Tuesday, December 13, 2016

The Lew Fields House - No. 307 West 90th Street




In October 1898 Clarence F. True filed plans for seven upscale houses which wrapped around the northwest corner of 90th Street and West End Avenue.  He received the commission from developers John T. and James A. Farley, who did business as Terrance Farley's Sons.  As the rowhouses were being constructed the Record and Guide commented on the brothers, saying on December 22, 1900 that they "have always been engaged in the building of the best residence improvements and have always kept abreast of the continually increasing demands of the times."

Clarence True was prolific on the Upper West Side and routinely turned to historic styles for his inspiration.  And he often mixed and matched disparate styles with gleeful abandon, as was the case with No. 307 West 90th Street; part of the Terrance Farley's Sons project.

Completed in 1901 the 18-foot wide, five-story residence was designed in the American basement plan which did away with the tall stoop so popular for the past half century.  Two bays wide, True designed the first four floors in an exuberant Renaissance Revival style--its bowed red brick front decorated with conspicuous limestone quoins, two appealing balconettes at the second floor, and an arched Renaissance-style entrance almost identical to that around the corner at No. 627 West End Avenue.  At the top floor True changed gears.  He abruptly turned from Renaissance to Flemish Revival, designing the attic level as a flamboyant Dutch gable fronting a red tiled pitched roof.


William Cumming Story and his wife, the former Fannie Ella Daisy Allen, moved from Central Park West to the 90th Street house.  Story was vice president of the American Savings Bank and vice president of the Standard Statistics Bureau; but it was his wife who claimed the spotlight.

Fannie Story's American roots were deep.   Her English and Dutch ancestors included an uncle, Enos Throop, who served as Governor of New York, and Stephen Allen, the first elected Mayor of New York.  Fannie followed the family's political traditions, serving as President General of the Daughters of the American Revolution, President of the Republican Women's Club and President of the City Federation of Women's Clubs.

The style morphed from Renaissance Revival to Flemish Revival at the attic floor, where Oscar Hammerstein and Herbert Fields later wrote songs.

The Storys had three sons, Allen, Harold and Sterling, and the family maintained a summer "cottage" in on Long Island in Cedarhurst.  And while the Storys were visible in society, the majority of Fannie's entertainments were related to her various offices.  On Thursday, January 30, 1907, for instance, she held a bridge party for the Manhattan Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution.

William Cumming Story did not simply sit at home while his wife was at meetings, teas and conventions.  In October 1908 he was inducted as a member of the West End Association; a civic group formed to promote improvements on the Upper West Side.

Rather surprisingly, the fight for office within the Daughters of the American Revolution was sometimes cutthroat.  In April 1908 Mrs. Donald McLean, the incumbent President General, supported Mrs. Matthew Scott, who was running against Fannie Story.  The McLean camp sent out a letter to all delegates to the upcoming congress.  It praised Mrs. Scott for her interest in the proposed Continental Hall in Washington D.C.  The Sun reported on April 9 "As for Mrs. William Cumming Story, who is running against Mrs Scott, the letter says that she doesn't care a continental for the hall, in fact is almost opposed to it."
Fannie Ella Daisy Allen Story -- from the collection of the Library of Congress

The fight was on.  "As soon as Mrs. Story's adherents heard about the letter they decided to get out one of their own, and accordingly they hastened to headquarters to obtain a list of accredited delegates and alternatives."  But the D.A.R. officials refused to release the mailing list.  "Mrs. Story's supporters had forgotten that the McLeanites are at present in control of the organization machine and that nothing can go out from headquarters without their sanction."

A reporter called at No. 307 West 90th Street to ask Fannie about the letter.  She said "I have no personal feeling against Mrs. Matthew Scott, who is running against me."  Confident of her win, Fannie said "I shall do everything possible to encourage Mrs. Scott to use her splendid abilities for the advantage of the cause dear to us both."

Fannie was president of the City Federation of Club Women at the time.  The following year was an election year and the fight was no less ruthless than the D.A.R. campaign.  The New-York Tribune opined on January 10, 1909  "'If any Tammany politician wants pointers in the art of manipulating elections let him come to us.'  This is the substance of remarks that may be heard among almost any group of clubwomen in these degenerate days."

Outspoken and opinionated, Fannie Story made her views known.  Indifferent to the feathers she might ruffle, she rallied for women's right to vote and railed against the pacifists concerned about war in Europe (all three of the Story boys would fight in the coming World War I).  And when she was asked to speak at a July 4 celebration in 1910, she may have surprised some in the audience.

While other speakers recalled patriotic feats of George Washington or Thomas Jefferson, Fannie spoke only of women--like Dolly Madison, Margaret Corbin (who helped to defend Fort Tryon), and Catherine Schuyler.  The New-York Tribune reported "She said that they suffered for their country as much as the men did."

About the time of the Independence Day speech the Storys had left West 90th Street.  The 1910 census shows the Lew M. Fields family in the house.  Lewis Moses Shanfield used the stage name Lew Fields.  As half of the enormously successful comedy team Weber and Fields, he had amassed a personal fortune.  The team broke up in 1904 when Weber took over operations of a music hall.  But the multi-talented Fields forged on as an actor and comedian, producer and theater manager.

Lew Fields, photo from The Actors' Birthday Book, 1909 (copyright expired)

With Fields had married his wife when she was 17 and working as a toy buyer for the Namm department store in Brooklyn.  They now had four children, Joseph, Frances, Herbert and Dorothy.  Also living with the family was Bob Harris.  He was the uncle of the Fields children, but was only five years older than Joseph.

Joseph seemed to find himself always in trouble. On December 29, 1911 The New York Times reported that Patrolman Boshamer noticed posters on trees along Broadway between 88th and 92nd Streets.  He tore them down; but when he returned later new ones had been tacked up.  He saw two boys busily replacing the posters.

"One of them was young Fields and the other was Herbert [sic] Harris, who lives with the Fields family at 307 West Ninetieth Street," noted the newspaper.  The boys appeared before a judge on December 28, who, "after giving the lads a kindly lecture, fined them east $1, which they paid."

Joseph and his brother Herbert attended De Witt Clinton high school.  In his senior year Joseph had missed so many classes he was in serious trouble.  He brought his father to school to smooth things over.  School officials, however, were not duped.  The youthful Bob Harris made a poor surrogate for the mature (and well-known) Lew Fields.

It ended with Joseph and his brother, Herbert, being expelled from De Witt Clinton; but they dared not tell their father about it.  Decades later Joseph told their astonishing story to Karl Schriftgeisser of The New York Times.  The reporter explained "They sold themselves to a private school as what used to be called, in less honorable days, 'ringers' for the football team.  That meant free tuition, and somehow they managed to be graduated without Lew getting wise."

Lew Fields continued to have theatrical successes, including his 1911 Hen-Pecks co-starring Vernon Castle, and his 1920 Poor Little Ritz Girl, with songs by Rodgers and Hart.  And so it was no doubt a shock to most who read the New York Times headline on August 21, 1921 "LEW M. FIELDS BANKRUPT."  The actor's attorney, Jacob I. Berman downplayed the situation.  He told reporters that Fields "had been forced to take the step because he wished to take a position without having his means of livelihood attacked by creditors."  He said that Fields would continue making payments "until the slate was clean."

In the meantime, although their mother vocally opposed their entering show business, the Fields children showed extraordinary talent.  The family was still on West 90th Street when, in 1922 Lorenz Hart and Herb Fields came up with an idea for a musical, Winkle Town.  Hart's biographer, Gary Marmorstein, wrote in his A Ship Without a Sail: The Life of Lorenz Hart, "The premise was so intriguing to Oscar Hammerstein II...that he offered to work with Herb Fields on a book for the show.  Fourteen or fifteen Winkle Town songs were written on the top floor of the Lew Fields house at 307 West Ninetieth Street."

Dorthy became a lyricist, sometimes working with Herbert.  Among her memorable songs would be "I Can't Give You Anything But Love," "I'm in the Mood for Love," "On the Sunny Side of the Street," and "The Way You Look Tonight," which won her an Academy Award.

Bad boy Joseph eventually became a Hollywood scenarist.  He teamed up with Jerome Chodorv.  Their main success was the screen dramatization of My Sister Eileen.

But before any of that happened, the 90th Street house was sold in September 1922.  In reporting on the sale, the New-York Tribune noted "The property will be altered into apartments."  The resulting renovation resulted in what a later sales report called an "apartment house for nine families."


Then in 1991 came another renovation, resulting in just two multi-floor apartments.  Flat paned windows replace the more charming curved examples that originally conformed to the bowed facade.  But overall Clarence True's delightful blend of styles survives remarkably intact.

photographs by the author

Monday, December 12, 2016

The Lost Stoddard Theatre -- No. 2433 Broadway

The Power and the Glory with Spencer Tracy and Coleen Moore was showing here in 1933.  from the collection of the New York Public Library

Residents of the Upper West Side enjoyed its wide avenues, improved transportation and modern apartments and homes in the first decade of the 20th century.  But an evening in the theater required, for some, a trip of 50 blocks or more to the entertainment district.  John Cort saw an opportunity in that inconvenience.

Cort had begun his career as half of the comedy act Cort and Murphy.  He left New York to manage a theater in Illinois; then went further west to rescue the struggling Standard Theatre in Seattle.  He turned it into that city's leading theater.  By 1903 his Northwestern Theatrical Association operated 37 theaters.

Now, in 1914, he looked to bring theater to the Upper West Side.  It was undoubtedly no coincidence that he would name his new enterprise The Standard Theatre.  Cort commissioned architect Thomas Lamb, best known for his theater projects, to design the structure on Broadway at 90th Street.   On September 5, 1914 The Sun described the completed building.  "The exterior of the building is of brick with ornamental terra cotta cornices and ornamental pediment over the main entrance."  Patrons entered the lobby and ticket office from Broadway; although a carriage entrance was located on the 90th Street side.

New York artist J. Alden Twachtman, who would later be represented in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, painted six panels in the lobby.  "These show Venetian scenes of the seventeenth century," wrote The Sun.  The ceiling here was of Circassian walnut and the upper walls were clad in Caen stone--a creamy colored limestone popular as a stand-in for marble.

The 1,493-seat auditorium was decorated in light gray touched in gold.  A mural over the proscenium depicted The Triumph of Dramatic Art.

John Cort did not intend for his new theater to compete with those downtown.  Instead, successful productions from the theater district would be re-staged here when they closed.  "'Popular prices will prevail,' is an alluring slogan of the new temple," suggested The Sun.


Too Many Cooks was playing at The Standard when this photograph was taken in October 1914, a month after opening.  photo by Wurts bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The Standard Theatre opened on September 5 with Kitty MacKay.  The following morning The Sun wrote "John Cort has added another beautiful playhouse to New York's already long list.  The review said that it "seems--to judge from the size of the audience last night--to fill the needs of the neighborhood."

It was not stage drama that drew throngs to the theater on Christmas Day that year.  The Volunteers of America used The Standard as a gift-giving depot; distributing 1,000 dolls to little girls in the neighborhood.

Upper West Side residents enjoyed first-class productions at The Standard.  On June 5, 1915, for instance, a week-long staging of The Chocolate Soldier, the musical version of Bernard Shaw's Arms and the Man, opened.  And on Sunday evenings, the New York Orchestral Society gave concerts here.

In the meantime, Thomas Lamb had designed the building to include retail stores along the street floor.  In March 1916 Adler's Waist Shops signed a lease.  The waist, or shirtwaist, was the most popular women's garment of the day.

In 1919 motion pictures were added to the live entertainment here.  About two years before John Cort's death in 1929, his son Harry Lindsey Cort, came to New York to manage The Standard Theatre.  The younger Cort was also a producer and musical comedy writer.  He collaborated with George E. Stoddard, writing comedies like The Elopers, Listen Lester, Just a Minute, Jim Jam Jems, and China Rose, all of which were produced at The Standard.


The Stoddard as it appeared on March 15, 1931.  photograph from the collection of the New York Public Library

Harry Lindsey Cort died in his sleep of a heart attack on May 6, 1937, at the age of 47.  The theater had, by now, been renamed The Stoddard Theatre after his partner. 

Earlier that year the Stoddard Theatre had been the scene of a disturbing incident.  Labor unions in the 1930s regularly resorted to violent and irresponsible methods to fight management.  On February 27, 1937 the 1,100 patrons watching a motion picture were victims of what was essentially domestic terrorism.  The following day The New York Times reported "Six persons were injured when a stench and tear-gas bomb, fashioned from a glass receptacle, exploded in the center of the right tier of orchestra seats at the Stoddard Theatre...Fragments of the glass container were scattered in the air, cutting persons in the vicinity about the legs."  Other patrons complained of eye irritation from the gas.

In 1933 Adolph Hitler was elected Chancellor of Germany.  His party's radical and racist views prompted efforts by some for religious and racial harmony.  On January 30, 1940 the Stoddard Theatre was the scene of a program of documentary films "intended to promote inter-faith amity," according to its organizers.  It was part of the New York Round Table of the National Conference of Christians and Jews, and about 800 people attended the showings.

By now meeting rooms on the second floor were available for rent.  The Knickerbocker Post No. 111 met here on the first and third Tuesday every month in 1944.

In 1952 the neighborhood was experiencing a terrifying wave of robberies, muggings and rapes.  In response the police department assigned extra patrolmen to street duty and established a night detail of detectives in unmarked police cars.  The New York Times reported "And as bait for the stepped-up drive attractive police-women in civilian finery were shifted from routine tasks."

Despite the increased police presence, armed robbers attacked the Stoddard Theatre around 11:20 on the night of September 17.  The manager was tied up and $400 was taken from the safe.

At the time of the heist, the days of the Stoddard Theatre were numbered.  Around 1956 the last motion picture was screened and the lobby and auditorium were gutted.  The ground floor was converted to a grocery, the Garden Market.

Reminiscent of the 1952 crime spree, an armed gunman terrorized Broadway on July 24, 1976 when he robbed three stores within four hours.  At 8:15 that morning he stole $500 from a dairy at Broadway and 72nd Street; then around 8:45 he hit the butcher shop at No. 2446 Broadway, taking $60; and finally held up the Garden Market at noon, getting away with $500.

The theater-turned-grocery store survived until 1985.  It was demolished to make way for a 22-story apartment building designed by Philip Birnbaum & Associates.


photo via streeteasy.com

Saturday, December 10, 2016

The Surprising Wm. S. Anderson Co. Bldg - No. 954 Lexington Ave.

On crowded Lexington Avenue No. 954 stands by itself.

When architect Gerard Fountain purchased the large brownstone home at No. 136 East 70th Street in 1896, he almost immediately took advantage of the advantageous Lexington Avenue corner location.  The avenue was already seeing commercialization, and he extended the structure into part of the expansive rear garden to accommodate ground floor stores and apartments above.

He went further in 1898 when he leased the remainder of the garden plot to the Wm. S, Anderson Co. as the site for its headquarters.  The real estate firm was founded in 1868 by William S. Anderson, and incorporated in 1895 with Harold D. Keeler as its president.  Anderson stayed on as vice-president and treasurer.

The leasing of the plot at No. 954 Lexington Avenue was part of an innovative idea.  As A History of Real Estate, Building and Architecture in New York City explained that same year, "On the principal that no man can cover the Island thoroughly and familiarize himself with district investors and conditions thereof, the company opened four offices in as many sections of the city."

The firm hired the architectural firm S. B. Ogden & Co. to design its modest main office building.  Completed early in the fall of 1898, the three-story brick structure was essentially neo-Renaissance in style.  The cast iron piers of the ground floor featured intricate Renaissance style decorations and delicate rosettes.  Above, the architect was sparing but clever in his use of stone.  It appeared as a continuous lintel over the broad triple office window at the second floor, and connected the three upper openings as a single lintel.  A stone bandcourse at this level creatively morphed into projecting sills supported by hefty brick supports.  Their reverse stair-stepped design was echoed in the brick cornice brackets.

S. B. Ogden & Co. was apparently pleased with its own work.  On October 1, 1898 it moved into the upper floor offices.  The firm would remain here until, at least, the 1920s.

In the meantime, the Wm. S. Anderson Co. conducted its extensive real estate business from its headquarters, boasting "telephone connections" in an 1899 advertisement.

After leasing the former garden plot for 22 years, the firm bought the land in April 1920.  By now Frank Knapp was president of the well-known business.  He had joined the company as an office boy in 1891 at the age of 14. 

In 1922 Knapp converted part of the upper section to an apartment.  But it would not be long before hints of financial problems appeared.  On June 13, 1929 the Lenox Hill Holding Company announced it had leased both the old brownstone at No. 136 East 70th Street and the Wm. S. Anderson Co. building.

The onslaught of the Great Depression naturally affected the real estate business.  On June 7, 1932 Frank Knapp surrendered the lease of No. 954 Lexington Avenue to the Dash Realty Corporation.  That firm also took over the lease of the 70th Street house.

Despite its apparent troubles, the Wm. S. Anderson Company continued to do business here.  Frank Knapp and his wife, Lillian, lived conveniently one block away at No. 973 Lexington Avenue.  In January 1947 he became ill, and died a few weeks later, on Sunday February 9.

By the late 1950s the office space where decades of Manhattan real estate was leased or sold had become a laundry business.  As the neighborhood filled with galleries in the second half of the century, the Yook Wah Lai Laundry was transformed into a most unexpected art venue.

Artist Mark Kraus was convinced in 1961 that "laundry windows afford some clear advantages over gallery showings."  A New York Times article explained "In the first place, galleries are sometimes hard for relatively unknown painters to get into; the standards of hand laundries are less exacting."

Kraus had a laundry list of advantages.  While galleries were normally opened about nine hours a day, the laundry was open from 7 a.m. to 11:00 at night or later.  He said window space was better than wall space, and "the fluorescent lights in the window call attention to his work from as far as a block away."

The artist paid the laundry $1 per day to display his art in the window.  The Times noted "If the venture is profitable, he may soon be displaying paintings in the windows of Chinese laundries in all the better parts of town."

But within the year Kraus would have to find new exhibition space.  In 1962 Demarchelier, an upscale food shop, was operating from No. 954 Lexington.  Throughout the subsequent decades it would be home to The Breen Box, which dealt in decorative items from India and Italy; The Golden Brioche food boutique; and the Alan Price Gallery.

In 2016 a less glamorous packing and shipping store is in the much-altered ground floor.  Other than the replacement windows, the upper stories of the surprising, free-standing commercial building are little changed since the Wm. S. Anderson Co. made its unexpected move into a mansion's garden.

photographs by the author

Friday, December 9, 2016

The Fries Bros. Building -- No. 92 Reade Street






In 1876 a wooden house still stood at No. 92 Reade Street, a reminder of the pre-Civil War era when the neighborhood was quietly residential.  In the rear yard was a small brick shop building.  In February that year Mary E. Earle bought the property in foreclosure, paying $4,600 (around $105,000 today).

Mary apparently recognized potential in the rapidly changing district.  On October 30, 1877 the lot was advertised “For Sale at a Bargain…price, $16,000.”  The frame house and shop were sold and resold with lightning speed.  In August 1878 William Zschwetske took title from John E. DeWitte and his wife Naomi, who lived in Boston.

It was the end of the line for the old wooden house.  Zschwetske cleared the lot and commissioned architect John B. McIntyre to design a modern commercial building.  The two-man team wasted no time.  Plans were filed the first week of September for a “five-story white marble store.”

McIntyre’s work covered a broad range of structures, from small brick and stone commercial structures to substantial loft buildings.  For this project he blended popular styles to create a quintessentially Victorian beauty.

The loft and store building was completed at a cost of $15,000.  Four floors of gleaming white marble sat above a cast iron storefront.  At street level flat paneled side pilasters and fluted Corinthian columns framed an offset retail space and a wide entrance to the upper floors.  The building’s relatively narrow 25-foot width prompted McIntyre to install a clever side panel to the loft entrance which, when opened, transformed the door into a wide service entrance capable of accommodating large items.

The upper floors took on a near-residential tone.  Tall windows at the second floor sat behind  pseudo-balconies with blind openings.  They were crowned with lusty marble French Second Empire pediments supported by leafy scrolled brackets.  Carved medallions were encased in scrollwork which rolled over the top like a cresting wave.   With each succeeding level, McIntyre gradually reduced the grandiosity of the window treatment.  He gave the third floor one centered Second Empire pediments, flanked by two reserved triangular Renaissance Revival pediments.  The fourth floor had a single Renaissance pediment, and two shelf-like lintels.  The scrolled brackets became slightly diminished at this level.  And on the top-most floor three projecting lintels were upheld by unadorned brackets.  Above it all a rather mundane pressed metal cornice crowned the design.

The second floor window pediments were similar to the cresting found on elaborate Victorian sideboards or dressers.

William Zschwetske, who lived in Elizabeth, New Jersey, transferred title to the new building to his wife, Augusta, on March 1, 1879.  Less than two years later, on January 3, 1881, the couple sold No. 92 Reade Street to Charles Fries for a satisfying $32,500.

Fries was the head of the chemical manufacturing firm Alexander Fries & Brothers.  Born in Bavaria in 1831, he came to New York in 1849 and co-founded the company with his brothers.  The firm specialized in scented oils and artificial food flavorings. 

At the International Exhibition of 1876 Alexander Fries & Brothers was commended for its “ethers and essences and oleo-margarine.”  The committee admired “the variety and chemical purity of artificial ethers exhibited, and for delicacy of flavor of fruit essences produced from them; also for production on a large scale, from fresh bullocks’ fat, of an excellent butter substitute known as oleo-margarine.”

Alexander Fries & Brothers produced aromatic chemicals like Oil Wintergreen, Rhondinol II which “replaces perfectly best natural Oil of Rose,” and Heliotrophine Crystals “sachet formula.”  In 1893 the firm, now known as Fries Bros., was working “to improve the quality of tobacco by the use of flavors,” and soon delved into the flavoring of liquors.

Fries Bros. initially rented space in the building to at least one other small business.  Haines & Underhill, “manufacturers of sheep leather,”were here in 1882.  In the meantime the ground floor store was home to the shoe store of Fridberg & Adler.

Otto Fridberg had arrived in New York from Mainz, Germany around 1877.  He became a naturalized citizen and found a high-paying job as a traveling salesman for a wine company.   Then he fell in love and married.  His brother-in-law, Dr. Jacob H. Asch, later explained “His love for her was almost morbid.  When he married he gave up his position as a traveling salesman…and bought the Reade-street shoe business that he might remain in the city to spend his spare time at home.”

Fridberg and his bride moved into a home at No. 164 East 105th Street.  But their idyllic love story quickly developed problems; greatly enhanced by Otto Fridberg’s sensitivity.  When two babies were born within a year, “it caused some remarks and touched Mr. Fridberg’s sensitive nature,” reported The New York Times later.

And in stark contrast to his happy home life, things were not harmonious at the shoe store.  Dr. Asch recalled “all went well until Mr. Fridberg discovered that his partner in the shoe business was not congenial to him.  The fact that they were not suited for one another worried him unnecessarily.”

Nothing, however, could have been more devastating to Otto Fridberg than the death of his beloved wife in 1884, “which changed his spirit.”  Asch explained “His friends thought that the gloom would pass away in a few months, as the children—a boy and girl—were bright and interesting, and their father seemed to idolize them.  In fact he showed such extraordinary attachment for them and spent so much of his time caring for them that his business was neglected.”

The doctor advised his brother-in-law that “his mind would be affected” if he “allowed his fondness for the babes to pass beyond the bounds of reason.”  Fridberg simply replied that he wanted to get out of the shoe business.

By now Otto Fridberg and the children had moved into the Asch residence, at No. 207 East 58th Street.  On the morning of June 28, 1885 he left the house; but he did not show up at the shoe store that day and he never returned home.  The police were notified by Dr. Asch asked that a “general alarm” not be sent out yet, saying that “a man who had more than an ordinary father’s affection for his children would surely return to them.”

Two weeks passed with no word.  Then Dr. Asch picked up The New York Times on July 12 and saw a small headline “Otto Fridberg Found Dead.”  With a dateline of Cape May, New Jersey, the article succinctly reported that the shoe dealer “was found dead in his room at the new Columbia Hotel here to-night.  He was suffocated by escaping gas.”

Authorities had tied to find relatives; but when they went to Fridberg’s old address no one knew where the family had relocated.  Dr. Asch called the death of the 35-year old “a sad mystery—sad because he had been unhappy, and mysterious because no one understood him nor the melancholy which seemed to blight his life.”

The shoe store was taken over by Morton F. Copeland.  In advertising its $2.50 shoe, the M. F. Copeland store promised “every piece of stock is tanned expressly for this shoe.”  M. F. Copeland manufactured its stock on an upper floor here, and asserted “Our lasts and patterns are the very latest, most stylish and best fitting ones used by the finest makers, and none but the most thorough workmen are employed.”

On Saturday, February 16, 1889 two veteran thieves broke into the Copeland factory.  Thomas Hanley also went by the alias Thomas Cleary; and his cohort, George Morton was known both as George Wilson and “Big Tommy.”  The men hired an express wagon and parked it in front of No. 92 Reade Street.  The rig was necessary to handle the amount of their anticipated haul.

After using a “jimmy” to break into the loft; they gathered up boxes of merchandise.  But just as they were leaving with 32 pairs of shoes, they were met on the stairs by Detectives Cottrell and Alonchle.  A struggle ended with shoes and men toppling down the stairs.  Alonchle was badly bruised from his fall down the stairs; but while his injuries were serious enough to land him on the sick list for a few days, they did not prevent him from taking his prisoner to headquarters.

M. F Copeland’s boot and shoe business seemed to be doing well.  And so when the firm’s bankruptcy was announced on April 23, 1891 it “caused a genuine surprise,” according to The New York Times the following day.  The embarrassment of bankruptcy was made worse three months later when Copeland and his brother, Harry, were charged with fraud.

By 1894 Charles Fries was leasing space in the building to E. Lothar Schmitz, manufacturer of safety razors.   The Fries brothers formed another firm, the Torsion Balance Company by 1899 which manufactured a variety of scales: milk scales, drug scales, and textile scales among them.

The Evening World, February 9, 1894 (copyright expired)

In 1898 the health of Charles Fries began to fail.  On February 21, 1900 he died at the age of 69 in his home at No 15 West 82nd Street.  The operation of Fries Brothers passed to his nephew, Dr. Harold H. Fries, a son of Alexander Fries.  He also became the President and Treasurer of the Torsion Balance Company.

The Spatula, May 1900 (copyright expired)

In the 1920s, when Harold Fries transferred title of the building to his Torsion Balance Company, another scale manufacturer, Becker Christian, was in the building.   Becker Christian sold its “balances” from the Reade Street location, while its factory was in Jersey City, New Jersey.

Dr. Harold H. Fries died at the age of 80 on June 30, 1946.  Although tenants changed throughout the rest of the 20th century--including the Yorktown Electrical Supply Co., for instance—the striking marble building did not.   In 1982 it received a splash of color after Port Richmond High School senior Fran Peduzzi won the “Paint a Bright Future for New York” contest.  The aspiring Staten Island artist was one of 200 finalists from city high schools in the competition sponsored by the Hudson-Shatz Painting Company.  Her winning mural was applied to the side of No. 92 Reade Street in November that year.

The mural was just one sign of the changing personality of Tribeca.  Art galleries, restaurants and trendy shops were taking over the former factories.  The same year that Fran Peduzzi’s artwork appeared on its eastern elevation, No. 92 was converted to residences above the ground floor store—just one spacious apartment per floor.


Although a bit scruffy, the 1879 storefront survives surprisingly intact.  And above, partially obscured by a regrettable zig-zagging fire escape, John B. McIntyre’s robust Victorian design remains a show-stopper.

photographs by the author

Thursday, December 8, 2016

The J. W. Dimick Building - Nos. 268-270 Canal Street


In the decade prior to the Civil War the five-story brick National Hall stood at Nos. 268-270 Canal Street.  An advertisement in The New York Herald on September 20, 1859 offered "One large room in the National Hall...suited for a meeting room or manufacturing."  Briefly the building was used by Noah Wheaton, "purveyor of Doors, Sashes, Blinds" and other housewares, including oaken ice boxes. The wealthy merchant and his family lived far to the north in the former Gracie Mansion.

The building was owned by Jeremiah W. Dimick, Sr. in the post war years.  He had formed the J. W. Dimick Co. in 1840, manufacturing and selling carpeting.  Dimick leased the building to Thomas Ryan for his paper box factory.  On August 13, 1868 disaster struck.  About 40 girls were at work at 5:00 that afternoon.  The weight of the large quantities of cardboard and paper, and the cutting machines proved too much for the aging structure.  The third floor gave way, plummeting workers and equipment through the floors.  Amazingly, only three teen-aged girls were injured.  One, 19-year old Mary F. Fallon, died the following day.

In 1886  Jeremiah W. Dimick, Jr. demolished the old brick structure and commissioned architect Lansing C. Holden to design a showroom building for his business, with rentable upper lofts.  Completed in 1887, the Queen Anne-style structure had nothing in common with the old National Hall.  Faced in cast iron, vast expanses of glass flooded the interiors with sunlight.  Holden used many expected elements, possibly chosen from the Atlantic Iron Works catalogue, like fluted Ionic pilasters, rusticated piers, and pencil-like colonnettes.  But he unleashed fanciful Queen Anne sunbursts and freckles in the spandrels above the second and fourth floors; and bow-tie like designs around frothy rosettes above the fifth.

Delightful details are splashed across facade.  The more restrained upper floor was added in 1907.
The J. W. Dimick Co. moved into the street level showroom.  An advertisement in The New York Herald announced "Carpeting--Just Received.  200 pieces of John Crosley & Son's new pattern English Brussels Tapestry; $1.25, in quantities to suit purchasers."  The price point seems to have held steady in 1874, when Dimick offered Kidderminster carpets "excelling Brussels and threeplies" for $1 per yard.  (The price would translate to about $21.50 per yard in 2016.)

At Christmastime that same year J. W. Dimick advertised "Save your carpets during the Holidays; 500 Crumb Cloths and Mats at reduced prices for cash."

In the meantime, the upper lofts were leased to tenants like Benjamin Marks, dealer in "woolens," here in 1884.

Jeremiah Dimick moved his carpeting business uptown and the showroom was taken by auctioneer Benjamin S. Wise by 1897.  An exciting three-day auction was held here beginning on June 29.  The cycling fad had swept the nation and bicycles were still highly expensive.  An 1897 Fowler bicycle retailed for $100--nearly $3,000 in today's dollars.

The 1897 Fowler was considered the top of the line.  Unwinding Fowler Facts catalog, 1897 (copyright expired)

Benjamin Wise auctioned off 500 1897 Fowlers, along with other makes (Victors, Peerless Mfg. Co.'s Crown Toledos, &c, &c.) and accessories.  Wise's auction ad promised "This is first opportunity the public has ever had to purchase 1897 $100 Fowlers at less than list."

The year after the bicycle auction Isaac H. Blanchard leased Nos. 268-270 from the Dimick family.  The principal of the Blanchard Press, he had become interested in printing while he was working for the Newark High School newspaper in the 1870s.

The New York Times later explained "In 1883, with $450 in savings and a note for the same amount, he bought a half interest in the printing business of Fred Oberhauser...and with his earnings paid his way through Princeton."  In 1891 he bought the other half of the business from Oberhauser's widow.  When he took Ancel J. Brower as a partner in 1898, the name was changed to the Isaac H. Blanchard Company.  It was at that time that the move into the Canal Street building occurred.

Labor disputes in the early 20th century were often violent and dangerous.  Printers went on strike in February 1906.  The strikers were not happy with workers who remained on the job and they intended to make their point well known.  On February 27 Thomas B. Dumphy left work with three other workers.  Three strikers, Edward Fister, George M. Michaud, and William J. Anderson followed them, issuing threats from behind.

Instead of being intimidated, Dumphy summoned a policeman.  The strikers were arrested and charged with disorderly conduct in the West 47th Street Station house.  Two of the men refused to give their names; and one said he was Charles A. Meyer of Sussex, New Jersey and that his companions were also from Sussex.  Their victims, of course, corrected that information.


The building's location on little Cortlandt Alley allowed for windows on the side.  Holden wrapped the cast iron slightly around the corner.

On the night of May 6, 1907 fire engulfed the three upper floors of No. 268-270.  About 2,000 people crowded Canal Street to watch as firefighters scrambled to rescue Blanchard Press employees.  The New York Times remarked "the scene was made more interesting by the use of a powerful search-light which lighted up the front of the building and brought out the men on the ladder in strong relief."

The employees had been working overtime on the top floor and were unaware of the fire, which began on the second, until an automatic alarm sounded.  Walter Deans, a lithographer, brothers Abe and Moe Levine, and one other worker found themselves trapped by the flames.  They hurried to the roof hatch, but it was tightly locked.  "They only gave up their attempts when the place was so full of smoke that they had to take to the fire escape to save themselves from suffocation," reported The Times.

When firefighters arrived "The flames were roaring from every window of the burning floors."  Extension ladders were raised to the fire escapes and the four men were rescued.  Isaac Blanchard later told reporters that the June issue of Burr McIntosh's Monthly had just been completed and was reach for delivery, but "the entire issue was destroyed."  He estimated his loss at $150,000.

The building was in the name of Jeremiah Dimick's daughter, Theresa D. Browning at the time.  Within the month she hired respected architects Israels & Harder to renovate the burned out floors.  A sixth floor was added at the same time, at a cost of $18,000.  While the architects continued the flow of Holden's design, theirs was a much more toned-down, neo-Classical take. 

While the Blanchard Press continued operating upstairs, Damsky & Katz moved its Empire Carpet Co. showroom into the first floor in November 1907.  On April 9, 1919 a rash of robberies took place throughout the city.  The following day The Times noted "Police reports of robberies in the city yesterday began early in the morning."  One was from the Empire Carpet Co.

Joseph Stanton was the engineer of Nos. 268-270 Canal Street; a position more widely known as a superintendent or maintenance man today.  When he arrived at work he found the door of the Empire Carpet Company's office open and the safe's contents scattered around.  When office workers arrived, they reported that the burglars had made off with $28 in cash and $2,000 in Liberty Bonds belonging to the employees.  "The police found the burglars had entered over the roof," said The Times.

In 1924 the New York Edison Company purchased the building.   The electric company found an innovative use for the showroom space.  On August 17 that year The New York Times reported "In view of the increasing improvement of electric trucks for frequent-stop city delivery routes, the New York Edison Company has set aside a portion of its new showroom at 270 Canal Street for a permanent display of electric trucks, charging boards, and batteries."  The showroom was set up to show "three street trucks, two industrial trucks, together with charging and battery exhibit[s].  The exhibits will be changed every three months."

Eight months later a massive blaze engulfed the five-story building across the street at No. 269 Canal in the Knickerbocker Doll Company factory.  At least 24 firefighters were overcome or sickened by the noxious fumes.  A triage center was set up in the New York Edison Company showrooms, described by one newspaper as "an emergency hospital."

An equal number of firefighters would be overcome three decades later when fire broke out in No. 268-270 Canal Street.  By now the street was filled with second-rate stores crammed with flammable merchandise.  The ground floor of No. 268-270 was home to the Self-Service Cut Rate Store.

In the second half of the 20th century No. 268-270 suffered abuse.  photo by Edmund Vincent Gillon from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The fire broke out in the store's basement at 5:50 on the afternoon of August 28, 1959.  Responding firefighters dealt with scorching temperatures around 90 degrees, as well.  Before the fire was extinguished 25 firefighters had been treated for heat exhaustion and smoke inhalation.


Like almost all of the cast iron structures in the Canal Street neighborhood, No. 268-270 suffered neglect in the second half of the 20th century.  But around 2000 it received a full exterior restoration, and today Lansing C. Holdens effervescent Queen Anne factory building shines.

photographs by the author

Wednesday, December 7, 2016

The Max Schwerin House - No. 448 West 23rd St.



By the 1850s handsome homes rose along the streets which had been laid out across Clement Clarke Moore's family estate, Chelsea.  Max Schwerin was among the first to purchase a building plot on West 23rd Street, between Ninth and Tenth Avenues.

Moore envisioned a high-end residential neighborhood on his land, and he included restrictive covenants in the deeds to ensure a higher class of home.  Max Schwerin's would not disappoint.  He purchased the plot at No. 448 West 23rd Street in 1854 and the upscale residence was completed two years later.

Before the end of the decade the entire blockfront would be filled with similar, Italianate and Anglo-Italianate-style homes.  But the Schwerin house would stand out.  It was slightly taller than its neighbors, and boasted elegant extras which announced that this was the home of a wealthy family.

Four stories high over an English basement, the brownstone-fronted structure featured elaborate segmental-arched window enframements which sat on dainty stone brackets, an especially handsome Italianate cornice, and costly carved and paneled double entrance doors.  The floor-to-ceiling parlor windows opened onto a cast iron balcony.

But the show-stopping element was the elaborately-carved brownstone entrance--an expensive and masterful example of the stone carver's craft.  Leafy scrolled brackets upheld an arched pediment filled with a filigree of vines and leaves.  They surrounded a deeply-carved shell which leaned slightly outside the lines of the pediment.


Max Schwerin was highly involved in politics and was elected vice-chairman of the 16th Ward Republicans the same year his new house was completed.  At the "rousing ratification meeting," as described by the New-York Daily Tribune, on the night of July 16, the group resolved "we will not be deterred from asserting and maintaining the rights of American freemen, by either the threats or violence of Southern Ruffians or the sickly apprehensions of Northern doughfaces."

Tragically for the Schwerin family, the violence in the South would claim the life of 20-year old Henry Remson Schwerin.  He died in the battle of Chancellorsville on Sunday May 10, 1863.

By now the Schwerins had left West 23rd Street.  Max had sold the house to Naftali K. Rosenfeld and his wife, Ida, in 1860.   While the war raged in the South, the Rosenfelds welcomed new life at No. 448 West 23rd Street.  On August 26, 1863 they placed an advertisement in The New York Herald which read "Wet Nurse Wanted--A Healthy Wet Nurse can get a good situation in this city by calling at once at 448 West 23d st., between 9th and 10th ave."

Like the Schwerins, Naftali and Ida Rosenfeld would not remain in the house long.  By 1866 it was home to Ziba H. and Marie Louisa Kitchen.  The Kitchens were originally from New Jersey.  Ziba was born in Hackettstown in 1812; and Maria Louisa was born two years later in Newark.  She was the daughter of Moses Ward and Fanny Brown Ward.

The couple had been married in the house of Moses Ward, Maria Louisa's father, in Newark in 1836.  They had three children, Marcus Lawrence Ward Kitchen, born that same year; Fannie, born in 1843; and Joseph Moses Ward Kitchen, born in 1846.

Ziba Kitchen was a principal in the dry goods firm Kitchen, Montross and Wilcox.  The successful firm operated from its own cast iron fronted building, designed by James Bogardus, at No. 85 Leonard Street.   As was expected of the wives of wealthy businessmen, Maria Louisa was highly involved in charitable causes.  She had been one of the founders of the Newark Orphan Asylum Association in 1859.


Fannie B. Ward Kitchen married John Clatworthy.  The young bride fell ill in the spring of 1866, and died on Tuesday evening, May 29 at the age of 23.  Her body was brought back to the 23rd Street house for her funeral the following Friday morning at 11:00.

The wealth and status of the Kitchens was exemplified by their golden wedding anniversary celebration on the night of January 6, 1886.  The New York Times reported on the affair, noting "The floral decorations were very beautiful and an elaborate supper was served by Clark."  The article mentioned that 400 guests were present in the house.

Maria Louisa Ward Kitchen -- photo via MyHeritage

No. 448 West 23rd Street was the scene of two funerals a few years later.  On Tuesday, May 31, 1892.  Maria Louisa Ward Kitchen died in the house on Saturday, May 28 at the age of 77.  Nine months later, on Friday, February 24, 1893,  Ziba Hazen Kitchen died at the age of 80 year.  His funeral, too, was held in the parlor on the following Monday morning.

Later that year the house would see a much happier event.  Julia Makee Kitchen was the daughter of Marcus Lawrence Ward Kitchen.  She was married in the parlor to Charles Julian Billson on Wednesday, December 20, 1893.  It would be among the last of entertainments hosted by the Kitchen family in the home.

By the turn of the century No. 448 had become home to soap manufacturer John T. Stanley and his family.  Born in London, Stanley had arrived in New York in 1860 and four years later founded the John T. Stanley Company, now one of the largest soap makers in the country.  John and his wife, Susan, had three children, Alfred and John, and a daughter, Margaret.  Both sons would join their father in the family business.  Margaret married educator Charles Howard Parmly in 1898. 


The intricate Italianate-style iron window guards at the basement level are original.

Susan Stanley was active in social issues--a diligent member of the Women's Christian Temperance Union, and an officer in the Demarest Branch of the organization.   The group, of course, rallied against the evils of liquor.  But when Susan hosted a regular meeting in the house on December 26, 1900, it caught the attention of newspaper readers nationwide.

The Demarest Branch was in the midst of launching a "vice crusade," the reach of which went beyond the saloon.  The day following Susan's meeting, the Chicago Tribune ran a headline reading "Kiss Held An Intoxicant--Much Too Popular With Girls, Says W.T.C.U. Speaker."

Indeed, Dr. Anna Hatfield had "interrupted a torrent of eloquence apropos of the saloon as the source of all evil to prove that the nectar quaffed from red lips was more fruitful of consequence than any alcoholic beverage ever distilled," wrote the Tribune.

Hatfield told the women in Susan's parlor, "I think kissing is the worst thing a young woman can do, and the amount of hugging and kissing that some girls--of our best families, too--submit to is literally a menace to our morality.  I know a young man well who declares that he rarely leaves a girl without kissing her good-night  He says that they not only eagerly accede to his request, but that several have insisted upon being kissed."

The women sat aghast as Dr. Hatfield explained that she had carefully studied the matter and discovered that many girls felt this was a way to get husbands.  "It is reprehensible.  These are supposedly well-brought-up daughters of rich parents.  The girls must be taught that it is wrong, not only to kiss a stranger, but to kiss the men they are engaged to,  Too great care cannot be taken."

One woman suggested "that an excellent and efficient way to stop the impropriety would be to instruct the young men in the evils of kissing."  The Chicago Tribune reported that her idea was quickly shot down.  "'But they like it,' said one woman impetuously." 

The Woman's Christian Temperance Union found other issues to rail against, as well.  At another meeting of the group in the West 23rd Street house, on November 21, 1904, the women voted to denounce advertisements in the subway.  They were equally unhappy with smokers and spitters; and agreed to send a letter to the Metropolitan Street Railway Company "calling attention to the use of the platforms of trolley cars by smokers and the unclean condition of said platforms caused by expectoration."

The family maintained a summer residence at Lake Mohonk, New Hampshire.  The 48-year old Charles Parmly died there unexpectedly on September 7, 1917.  His funeral was held in the 23rd Street house.  Margaret stayed on in the residence with her parents.

Seven years later Susan Stanley died in the summer house, on Thursday, June 26, 1924.  As had been the case so many times in the past, her funeral was held in the parlor of No. 448 the following Sunday afternoon.

In 1928 the City announced plans to widen West 23rd Street.  All "encumbrances" were ordered removed to facilitate the project.  This required the removal of all the high stone stoops along the row.   The entrances were lowered to the former basement levels, and the former doorways converted to windows.  Rather amazingly, the Stanley family preserved the rare carved enframement, and even saved the carved entrance doors.  A wrought iron balconette was installed in front of the grand doors.

Ironically, the plans for the street widening were never carried out and the loss of the many stoops was for nothing.

On January 6, 1935 the 91-year old John T. Stanley died unexpectedly in No. 448 West 23rd Street.  His would be the last funeral to take place in the residence.  Margaret Parmly now lived alone in the venerable brownstone.


By mid-century the Stanley house was being operated as furnished rooms.  Around 1982 a conversion resulted not only in five apartments within the house; but the restoration of the brownstone stoop.  Although the elegant cast iron parlor balcony has been lost; the Schwerin mansion survives astonishingly intact; a reminder of a time when wealthy families lived on the block and kissing was a shocking evil.

photographs by the author