usefulness.”

Although the upper floors were devastated, Harding & Gooch’s “fireproof” structure withstood the conflagration.  The trade journal announced “The upper portion of the building was gutted, but the structure proved most substantial, and remained almost intact from the outside aspect.”

Robert J. Horner estimated the damage at $50,000.  The building was repaired and operations continued until 1912.  That year, in February, the firm moved to No. 22 West 36th Street.  Robert J. Horner, Sr. explained to the Record & Guide that because of “the general tendency of all business to move farther uptown on account of the greater transportation facilities the firm decided upon the move.”

Furniture like this elaborately-carved sideboard was constructed and stored in the 24th Street building.  New-York Tribune, December 12, 1909 (copyright expired)
The former furniture warehouse and factory was taken over by a most unexpected tenant:  The Boyertown Chapel.  For six years it would be the scene of funerals and wakes amid the factories that had cropped up along the block.

On March 2, 1918 R. J. Horner & Co. leased the entire building to the Kimberly & Clark Co.  The Wisconsin paper manufacturers would store its goods here for years, getting a new landlord when the Robert J. Horner estate sold the building to Emil A. Stumpf on August 6, 1922.  The buyer made a quick profit when he resold it two months later to Clara P. Trunk for $105,000.

In 1945 Robert L Marx took the top three floors for his pipe manufacturing factory.  A printing firm was on the 4th floor and the lower three floors were used as storage.  The following year, with soldiers returning home from war, Marx became active in promoting the hiring of veterans.  He told a reporter “With the boys coming back today there is just as big a job to do as ever, and something should be done to bring attention to those companies that are making the real effort to give the veteran a job and make him a functioning part of our national economy.”

His proposal to “bring attention” to firms that hired veterans was a special flag.  His idea went all the way to the War Department where a design was approved by Secretary of War Robert P. Patterson.  The flag was unveiled in Robert Marx’s office in the 24th Street building on June 7, 1946, with members of the American Veterans Committee and the United States Employment Service present.

Joseph B. O’Connor, Regional Director of the United States Employment Service commended Marx’s idea.  The New York Times reported “Foreseeing support of the flag both on a local and national scale by his organization, Mr. O’Connell added: ‘Something like this is needed to stir up employers.  Also it would act as an incentive for them to do more than they are doing at the present time.’”

At mid century the ground floor was converted to the showroom of the Montauk Rug & Carpet company.  The upper floors were home to firms like the Continental Corp., manufacturers of wooden novelties; and the Frances Yarn Company.


Little has changed to the upper floors of the handsome warehouse building.  An ill-advised coat of chocolate-colored paint covers the limestone base; but the Montauk Rug & Carpet showroom still calls the ground floor home after more than half a century.  

photographs by the author

Friday, December 16, 2016

The Robt. L. Livingston Mansion - No. 12 East 96th Street

A sidewalk shed testifies to interior work in late 2016.


Robert Linlithgow Livingston’s family was among the oldest and most respected in New York.  His first ancestor in America, Robert Livingston the Elder, arrived in Albany in 1674.  The family estate, Livingston Manor along the Hudson River, was expanded until it was larger than the state of Rhode Island.

In 1892, at the age of 18, Livingston entered the banking firm of Kountze Brothers as a clerk.  His position there was bolstered when he married Helen Kountze in Grace Church on December 12, 1902.   In January 1904 he was admitted as a general partner.  Tragically, just one month later Helen died.

The young widower moved into the mansion of his aunt, the Countess Henri de Longier-Villars at No. 311 Fifth Avenue.  Following the expected period of mourning, he resumed the life of a bachelor millionaire.  On one trip to Europe very old money would meet the very new.

Massive fortunes from silver, gold and copper were being made in the Far West.  The wives and daughters of these new millionaires struggled for acceptance by East Coast socialites who most often viewed them as nouveau riche and uncultured.  And so the wife of Dennis Sheedy, Director of the International Smelting Company in Denver, had their two daughters, Marie and Florence, educated in a convent school and took them on extensive trips to Europe.

It was on one such trip and Robert L. Livingston met Marie Sheedy, known by newspaper readers as “the richest girl in Denver.”  A romance bloomed and Marie’s mother seems to have grasped the opportunity.  A telegram to The New York Times from Denver in 1911 noted “Although the Sheedy home is in Denver, the family have spent a great part of the Winter season at the Plaza, in New York, during the past few years.”

After Robert and Marie were “seen frequently” at social affairs and despite the difference in their ages (Livingston was now 34 and Marie was “in her early twenties”), their engagement was announced in December 1910.  The Times mentioned that she “is popular among the younger set in New York” and “attended nearly all of the dances and entertainments given by the younger society girls in New York.”

The couple was married in the Sheedy mansion in Denver on February 15, 1911; a local newspaper calling it “one of the most fashionable ever held in Denver.”  The article noted “The wedding gifts were magnificent, including a residence in New York and a rope of pearls to the bride from her father, who is a mining man.”

Livingston’s remarriage seems to have caused tensions at Kountze Brothers, and he resigned upon his return from the honeymoon.  In 1912 he became general partner in the newly-organized brokerage house of Adams, Livingston and Davis.

The Manhattan house presented by Dennis Sheedy was a vintage brownstone at No. 41 East 75th Street.  But by the spring of 1916 the couple anticipated a modern home.  On May 27 that year the Record & Guide noted that Livingston had purchased property on the south side of East 96th Street, near Central Park, “and contemplates the erection of a handsome five-story residence.”

Seven months later, in December 1916, Odgen Codman, Jr. filed plans for the $60,000 mansion.  The architect and designer had completed his own Parisian-styled mansion almost directly across the street, at No. 7 East 96th Street, in 1913.  His vision for the block was an enclave of picturesque French residences; and when Livingston purchased his lots, the Codman-designed mansion of Lucy Dahlgren was just being completed at No. 15.   The project led the Record & Guide to note “the addition of Robert L. Livingston to the 96th street colony,” on September 30, 1916.

Delicate floral festoons drape from bracket to keystone to bracket along the ground floor.
Completed in 1917 the limestone-clad Beaux Arts-style house at No. 12 East 96th Street sat on a rusticated granite base.  The expected French-style mansard roof brought the 96th Street elevation to five full floors.  But to the rear, unseen from the street, the mansion was seven stories high.

The Livingston mansion was completed just in time for an addition to the family.  In October 1917 newspapers made note that the Livingstons had closed “The Ledges,” their summer estate in Magnolia, Massachusetts and were at 96th Street for the winter.   A few weeks later, on November 19, The Sun reported that the couple “are receiving congratulations on the birth of a daughter yesterday at their home, 12 East Ninety-sixth street.  It is their third daughter.”


By 1921 the Livingstons had purchased a new summer estate, Balleylock, in Beverley Farms, Massachusetts.  The family continued to expand.  On May 16 that year The New York Herald reported that the Livingstons “are receiving congratulations on the birth of a son on Saturday evening.  The boy, who will be named after his father, is the seventh descendant in direct line from Robert Livingston of Livingston Manor.”

Exactly one week later The New York Times reported “Robert L. Livingston of 12 East Ninety-sixth Street has taken his three elder children to Balleylock.”   There the estate staff would care for the girls while the dutiful Robert rushed back to Marie.  “Mr. Livingston will return, but, with Mrs. Livingston and their baby, now a week old, he will rejoin the other children late in June.”

In the spring of 1925 Robert L. Livingston caught a cold which progressed to pneumonia.  He died in the 96th Street mansion on Sunday morning, April 12, at the age of 49.  Marie lived on in the house with the children; however she spent less time here.

On December 3, 1930 The Times reported that Marie, who had been in Pau, France for about a year, “will return here next Summer and go to Callender House, her place in Bar Harbor.  She will occupy her old home at 12 East Ninety-sixth Street next Winter, when she will introduce her daughter [Denise] to society.”

By now, however, Ogden Codman, Jr.’s exclusive French enclave was all but a memory.  Only three private homes survived on a street of modern apartment buildings.  In 1934 the family of Samuel Friedman was occupying the Livingston mansion.  They were still here in December that year when the engagement of daughter Eleanor to Robert Strasser was announced.

But the end of the line for No. 12 as a grand residence was near.  In 1939 it was sold and converted for us by a succession of upscale private schools.  The Emerson School was in the building in the last half of the century.  The exclusive school accepted only 55 students, ages three through five.  The 1971 tuition for five-year olds (about $7,000 in 2016) required an additional $225 for lunch.  The school promised the parents of potential students a “rich reading readiness” program, including lessons in French.

By 1983 the former mansion was home to the Carnegie Hill School; and in 1988 was converted to the All Children’s House, an institution for homeless children.  It was a short-lived experiment and by the turn of the century La Scuola d’Italia “G. Marconi” was using the house—offering bilingual instruction from nursery school through high school age.

In 2015 the school put the property on the market for $21,750,000.  The realtor’s listing noted “The townhouse contains stunning original details, including intricate moldings, multiple fireplaces, a grand staircase, a wood-paneled ballroom, and a wrought-iron balcony.”


Neighbors and preservationists will wait to find out the fate of the remarkably-surviving mansion.

photographs by the author

Thursday, December 15, 2016

The Oliver H. Payne Carriage House - No. 126 East 66th St


In 1889 architect Charles C. Haight set to work on two mansions designed to appear as one, at the northern corner of Fifth Avenue and East 66th Street.  The hulking residence for millionaire Henry O. Havemeyer would sit at the corner and face sideways, taking the address No. 1 East 66th Street.  Its matching, smaller brother, at No. 852 Fifth Avenue would become home to bachelor Oliver Hazard Payne.

Havemeyer's mansion faced 66th Street.  Payne's residence (to the left in this photo), looking much like simply another turret, faced Fifth Avenue.  photo by  Byron Company, from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York http://collections.mcny.org/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&VBID=24UAYWO9LAKQ&SMLS=1&RW=1280&RH=894

Once in their grand homes, the two moguls addressed another need, their carriage houses.  In June 1895 Havemeyer purchased the three-story house at No. 134 East 66th Street, between Park and Lexington Avenues, from Edgar Davidson (the address would later be renumbered No. 126).  It completed a plot necessary for two lavish private stables--one for himself and the other for Payne.

Havemeyer was obviously in charge of the project.  He owned the land and it would appear he chose the architects, S. E. Gage and W. J. Wallace.  Wallace was his cousin.  The two stables, designed to appear as a unit, were completed in February 1896.  The behind-the-scenes dealings between the two neighbors were obvious when Havemeyer transferred title to the "three story brick stable" on February 26.  The price listed was "nominal."

The architects had created harmonious Romanesque Revival structures of light-colored Roman brick, trimmed in brownstone and terra cotta.  Like his mansion, Payne's carriage house was a smaller version of Havemeyer's.  Only about half as wide at 28 feet, it was nevertheless spacious and functional.

Munsey's Magazine, May 1900 (copyright expired)

In 1900 Munsey's Magazine described the interior as having "tiles and polished wood and wrought metal of modern magnificence," and depicted its "church-like solemnity, where ten or a dozen traps may repose at once in dignity and comfort; the harness cupboards with plate glass doors, and the velvet lined cases for the shining bits and buckles."

Upstairs were the living quarters for Payne's stable staff.  "The coachmen and grooms are no less well treated than the aristocratic beasts they serve, for their quarters overhead abound in hard wood, enameled tubs, shower baths, and all the comforts of modern heating, ventilation, and plumbing."

Two years later, in an article about Manhattan's lavish private carriage houses being outfitted with modern "sanitary science," Engineering Review mentioned "the private stables of New York's horse-loving millionaires have become celebrated by reason of the addition of such well-known stables as those of H. O. Havemeyer and Colonel Oliver H. Payne at 134 and 136 East Sixty-sixth street."

Rounded bricks soften the corners, while tapered bricks create a sunburst effect over the arched opening.

Born in Cleveland, Ohio on July 21, 1839, Payne was named after Oliver Hazard Perry, a relative of his mother, Mary Perry.  He earned his title Colonel during the Civil War in the 124th Ohio Infantry.  Following the war, he invested in iron and oil refining.  When Standard Oil acquired his interests around 1868, he became the treasurer of that firm.  He assisted in the formation of U. S. Steel and organized the American Tobacco Trust.  By the time he moved his horses and fleet of vehicles into the 66th Street structure he was considered among the 100 wealthiest men in the United States.

The mothers of Manhattan's debutantes may have had high hopes to snag Manhattan's most eligible bachelor, but marriage was not in Payne's future.  And while he enjoyed his massive fortune, building the world class steam yacht Aphrodite in 1898, for instance, he was lavishly generous to his family.

He gave his sister in Ohio "a beautiful home in the outskirts of Cleveland, besides providing for the education of her children," according to The Sun, and he built a Fifth Avenue mansion for his other sister, Mrs. William C. Whitney.   When her son, Payne Whitney, was married to Helen Hay in February 1902, he presented the couple with a stunning wedding present--a marble mansion at No. 972 Fifth Avenue designed by McKim, Mead & White. 

photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York
Oliver H. Payne's name appeared in newspapers in 1914 when the list of Americans earning more than $1 million per year was made public.  That amount would translate to about 25 times that much today.  His philanthropies were well-known, although he "would never discuss it," according to The Sun.  In 1913 he gave $4,350,000 to Cornell University, where he had already established its medical school.  His gifts to the university would top $8 million in his lifetime.

The bachelor millionaire died in his Fifth Avenue mansion on June 27, 1917 at the age of 78.  His holdings in the Standard Oil Company alone were estimated at the time at a staggering $90 million.  His will left large gifts to institutions like the New York Public Library, the Lakeside Hospital in Cleveland and Dale University, each of which received $1 million.   The Metropolitan Museum of Art received gifts, including a priceless late Gothic tapestry.  The Sun reported that it "has the exceptional interest of being signed by Jan Van Room, also called Jan Van Brussel, who was painter to Margaret of Savoy, Regent of the Netherlands (1507-1530)."

Payne Whitney's share of the estate was significant.  He received all of his uncle's "chattels, furniture, pictures, silver, china books, and personal effects, all his interests in social, shooting or fishing clubs, as well as his yacht and the country place called 'Greenwood Plantation" in Thomasville, Ga., and all other real estate except the place in Ulster county," according to The Sun on July 7, 1917.  Among "all other real estate" was the carriage house on East 66th Street.

By 1920 Payne Whitney's fleet of vehicles had a different type of horse power than his uncle's.  Cabriolets and broughams had been replaced by touring cars and limousines.  Louis Weiniger was Whitney's chauffeur and he lived upstairs in the former carriage house.  On September 16, 1920 he drove his employer to Wall Street.

Domestic terrorism had gripped Manhattan for two decades.  In the early years of the 20th century it was anarchist groups like the Black Hand which were responsible for bombings and murders.  Now communist agitators plotted deadly attacks.  Just before noon that day, Louis Weiniger was parked in an unfortunate spot.

In the equivalent of today's car bombings, a horse-drawn wagon containing 1,000 pounds of dynamite and 500 pounds of iron sash weights and other shrapnel pulled up to the J. P. Morgan building at No. 23 Wall Street.  The subsequent blast was fearsome, blowing out the glass panes of office buildings for blocks. There were 30 immediate fatalities and hundreds of injured. Six more would subsequently die of wounds.

Other drivers were not as fortunate as Louis Weiniger.  photo from the collection of the Library of Congress
Payne Whitney's chauffeur was among the luckier victims.  He was treated for scalp wounds received from flying debris.

When Whitney died on May 25, 1927, he left what The New York Times declared "The largest estate ever appraised in this country"--$178.893,655, or about $2.5 billion today.  Much of his wealth was held in stocks.  The newspaper noted that "This enormous volume of stocks...grew from a fund of many millions set aside some years ago for Mr. Whitney and others by Mr. Whitney's uncle, the late Colonel Oliver H. Payne."

At the time of his death, the carriage house was valued at $80,000.  It passed to Whitney's son, John Hay Whitney.   Almost unique among personal stables of the 19th century, No. 126 East 66th Street continued to be used as a private garage.  In 1969 John Hay Whitney housed his nine vehicles here.  That year the AIA Guide to New York City noted "Rarely does even consciously monumental architecture achieve such power."

Somewhat sadly, by the time the editors Norval White and Elliot Willensky made the comment, the Havemeyer carriage house had been demolished, leaving the Payne stable looking a bit off center and squashed. 

Whitney died in 1982.  Known familiarly as Jock, his remarkable and varied career included U. S. Ambassador to the United Kingdom, publisher of the New York Herald Tribune, president of the Museum of Modern Art, and chairman of the board of Selznick International Pictures.  He funded half of the production costs of Gone with the Wind, and for the 1940 film Rebecca.

The Payne carriage house continues its original purpose today--a garage on the ground floor and a single residence above.  While it could stand a facade cleaning, its continuous use by a single family has resulted in its nearly perfect preservation.

photographs by the author

Wednesday, December 14, 2016

The 1857 Nos. 261-267 Canal Street



On Tuesday, October 23, 1855 Sophie Gougenheim, the eldest daughter of A. M. Gougenheim, was married to Mario Manzocchi of Naples in the Roman Catholic Church of St. Vincent de Paul.  It would be among the last services held in the church, whose buildings engulfed the Canal Street blockfront between Lafayette Street and Broadway.


Daniel Devlin had big plans for the sprawling factory and store building he envisioned at Nos. 261-267 Canal Street that year.  He purchased the properties from the Church and began a two-year construction project.   Completed in 1857, the five-story Italianate-style building was faced in gleaming white marble above an elegant cast iron base.  The elegant structure held its own among the lavish retail palaces of the day.  The store fronts included fluted Corinthian columns with elaborate capitals.  Above, the architrave openings were decorated with triangular pediments, carved lentils and diminutive sill brackets.  Quoins ran up the sides.

The ground floor was divided into four individual retail stores.  Edward A. Nichols ran his silk goods shop from No. 263 in 1866.  He leased a back room of the second floor "in which goods are store by him before their examination and assortment," according to The New York Times.

The front office on that floor was occupied by an attorney's office, where William Trues worked as an office boy.  Just as one of Nichols's clerks, LeGrand W. Ketchum, reached the top of the stairs on Thursday, November 8, he saw William Trues leaving the storeroom, "with something apparently under his coat."

Alerted, Ketchum followed the boy, then found a policeman and had him arrested.  Trues had two bundles of silk valued at $165 under his coat--a heist worth more than $2,500 today.  He confessed to having stolen at least 10 other pieces of silk; but offered a credible excuse--at least in part.

Trues had taken his first stolen silk to a tailor, Wolff Holzmann, at No. 124 Walker Street.  Holzmann purchased the silk, then threatened to have the boy arrested if he did not continue to supply him with goods.  The felonious tailor soon joined Trues in jail, and both were held on $1,000 bail.

Another tenant of a store and upper floor space was Andrews, Sanford & Smith, who were in the building by 1870.  The firm manufactured ladies' hats upstairs, and ran its retail operation selling dry goods at street level.  That year it advertised for a "first-class milliner" to work in its shop.

The high-end stature of the store was evidenced following a break-in on December 25, 1870.  On January 7, 1871 Andrews, Sanford & Smith placed an advertisement in The New York Herald:  "Our store, 261 and 263 Canal street, was robbed on Christmas night of Velvets, Satins, Silks, black Ribbons, white and black Thread, Lace, &c.  The above reward will be paid for the recovery of the goods, or in proportion to what is found, and no questions asked."  That reward was a stunning $1,500, around $30,000 in 2016 dollars.

Daniel Devlin died in February 1868.  A clause in his will forbid the sale of any of his real estate before five years of his death; and then only "at public auction."  The heirs apparently waited impatiently for the deadline, and on January 10, 1872 the announcement of the forthcoming auction was announced.

Executors Henry F. Spaulding and Jeremiah Devlin noted "The stores were built by the late Daniel Devlin and are constructed in the most thorough and substantial manner, have modern improvements and conveniences and are capable of being sub-divided so as to accommodate a number of tenants."  They noted that the current annual rental income was $72,000.

S. N. Robbins operated his carpet store here in the early 1870s.  He was described by The New York Herald as "a gentleman of culture and refinement, and was highly esteemed by a large circle of business as well as personal friends."

On July 26, 1875 he left the store at around 3:00, as was normal.  But he never returned to the high-end Grand Central Hotel where he lived with his wife and two sons.  Mrs. Robbins and their youngest son were "in the country," as was the case with most moneyed families in the summer months.

Twelve hours later, at 3:00 in the morning, a policeman in Central Park near 102nd Street heard a gunshot.  The following day The New York Herald reported "on search [he] found Mr. Robbins lying in a cluster of bushes, dead.  He still held the fatal weapon in his right hand."

The Herald noted that for some time he had complained of  being "very ill," and added "He is supposed to have been suffering from a temporary aberration of mind."

Another upscale manufacturer in the building at the time was maker of ladies' and children's underwear, Bernard. King, on the third floor.  The quality of the firm's garments necessitated only the most qualified workers.  On February 1, 1877 it advertised for "A first class designer who has held the leading position with first class suit houses and is a guaranteed cutter and fitter."

Another carpet manufacturer, Eugene S. Higgins not only had his store here in 1878, he now owned the building.  The store at No. 261 was home to B. L. Coffin's "notions and white goods" business; and the store at 263 and 265 held the Hill Brothers' millinery and straw goods store.  On the second and fourth floors were Cohn, Ball & Co., makers of boys' and children's clothing.  Sharing the third floor with Bernard King was R. Elias & Co., shirt manufacturers, and the fifth and sixth floors at Nos. 261 and 263 were leased to the Lingerie Manufacturing Company.

Other tenants included William O. Headley & Sons, manufacturers of trunks, whose store was at No. 267; and Thomas Chatterton & Co., clothing dealers.

Just after 4:30 on the morning of March 26, 1878 fire broke out in B. L. Coffin's store.  The fire burned and spread for some time, finally reaching the upper floors where the flames were noticed.  By the time firefighters arrived, the structure was an inferno.  At one point Fire Chief Bates feared "the entire block would fall a prey to the flames," as reported by The Times.  Firefighters battled the fire until noon before finally extinguishing it.

The 1872 boast that the floors could be sub-divided was now blamed in part for the disaster.  Investigators said "Subsequently it was altered to suit the convenience of a number of tenants and lath and plaster partitions were erected, dividing the different floors."  The cheap materials added to the fuel.

The damaged was severe.  "The interior of the building above the store floors is destroyed and the roof is entirely gone.  A portion of the rear wall has fallen...The front and side walls are almost intact."  Extensive repairs were made and it was most likely at this time that the sixth floor was added.

On New Year's Day, 1892 the Canal Street building would become home to its most visible tenant, well-known carriage makers Studebaker Bros. Manufacturing Co.  The firm made and sold a dizzying variety of vehicles, as evidenced in an advertisement in The Sun later that year, on October 9.  It listed "High Grade Carriages, victorias, broughams, wagonettes, phaetons, surreys, buggies, runabouts, and all varieties of carts and traps.  Farm Wagons, express wagons, all kinds of business wagons."

Studebaker Bros. were in the central portion of the building--Nos. 263 and 265.  Their depiction of the structure, therefore, narrowed it.  Studebaker Bros. Catalogue 1892

In an age when dirt streets produced clouds of dust which entered windows and frustrated Victorian housewives, the ad noted "We invite special attention to our Street Sprinkler with new patented device for distributing water" and "Our 'Little Gem' lawn sprinkler excels anything in its line."

On October 8, 1894 The New York Times printed an article headlined "New from Track, Stable, and Salesroom."  In what was most likely a paid-for plug, the article included "Fancy driving traps of excellent quality, stylish design, and moderate prices, are a feature of the stock of Studebaker at 265 Canal Street."

Among the scores of vehicles available in 1892 were the buggy above and the stylish Spider Phaeton.  Studebaker Bros. Catalogue 1892

At the turn of the century, by August 1900, Studebaker had relocated a few blocks north to Broadway and Prince Streets.   The building now housed firms like the J. G. Shaw Blank Book Co., and D. Galewski & Co. which took two floors, comprising 20,000 square feet, in 1916.

The Sun, March 21, 1909

D. Galewski & Co. had been located at Nos. 321-323 Broadway for 16 years, manufacturing traveling bags and suitcases.  Headed by Sigmund Galewski, it would remain here into the 1920s.

In 1917 Philadelphia-based paper manufacturer Whiting-Patterson Company leased the entire building from Eugene Higgins.  The Sun reported "The lessees will occupy a large portion of the space and sublease some of the upper floors.  Extensive alterations will be made to the building."


D Galeswki & Co. was still here in 1922 when another leather bag manufacturer, Samuel Bercowitz, tried to pull a fast one.  On October 7 Bercowitz asked Sigmund Galewski to cash a $900 note for him; which Galewski kindly did.  Later, however, he realized that the Bercowitz had carefully altered the numeral 1 on the note, changing $100 to $900.  Bercowitz landed in jail charged with grand larceny.

Two months later the Shoe and Leather Reporter revealed that Bercowitz's $15,000 bail had been reduced to $10,000.  The lowered amount was due to his sudden remorse.  The journal said Bercowitz's lawyer "told the court his client desire to be released from jail in order to make restitution."

The 1930s saw several of the tenants hit hard by the Great Depresion.  In 1937 Jovanis Sardelis declared bankruptcy, and in 1939 both Tri-Boro Engraving Co. and the Pioneer Metal Goods Mfg. Co went under.

The ensuing decades would see a wide variety of businesses in the building, including General Die & Stamping Corp. and Stransky Products Corp. in the 1940s; and Rosenblum in the early 1950s, whose "Magnetsik" was guaranteed to "cement everything, wood, celluloid, glass, metals, china, bakelite, marble, plastic."  For fifteen cents customers could try a sample.

Perhaps as devastating as the Great Depression was the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks.  There were ten apparel factories in the building.  With streets shut down for months and delivery trucks unable to get to the site, four of the garment companies had closed within a year.


Eventually, of course, things returned to normal on Canal Street.  Recently a far-reaching restoration of the facade was initiated, headed by the architectural firm CTS Group.  The sorely abused ground floor has been rescued.  And other than the 20th century fire escape (which apparently is soon to come down), the remarkable marble building is much intact.

photographs by the author