The 1892 John Stich House - 117 East 95th Street

 

In 1891, developer Francis J. Schnugg hired Louis Entzer, Jr. to design nine abutting houses on the northern side East 95th Street between Park and Madison Avenues.  Along with the eight homes the pair created a year earlier, they would nearly fill the blockfront.

Completed in 1892, Entzer's row would compliment the earlier houses.  The four designs were configured in an A-B-C-C-D-D-B-A pattern.  Among the B models was 117 East 95th Street and, like its architectural siblings, was three stories high above a basement.  The undressed stone blocks and the heavy voussoirs over the arched parlor windows were Romanesque Revival in style.  Above the double-doored entrance, a stained-glass transom incorporated the address.

Entzer gave the planar sandstone of the upper two floors interest by striating it with bands of rough cut stone.  A sheet metal oriel dominated the second floor--its whimsical bosses along its base and the artistic panes of the upper sashes were Queen Anne in design.  The architect continued to blend styles by placing Gothic Revival, square-headed drip moldings above the top floor windows.  An elaborate and highly unusual pressed metal cornice completed the design.

The house became home to the John Stich family.  Born in 1856, Stich was the head of the John Stich Building Company.  He and his wife, the former Rose Herrmann, had two daughters: Mildred, born in 1882, and Nellie, born in 1886.

John Stich (original source unknown)

The 1899-1900 winter social season saw 18-year-old Mildred's debut.  Debutante entertainments often stretched for weeks, and on January 7, 1900, the New York Herald reported, "Mr. and Mrs. John Stich, of 117 East Ninety-fifth street, gave a musical and dance on New Year's night in honor of their daughter Mildred."

Two years later, on October 1, 1902, the New York Herald reported that John and Rose had announced Mildred's engagement to Saul Manovitch.  It may have been that article that provided Mary Smith the alternative identity she needed.

Shortly afterward, Mary Smith, described by The New York Times as "stylish and twenty-five years old," went on a shopping spree in the Stern Brothers' dry goods store on West 23rd Street.  She was arrested on October 25, 1902 "charged with obtaining goods under false pretenses."  The article said she confessed "to having obtained a large quantity of goods by representing herself to be the daughter of Mrs. John Stitch [sic] of 117 East Ninety-fifth Street."

John Stich sold the 18-foot-wide residence in April 1903 to Hyman (who often angelized his name to Herman) Adelstein.  He was born in Russia (in an area that would later become part of Poland) on December 7, 1868 and came to America in 1887.  He was a partner with Herman Avrutine in an iron foundry.

Hyman and his wife, the former Rosa Solvey, had six children--the eldest, Michael, was 13 years old when the family moved into 117 East 95th Street and the youngest, Sidney, was three.  Also living with the family was Ida Ksofsky, a niece.  Ida's time here was relatively short.  On February 4, 1906, Hyman and Rosa announced her engagement to Ezekiel Yachnowitz.

The Adelsteins were supplanted by the Jacob Lunitz family as early as 1912.  Lunitz was president of the Laclun Realty Company.  Like Hyman Adelstein, he was born in the Russian Empire around 1865.  He arrived in the United States in 1878.  Jacob and his wife, the former Betsie Horwitz, had six surviving children.  Two others, Feige and Salie, had died in 1894 and 1900, respectively.  The family maintained a summer home in Tannersville, New York.

Jacob and Betsie announced daughter Pansy's engagement to Louis Propp on March 1, 1920.  The Lunitzes were already planning a move and on July 10, the Record & Guide reported that they had sold 117 East 95th Street to Ernest and Oscar Sondheim.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Brothers Ernest and Oscar Sondheim were partners in The Imperial Metal Manufacturing Corporation, the factory of which was located in Long Island City, and in the Perfumers & Jewelers Box Company on West 14th Street.

The bachelor brothers purchased 117 East 95th Street as a family home.  Living with them here were their widowed mother and their unmarried sisters.

Ernest Sondheim was the last of the family to occupy the house.  He died in 1954, 34 years after moving in, and his estate sold the house to George Axelrod.  He resold it eight years later, in August 1962, to designer Stephen Kyle and his wife, entertainer, lyricist, playwright, and screenwriter Betty Comden. 

The couple, who were married in 1942, had created their own names.  Stephen Kyle was born Siegfried Schutzman and Betty Comden was born in Brooklyn in 1917 as Basya Cohen.  They had two children, Susanna and Alan.  

Betty Comden, from the collection of the New York Public Library

Betty Comden formed a troupe, the Revuers, in 1938 that included Judy Holliday, Adolph Green, and Leonard Bernstein.  Comden and Adolph Green partnered to write musical plays.  Their first Broadway production was the 1944 musical On the Town.  They relocated to California and, working for MGM, wrote screenplays.  Among their output were The Barkleys of Broadway, Singin' in the Rain, and The Band Wagon.

Now, back in New York City, Betty and Stephen became close friends with Leonard Bernstein.  When his wife, Felicia Montealegre, died in 1978, Betty wrote a moving letter that ended,

You are so much, Lenny--so many qualities and gifts and inner voices not given to many human beings.  You will find your strength somehow in them--and in the beautiful elements added to them by the co-mingling of your life and Felicia's.

        Much love, always, from Steve and from me.  Betty

A year after that letter, Stephen Kyle died of pancreatitis.  

Betty Comden and Adolph Green received the Kennedy Center Honors in 1991.  She died in the New York Presbyterian Hospital on November 23, 2006 at the age of 89.

The following year, an apartment was installed in the basement level.  When the house was offered for sale in 2011, The New York Times described the main portion as having five bedrooms and three baths.  Outwardly, little has changed to the 134-year-old residence.

photographs by the author

A "Thieves' School" -62 East Third Street

 

62 East Third (right) was one of a pair erected in 1838-39.  photograph by Carole Teller

The Greek Revival style was just beginning to nudge out the Federal style in 1838, when John Hanrahan began construction of two brick-faced homes at 56 and 58 Third Street between First and Second Avenues.  (They would later renumbered 62 and 64 East Third Street) Completed the following year, they were three stories tall above brownstone-clad basements.  Cast iron stoop railings wrapped the newels, which sat upon stone drums.  Typical of the style, the entrances were flanked by sidelights and framed by stone pilasters and a heavy entablature.

The original owner of No. 56 was William H. Mott, who leased the house.  Living here in 1840 was Kendrac W. Follet, a painter, followed by Rev. Darius Eliot Jones and his wife, the Dorcas Ann Letts.

Born on October 18, 1815 to musician Abner Cheney Jones, Darius married Dorcas around 1828.  The couple would have four children, Mary, Kate Louisa, Charles B. Hatch, and Abner Campbell.

In addition to his ministry, Jones was a hymnist.  He wrote "He that Goeth Forth With Weeping" and "Jesus, Lord of Life and Light," and compiled volumes like Songs for the New Life, Hallowed Songs, and National Church Harmony.

Sadly, the couple's first son, Charles, died in the house on August 27, 1843 at just one-and-a-half years old.  His funeral was held in the parlor two days later.

As early as 1845, David C. and Jane Buchan occupied the house.  Buchan listed his profession as "chairmaker," and advertised himself as the "manufacturer of curled, maple and fancy chairs."  

A metal David C. Buchan chair tag.  Chair tags were affixed to the bottom of a chair to identify (and advertise) the maker.

As was common, the Buchans took in a boarder.  Living with the family in 1845 was silversmith George W. Gilchrist, and in 1851 schoolteacher Peter L. Ewell was here.

Starting around 1855, Cornelius L. Everitt and his widowed mother, Mary, occupied the house.  Cornelius was born in 1808 and when he and Mary moved in he was secretary of the New-York Gaslight Company.  He would eventually rise to president of the firm, as well as president of the Mercantile Literary Library, and secretary and treasurer of the Second Company, 7th Regiment, National Guard.  Additionally, he would become vice-president of the Broadway Savings Bank and a director in the Stuyvesant Insurance Company.

The New-York Tribune would later describe Cornelius Everitt, saying:

He was very correct and methodical in all his habits, and his strong common sense and well known probity, caused him to be sought after as a trustee and executor of estates requiring prudent and skillful management.

Everitt moved from 62 East Third Street in 1859.  He was followed in the house by John Harpell, a butcher in the Washington Market.  The affluent Harpell family would remain until 1872.  Harpell and his wife had two young adult children, a son and a daughter.

The Harpells also took in a boarder, who in 1859 was Thomas Hanlon.  Because of the tight quarters, Hanlon shared a bedroom with the Harpells' son.  The bedroom of their daughter, Henrietta, adjoined it.  

According to Henrietta, on the night of May 27 that year, she had left her bedroom door ajar "on account of the warmness of the weather," as reported by the New-York Daily Tribune.  At around 2:00 in the morning, Henrietta awoke to find Thomas Hanlon attacking her.  She screamed, and Hanlon dived under a bed in the corner of the room.  The article said, "he was captured shortly after by her father and brother."  He was charged with assault and battery.

After the incident, the Harpells were, apparently, more careful in choosing their boarders.  James M. MacGregor, for instance, lived with the family in 1863 through 1865.  He was superintendent of buildings for the city.

The Herman Zimmer family replaced the Harpells in 1872. He and sons Alfred F. and Emil Zimmer listed their professions as clerks.  The family occupied the house at least through 1880.

At the turn of the century, the East Third Street neighborhood had declined.  No. 62 was operated as a rooming house and its occupants were no longer respectable.  Living here in 1905, for example, was James Nixon.

On the night of October 9 that year, he and Thurston Gladheim were drinking in the Dry Dock Hotel at East Third Street and the Bowery.  President Theodore Roosevelt had just mediated the Treaty of Portsmouth, which ended the Russo-Japanese War and the two men were discussing it.  The Sun reported, "Incidentally the subject of wounds was broached."

James Nixon, who apparently had psychopathic tendencies, told Gladheim, "If you were excited enough, I could stab you with this knife and you wouldn't feel it."  In a flash, he thrust his pocket knife into his friend's chest.  The wounded man staggered out of the saloon and "almost into the arms of Policeman Muller."  Muller called an ambulance and Gladheim was transported to a hospital where his condition was deemed "very precarious."  James Nixon was held without bail awaiting "the outcome of Gladheim's injuries."

In May 1907, Henry Cohen was arrested with a boy, Jacob Stein, for arresting 500 coats from the factory of Jacob Davis.  The boy was let free as "only a tool."  Cohen, on the other hand, was found guilty.  In hopes of a lighter sentence, he told detectives about Theodore (known as Teddy) Grant, who "was not only running a fence, but a school for boy thieves," reported The Evening World.

On the night of May 17, four detectives staked out 62 East Third Street.  When 19-year-old Joseph Kist and "a driver, who lives in the house," entered the basement door, the detectives followed and attempted to arrest Kist.  "There was a struggle when he tried to escape," said the article.  The noise was heard on the floor above, and then there came a grating sound, as if something were coming down the chimney."

Theodore Grant, thinking that police were trying to get in the front door, attempted to slip into the basement through the chimney grate.  "The feet were seized and the man was drawn forth.  He fought hard but was soon in handcuffs."  In the parlor level, police discovered what The New York Times called, "a school of instruction in Crime."  The Evening World titled its article, "$50,000 Loot Found In Alleged Fence, Run, Police Say, By A Fagin."  The teenaged "pupils" were arrested and the spoils of their lessons were confiscated.  "There were many pieces of lace, jewelry of value and other goods, all of which, it is declared, had been stolen from express companies in transit," said The Evening World.

  

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Louis Sockler rented a room here in 1924.  Late on the night of November 30 that year, he walked into I. Silberforf's store at 359 East 10th Street.  He was greeted by a man who said, "Come right in the backroom.  The boss is giving a party tonight."

What Sockler could not have known was that the "clerk" was one of three gunmen who had tied Silberforf to a chair a few minutes earlier.  As the crooks tethered Sockler to a chair next to Silberforf's, a second customer entered the store.  The scenario was repeated and now three victims were tied and bound in the backroom.  The New York Times reported, "Then the thieves took $100 from the pocket of Silberforf, $30 from Sockler, and 85 cents from Levison."

While one gunman was guarding the prisoners, the others started to rifle the cash drawer.  They were interrupted by two  more customers and fled.  Nevertheless, Sockler and the other two victims gave detailed descriptions of the thieves.

In June 1930, Nathan Yochnowitz purchased 62 East Third Street.  The house was converted to four apartments and that configuration survives. today.

many thanks to artist Carole Teller for suggesting this post

The 1927 Three Arts Club - 340 West 85th Street

 

photo by Greghenderson2006

In the last decades of the 19th century, a wave of independent-minded women changed New York City's workforce.  No longer restricted to nurses, school teachers and domestics, young women came to the city to take new positions like "typewriters" and stenographers.  In response, hotels for single working women began cropping up throughout the city.  They offered single women a safe environment, friendship, and affordable accommodations. 

In 1902, Jane Harris Hall, a deaconess of the Protestant Episcopal Church, took the concept a step further.  She recognized another group of women who traveled to New York City alone--those not seeking employment, but artistic education.  Based on the American Girls' Club in Paris, she founded the Three Arts Club for female students in the drama, fine arts, and musical fields.  The club opened in an old brownstone, and in its March 1905 issue, The Designer explained:

Under its roof may be had, for the nearly nominal sum of from three to five dollars a week, all the advantages of the usual club life, together with the important addition of the comforts and privileges of home; for the new club house, on the sunniest corner of Sixty-second street and Lexington Avenue, combines both club and living-rooms within its four-story brownstone walls.

On November 27, 1909, The New York Times reported that the Three Arts Club had purchased the six-story apartment house at 338-340 West 85th Street.  Seventeen years later, the renovated apartment house was no longer adequate.  On June 15, 1926, the officers announced that the building would be demolished and replaced.

Architect George B. de Gersdorff designed an eight-story Colonial Revival-style structure faced in red brick and trimmed in limestone.  Completed in 1927 at a cost of $400,000 (about $7.2 million in 2026), its tripartite design focused on utility rather than ornament.  

The centered, arched entrance was flanked by engaged columns with palm leaf capitals that upheld an entablature that announced "The Three Arts Club."  A stone architrave around the window directly above it and a wrought iron, colonial-style railing created a faux balcony.  The upper two sections were unadorned other than stone keystones at the second and eighth floors.

photograph by Greghenderson2006

Inside were accommodations for 153 students.  Wealthy benefactors had generously donated to the structure.  Frederick W. Vanderbilt donated the Louise Anthony Vanderbilt Library in memory of his wife, and the club's president, Mrs. John Henry Hammond (the former Emily Vanderbilt Sloane), gave the club "the little theatre and assembly room with lounge and balcony," according to The New York Times.  Marcia Tucker, wife of millionaire Carll Tucker, "gave the studio or aerial work shop, reached from the eighth floor, where the elevator stops, by a stairway," said the newspaper.  "There is also sufficient room on the roof for a garden and sleeping porch."

As construction drew to an end, on March 19, 1927, The New York Evening Post reported that the Three Arts Club, "expects to formally open its large new building June 1."  The article praised, "The splendid work which the club has accomplished in giving a comfortable and inexpensive home to the young art students who come to New York is well known throughout the country."

The targeted completion date was optimistic and the understated, formal opening took place on November 17.  Among the six speakers who gave "five-minute addresses," according to The New York Times, was the club's founder, Jane Harris Hall; the building's architect, George B. de Gersdorff; and conductor and composer Walter Damrosch.  The guest of honor was operatic diva Emma Calvé.  Following the dedication, tea was served in the large dining room in the basement.

Maria Tucker's "aerial work shop" on the roof can be seen this 1940 photograph.  photographer unknown, via www.nyc.gov

In addition to being a place to live, the Three Arts Club was a venue in which to exhibit the work of its residents.  The theater, for instance, was where members staged a Christmas play, The Nativity of the Manger, in 1929.  And every year an art exhibition was held.   

The club also held events for the residents.  On December 31, 1934, for instance, The New York Sun reported that teacher and author Harriet Ayer Seymour "will give a course of four free lectures on adult education in music at the Three Arts Club."  And on April 13, 1937 the newspaper reported on the "bridge party and fashion show to be held in the ballroom of the club."

Residents (one shockingly smoking a cigarette) enjoy the "roof garden" in 1940.  photographer unknown, via www.nyc.gov

When the Three Arts Club opened in 1927, The New York Times had remarked that it had a "long waiting list."  Nothing had changed on August 13, 1946, when the newspaper reported that it was completely filled and, "The director...estimates that she has turned away 1,000 girls in the last three months."

The changing mores in the post-World War II years was reflected in a notice in the Columbia Spectator on October 28, 1949.  "The 'Three Arts Club' has extended an invitation to Columbia men to come to an informal dance to be held Saturday night at 340 West 85th Street."  The thought of men milling about in the clubhouse would, no doubt, have prostrated Jane Harris Hall in 1902.  (She would have been even more disturbed to know that the event lasted until 1 a.m.)

Three years later, on July 8, 1952, The New York Times reported that the Three Arts Club, "which for nearly half a century has served as a nonprofit residence for women students of the drama, music and fine arts, will close as of Sept. 1."  The article said the board of managers "will try to sell the eight-story clubhouse."

Their attempts were successful and in November 1952 the building was sold.  The new owners converted the building to the Brandon Residence for Women, catering to students and working women.  But, as had been the case with the Three Arts Clubs, women-only residences were becoming passé and the venture was short lived.

Within a year, 340 West 85th Street was the national headquarters of the Volunteers of America.  Founded in 1896 by Ballington Booth and his wife, Maud, the organization was in the building in time for its busiest time--Christmas.  On November 27, 1953, The New York Times remarked, "The army of Santa Clauses from the Volunteers of America will take over their traditional posts today alongside red chimneys on strategic sites in New York."

The donations went to good use.  On March 7, 1958, for instance, The New York Times reported that the Volunteers of America "provided aid last year for more than 79,000 persons in New York City and Westchester County."  The organization also staged used clothing drives for the needy and hired "many homeless and unemployed people to work in repairing these articles and making them available to the more unfortunate," as worded by National Field Secretary Oliver P. Strickland in March 1959.

The Volunteers of America continued to operate here until 2017, when it sold the building to the West Side Federation for Senior and Supportive Housing.  It accommodated 125 formerly homeless seniors in single-room-occupancy units.

The institution initiated a renovation in May 2026.  The conversion will result in about half of the units.  The 61 affordable studio apartments will continue to house persons over 55 years old with low income.

many thanks to historian Anthony Bellov for suggesting this post

The Lost Gerard W. Morris Mansion - 25 Fifth Avenue

The Morris house is in the center of the frame.  photograph from the collection of the New York Public Library.

Born on July 11, 1799, Gerard Walton Morris had a sterling American pedigree.  His grandfather was Lewis Morris, a United States Senator, a Founding Father, and the last Lord of Morrisania Manor.  His grandmother was Mary Beekman Walton, who came from two distinguished Colonial families. Gerard's father, Richard Valentine Morris, was Commodore of the U.S. Navy and a member of the New York Assembly.

Gerard W. Morris married Martha Pyne on October 8, 1827.  Within the subsequent decade, mansions began appearing along lower Fifth Avenue, sparked by the construction of the Henry and Laura Brevoort house on the northwest corner of Fifth Avenue and West 9th Street in 1834.  Six years later, the Morris family were living in their new brownstone mansion at 25 Fifth Avenue, across from the Brevoorts.

The Drake Mills mansion next door at 23 Fifth Avenue sat upon two building plots, affording a capacious side garden.  Although less sumptuous than the homes of the Brevoort and the Mills families, the Morris house held its own in fashion and luxury.  Four stories tall above an English basement, its cast iron stoop railings sat atop stepped wing walls.  Typical of the Greek Revival style, the entrance was flanked by stone pilasters that upheld a layered entablature.  Also typical was the squat fourth floor that supplanted the dormered, peaked attic of the Federal style, which was quickly becoming passé.  

When the couple moved into their new home, they had eight children.  A ninth, Arthur Rutherford, would arrive in 1846.  The family's country estate was in Morristown, New Jersey.

Gerard Walton Morris (original source unknown)

Tragically, two of the Morris children died in 1850--Anne Walton died on February 22 at the age of 20, and Richard Valentine died the following month, on the 24th, at the age of 11.  The next year, on August 28, Isabella died at the age of 23.

Honora S. Morris was 21 years old in 1852.  Her wedding to wealthy stockbroker Francis Julius Baretto was held in the Church of the Ascension on May 5 that year.  The newlyweds lived in the Fifth Avenue house and at their summer estate, West Farms, in Westchester County.

Honora Morris Barretto (original source unknown)

The church was the scene of another, more somber Morris ceremony the following month.  On June 9, the New York Evening Express reported that Mary Pyne Morris, "wife of Gerard W. Morris of this city, and daughter of the late John Pyne of South Carolina," had died at the age of 46.  Her funeral was held in the Church of the Ascension on the 10th.

The population of the Fifth Avenue mansion quickly grew.  Gerard Morris Barretto, Annie Barretto and Frances Baretto were born in 1853, 1854 and 1857 respectively.  Sadly, little Annie would die two months before her second birthday on September 28, 1856.

(Unusual for the time, none of the many Morris family's funerals were held in the Fifth Avenue parlor, but at the Church of the Ascension.)

The parlors were the scene of a joyous occasion on December 19, 1854 when Mary Morris (known as Minnie) was married to Jonathan Edwards.  (Gerard W. Morris would attend yet another funeral of one of his children three years later when Minnie died at the age of 22.)

In August 1865, Gerard Walton Morris was at West Farms, the summer home of the Barrettos, when he died on July 19 at the age of 67.  His funeral was held in St. Ann's Church in Morrisania, once the familial estate of his ancestors.

Honora Barretto died at the age of 35 in 1866 and Francis Barretto and his children left 25 Fifth Avenue shortly after.  Still living here were bachelor brothers Gerard Walton Morris Jr., who was a lawyer; Henry Walton Morris, and John Pyne Morris.  Their only other surviving sibling was Reverend Arthur Rutherford Morris.  John Pyne Morris had served in the Civil War, attaining the rank of captain.  He would die in 1868.

from the collection of the New York Public Library

The Morris brothers leased their childhood home to Sophia Dye, the widow of George Dye, in 1871.  She operated it as a high-class boarding house, taking in only a handful of boarders at a time.  Among them that first year was merchant James S. Chappel, who would remain at least through 1874.

Sophia Dye continued to lease the mansion until 1881, when it was rented by attorney Henry C. Bowers and his wife, the former Estelle Durant.  In September 1884, Estelle's parents, Charles C. and Margaret L. Durant, moved into the mansion with the couple.  Now retired, Charles had been a banker and the president of the Rock Island Railway.  The New York Times said he had "accumulated a large fortune" and was "now estimated to be worth far more than a million dollars."

The Durants, most likely, moved in with their daughter and son-in-law because Charles was exhibiting an "unsound mind," or what today we would recognize as the symptoms of dementia.  Four months after moving in, in December 1884, Margaret L. Durant died in the residence.

In the spring of 1885, a court deemed Durant incompetent to handle his financial affairs.  Two weeks later, on March 24, Estelle's brother, Howard M. Durant, visited.  He told her that he would like to take their father on a drive.  In fact, he essentially kidnapped him.  Charles Durant never returned to 25 Fifth Avenue and he died the following month.  A bitter court battle among the siblings erupted, each word followed closely by the newspapers.

Around 1895, General Daniel Edgar Sickles purchased and moved into the former Drake Mills house with his wife, Carmina.  At the same time, he purchased 25 Fifth Avenue and rented it to Charles Runyon and his wife, the former Isabel Mercein Fitz Randolph.  

from the collection of the New York Public Library

Born on March 4, 1837, Charles Runyon had a long career in the coal business.  He had been secretary and treasurer of the Superior Mountain Coal Company and was instrumental in organizing the Hoboken Coal Company.  He then founded and was president of the Communipaw Coal Company.  He and Isabel were married in 1864 and they had a daughter and three sons, one of whom, Carmen Randolph, moved into the mansion with his wife, Helen O. Wiley.

Charles Runyon died in the house on October 13, 1903.  Isabel remained in the house with her son and daughter-in-law at least through 1908.  

By 1910, the mansion was once again operated as a high-end boarding house.  The names of the select residents, like the O. Webers, here in 1911, appeared in Dau's New York Blue Book of high society.

By then, Daniel E. Sickles was experiencing money problems.  On October 11, 1912, The New York Times said he had "become involved in further financial difficulties," and reported that he was was far behind in his mortgage payments on the two properties and "owed $11,000 for three years' taxes."  Finally, on August 1, 1914, the newspaper reported that both properties had been sold at auction.  The article disclosed that the corner property "brought $104,850," and 25 Fifth Avenue "went for $37,400."  (The price paid for the former Morris mansion would translate to about $1.2 million in 2026.)

In October 1916, Oak Point Corporation purchased the two properties along with 1 East 9th Street and 27 Fifth Avenue.  They were demolished for a 13-story apartment house completed in 1921, which survives.

photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

The 1826 Abraham B. Vanderpoel House - 38 Dominick Street

 

photo via New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission

In 1821 the by-then fetid canal, originally established to drain the swampy Lispenard Meadow, was covered over, creating Canal Street.  Quickly afterward, streets to the north opened and development began.  Among the first streets to open was Dominick Street, named in honor of George Dominick who fled France in the mid-18th century and became a vestryman of Trinity Church and a captain of the militia.

The new street sat upon land owned by Sarah Livingston, the wife of Robert Livingston.  She had inherited it from her grandfather, Anthony Lispenard.  On March 10, 1826, she sold 12 vacant lots along Dominick Street to Smith Bloomfield who filled them with prim, two-and-a-half story brick-faced homes.  

Among them was 39 Dominick Street.  (Confusingly and inexplicably, the odd and even street numbers were flipped in 1867, and No. 39 got the new address of 38.)  Like its neighbors, its Federal design included a doorway flanked by fluted wooden columns, narrow sidelights and a generous transom.  Two dormers pierced the peaked roof.

Abraham Barent Vanderpoel moved his family into the house in 1827, apparently renting from Bloomfield.  Born in 1788, he listed his profession as "custom house officer."  He and his wife, the former Harriet Goodwin, would have three children: Mary Vanburen, Sarah and Barent. 

The Vanderpoels left the house around 1835, initiating a series of occupants.  Dry goods merchant James L. Brinckerhoff was here in 1836, followed by Isaac N. Seymour and his family by 1840.  Seymour was the treasurer of the Delaware & Hudson Canal Company.  The family remained through 1858.

Abby J. Gorham, a widow, moved into the house in 1859 with her son Shabael C. Gorham.  The family had deep American roots, tracing their origins to John de Gorram who arrived on the Mayflower.  Never married, Shabael died at the age of 41 on November 23, 1861.  The New York Times noted, "Funeral services will be held at the house of his mother, No. 39 Dominick-st., on Monday."

The family of fish dealer Samuel H. Wood occupied the house from 1863 until 1867.  On February 23 that year an announcement in the New-York Tribune reported that the property "now known as No. 38 in Dominick street" would be auctioned.  It was purchased by Samuel Giveans Trusdell.

Trusdell was a partner in the coffee business Trusdell & Phelps.  He married Phebe Jane Edsall in 1863.  Born in 1835 and 1840, respectively, they would have one child, Samuel Edsall, who was born in the house in 1868.

The family would remain here for decades, taking in at least one boarder over the years.  Katie E. Moore lived with the Trusdells in 1884.  She was a teacher in the primary department of Grammar School No. 10 on Wooster Street.

In 1886, the home's Federal architecture was decidedly passé.  On April 3, the Real Estate Record & Guide reported that Phebe (who was the owner of record) had hired architects and builders J. Hankinson's Son to raise the attic to a full story.  The renovations cost the Trusdells $1,100, or about $37,800 in 2026.  Interestingly, while the contractors gave the remodeled house a fashionable Italianate cornice, it did not touch the vintage doorway.

As late as 1940, the doorway, with its slender columns, was essentially unchanged since 1826.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

Samuel Edsall Trusdell died at the age of 28 on April 29, 1896.  His father survived him by four years, dying in the Dominick Street house on December 27, 1900 at the age of 65.  

It is unclear how long Phebe, who died in 1926, remained here.  In 1929, George Tombini leased 38 Dominick Street, and by 1940 the Campone and De Sapio families shared the house.

It was well-filled.  Pasquale Campone and his wife, Antonette, had five children, Rose, Pasquaela, Doris, Betty and Anthony.  Gerard De Sapio was married to Antonette's sister, Marinetta.  An Italian immigrant, he owned a trucking business.  The couple had two sons.

Anthony Capone was born in 1914.  He worked as a shipping clerk for the Equitable Trading Corporation, a wholesale liquor distributor on Hudson Street.  In 1936 he and eight other employees devised a scheme to augment their salaries.  It worked for several years, but then on July 13, 1940, The New York Times reported that the group had been arrested for the theft of "about $50,000 of liquors from the concern in the last four years."

Anthony's cousin would make a name for himself in New York politics.  Born on December 10, 1908, Carmine Gerard De Sapio attended St. Alphonsus parochial school and briefly attended Fordham College.  He often loaded freight at his father's business.  While in his teens, he contracted iritis, an inflammation of the eyes.  It necessitated his wearing dark glasses for the rest of his life, and they became his trademark.

The teen became involved with the Daniel Finn's Huron Club in Greenwich Village.  It was a center of Tammany power within the district.  De Sapio became Finn's "lieutenant."   By 1937, he had amassed enough power within Tammany to organize the Tamawa Club, challenging Finn's leadership in the district.  

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

Carmine De Sapio married Theresa Natale in 1937 and he moved out of 38 Dominick Street.  By 1949 he was the "boss" of Tammany Hall.  His downfall came in the 1960s when, according to The New York Times, "Denounced as corrupt and authoritarian, he was abandoned by onetime allies."  In 1969 he was sent to prison, convicted of bribery charges.

In 1954, the Capone and De Sapio families converted the ground floor to a restaurant.  When Marinetta De Sapio died at the age of 76 on October 25, 1965, The New York Times remarked that she had lived "for many years at 38 Dominick Street."

Around 1987, the restaurant space became Sagebrush Canyon, which featured live jazz music.  By then, the ground floor windows had been replaced by a single opening.  

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

The restaurant Alison on Dominick Street opened in 1990, its atmosphere described by The New York Times as "harmonious and comfortable and the soft lighting very seductive."  It remained until 2002.

The four 1826 houses were considered for landmark designation in 2012.  No. 38 is at the right.  photograph by Jason Kessler

A renovation completed in 2010 returned 38 Dominick Street to a single family home.  As a nod to the now lost Federal-style doorway, two disproportionate Ionic columns were shoehorned into the entrance.  Today its entablature is inscribed "Post Modern" in Greek lettering.

photograph by Jason Kessler

It and the other three remaining houses of Smith Bloomfield's 1826 row were considered by the Landmark Preservation Commission for landmark designation in May 2012.  The owners of No. 38 strongly testified against its designation, citing the drastic alterations to the nearly 200-year-old building.  The LPC agreed and only 32 to 36 Dominick Street were given landmark status.

many thanks to reader Jason Kessler for suggesting this post

The 1891 Hotel Renaissance (Columbia Club) - 4 West 43rd Street

 

photo by Anthony Bellov

Even as he and Bruce Price were designing part of David H. King Jr.'s ambitious "King's Model Houses" in Harlem, Clarence S. Luce was working on another project for the developer--an upscale residential hotel in Midtown.  As the Renaissance Hotel neared completion on August 16, 1891, The New York Times called it, "an ornament to the city" and described it as, "magnificent."

The article began saying, "One of the handsomest and most interesting buildings in the city is the new Hotel Renaissance, in West Forty-third Street, near Fifth Avenue."  The journalist described the style as "a type of the Renaissance with pronounced American interpretations."  Anticipating skyscraper technology, Luce employed an iron skeleton "and hollow terra-cotta brick, strong and light."  The article said the foundations were "like the grave of a tavern keeper's wife, 'both wide and deep.'"  

Luce faced the two-story rusticated base with marble, "calculated to reflect the general renaissance style."  It was dominated by the Caen marble entrance, designed as a double-height porch with paired columns.  

photo by Anthony Bellov

The four-story midsection was faced in tan brick and trimmed in limestone.  The windows of the fifth floor imitated Renaissance balconies, with stone balustrades and engaged columns that upheld arched, shell-filled pediments.  Extravagantly decorated terra cotta panels separated the top floor openings, and a stone balustrade sat upon the overhanging cornice.

Guests entered into a "round arched vestibule" wainscoted in "marble in beautiful tints," as described by The New York Times, and the walls were frescoed.  On either side were the reception room and a cafe, "both of them large and handsomely-decorated saloons [i.e., rooms]."  The vestibule led to the "main hall" and the courtyard, around which the principal ground floor rooms were arranged.  The courtyard featured a fountain surrounded with "growing flowers and tropical plants."  The result, said the writer, was "an effect similar to the interiors of the most celebrated structures of this class in Florence, Paris, and Madrid."  Interior balconies at the second floor were available to all residents from which to enjoy the courtyard's afternoon and evening music.

Residential hotels differed from apartment buildings in that the suites did not have kitchens.  Guests, who signed months- or years-long leases, ate in a large communal dining room, similar to an elegant restaurant.  All the amenities of a transient hotel (like maid service, for instances) were provided by the management.

Also on the ground floor were four private dining rooms, two each on either side of the courtyard.  "From the Florentine galleries that separate the private dining rooms from the court yard, the main dining room in the back of the building is reached," said the article.  The reporter deemed it, "one of the handsomest dining halls in the country."  Engulfing the entire 125-foot width of the building, it was visually broken up by "mural arches" that gave the impression of three rooms "thrown into one."  The Times said, "The ornamentation of this room is in the highest form of the frescoer's art."  (The article mentioned that King had hired "one of the best chefs of Paris.")

The walls of the first floor rooms were decorated with hand-decorated Louis XV-style panels.  The private dining room walls, however, were covered in silk and the furnishings were "in the style of the empire."  The motif was carried into the two oval elevators, which were "finished in gold and Vernis Martin, with painted panels and Louis XV decorations."

The New York Times, October 6, 1891 (copyright expired)

Each of the apartments looked onto the courtyard.  The New York Times explained, "Each suite is entered from the hall through a private vestibule, thus insuring perfect privacy for all."

The Hotel Renaissance opened on October 1, 1891.  It was patronized by some of Manhattan's wealthiest citizens, either as their permanent city residence or during the winter season.  Among them were James and Sarah Roosevelt and their son, Franklin.  In her Franklin and Eleanor, An Extraordinary Marriage, Hazel Rowley writes:

Franklin and his parents (accompanied by servants and tutors) spent time in New York City, where they had an apartment at the Renaissance Hotel, on West Forty-third Street.

C. Grayson Martin purchased the Hotel Renaissance following David H. King Jr.'s death in April 1916.  He quickly swapped it with George N. and Julius Black for the X. Y. Ranch in Colorado.  On January 17, 1917, The New York Sun said the 5,000-acre X. Y. Ranch was "one of the best known ranches in the West."  The value of the Hotel Renaissance was estimated at $1 million, or about $24.5 million in 2026.

The Black brothers closed the Hotel Renaissance and leased the property to the Columbia University Club, which had been located at Gramercy Park for more than a decade.  The club hired architects Henry F. Hornbostel, Kenneth MacKenzie Murchison, and Alger C. Gildersleeve to convert the hotel to a clubhouse.  

A year and "more than $100,000" later, almost to the day, The New York Times reported on January 27, 1918 that the renovations were completed and the opening would be celebrated by a dinner on February 7.  It said the architects had "transformed it into one of the best-equipped clubs in the Forty-second Street club centre."  

The New York Herald explained that the upper floors now contained 104 rooms "for members who wish to live at the club."  There were also exercising rooms, baths, and four squash courts on the roof.  The "immense dining room," said the article, which was designed by Hornbostel, "is in simple white stone, with great light brackets in silver and a frieze that includes some paintings of scenes of the Columbia campus as it is to-day and was in the days of Hamilton."  (The frieze was executed by muralist James M. Hewlett.)  Also on the ground floor were "lunch rooms and private dining rooms," according to the New York Herald.  A large library on the second floor could also be used for meetings.

photo by Anthony Bellov

College life throughout America was disrupted by the country's entry into World War I.  On April 5, 1918, a service flag was raised above the clubhouse and on November 10 that year, the university's president, Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler and Major Herbert C. Earnshaw, Commandant of the Students' Army Training Camp, spoke here.  "The war activities of the college will be the subject," announced The New York Times.

Shortly after the end of the war another issue--Prohibition--would rock the organization.  On the "first bone-dry prohibition day," as worded by The New York Times, an announcement informed members "that afternoon tea will now be a feature of the club's gayeties."  The article then reported on a serious side effect of the law's enactment.  "Prohibition...has also made it necessary to practically double the annual dues."

Prohibition crippled the finances of hotels, clubs and restaurants.  The condition was no doubt a major factor in the club's decision to alter the ground floor to provide additional income.  On October 1, 1922, the New York Herald reported, "The Columbia University Club will install stores in the club property...All but 25 of the 125 feet of frontage of their building will be changed on the grade floor into business use."  The practical renovation unfortunately greatly decimated Luce's Italian palazzo design.

Over the years, the Columbia University Club was home to distinguished alumni.  Among them were prominent architect Henry Rutgers Marshall; poet, novelist and editor Henry Morton Robinson; and retired Brigadier General Rodney Hamilton Smith.

One of the most colorful residents was William Cullen Bryant Kemp, described on the Columbia campus as the "perpetual student."  As a young man, Kemp was attending Columbia when his uncle left him $2,500 a year "as long as he remained at school."  (The income would equal about $50,000 a year today.)  He took the wording seriously and earned his first degree, a Bachelor of Arts, in 1868.  He continued to matriculate at Columbia, earning a list of degrees that included A.M.,  M.D.,  LL.M., LL.B, Ph.D., C.E., E.E., Mechanical Engineering, Pharmaceutical Engineering, and a B.S.  Kemp was living here on February 3, 1929 when he died at the age of 79.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

In 1922, although Prohibition was still in effect, the Columbia University Club hired Irish-born Michael J. Dunne as its head bartender (presumably dispensing sodas, iced tea and such).  Although his only education was from an Irish primary school, he was a voracious reader.  The New York Times remarked that he, "could converse on a variety of topics with the many men of distinction who patronized his bar."

The members called Dunne "Serjeant," the title bestowed only on the highest class of barristers in England.  In 1960, author Henry Morton Robinson presided over a "large gathering in the club," as described by The New York Times, during which Dunne received the degree of D.D.L.," Doctor of Delectable Libations, and a scroll.

The following year, Dunn visited his birthplace, Engfield, County Meath, Ireland.  On his trip he became ill.  He made it back home before dying at the age of 71 on August 15, 1961.  He had held his position at the club for 39 years.

On February 13, 1973, the club's board of governors voted unanimously to sell the 43rd Street building.  John Reeves, the group's president, explained that the maintenance "had become too expensive for the needs of the 1,500 members."  The club moved into the Princeton Club at 15 West 43rd Street.

The former Columbia University Club building sat vacant for slightly more than two years before a buyer was found.  On May 7, 1975, The New York Times reported, "The Rev. Sun Myung Moon's Unification Church has purchased the former Columbia University Club building at 4 West 43d Street for use as its American headquarters."  The church had paid $1.2 million (about $7 million today) for the property.  A spokesperson said, "the upper floors would be used to house about 50 staff members and their families.

photo by Anthony Bellov

The Holy Spirit Association-Unification of World Christianity continues to use the building for its headquarters.  It, additionally, offers rental offices to non-profit organizations, and large spaces for events.

many thanks to historian Anthony Bellov for suggesting this post