Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Former Proskurover Zion Congregation - 431 East 6th Street


photograph by Carole Teller

In 1851, the family of Joseph Oehrlein lived in the newly completed flat house at 90 Sixth Street.  (The address would undergo several changes--it would be renumbered 96 Sixth Street in 1851, to 431 Sixth Street in 1868, and by the turn of the century the "East" would be added to the address.)  Like the other flat (or apartment) buildings along the block, it was likely designed in the Italianate style.

Joseph Oehrlein listed his profession variously as musician, singer and teacher of music.  He and his wife had at least one son, Joseph Jr.  Also living in the building in 1851 were Adam Lofferholz, a locksmith; police officer Luke Usher; and the family of carpenter Abraham Seaton.

The Musical Review & World July 30, 1864 (copyright expired)

The Oehrlein family remained here at least through 1864, by which time Joseph Jr. was working as a clerk.    

Around 1867, Valentine Kaemmerer moved his family into the building and converted the ground floor to a German meeting hall named Beethoven Hall.  The Beethoven Maennerchor, a singing group, was organized on August 16, 1859 and had 75 members, many of whom "are well-trained singers," according to the New York Herald.  Other men's singing groups also met here.  On May 17, 1869, The New York World reported on the city's various "German vocal societies."  The long list explained "what they are called and where they meet."  On the list was the Rheinischer Saengerbund, which met at "Beethoven Hall, 431 Sixth street, Saturdays."  Another group on the list was the Uhlandbund, "in honor of a German poet Uhland," said the article.  It met at 431 Sixth Street on Mondays and Thursdays. 

Kaemmerer also provided entertainment to the public.  On April 25, 1869, the New York Herald reported on the "principal places of summer resort for our German population."  In addition to the music or beer halls, however, there were "places equally inviting, because of their cheapness and because they contribute to enhance social enjoyment."  Listed among the latter grouping was "Kaemmerer's Beethoven Hall, No. 431 Sixth street." 

On June 28, 1870, the New York Herald reported, "A stranger passing through the east side of the city yesterday, from Houston street to Tenth, and from Second avenue to Avenue B, would have thought that it was a grand holiday.  The streets were crowded with Germans, and every window on the route had a German and American flag floating in the breeze."

The event was the cornerstone laying of a new Beethoven Hall.  "A multitude of Germans had assembled at 431 Sixth street, when, at about 2 o'clock, Sheriff James O'Brien arrived and received a hearty welcome from the members of the Maennerchor."  A procession wound through the East Village streets to the site.

Following the completion of the new Beethoven Hall, newspapers referred  to 431 East Sixth Street as "Little Beethoven Hall" or "Kaemmerer's Beethoven Hall."  With the musical groups gone, the hall became a popular venue for political meetings. 

As early as the fall of 1886, Charles Dudenhausen was the hall's proprietor.  It was the meeting place of the Joe Hooker Post, a veteran group.  On November 7, the New York Dispatch reported, "A pound party and hop will be given at Dudenhausen's Beethoven Hall, No. 431 Sixth street, on next Saturday evening, by the comrades of Joe Hooker Post."  The article noted, "Comrade Jos. Nohles's Band will furnish the music."  (A "pound party" was a gathering to which each attendee or couple brought a pound of foodstuffs like coffee, sugar, flour and such.  The staples were then distributed among the needy in the community.  A "hop" was a dance.)

The hall continued to host political meetings.  On January 11, 1894, The New York Sun reported that a meeting of "anti-Patterson Republicans" had met "at Little Beethoven Hall, 431 Sixth street."  The article described the group as "anti-machine Republicans."

Over the coming decades, the changing demographics of the neighborhood were reflected in the activities here.  By 1905, the Magyar Roosevelt Club, a Hungarian Republican club, held its meetings here.  On March 17, 1906, the group unveiled a portrait of President Theodore Roosevelt.  The New-York Tribune reported, "The portrait, half length, was painted by Julius Tammasy, a young Hungarian artist, who recently came to the country."

Major change came in 1927.  On February 5, the Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported that architect Philip Bardes had completed plans to renovate 431 East 6th Street to "a four-story brick store, synagogue and residence...for the Center of Prosgurever [sic] Zion Congregation."  The alterations would cost the congregation the equivalent of $371,000 in 2026.

The Proskurover Zion Congregation was founded in 1900 by 20 young immigrants from Proskurov in western Ukraine.  Bardes stripped off the facade and replaced it with Flemish bond beige brick.  His vaguely neo-Classic design included arched openings at the first and second floors.  The tympana of first floor windows were inscribed with Magen Davids, and between the French windows of the second floor were stone tablets carved with menorahs.  A stone plaque above the doorway was inscribed in English and Hebrew, "Center of the Proskurover Zion Congregation."  Atop the brick-and-stone parapet was a rod-supported Magen David.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

The New York Times was not especially complimentary to the synagogue in its article on May 5, 1958.  "A proud and once warlike people honored their dead yesterday in a dingy hall on East Sixth Street.  Members of the Cossack community met to honor cavalry men who fell in battle with Bolshevik forces."  The article noted, "The day was chosen because on May 4, 1918, regiments of Don Cossacks under General of Cavalry Peter Popoff captured Novocherkassk, the capital of the State of the Army of the Don, from the Communists."

At some point in the third quarter of the century, the Proskurover Zion Congregation quietly left 431 East 6th Street.  On December 30, 2015, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported that Rabbi Michael Strassfeld had been researching the congregation.  The article said he, "has been unable to gather any more details about the congregation (when did it shut its doors?)."

What is certain is that in 1988 the building was converted to loft residents by a group of artists.  An art gallery was installed in the cellar.  There were now two apartments on the first floor and one each on the upper stories.  In the process, the Magen Davids were filled in on the first floor and the menorahs shaved off on the second.  The Star of David above the parapet was, as well, removed.  Oddly enough, the panel above the entranceway was not erased.

photograph by Carole Teller

Among the early residents was photographer William Wegman.  Born in 1943, he was perhaps best known for his compositions of posed dogs in various costumes.

William Wegman and two of his dogs in front of a few of his works.  from the collection of the Library of Congress.

In 2015, Peter Kohn, described by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency as "a veteran construction supervisor," inspected a vacant six-story office building on the Upper West Side.  In the basement, his flashlight illuminated a pair of large tablets leaning against the wall.  The marble slabs were engraved with Yiddish lettering.  Hoping to prevent their ending up in a landfill, Kohn took photographs and looked for someone who could identify them.  The newspaper reported, "They were from the Proskurover Zion Congregation, a long-defunct congregation in the East Village."

The translated inscriptions revealed that they were "mostly lists of names of members of, and contributors to, the shul and its women's auxiliary," said the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.  They were entrusted to Rabbi Michael Strassford.  The article explained that the retired leader was "best known as an author of the series of 'Jewish Catalog' do-it-yourself guides to Jewish life in the 1970s [and who] collects such artifacts."

The menorahs were shaved off the panels flanking the second floor window.  photograph by Carole Teller

The grossly unsympathetic replacement windows, entrance door and painting of the first floor masonry are regrettable.  Nevertheless, its rescue by the 1988 group of artists is laudable.

many thanks to artist Carole Teller for suggesting this post

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

George F. Pelham's 1902 El Casco Court - 205 West 103rd Street


photograph by Anthony Bellov

Born in Castelmezzano, Italy, Canios Vincent and Joseph Paternò were the sons of a building contractor, Giovanni 
Paternò.  Upon his death, they took over his real estate business (Canios having Anglicized his name to Charles by then).  Early in their career, in 1902, they erected a sprawling apartment building at 205-209 West 103rd Street between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue.

Costing $150,000 to erect (about $5.79 million in 2026), the six-story, U-shaped structure was the work of architect George F. Pelham.  His four-level, Renaissance Revival design included a rusticated stone base.  The upper three sections were faced in beige brick and trimmed in limestone and terra cotta.  The second and sixth floor windows were framed with modified Gibbs surrounds and connected by decorative terra cotta bands.  Those of the three-story midsection wore splayed stone lintels with prominent scrolled keystones.  The paneled fascias of the robust cornices featured lions' heads.  

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

The building's U-shape provided additional ventilation and light to the apartments.  The entrance was nestled far back between the two wings, its off-set doorway flanked by polished stone Ionic pilasters.  The framework of intricate Renaissance carvings were the sole decoration of the otherwise spartan entrance court.

photograph by Anthony Bellov

Apartments in the El Casco Court ("The Helmet") ranged from three to six rooms with a bath, with rents equaling $1,300 to $2,000 per month today.  They attracted middle- to upper-middle-class families.

Buildings like this saw canvas awnings installed over the windows in the spring and removed in the fall.  They shaded the apartments from heat and protected expensive upholstery from damaging sunlight.  The process was dangerous.  On October 11, 1907, Richard Pieble and William Ray were removing the awnings.  Ray was working at the fourth floor and Pieble was directly below him.  The New York Times reported that the 32-year-old Ray, "lost his balance and fell."  The "full weight of the man's body" landed on Richard Pieble "and both were thrown to the sidewalk."  William Ray died later in the hospital, while Pieble "escaped with a laceration of the forehead," said the article.

Mrs. Florence Brewster Hudnall, who lived here as early as 1908, was a celebrity of sorts.  She was the New York City leader of the New Thought movement--the philosophy that maintained that mental and spiritual alignment and diet could substantially extend one's life.  The Evening World columnist Rose C. Tillotson visited Hudnall in her El Casco Court apartment on April 7.  Florence told her in part:

There is no reason why women should grow old.  When the Consciousness of Infinite Union is learned one may aspire to become one hundred and in order to accomplish this a pink diaphragm should be cultivated.

When Rose Tillotson asked how a woman could acquire a pink diaphragm, Florence quickly responded, "Drink sour milk."  She then expounded, "A diet of onions, carrots, cabbages and apples, and plenty of sour milk will produce wonderful changes in the appearance of the aging man or woman."

George Henry's outward profession was "a horse dealer," according to the New-York Tribune.  The New York Times called him "a wealthy turfman."  More importantly he was the head of an extensive policy business in the rear of a saloon on the Bowery.  (Policy rackets were a version of a numbers game or illegal lottery that preyed on the desperate poor.)  Al Adams had been known as the "Policy King" until his suicide in 1906.  George Henry's operation, according to police, was "a continuation of that conducted by 'Al' Adams."

George Henry's illegal and lucrative operation ended with a raid on February 11, 1909.  He and three cronies were arrested.  In a safe in the saloon's backroom, officers found $250,000--more than $9 million today.  Henry's operation was vast.  The New-York Tribune reported, "The books indicate that this saloon was the headquarters of the business of policy drawings, not only for this city, but for points as far West as Wisconsin."
 
A much more respectable resident was Casper William Dean, whose family lived here by 1911.  Dean was born in 1844 in Milan, Ohio.  He earned his civil engineer degree from Kenyon College and married Margaret H. Sweeny in 1881.  The couple came to New York city in 1901.  He co-founded the Dean & Westbrook engineer firm, which was later renamed the C. W. Dean Company.

On the afternoon of April 4, 1911, Dean was sitting as his desk "talking with some of the head clerks," as reported by the New-York Tribune.  He suffered a heart attack and died "in his office chair."  

Residents of El Casco Court maintained at least one servant.  Mrs. Laura E. Gibson worked as a maid for the Eugene B. Heath family.  She had a husband and child in Johnstown, Pennsylvania.  Absence, in her instance, did not make the heart grow fonder and Laura Gibson fell in love with a young policeman, James Bradley, who lived in the Bronx.

When Bradley did not show up for duty on December 5, 1913, an officer went to his home.  Policeman Beyer found the doors and window shutters of the "small frame cottage" locked.  He pried open a shutter and saw the bodies of Bradley and Laura Gibson in the kitchen.  The New York Sun reported, "Both bodies were fully dressed except that Bradley had removed his collar and coat.  His coat, nightstick and revolver were on a chair and on a table lay the woman's hat, coat and muff and two diamond rings."

Evidence suggested that Laura had poisoned them with hydrocyanic acid.  "A half emptied decanter of whiskey stood on the table," said the article.  Also on the table were eggs and milk, a common antidote.  Investigators surmised that the unmarried Bradley suddenly realized what Laura had done and tried, too late, to reverse the poison.

Bachelor attorney Leo Fassler lived here at the time of the tragedy.  Among his clients was Frances P. S. Oakley, the widow of John B. H. Oakley and the daughter of Egbert B. Seaman, a co-founder of the Mason-Seaman Transportation Company.  Fassler (and presumably Mrs. Oakley) were surprised when Egbert Seaman's will was read in July 1914.  It said in part, according to the New York Herald, "Mrs. Frances P. S. Oakley, is to be cut off from her share of the $150,000 estate if she marries Leo Fassler."

The New York Herald said that Fassler's friends confirmed that "the only relations between him and Mrs. Oakley...have been those of attorney and client."  Fassler, who was told of the provisions from a reporter from The Sun, suggested that Seaman was unbalanced, saying, "he freely forgives Mr. Seaman because he is dead and does not believe he would have made any reference to him in the will had he known what he was doing."  Fassler added, "I don't know why he did that.  Certainly he couldn't disgrace me."

Among Fassler's neighbors in the building were H. Douglas, a "prominent insurance man," according to the New-York Tribune, and his wife, the former Helen Potter.  Helen, a former actress, had been secretly seeing another man, Hoboken liquor dealer Joseph Mogha.  The affair became apparent when Mogha showed up to their apartment on August 12, 1915.  Helen appeared in night court on August 17, charging that Mogha "threatened her and her husband with death...unless she eloped with him."

The previous day, Helen had seen Mogha "near her apartment again" and, fearing another scene, had him arrested.  She told the court, "He made so much noise that the entire house was aroused.  Finally he was made to leave the building, but not before he threatened the superintendent with death also."

Helen had to admit that "she had known Magha for several years and had visited Coney Island with him many times, as well as cafes about town," reported the New-York Tribune.  The magistrate asked, "Did your husband know you were going to these amusement resorts with this man?"

"Certainly not," she replied.

"Why did you do this?" he asked.

Helen did not answer.  And her character was even more injured by Joseph Mogha's testimony.  He told the court:

I met her one night at a cabaret.  She had beckoned me to come over to her box, and we had some cocktails.  I got to know her better as time went on and we went out together quite frequently.  She told me that she was a married woman.

Mogha was found guilty on disorderly conduct and ordered "not to visit Mrs. Potter for three months."  The Potters' marriage, one assumes, was over.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Born in New York City on May 20, 1852, William Ryerson King and his wife, the former Margaret J. King, had three children, Ethel M., Olive J. and Percy.  In 1879, King joined the Standard Oil Company as a salesman and ascended through the ranks.  In 1914, he was promoted to vice president in charge of the domestic operations of the firm.

Despite the family's comfortable financial status, William R. King took public transportation to his office.  On the morning of December 30, 1919, he purchased his ticket at the 103rd Street subway station and moments later was seen leaning against the wall at the end of the platform.  According to the New-York Tribune, he suddenly dropped to the floor.  The article said "a large crowd surrounded Mr. King's body."  A policeman called for an ambulance, but King was dead before it arrived.

The New-York Tribune reported, "At the home of Percy King, the financier's son, who is also well known in Wall Street as a lawyer, it was said that the probable cause of Mr. King's death was cerebral hemorrhage."  Margaret King survived him by nearly seven years, dying on June 25, 1926.

At the time of William King's death, Dr. Samuel J. Einstein and his wife, Rose, occupied an apartment here.  The couple was married in 1901 and had two children, Edward, born in 1905, and Florence, born in 1908.  The dentist and his wife lived happily, according to Rose, until 1913, when another woman came between them.

Rose sued Mary Benzur, the wife of furrier John Benzur, for $25,000 "for alienation of the affections of her husband," reported the New-York Tribune on May 16, 1914.  Benzur, on the other hand, accused the Einsteins of concocting a blackmail plot.  She said that Rose Einstein had repeatedly demanded "large sum of money to suppress an impending 'scandal,'" said the article.  Mary Benzur's vitriol was not restricted to Rose.  The New-York Times reported, "Mrs. Benzur denies that she ever had any interest in Einstein, except as one of his patients, paying him large fees for his work on her teeth."

As it turned out, Mary Benzur's story would have a tragic ending.  The following year, on October 18, 1915, John Benzur sent his clerk, Charles Dappel, to the couple's apartment "to fetch his employer's eyeglasses," according to the New York Herald.  Dappel smelled gas as he approached the apartment.  He found Mary Benzur unconscious.  Three physicians and an ambulance surgeon frantically worked on her, but "Mrs. Benzur was beyond aid," said the article, which added, "It was said that she had lost a brother in the war recently."

The Musician, October 1920 (copyright expired)

The El Casco Court continued to be home to respectable, middle-class residents in the coming decades, like operatic soprano Anna Eugénie Schoen-René whose apartment doubled as her studio for voice students in the 1920s.

Anna was born in Koblenz, Germany in 1864.  Her father, Baron von Schoen, was a Court Councilor to the Emperor.  She later added her mother's maiden name to her surname.  She studied voice in the Royal Academy of Music in Berlin and debuted as Cherubino in The Marriage of Figaro in Paris.  Her first appearance at the Metropolitan Opera came in 1892.  A bout of tuberculosis ended her singing career and she turned to coaching.  Among her students were Risë Stevens, Paul Robeson, Eva Gauthier, Kitty Carlisle and Margaret Harshaw.

photograph by Anthony Bellov

In 1988, El Casco Court was converted to a cooperative.  It was possibly at this time that the cornices were removed.  Otherwise, the exterior of the building is relatively unchanged since its opening in 1902.

photograph by Dayle Vander Sande

many thanks to reader Anthony Bellov for suggesting this post

Monday, November 16, 2026

The Lost Steinway & Sons Factory - Park Avenue and 52nd Street


Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)

Heinrich Engellhardt Steinweg invented a small piano for his son in 1834, using a combination of German and English construction methods.  It drew attention of musicians and sparked a massive change in his family's lives.  Upon arriving in New York in 1850, Steinweg anglicized his name to Henry Engelhardt Steinway.  In March 1853, he and sons Charles and Henry Jr. established Steinway & Sons in "a curiously small edifice in Varick-street," according to The New York Times later.  The workrooms turned out one instrument a week.  Henry's grandson, William (son of Henry Jr.) was admitted to the firm in 1856.

William Steinway was highly involved in the German music association, the Liederkranz Society.  Equally active in the group was architect Louis Burger (both men would be elected president).  It was likely that this close relationship resulted in Burger's being commissioned to design a new Steinway & Sons factory uptown.

At the time of William's joining the firm, the firm had exploded in business.  With a reputation of creating high-quality instruments, Steinway & Sons was emerging as a world-class piano maker.  The chosen site for the factory was the block of Fourth Avenue (later Park Avenue) and Lexington Avenue, and from 52nd to 53rd Streets.  Ground was broken in 1859 and construction completed the following year.  On September 1, 1860, The New York Times remarked, "The cost of the building and ground is about $150,000."  The figure would translate to about $6 million in 2026.

Burger created an inverted L-shaped building in the Italianate style.  Four and five stories tall, the Fourth Avenue front was divided into nine three-bay wide sections.  Eight were identical, their rows of repeated elliptically arched windows capped with hefty brick lintels.  The central section relieved the monotony, rising above the roofline with a gable outlined with arched, brick corbels.  Here the openings were fully arched and two decorative balconies added flair.

Cartographer William Parris's 1862 Fire Insurance Map shows the original L-shaped footprint.  Notice the Steinway lumber yards across East 53rd Street.  (copyright expired)

In the rear yard were outbuildings, like the four drying houses where "about 240,000 feet of lumber [are] constantly under the process of kiln-drying," reported Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper on September 22, 1860.  

Part of the basement was devoted to "all the iron-work, places and bars, drilling-machines, japanning works, and the rosewood veneers."  

Workers busy in the finishing department where the empty cabinets still sit on sawhorses.  Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)

Other departments included planers, case-makers, a varnishing room ("where every case remains from three to four months, to be thoroughly varnished," according to The New York Times), the sounding-board floor, and a floor where "the instruments are strung, the action and key-boards fitted in, and the tops, legs, and lyres adjusted and put on."  There were also a department for finishing and polishing, and a salesroom.   

Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper deemed the new factory "magnificent" and reported on a particular innovation, the "telltale clocks."  Placed at the far ends of the building, the two clocks tested "the trustworthiness of the night watchman."  The clocks were connected to stations throughout the building, "and if they are not touched at certain intervals the watcher has neglected his rounds, and the tale is recorded on the faces of the dials," said the article.

The factory communicated with the Steinway salesroom on Walter Street by a private, short-distance telegraph.  (The distance would be shortened in 1863 when Steinway & Sons erected its new building at 109 East 14th Street.)

Smart carriages with well-dressed visitors arrive to the factory's opening on August 31, 1860.  from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

Steinway & Sons opened its new factory on August 31, 1860.  The New York Times reported, There was a large and very respectable number of visiters [sic] present."  Musicians were on hand to demonstrate the various pianos.

Visitors to the opening listen to a pianist demonstrating a Steinway grand piano.  Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)


The New York Times reported on September 1, 1860 that the 350 skilled craftsmen "turn out about thirty square and five grand pianos every week" from the new factory.  But within only three years, the facility was inadequate.  On May 10, 1864, according to The New York Times, Steinway & Sons simultaneously opened its new East 14th Street showroom and "an additional wing to their factory."  Now, said the article, it forms "three sides of a square" and noted, "They employ many hundred hands, and use all the labor-saving machinery that has yet been discovered by themselves or others, to expedite the various processes."  Steinway & Sons was now, said The New York Times, "the largest piano-forte makers in the world."

The new wing extended along East 52nd Street. Valentine's Manual of Old New York, 1919 (copyright expired) 

Always innovating, in 1878 Steinway & Sons introduced its Parlor Grand.  At six-feet long, it was 12-inches shorter than a regulation grand piano.  On December 23, the New-York Express reported, "This new style, lately introduced, has created a genuine sensation in musical circles at home and abroad, and the demand is so large that the Steinways cannot promptly supply enough of them."  The article noted in an exhausting run-on sentence:

Steinway & Sons are the only manufacturers who make every part and particle used in the construction of a piano, from the iron plate of a grand piano to the smallest hitch-pin for the strings, in their own factory, which is now conceded to be not only the most perfectly-arranged, but by far the most extensive establishment of its kind in existence, supplying these standard pianos to all parts of the civilized world.

The Steinway factory was a strictly non-union establishment.  Its highly-skilled craftsmen were well-treated.  Nevertheless, other labor groups targeted the factory during their own strikes.  In June 1872, for instance, the furniture-maker union went on strike, headed by the "Eight Hour Men," who demanded that work days be reduced from ten to eight hours.  On June 13, things got ugly.  The New-York Tribune reported that "between 200 and 300 strikers surrounded the factory," noting that, "The crowd was largely composed of men who did not represent the piano-forte trade."  The newspaper added, "as there was a rumored intention to destroy the building, the police of the Nineteenth Precinct were called out."

In 1882, a strike that did involve the Steinway workers took place, and its cause was surprising.  The New-York Tribune explained, "They were not dissatisfied with their wages; but they did not like one of the bookkeepers."  The workers demanded that the bookkeeper be fired.  When that did not happen, a group of employees walked out.  

On November 21, the New-York Tribune reported, "This was nine weeks ago, in nice, pleasant weather, when idleness was delightful."  Steinway & Sons retained its bookkeeper but fired the strikers.  Now, said the article, "finally the cold weather has forced the strikers to beg for work.  The bookkeeper is not discharged.  They have gained nothing.  What is worse, they probably have learned nothing."  The workers were given their jobs back, but the newspaper was distinctly unsympathetic.  "This was clearly a case where the men should have been kept out in the cold."

In the meantime, on June 22, 1875, the New-York Tribune reported on the progress of the "sinking" of the Fourth Avenue railroad tracks.  The locomotives that ran down the middle of the avenue had belched smoke and cinders and made the thoroughfare undesirable for residential use.  "The work of sinking the track was begun in the Fall of 1872," said the article.  Now, "the first train to run all the way from the Grand Central Depot to the Harlem River upon the sunken tracks" had taken place two days earlier.  The "improvement" would greatly affect the Steinway & Sons factory location.

On December 2, 1904, the New-York Tribune reported on a rumor that the New-York Central Railroad had purchased the factory property "for the purpose of carrying out its plans for bettering the Grand Central Station" neighborhood.  Charles H. Steinway replied that the factory had stood "for the last fifty years, and I think it is likely to be on the site for fifty more years."

But on June 13, 1909, The Sun remarked, "Since the locomotive was banished from the New York Central tunnel a number of costly private dwellings have been erected in the avenue and many more will of course be built there."  The article reported that E. Clifford Potter had purchased the Steinway factory property.  "When the new owner obtains possession next year the block will no doubt be cut up into sites for private dwellings or elevator apartment houses," said the article.

Steinway & Sons erected a sprawling facility in Long Island City.  On November 19, 1910, The New York Times reported that the firm had vacated the Park Avenue site and E. Clifford Potter would "devote the entire plot to one or more large apartment houses."  The massive Montana apartment building, known as "the House of Millionaires," according to The Edison Monthly in October 1919, replaced the factory.  (It survived until 1954, replaced by the Seagram Building.)

photo by Wurts Bros, from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The 1928 Art Deco 3 East 84th Street


 photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

In 1924, 43-year-old architect Raymond M. Hood anticipated the Art Deco style with his stylized neo-Gothic skyscraper, the American Radiator Building.  Three years later, his design for a nine-story-and-penthouse apartment building for publisher Joseph Medill Patterson would be full-blown Art Deco.  Hood worked in association with John M. Howells on the design.  Known only by its address, 3 East 84th Street, the building is faced in limestone.  Vertical, full-height bays draw the eye upward to the geometric shapes and setbacks that would inspire Hollywood set designers a decade later.

Hood placed the entrance under a frieze of zig-zagging, Mayan-inspired carvings.  The motif was echoed in large, pressed metal spandrel panels and in the geometric grills that fronted the single set of French windows on each floor.


Completed in 1928 at a cost of $275,000 (about $5 million in 2026), the building won the American Institute of Architects award for "the best apartment house over six stories" that year.  At the awards dinner, Philip L. Goodwin, unfamiliar with the still new "Art Deco" term, struggled to pin down the style.  He said in part that the building:

...is in the modified form of the so-called modern style.  By this I mean that is has no cornice, a setback and the treatment of the spandrels between the windows is simple, with such decoration as there is, of a non-historical sort.  In order words, Messrs. Hood and Howells, the architects, have designed the building of modern materials and ornamented it with design invented by themselves, and not gotten out of a book.

Each apartment contained ten rooms and engulfed an entire floor.  Rents started at $4,000 per year--about $8,250 per month in today's money.  Decades later, in 1995, architectural journalist Christopher Gray would comment, "The interior was also surprising, a wild combination [of] abstract patterns  and ornament--the elevator was nearly Mayan in character."  

Among the initial residents was its builder, Joseph Medill Patterson, who occupied the penthouse.  Born in 1879, he founded and published the New York Daily News.  

Joseph Medill Patterson, around 1910.  from the collection of the Library of Congress.

Following his father's death in 1910, he took over the management of the Chicago Tribune.  He also wrote plays that dealt with societal problems.  He lived here with his mistress, news editor Mary King, and their son and daughter.  Patterson's wife, the former Alice Higginbotham, charged him with desertion that year, although they would not be divorced until 1938.

The spectacular Art Deco entrance doors, photographed here in 1929, survive.  photograph by Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

Other initial residents were Maude M. Monell, Carleton W. Betts and Paul Whitcomb.  On September 19, 1928, the New York Evening Post reported that Whitcomb had leased an apartment and two months later, on November 23, 1928, the newspaper reported that Betts "leased an apartment consisting of an entire floor."

Carleton Walter Betts graduated from Yale in 1916 where he had been a football star.  He married Ruth J. Teal on November 5, 1919 and they had a daughter, Audrey.  

Carlton Walter Betts during his Yale football years.  from the collection of the Library of Congress

Like his landlord, Betts apparently had a wandering eye.  He and Ruth were divorced in April 1931 and on March 18, 1932, The New York Times reported that he and Ruth Moore Moriss MacCollom had been married.  His bride, too, was divorced.

Maude M. Monell was the widow of Colonel Ambrose Monell, the wealthy president of the International Nickel Company, who died in 1921.  Maude was the sole heir to his massive estate--equal to $270 million today.  Living with her were her two sons, Edmund Converse and Ambrose 3d.  A daughter, Barbara, was married.

Like all the residents of 3 East 84th Street, Maude Monell's movements were documented within the society columns.  On February 21, 1929, for instance, The New York Times noted, "Mrs. Ambrose Monell returned from Europe yesterday on the Olympic and is at the Plaza before going to 3 East Eighty-fourth Street."  (Wealthy families routinely checked into high-end hotels after being away for extended periods.  That gave the domestic staff time to put away dust covers, bring in fresh flowers and otherwise ready the homes.)

The Monell name appeared in newsprint six months later for a much more somber reason.  Ambrose, who was 23, was killed in an airplane crash at Greenwich, Connecticut on August 2, 1929.

The family of James Aloysius Farley lived here as early as 1930.  Born in 1888, Farley married Elizabeth A. Finnegan (known familiarly as Bess) on April 28, 1920.  They had three children, Elizabeth, Ann and James Jr.  On March 19, 1930, The New York Sun reported that Farley, "is likely to be appointed as [Police Commissioner Grover] Whalen's successor by Mayor Walker."  The article described Farley as "chairman of the Boxing Commission, and secretary of the Democratic State Committee, who made a fortune in the building supply business and whose standing in Tammany Hall is A-plus."  

James Aloysius Farley, from the collection of the Library of Congress.

His meteoric rise within the Democratic political sphere was reflected in an article three years later.  On January 11, 1933, The New York Sun reported, "The President-elect and Mrs. [Franklin D.] Roosevelt will be guests tonight at a dinner given by Mr. and Mrs. James A. Farley at their home at 3 East Eighty-fourth street.  Among the guests will be Cardinal Hayes, Mgr. Keegan and Edward J. Flynn, Democratic leader of the Bronx."  Later that year, Roosevelt appointed Farley the United States Postmaster General.

From his start operating a building supply business, Farley rose to become one of the most recognized figures in American politics, serving as chairman of the New York State Democratic Committee from 1930 to 1944, and of the Democratic National Committee from 1932 to 1940.  The family left 3 East 84th Street in 1943 to live in the Waldorf-Astoria.

In the meantime, a British-born couple, John J. and Jeanne Dwyer, worked as Joseph Patterson's butler and chambermaid.  In September 1930, Joseph and Mary went to Chicago for an extended period.  In December, Joseph Patterson's daughter, Alica, "an aviation enthusiast," as described by The New York Times, occupied the apartment before traveling to China.  

On March 16, 1931, the ninth-floor tenant complained to the superintendent, Frank Paine, that water was seeping through the ceiling.  When no one answered the penthouse door, Paine used his passkey.  The New York Times reported, "He found the water was coming from a tap in the kitchen sink that evidently had been open for several days."  He went looking for the Dwyers.  A radio played in one of the rooms.  Paine found the principal bedroom door locked and, after forcing it open, discovered the couple's bodies.  John J. Dwyer had shot his wife and then committed suicide.  Detectives said they were "as a loss to explain why the tragedy took place in Mr. Patterson's room rather than in the room assigned to the servants."

Princess Lazarovich-Hrebelianovich and her step-son, Prince Doushan, lived here in 1941.  On July 15 that year, her husband, Serbian Prince Eugene Lazarovich-Hrebelianovich died in Heidelberg, Germany at the age of 71.  Prior to her marriage in 1903, the Princess was actress and author Eleanor Calhoun.  (The Prince's first wife had died three years earlier.)  She had collaborated with the Prince in writing a two-volume work, The Serbian People: Their Past Glories and Their Destiny, published in 1910.

Eleanor Calhoun in the role of Dora in Diplomacy in 1895.  from the collection of the New York Public Library

In her previous life, Eleanor Calhoun debuted on stage as Juliet in Romeo and Juliet in the Grand Opera House in San Francisco.  She was known for her Shakespearean roles and appeared in London and Paris.  Upon marrying Prince Lazarovich-Hrebelianovich, she devoted herself "to her husband's interests in the liberation of Serbian lands in Macedonia," according to The New York Times.  She wrote her memoirs, Pleasures and Palaces, in 1915 and in 1926 her The Way: Christ and Evolution was published.  

The fascinating Princess Eleanor Calhoun Lazarovich-Hrebelianovich died in her apartment at the age of 92 on January 11, 1957.

On August 30, 1943, The New York Sun reported that Elliott Nugent, "producer and actor," and his wife, Norma Lee, had taken an apartment.  Two months later, the newspaper reported that Shelton Ellsworth Prentice and his wife, Sheila Potter, had signed a lease.  

Wurts Bros. photographed the building again in 1946.  from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

Born in Dover, Ohio in 1896, Elliott Nugent's father, J. C. Nugent, was also an actor.  When he and Norma moved in, he had appeared in numerous motion pictures and directed the 1939 Bob Hope-Paulette Goddard film The Cat and the Canary and Never Say Die the same year, also starring Hope.  

Elliott Nugent in a 1931 MGM publicity shot.

Sheldon Ellsworth Prentice was born in New York City in 1914 and graduated from Harvard University in 1936.  He was a partner in the investment banking firm Dominick & Dominick at 14 Wall Street.  He and Sheila had two daughters, Clare, who was three, and Sheila, who was two; and a newborn son, Sheldon Jr.  In January 1942, Prentice took a leave from Dominick & Dominick to join the U.S. Naval Reserves.  He came home on leave in March 1944 after serving in the South Pacific.  It would be the last time his family would see him.  On March 31, 1945, The New York Times reported that the 31-year-old had been killed in action in the Pacific.

In 1957, Doris Duke and her mother, Nanine, donated their magnificent mansion at 1 East 78th Street to New York University's Institute of Fine Arts.  Doris  moved into 3 East 84th Street.  At the time of their moving into 3 East 84th Street, Fortune magazine estimated Doris Duke's assets at "between $100,000,000 and $200,000,000."  The lower figure would translate to more than $1 billion today.

Doris Duke had barely settled in when she suffered a terrific loss.  She had a flight to Paris to catch on the afternoon of November 5, 1957.  When her chauffeur was late, at around 5:40 she hailed a taxicab in front 3 East 84th Street "en route to New York International Airport, Idlewild, Queens," as reported by The New York Times.  Just as her luggage was loaded into the cab, the chauffeur drove up.  The newspaper reported, "Miss Duke's luggage was transferred out of the cab.  Apparently, however, one small flight bag was left in the trunk."  It was a significant oversight.  Inside the bag was jewelry valued at the equivalent of $175,000 today.  The New York Times reported that Duke, "canceled her scheduled trip to Paris and returned to Manhattan, where she reported her loss to police."  It is unclear whether the jewels were recovered.


Hood and Howells's ground breaking Art Deco structure survives wonderfully intact--an easily overlooked architectural wonder hidden on a side street.

uncredited photographs by the author