In 1886, the Church of St. Jean Baptiste established the Villa-Marie Academy in two former houses at the northwest corner of Lexington Avenue and 79th Street. Its female students were taught and overseen by the Sisters of the Congregation of Notre Dame of Montreal.
The newly formed 1142-1148 Lexington Avenue Corporation purchased the property in 1927 as the site of a 15-story apartment building. Harry E. Warren was commissioned to design the structure, and Louis Allen Abramson was brought in as consulting architect.
Their neo-Renaissance-style structure was completed in 1928 at a cost of $400,000, or about $7.5 million in 2026 terms. Sitting atop a short granite water table, the two-story base was faced in Caen stone. Stores lined the avenue side. The entrance at 139 East 79th Street was modestly framed, and an engaged, spiral colonette at the corner composed the only decoration at this level. The mid- and top sections were faced in ruddy red brick and trimmed in stone. Faux Renaissance-style balconies clung to the fourth and fourteenth floors, connected by broad stone bandcourses decorated by rosettes.
Each apartment engulfed a floor and included "a private elevator vestibule with marble or tile floor." Typically, they had 11 rooms and four baths. The 13th floor apartment had 10 rooms and three baths, and the 14th floor suite had 12 rooms and five baths. The second and penthouse levels contained six rooms and three baths, with the penthouse enjoying a terrace.
An advertisement in The Spur on March 15, 1923 asked, "How many sun windows have you?" and boasted, "The full floor apartments have sunlight on every side...from 22 sun windows." The building was a cooperative and an advertisement urged, "The cost is extremely moderate for such high-type apartment homes." That, of course, was relative.
The apartments sold quickly, many of the sales happening during construction when the buyers' personal architects and designers could make modifications. Among the intitial owners were Harold G. Hathaway, Dr. Louis F. Bishop Jr., Frederick H. Babcock, John N. Cole, Anna Pomeroy James Alexander and Van Rensselaer Halsey.
A stockbroker, John N. Cole married Helen Dodd on April 22, 1922. She was the daughter of Mrs. Eugene R. Burnett from a previous marriage. Their son, John Jr., was born in 1923 and the family's country home was in East Hampton.
On March 4, 1928, The New York Times reported that the Coles had purchased the 14th floor apartment as well as "one room on the floor below, connected by a private staircase." At the same time, Helen's mother purchased the 15th floor apartment. "Thus the family has bought twenty-three rooms and eight baths," said the article.
Harold G. Hathaway was a former attorney and partner of John W. Davis, the Democratic nominee for President in 1924. He was now a partner in the banking and brokerage firm of Edward B. Smith & Co. He and his wife, the former Louise Phillips, had two sons, Phillips, born in 1920, and Harold, born in 1927.
Among the bankers and attorneys was one titled resident. Belva Dula was one of the four children of American Tobacco Company vice president Robert Byron Dula and his wife, Josephine Carr. Belva married Townsend Hornor in 1909. Within two years of his death in 1923, she was married to Count Ponpeo Pieri. Belva was now listed in social registers as Countess Belva-Dula Pieri. Interestingly, she and the Count do not appear to have lived together.
Upon the death of Josephine Carr Dula in 1929, her substantial estate was essentially divided among her children. For some reason, according to The New York Times on November 23, "Countess Pieri receives an additional $50,000." (That bonus would translate to about $950,000 today.)
Anna Pomeroy Alexander was the wife of James Strange Alexander, chairman of the board of the Guarantee Trust Company. The couple had two adult children. There was apparently a strain in the couple's relationship and when Anna moved into 139 East 79th Street in October 1928, James took an apartment at 440 Park Avenue. James S. Alexander died on July 26, 1932, leaving an estate equal to nearly $26.5 million today. The New York Times reported, "The widow, Mrs. Anna Pomeroy Alexander, of 139 East Seventy-ninth Street, receives only a $10,000 legacy, due, the will explained, to ample provision having been made for her during Mr. Alexander's lifetime."
Harold G. Hathaway returned to law in 1934. He left Edward B. Smith & Co. in November and founded a law firm with three partners. (At the time, Phillips Hathaway was 14 years old and enrolled at the Choate School.) In the summer of 1935, Harold Hathaway was diagnosed with an stomach problem that required surgery. According to his physician, Dr. William J. Hinton, he "expressed fear that he would not survive" the procedure.
On Friday night, October 10, 1935, the 44-year-old Hathaway reserved a room at the University Club. At 9:00 the next morning, William Sorkey, a valet, went to his room to awaken him. Hathaway had committed suicide. The New York Times reported, "Detectives said he had strangled himself with the silken cord of his dressing gown by tying one end of it to a bed post and knotting the other about his throat."
Frederick Howard Babcock and his wife, the former Gertrude T. Bodine, were also original owners. Born in 1887, Babcock graduated from the United States Naval Academy in 1908 and joined General Electric. When America entered World War I, Babcock resigned and "returned to the colors," as worded by The New York Times. He served on the U.S.S. Mississippi throughout the World War I. When the war ended, he returned to General Electric. He and Gertrude had three adult children, Frederick Jr., John Bodine, and Barbara.
Among the residents of 139 East 79th Street at midcentury was Thatcher M. Brown. Born in New York City in 1876, Brown was a widower. An 1897 graduate of Yale, he entered the banking firm of Brown Brothers, founded by his great-grandfather in 1818. He was president of the board of the Union Theological Seminary and director in numerous corporations. He died in his sleep here on May 2, 1954.
Among Brown's neighbors in the building were Stuyvesant Wainwright and his wife, the former Louise Flinn, who were in the building as early as 1946. Born in 1891 and 1901, respectively, the couple were married in 1934 and had three children, Peter Stuyvesant, Mimi Louise, and Patricia. The family's country home, Duckwood Lodge, was in Hampton Bays, Long Island.
Wainwright was a descendant of Peter Stuyvesant. He graduated from Columbia Law School in 1916 and served on a Navy destroyer in World War I. Although 50 years old, he served with the Coast Guard on coastal patrol duty during World War II. Despite his law degree, Wainwright went into the brokerage business. But it was his skill at cards that made him well known to most Americans. Described by The New York Times as a "life master bridge player," he and Harold Vanderbilt had organized the Vanderbilt Cup tournament.
The family's pedigree was announced by The New York Times in September 1946 in reporting on Mimi Louise's marriage to Charles Payson Coleman. The article said she "is a great-granddaughter of Bishop Jonathan Mayhew Wainwright of New York, who was an ancestor also of Gen. Jonathan Mayhew Wainwright, hero of Corregidor. She is a granddaughter of Mrs. Carl F. Wolff of this city and the late Stuyvesant Wainwright."
Patricia Wainwright was married in the apartment on November 16, 1956 to Ricardo Bonicatti, who lived in Rome. The New York Times noted that Patricia "studied at the Brearley School here and was graduated from the Westover School, Middlebury, Conn., attended Vassar College and graduated in 1952 from Barnard College."
Stuyvesant and Louise went to Naples, Florida to escape the New York winter of 1975. Stuyvesant Wainwright died there at the age of 84 on February 4.
The apartments still engulf an entire floor. Happily, when replacement windows were installed, they successfully mimicked the original six-over-six sashes. Although some air conditioning units have been gouged into the facade--a few ruining the stone bandcourses and rosettes--the 98-year-old building survives relatively unchanged.
photographs by the author














.jpg)

.jpg)










.jpg)




.png)