Schwartz & Gross's 1929 175 East 79th Street

 

On April 3, 1928, the architectural firm of Schwartz & Gross filed plans for "a fifteen-story and pent-house apartment building" at 171 through 175 East 79th Street.  The New York Sun reported, "The building will have four apartments on each floor in three-room and bath and six-room and three-bath suites."  The New York Times added that the structure would be erected by the Tishman Realty and Construction Company, Inc.

Construction was completed in 1929 at a cost of $480,000--or about $9 million in 2026 terms.  Faced in rough-faced brick, the neo-Renaissance-style structure was trimmed in brownstone and terra cotta.  The entrance and the pilasters of the paired third-floor windows were decorated with intricate Renaissance-style designs.  The first- and second-floor openings were framed by brownstone quoins (painted white today).  Schwartz & Gross's treatment of the first floor voussoirs was highly unusual--alternating from brick to brownstone.

The edifice rose as a sheer cliff, relieved by terra cotta bandcourses; those below the fourth and sixteenth floors supported by arched, brick corbel tables.  Vast multi-paned casements flooded the apartments with natural light.

At least one critic had a slight problem with the new building.  On March 9, 1929, Marcia Clarke Davenport wrote in The New Yorker:

The Tishman organization, whose architects are Schwartz & Gross, has put up a good building at 175 East Seventy-ninth Street. It includes all the features I have always admired in this company’s work, but—every bedroom in the house must be reached through a living-room or a dining-room. That there has been a pardonable desire to save space is obvious; nevertheless, the result is unfortunate. This isn’t a hotel or a pied-a-terre sort of place; it’s a house people are meant to live in, as is proved by the excellent kitchens and pantries, comfortable dining-rooms, the ample baths and closets, the wood-burning fireplaces, the maids’ rooms and baths, and the well-handled ventilation and lighting.

Among the initial tenants were Charles H. Adams and his wife, the former Harriet Beachman.  The couple had an adult son, Charles Jr.  Harriet escaped the cold of their first winter here by traveling to Florida with friends, Edward E. Wright and his wife.  They headed home, leaving Florida on March 2, 1930 in the Wright's touring car, which was driven by their chauffeur.  About 16 miles south of Lyons, Georgia, B. Collins attempted to go around a parked Standard Oil Company truck.  He drove head-on into the Wright's vehicle "with a terrific impact," according to The International Blue Printer.  Beatrice and Mrs. Wright were killed.

On October 26, 1930, Alfred N. Wheeler Jr. signed a lease "for a long term of years," as reported by the New York Evening Post.  He was the son of prominent Connecticut jurist Alfred N. Wheeler.  And he had a very good reason to be looking for a new apartment.  

Five days later, The New York Times reported, "Miss Romaine Bristow...will be married to Alfred N. Wheeler Jr., of this city, son of Alfred N. Wheeler of New Haven, Conn., on Nov. 25 in the Church of the Resurrection."  Romaine was well-known in society.  The newspaper noted that she was the granddaughter of Columbus C. Baldwin, "who was identified for many years with New York and Newport [society]."

The ceremony was covered by society columns in newspapers in several states.  On October 31, the New York Evening Post noted, "Mr. Wheeler and his bride will live at 175 East Seventy-ninth Street when they return from their wedding trip."

Alfred Wheeler wore tails and silk top hat to his wedding.  The New York Times, November 26, 1930

Morton E. Van Raalte and his wife, the former Marion Rau, also signed a lease in 1930.  Born in 1898, Van Raalte was the son of wealthy manufacturer Emanuel Van Raalte and a 1920 graduate of Columbia College.  When they moved into 175 East 79th Street, he was affiliated with his father's firm, the Van Raalte Company.

Shortly after the couple moved in, Emanuel Van Raalte died, leaving an estate of $1,355,674, according to The New York Times.  The figure would translate about $26 million today.  The newspaper said that the bulk of the estate would be divided equally among Morton and his three siblings.  Morton and Marion Van Raalte's country home was in Lawrence, Long Island.

Already living here were Rene de Albornoz Carrillo and his son Rene Jr.  Carrillo was, according to The New York Times, a "member of an old Spanish family."  Twice married and twice divorced, the elder Carrillo was the head of the importing and interior decorating firm, R. Carrillo & Co., Inc.  His daughter was married in 1924, and Rene Jr. graduated from Princeton University in 1930 and joined his father's business.

The 55-year-old Carrillo suffered from "high-blood pressure and a nervous disorder," according to the New York Evening Post.  On the evening of December 9, 1931 the father and son played cards.  During the game, the elder Carrillo "discussed business affairs with his son," reported The New York Times, and mentioned that he wanted to bring an acquaintance into the business.  He told his son that he wanted to make his vision of the company clear, "in case I die."

The next morning, Rene Jr. arose at around 9:00.  He found his father, "dressed only in his pajamas...slumped down in a chair in his bedroom with a bullet wound in the right temple."

A note left on the bureau read:

Dear Rene:

I hate to do this, but I cannot stand this strain any longer.  Would put N. W. in the business and carry out our plan of yesterday.  Tell him to remember the letter I spoke to him about.  It's in the safe.  Good-bye to you and all that I care for.  It's hard to leave you all.

                                                            Love, Father

On 16, October 1936, The New York Times reported, "Don Ross and his wife, Jane Froman, both of stage and screen, have leased a penthouse at 175 East Seventy-ninth Street."  Born in 1907, Jane Froman studied voice at the Cincinnati Conservatory of Music until 1930.  She made her national debut on radio in 1929, the year she met vaudeville performer Donald McKaig Ross.  They were married in 1933 and moved to New York City that year.

Don Ross and Jane Froman in the early 1940s.  from the collection of the Jane Froman Papers

Jane joined the Ziegfeld Follies where she became friends with Fannie Brice.  Reportedly, when composer and producer Billy Rose was asked to name the top ten female singers, he replied, "Jane Froman and nine others."  By 1934, Jane was the "number-one female singer on the radio," according to a nationwide poll.

When the couple moved in, Jane had completed two films, the 1933 Kissing Time and the 1935 Stars Over Broadway.  They established their own radio program in July 1937.

Unfortunately, while Froman's career soared, Ross's did not.  They were divorced in 1948, five years after Froman was severely injured in an airplane crash on February 22, 1943 as she was traveling to entertain troops.

Resident Lewis Osborn was described by The New York Times as a "well-known bridge player and Wall Street customers' man."  He and his wife, the former Florence Fitch, were married in 1933 and occupied a three-room apartment on the eighth floor in 1939.  Florence was equally involved in bridge.  She who wrote newspaper and magazine articles on the game and the two operated bridge clubs in New London, Connecticut.

Born in 1907, Osborn worked for the brokerage firm of Francis I. du Pont & Co.  He was scheduled to play in the Eastern bridge championships starting on February 19, 1939, but he asked a fellow player to find a substitute for him.  He said that business "would prevent his participating."

But in fact, Osborn was having domestic problems.  Florence had left their apartment on February 16 and had not come home.  At 4:00 on the morning of February 22, a neighbor complained about the odor of gas.  The handyman, James Findlay, discovered a small leak on the ninth floor, and repaired it.  A much larger problem, however, was in the Osborn apartment.

At 9:05, Findlay broke into the Osborn apartment to find the kitchen filled with gas fumes.  Unthinking, he flicked on the light switch and the spark caused an explosion "that shattered the kitchen window, smashed the dishes and rocked the other rooms in the apartment," reported The New York Times.  Findlay was knocked to the floor, but was otherwise uninjured.

Lewis Osborn's body was on the kitchen floor.  The New York Times reported that he had "turned on all of the five jets of the kitchen range and sealed the room with adhesive tape."  He left two notes: one that gave funeral directions, the other addressed to Florence.  That one said he was "taking this way out" so she could have her freedom.

Close inspection of the carved entrance reveals a Jazz Age take on Renaissance designs.  Here a very 1920s nymph hides in twining vines.

Pincus and Anne Berner occupied an apartment here by the outbreak of World War II.  Born in 1899, Berner was a member of the law firm of Ernst, Can, Berner & Gitlin, whose clients were mostly from the entertainment and literary fields.  Pincus Berner was the personal attorney to the likes of Sinclair Lewis, Ayn Rand, Christopher Morley, Thomas Wolfe, William Saroyan, and Harold Robbins.  He was the co-executor of Thomas Wolfe's estate.

The population of the Berner apartment was temporarily increased by one during World War II.  A program evacuated children from bomb ravaged Britain and placed them into American homes.  The Berners took in Robert Gilders.  As Christmas neared in 1945, a British-American broadcast reunited some of the youths and their American foster families.  Robert Gilders, now a teen, lamented that he had been unsuccessful in converting his friends to baseball.  "It's no use," he said.

In 1960, Edgar I. Levy and Howard W. Woolf purchased 175 East 79th Street.  They quickly resold it to their tenants, who had formed the 175 East Seventy-ninth Tenants Corporation.  On November 11, 1960, The New York Times reported that the association "plans to remodel the house and operate it as a cooperative," noting, "It has fifty-six apartments and two penthouse suites."

Among the first owners were the Francesco A. Zara family.  Born in 1889, Zara, an associate vice president with the National City Bank of New York, married Mildred Gautier Rice on November 19, 1953.  Their country home was in Southampton, Long Island.  

On Saturday night, September 8, 1962, the Zaras had either returned to Manhattan for the winter season or were out.  In either case, The New York Times reported that while the two maids were sleeping, burglars entered the Southampton residence and "ransacked the house."  The thieves slinked away with jewelry worth the equivalent of $638,000 today.

Well-known television actress Melba Rae and her husband Gilbert Shawn, lived here following the conversion.  Shawn had been in radio and he helped get Melba her role in the Broadway play Janie.  She was, by now, known nationwide as Marge Bergman on the soap opera Search for Tomorrow.  Melba Rae died of a cerebral hemorrhage in December 1971 at the age of 49.

Gilbert Shawn and Melba Rae.  (original source unknown)

Resident Kenneth Gallant, a bachelor, occupied a 15th-floor apartment in the early 1970s.  When his friends could not contact him for several days in late December 1974, they went to his apartment on New Year's Day 1975.  When they got no answer, they asked the superintendent to check his apartment.  What Harold Beland discovered was horrific.  

The New York Times reported that he found Gallant's nude body in the bedroom "with an electrical cord around his neck."  Police said there were no signs of a break-in or robbery, adding, "the cause of death appeared to be strangulation."

It was possibly during the facade renovation in 2015 that the stonework of the first and second floors was painted.  Sadly, the coop board did not step in when several owners replaced the 1928 casements, so vital to Schwartz & Gross's design, with myriad, unsympathetic substitutes.  (Snap-in muntins would have given the appearance of the original casements.)

photographs by the author

The 1928 Belvoir - 470 West End Avenue

 

Known for its lavish private homes in the late 19th century, West End Avenue would, instead, be lined by high-end apartment buildings before the 1930s.  In 1927, the newly formed 470 West End Avenue Corporation demolished the seven houses at the southeast corner of West End Avenue and West 83rd Street and hired architect George F. Pelham to design a 15-story apartment building on the site.

Construction, which was completed in 1928, cost the equivalent of $28.2 million in 2026.  Pelham faced his tripartite, Renaissance Revival design in sandy-colored brick.  Stone quoins and cast stone panels of swags and cartouches decorated the two-story base.  The entrance sat within a handsome, double-height frame that terminated in a broken pediment and urn.

Faux Venetian-style balconies at the eighth and fourteenth floors relieved the otherwise unembellished mid- and top sections.  Rather than a parapet, Pelham capped the brick cornice with brick piers connected with iron railings.

The building filled with a variety of well-to-do residents.  Among the first were Louis W. Herman and his wife, Hortense; orchestra leader Eddie Elkins; and printing executive John L. Schoenfeld.

Born in 1897, violinist Eddie Elkins was the leader of the 10-piece Knickerbocker Grill Orchestra.  He and his jazz band made several dance records.  On December 10, 1929, they were at the Manhattan Studios on Park Avenue and 134th Street where they were to be part of a scene in the motion picture The Black and White Review.  A fire broke out and a disaster reminiscent of the Triangle Shirtwaist blaze followed.  A sub-headline in The Evening Post read, "Actors Killed In Jam At Exit...100 Caught in Flaming 2-Story Brick Building Used to Make Sound Pictures."

Violinist and orchestra leader Eddie Elkins (original source unknown)

A sub-headline in The Staten Island Advance read: "Girls in Blazing Ballet Dresses Leap to Death from Upper Windows." 

Eddie Elkins survived and was interviewed by The Evening Post in his apartment that evening.  He told the reporter that, "a slight crackling sound behind a pile of scenery first made him think something might be amiss.  When he stepped around the obstacle, a heavy drapery was blazing furiously and while he looked, the flames leaped to the rafters of the studio."

Elkins shouted an alarm toward the dressing rooms, but many of the performers thought he was calling them to the stage and finished their costuming.  Elkins ran up the stairs "for the $1,000 violin he had left in his quarters," recounted the article.  He grabbed it, leaving behind his bow, valued at $100.  In rescuing the instrument, he suffered "burns about the body."  In the end, 10 persons lost their lives and 20 were injured.

Louis W. Herman was a "registered stock specialist," as described by The New York Times.  He and Hortense escaped the Manhattan winter in 1930 by going to Palm Beach, Florida.  On February 26, thieves broke into their suite in the Ambassador Hotel.  Part of an underworld gang involved in burglaries, murder and counterfeiting, they escaped with $40,000 in Hortense's jewelry (about $771,000 today).  

Three months later, on May 28, The Sun ran the headline: "Gem Band Linked To Murder; Million In Bad Money Seized."  New York detectives had raided a hotel room, arrested the men, and seized "$300,000 in jewelry," according to the article.  Possible victims were contacted and The Sun reported, "Mrs. L. W. Herman of 470 West End avenue came in her limousine to Police Headquarters, where a dazzling array of jewels...is laid in a strong guarded room for inspection."  Hortense identified 11 of the 27 pieces.

Terra cotta frames pretend to be Venetian balconies.

The Hermans' wealth was reflected the following year when Louis protested his taxes.  On December 15, 1931, The New York Times reported, "An income tax refund of $42,500 for the year 1919 has been awarded to Louis W. Herman of New York as a result of a Federal court decision."  Herman's rebate would equal just under $900,000 today.

Other residents in the 1930s included Max Greenberg, president of the Paramount Hotel Corporation; Herman Kushner, president of the Luckey Style Dress Corp.; Frank Margulies; and Joseph and Bertha Bulova.  

Joseph Bulova was born in 1851 in a village near Prague, Czechoslovakia.  As a boy, he was apprenticed to a jeweler and in 1869, as an 18-year-old, he immigrated to New York City "with fifty cents," according to family lore.  He eventually established a jewelry store on Maiden Lane.  The shop developed into the massive Bulova Watch Company.  By the 1930s, the firm had factories in Queens, Rhode Island, Massachusetts and Switzerland.

Joseph Bulova (original source unknown)

Bulova took an active part in the business until August 1935, when he fell ill.  He died in his apartment on November 18 at the age of 84.

Frank Margulies was born in 1898 and started out as a featherweight prize fighter under the name of Frankie Brown.  He fought in the ring until 1918.  By the time he moved into 470 West End Avenue, he was "the shakedown man" for "an extortion ring run by Broadway racketeers," according to The New York Evening Post in 1931.  On November 24 that year, he was arrested and held "in $10,000 bail for a hearing December 1," as reported by The New York Evening Post.

Four victims of the mob had bravely agreed to testify against him.  At the time of the arrest, they were being guarded by detectives.  One of the victims, Alexander A. Rapport, reported that Margulies had come to his office to collect $2,000 in "protection."  Margulies told him, "Unless you kick in, your body will be found in the Hudson.  We've got the police on our pay roll."  Rapport told detectives that Margulies pulled out a knife and "remarked that he usually cut up persons who refused to contribute."

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

John L. Schoenfeld and his family were still living in 470 West End Avenue in May 1934 when he was appointed a member of the State Commission of Corrections.  In reporting on the appointment, The New York Sun remarked that the 51-year-old "is a close friend of Warden Lewis E. Laws of Sing Sing and is a life member of the American prison Association and a member of the League to Abolish Capital Punishment."

In the early 1960s, the FBI began collection information on writer and activist James Baldwin.  The bureau was not concerned about his brilliant novels, of course, but with his activism within the civil rights movement.  He took part in the 1963 March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom and in the voting rights march from Selma to Montgomery in 1965.  FBI agents tracked him down to 470 West End Avenue in 1963.  His extensive file at the Federal Bureau of Investigation included the notations:

On December 10, 1963, [redacted] Security Supervisor, New York Telephone Company, New York City, advised that JAMES BALDWIN resides in Apartment 6A, at 470 West End Avenue, New York City, and has unlisted telephone number TA 7-7773.

On December 10, 1963 [redacted] 470 West End Avenue, New York City, advised that the subject has resided in Apartment 6A at that address for the past three months.

In 1965, Baldwin's extended family purchased the house-turned-apartments at 137 West 71st Street.  He moved into an apartment in that building.  He was still living there where he died in France on December 1, 1987.

In 1970, the building, now known as The Belvoir, was converted into a cooperative.  Often misattributed as being the work of Emery Roth, the exterior of George F. Pelham's reserved Italian Renaissance Revival style building is nearly unchanged in nearly a century.  

photographs by the author

The Lost Hermann Gehnrich House - 444 East 89th Street

The vintage house with its polychromed details had survived intact in 1932.  A section of the cornice was lost when the apartment building to the right was constructed.   from the collection of the New York Public Library

After the New York and Harlem Railroad was extended along Fourth Avenue in the 1830's, a hamlet grew up around the 86th Street station.   In the 1850's an influx of German and Irish immigrants settled in the village, many of them hired to build the Croton Aqueduct.  At some point around the time of the Civil War, it became known as Yorkville.  Eventually Yorkville would rival, then overtake the Lower East Side as the center of the German immigrant community.

A flurry of construction followed the end of the Civil War.  In the early years of the 1870s, wooden houses--two and three stories tall with high basements--were erected along both sides of East 89th Street between York and First Avenues.  Among them was 444 East 89th Street, home to William H. and Sara A. Mott.  Like the others along the block, it was faced in clapboard.  The paneled wooden fence posts mimicked the newels of the stoop railings.  Floor-to-ceiling parlor windows opened onto an ample porch, where the Motts would have found relief from warm evenings.  The architect-builder embellished the upper openings with handsome molded lintels with carved ornaments.  The deeply overhanging cornice was upheld by thin, scrolled corbels with hanging finials.

In May 1880, William and Sara Mott sold 444 East 89th Street to Anne M. Donnell.  She rented space in the house to families, one per floor.  Anne advertised it for sale in the New York Herald on March 25, 1891:

Fine Private House, Garden, full lot; all improvements on each floor; 15 large rooms; arranged for three families; $10,500.

The "improvements" would most likely have included indoor plumbing.  The price Anne Donnell asked would translate to about $383,000 in 2026.  It was purchased by Rudolph Ladensack, who resold it on June 6, 1892 to Hermann and Magdalena Schaefer Gehnrich.

Born in Germany, the couple had three sons, William T., Herman John, and Charles L.  The brothers pursued very different career paths.  

William turned to metalwork and on April 8, 1899, The Metal Worker listed him among the students enrolled in the evening class of Sheet Metal and Cornice Work at the New York Trade School.  It is possible that he commuted from Yorkville to the school at 67th Street and First Avenue by bicycle.  Four years before that article, William had signed a petition to the Board of Alderman, urging a "bicycle path between the upper and lower parts of the city."

Herman John Gehnrich was also an ardent bicyclist.  On August 7, 1900, The New York Times reported on the upcoming "open moonlight and double century run" by the New York State Division of the Century Road Club of America, an organization for bicycle enthusiasts.  "Entries for this run can be sent to the Secretary, H. J. Gehnrich, 444 East Eighty-ninth Street."

Charles L. Gehnrich was involved in charity work for the state.  As early as 1902, he worked as a clerk in the Department of Inspection of the State Board of Charities.  The 1904 Annual Report of the State Board of Charities explained, "This department has charge of the visitation and inspection of all institutions, societies or associations which are of a charitable, eleemosynary, correctional or reformatory character."

In the meantime, Herman John Gehnrich died on December 29, 1900 at the age of 21.  His parents did not disclose any funeral arrangements to the public.

from the collection of the New York Public Library

William brought his bride, Minnie, to live at 444 East 89th Street.  In 1906, they had two twin boys, Charlie and Willie.  The family suffered unspeakable grief on March 24, 1908.  The Inquirer reported, "locked in each other's arms, twin babies this afternoon plunged headlong from the second-story window to the yard in the rear of their home, at 444 East Eighty-ninth street."  The article said that Minnie, "having household duties to attend to, had locked the guards on the rear second-story window of her home, leaving the twins, Charlie and Willie, barely two years old, playing in the room."

The New York Times reported that Minnie entered the room "just as they toppled from the window, and she ran screaming downstairs into the yard.  Policeman Lederman found her holding the unconscious infants in her arms and weeping over them."  The boys had landed on the pavement in the rear yard, fracturing their skulls.  

According to The Evening World, "The father of the twins, William Gehnrich, came from the sheet-iron factory where he works, in East Ninety-second street, and took the mother to the hospital.  She was frantic with grief."  The New York Times noted, "There is no hope that the twins will live."

Minnie Gehnrich's anguish was increased when her husband, perhaps overcome with grief, died four days later.  Once again, The New York Times remarked only, "funeral private."  

Hermann and Magdalena moved to Brooklyn by 1917.  Hermann died on February 18, 1920 and Magdalena on July 14, 1922.

George Repp and Carl Wetzler leased the basement level of 444 East 89th Street for the offices of Repp & Wetzler, "baker oven builders."  An advertisement in The Retail Baker in October 1917 touted, "repairing of all patent and American ovens our specialty."  Rooms were rented in the upper floors.  Among the tenants here in 1923 was 21-year-old John Gick, arrested for operating a vehicle while intoxicated on October 9 that year.

When 444 East 89th Street was sold to Michael Demetroules and George Hadjinanos in September 1926, The New York Times described it as "a four-story flat."  The article said, "The purchasers contemplate extensive renovations."

The quaint wooden building was remodeled.  The porch was removed and a Colonial-style entrance installed slightly below grade.  The architect modernized the vintage elements by streamlining the window frames and reducing the cornice corbels.

mage via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

A renovation completed in 1945 resulted in one apartment per floor.  By then, 444 East 89th Street was the last remnant of the 1870s block.  The end finally came in the early 1970s when the house and the properties to the corner of York Avenue were demolished for a 33-floor apartment building, completed in 1974.

image via compass.com

The Lonely George and Annie Smith Mansion - 1033 Fifth Avenue

 

In 1870, Harriet Track erected four elegant homes on Fifth Avenue between 84th and 85th Streets.  Designed by Stephen D. Hatch, the American basement plan homes were four stories tall with an attic.  Among them was No. 1033.  Faced in brownstone, its French Second Empire design was the latest in domestic fashion.  

A portion of No. 1033 can be glimpsed at the side of 1034 Fifth Avenue, which had just been given a new front in 1912.  No. 1033 would follow suit within months of this photo.  photograph by Wurts Brothers from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

Jacob Campbell purchased 1033 Fifth Avenue as an investment.  He leased it to Edward Payson Hatch and his wife, the former Elizabeth C. Height.  Born in Norwich, Vermont on July 11, 1832, Hatch started his retail career at the age of 15 earning $4 a month.  By the time he and his family moved into 1033 Fifth Avenue, he had been highly successful.  The New York Herald noted, "After making a fortune in the sewing machine business Mr. Hatch retired from business."

Then, in 1879, he got a call from John Taylor Lord.  The New York Herald later explained, "the firm of Lord & Taylor became involved in financial difficulties and he was asked to take charge of affairs."

Elizabeth Height Hatch was born in New Jersey, where her ancestors first settled in 1721.  She and Edward had one son, Edward Jr., and six daughters.  Their country homes were in  Arlington, New Jersey and Burlington, Vermont.

On April 28, 1889, The New York Sun debunked a common assumption, saying, "There is no Taylor in Lord & Taylor."  The newspaper explained, "The firm is composed of Samuel Lord, Jr., who lives in Orange, and Edward P. Hatch, who lives at 1,033 Fifth avenue."

Samuel Lord Jr. died in 1896.  John Taylor Lord was now Hatch's partner in the firm.  Upon his death in January 1903, Edward Hatch became the sole head of Lord & Taylor.  That same year, Hatch finally purchased 1033 Fifth Avenue.

At the time, the Hatches' butler was 25-year-old William Johnson.  On August 3, 1903, the 25-year-old took a few days off.  His subsequent behavior--going into three pawnshops on Sixth Avenue--made Detective Rochester suspicious.  Rochester went into one of them and "learned that he had pawned several pieces of silk," according to The New York Times.  The detective detained Johnson and "he found a dozen pawn tickets sewed on the negro's underwear representing silverware, jewelry, suits of clothes, and silk to the value of several hundred dollars."  He also had letters addressed to Edward P. Hatch Sr. and private papers.

Hatch was notified and he and his daughter, Cornelia, appeared in court the following day.  Johnson confessed to stealing $40 worth of silk and "several hundred dollars' worth of silverware."

Elizabeth Height Hatch died on February 2, 1906 "after a lingering illness," as reported by The Christian Advocate.  In reporting her death, the newspaper mentioned that she and Edward were "largely instrumental" in establishing the church in Arlington, New Jersey.

Red Rocks, the Hatch country place in Burlington, Vermont, was described by the New-York Tribune in 1909 as "a splendid estate on the shore of Lake Champlain.  The article said Hatch "spent large sums in laying out driveways through the woods, providing lookouts over the lake, building permanent stone highways and installing public drinking fountains," said the newspaper, adding, "He loved his estate and loved to see the people in general visit and admire the work of his hands."

Hatch had seen intense grief by the time of that article.  Only two children, Edward and Cornelia, were still alive.  In September 1909, he was at Red Rocks.  The New York Herald said, "He had been in poor health for weeks, but was able to be out and chat with his friends on Sunday afternoon."  That evening he "had a sinking spell and failed rapidly."  He died of a heart attack the following morning, September 21.

The Hatch estate sold 1033 Fifth Avenue in March 1910 to Charles Sooysmith for $150,000 (about $5.24 million in 2026 terms).   Plans were filed for a replacement house, but for some reason, Sooysmith changed his mind.  Two years later, he resold it George C. and Annie S. Smith.  The Sun reported on March 31, 1912, "It is the intention of the purchaser to practically rebuild the house."

The Smiths commissioned the architectural firm of Hoppin & Koen to bring the outdated mansion into the 20th century.  The brownstone facade was removed to be replaced with limestone.  Hoppin & Koen's dignified Beaux Arts design was reservedly decorated with elegant, French Classic Louis XV motifs, like the panels of double-swags and ribbons below the second-floor windows, and the swags and wreaths below the third-floor openings.  Two segmentally arched dormers peered over the stone balustrade that fronted the mansard.

Born in 1858, George Campbell Smith was a partner in Stead & Smith, the publishing firm co-founded by his father.  He married Anne Kammerer Schmertz on January 18, 1888.  The couple had three children, Dorothy Frances, George Jr., and Annie J.  The family's country home, Blythewood, was in East Norwich, Long Island.

Annie's engagement to Leon H. Abbett was announced in September 1919.  It sparked entertainments, like the Smiths' dinner and dance at the Metropolitan Club for the couple on November 14.

Annie J. Smith's engagement photograph.  The New-York Tribune, December 25, 1919 (copyright expired)

At the time of that dinner party, the Smiths had already sold the mansion.  The sale was announced in the New York Herald on October 4, 1919.  The Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported the sale price at $210,000, or just under $4 million today.

The buyers were Milo Merrick Belding and his wife, the former Annie L. Kirk.  Milo was born in New York City on April 14, 1865, "the day of Lincoln's assassination," as noted by The New York Times.  His deep American roots were reflected in his membership in the Founders and Patriots of America and the Sons of the Revolution.

Milo Merrick Belding (original source unknown)

In 1884, he took a job as a clerk in his father's firm, Belding Bros. & Co., "the largest manufacturers and distributers of silk thread in the United States," according to The New York Times in 1931.  Upon his father's death in 1912, Milo Belding became president.  He was, as well, president of the American Union Life Insurance Company.

Belding commissioned a sea-worthy yacht, the Cocoon, in 1923.  The vessel needed only "finishing touches" in November 1924 and those were to be done in Florida.  Milo invited two guests--his secretary, W. H. Stillhammer, and Dr. George M. Smith--to accompany him on the cruise.  The vessel had a crew of four.  

Around dusk on November 22, "the yacht was heading in toward Government Cut after having made a test trip down the bay, around Cape Florida and into the Atlantic," reported The New York Times.  Belding and his guests heard a loud noise that they initially thought was a door slamming or glass breaking.  Another came two minutes later and this time "they plainly identified it as a gunshot."

The Cocoon was under fire from the Coast Guard, which, despite its being fully lighted, was mistaken for a rum runner.  The yacht was boarded and searched.  "When no liquor was found the Cocoon was permitted to steam to her berth, and the officer expressed his regrets," reported The New York Times.

Understandably, Milo Belding was not ready to accept the apology.  He told reporters that "the affair would be reported to Washington."

That year, the abutting houses to the south were demolished and replaced with an apartment building designed by J. E. R. Carpenter.

The Smith mansion now snuggled up to a behemoth. photograph by Wurts Brothers from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

The following year, the property to the north of 1033 Fifth Avenue was filled with another J. E. R. Carpenter-designed apartment building.  The Smith mansion was now sandwiched between two soaring structures.

Image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

Around October 1, 1931, Milo Belding contracted what was described as a "mild cold."  Two weeks later, it developed into bronchitis that "fatally affected his heart," as reported by The New York Times on October 14.  His funeral was held in the mansion two days later.

Belding's massive estate was reflected in an article in The New York Times on January 9, 1934, which began, "The Association for the Aid of Crippled Children will get more than $10,000,000 of the wealth of the late Milo M. Belding.  That figure would translate to $240 million today.

Annie Kirk Belding died in the mansion on September 4, 1944.  In reporting her death, The New York Times remarked that she had been a director of the Association for the Aid of Crippled Children since 1925 and that she helped establish the Milo M. Belding Fund for the aid of crippled children."

Singer Morton Downey purchased 1033 Fifth Avenue.  Born in 1901, he was known as The Irish Nightingale.  He and his wife, actress Barbara Bennett (sister of actresses Constance and Joan Bennett), were divorced in 1941.  They had five children, including Morton Downey Jr., who would go on to become a talk show host and actor.

On October 1, 1945, The New York Times reported that Downey had sold "the five-story house with elevator" to the Herbert J. Freezer Company.  It became home to Herbert J. Freezer and his wife, Michael Stone Freezer.  The couple had a son, Winthrop.  Their residency would be relatively short.  The Freezers separated in 1950 and the mansion was sold to actress Eva Gabor.

According to Sam Staggs in his Finding Zsa Zsa: The Gabors Behind the Legend, "Eva daydreamed of a gilded life in her spacious multi-story, with herself as chatelaine and vassals at her side."  On November 29, 1950, The New York Times announced that she "intends to alter and occupy the property as her town house."

Eva invited her mother, Jolie, to inspect the mansion.  According to Staggs, Eva recalled, "She told me I am not her smartest daughter, since it was evident to anyone with eyes that ten apartments could be made in the building."  The dutiful daughter followed her advice.  Within a year, there were six apartments in the former residence, including a triplex.

The Government of Iran purchased 1033 Fifth Avenue in 1960 as the residence of Iran's United Nations mission chief.  It remained so until the Iranian Revolution in 1978-79 that overthrew the Pahlavi monarchy.

On December 23, 1990, The New York Times reported, "Acquired by Iran in the mid-60s' [sic] and furnished with Persian rugs, antique mirrors and crystal chandeliers, the town house at 1033 Fifth Avenue...has declined in the last decade or so."  The article explained that the Iranian Government intended to spend $250,000 in renovating the building.  Architect George Schwartz was commissioned to "modernize" the building and reconvert it into a single residence.  The work included new electrical, heating and air conditioning systems, and the updating of the kitchen and bathrooms.

The mansion--vised between two 1920s apartment buildings--is home to the Iranian Ambassador to the United Nations today.

photographs by the author

M. Louis Ungrich's 1886 345 and 347 West 123rd Street

 
Developers Frank Tilford and F. Keller hired architect M. Louis Ungrich in the spring of 1885 to design a row of 10 "three-story basement brick and stone private dwellings" on West 123rd Street between Morningside and Manhattan Avenues.  Turning to the popular Queen Anne style, Ungrich designed the row as five alternating, mirror-image pairs--A-B, C-D, A-B, C-D, and A-B.

The easternmost homes, Nos. 345 and 347, were among the A and B models.  At just 16-feet wide, they were clad in red brick and trimmed in brownstone and terra cotta above the stone-faced basements.  The squiggly spindles of the iron stoop railings and areaway fencing were typical of the often light-hearted Queen Anne style.  The two homes shared a stone bandcourse above the parlor and a bracketed intermediate cornice above the second floor.  An elaborate terra cotta plaque of swirling vines behind a shell straddled the property line at the third floor.  Each gable was decorated with a terra cotta rondel with a full-relief flower erupting from a sunburst.

Terra cotta details enhance the building's charm.

Tilford & Keller initially leased the homes.  An advertisement in the New-York Daily Tribune on January 23, 1887 read, "For Rent--The new and elegant house, 345 West 123d-st.; has never been occupied; will be decorated to suit tenant and rented for half rate until May 1."

It appears that the first to occupy 345 West 123rd Street was the William Mahl family.  William was born in Germany in 1843 and his wife, the former Mary Ann Skidmore, was born in England in 1848.  Mahl was the controller of the Southern Pacific Railroad Company, and he and Mary Ann had three children, Frederick William, John Thomas (known as Tom), and Edith Virginia. 

The family was still here in 1891 when Tom was studying at the Columbia University School of Mines.  The family moved away around 1892, three years before he graduated. 

(Tom's story would have a sad ending.  He married Ella Hutchins Botts in 1894 and upon graduation he was appointed the head of the Department of Maintenance and Ways of the Houston and Texas Central Railway.  The couple moved to Houston.  Ella died at the age of 29 on June 13, 1900 and, according to The New York Times, "Soon afterward his own health gave way and his physicians advised him to travel extensively.  He had consumption, they said."  In March 1901, the Mahls received word that "death was not far distant."  Mary Ann was with Tom in a private train car on March 31, 1901 when the 27-year-old died.)

The families along the row maintained a small domestic staff.  Mrs. Elizabeth Murphy, who followed the Mahls in 345 West 123rd Street, had at least one servant, Sadie Scott.  Around noon on June 1, 1894, Elizabeth returned from church and, according to The Evening World, "deposited in a closet a diamond ring valued at $100 and $125 in bills."  (Why Elizabeth would have taken the cash--equal to more than $4,800 in 2026--to church in the first place is puzzling.)  Later that afternoon, she noticed that the closet door was open and discovered the cash was missing.  The newspaper reported, "Sadie being the only one in the house suspicion fell on her."  Despite Sadie's strong denial of the crime, she was arrested and charged with grand larceny.

Tilford and Keller were looking for a new tenant for No. 347 in 1890.  Their ad on April 9 read: "Just Look--347 West 123d-st. to lease for only $1,000; three story, high-stoop house, with every improvement; decorated, chandeliers and sanitary plumbing."  The mention of chandeliers was significant.  New homeowners and renters most often had to supply their own lighting fixtures.  And "sanitary plumbing" reveals that the houses had indoor plumbing and toilets.  The rent was extremely reasonable, translating to about $3,000 per month today.

In 1896, Tilford & Keller sold the houses--345 West 123rd Street to Herbert M. Johnson and 347 to Charles D. Folsom.  

Herbert M. Johnson resold No. 345 in April 1897 to William M. Badger and his wife, Eliza.  William would not enjoy the house for long.  He died in 1899.  

Eliza sold the dwelling on May 3, 1902 to Daniel and Jane T. McGowan for $13,000 (about $500,000 today).  In an unsettling instance of déjà vu, Daniel McGowan died in the house less than a year later, on February 28, 1903.

In the meantime, Charles Folsom rented 347 West 123rd Street.  His tenants (who appear to be Harry Hull St. Clair Sr. and his wife, the former Mary Louise Harber) immediately took in a boarder.  In fact, they gave up half of the house in doing so.  An advertisement in the New-York Tribune on August 16, 1896 read: "347 West 123d-St--Strictly private family offer, with board, three large rooms; second and third floors."  ("Strictly private family" stressed that this was not a boarding house situation.)

Living here in 1896-97 was Arthur Moult Smyth, a civil engineer.  Born in 1868, he earned his Engineer of Mines degree from Lehigh University in 1890.

Harry and Mary St. Clair had a daughter, Helen, born on June 28, 1877.  On Christmas Day 1897, Mary Louse St. Clair died at the age of 44.  Newspapers noted that her funeral services would be "private."  

(Helen would go on to great success.  She would graduate from the Classical School for Girls, from Barnard College, and from Columbia University Phi Beta Kappa.  She would received her law degree from New York University Law School.)

In 1940, the original doors were intact and the masonry was not yet painted.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

In the early 1900s, William Henry Bolander and his wife, the former Jennie Damon, lived at 347 West 123rd Street.  Born on September 11, 1838, he was placed in charge of the New Haven Railroad's "Pier 6, East River" in 1878, according to The New York Times.  William still held that position when he died on October 28, 1913 at the age of 75.  His funeral was held in the parlor on the 31st.

The McGowan family retained possession of 345 West 123rd Street into the Depression years.  By the mid-1940s it was operated as a rooming house.  Among the tenants in 1947 was Lamar Harris who got into trouble in Ossining, New York on the afternoon of April 7 that year.  The Citizen-Register reported that he was arrested at the Ossining Railroad Station "on a charge of disorderly conduct" and fined $10.  The article did not go into details of what constituted his offense.

Next door, 347 West 123rd Street was home to the St. Joseph Council Service Station of the Knights of Columbus in the post-World War I years.  Never converted to apartments, it is a single-family home today.  Its architectural fraternal twin was less lucky.  There are eight residential units in 345 West 123rd Street.

photographs by the author