Friday, July 22, 2011

The 1903 Isaac L. Rice Home -- 346 West 89th Street

photo by

Twenty-five years after Frederick Law Olmsted had planned the idyllic Riverside Park along Riverside Drive, it was finally completed.  Imposing views of the Hudson River and New Jersey palisades, along with the pleasant green park made residential lots desirable.

By the turn of the century, Riverside Drive was the Upper West Side’s answer to Fifth Avenue.  Here millionaire builders were less restricted and, along with the many upper-class row houses, were no fewer than thirty free-standing mansions with lawns and gardens.

In 1899 the site for the planned Soldiers and Sailors Monument was chosen in the park at 89th Street.  That same year real estate developer William W. Hall sold the plot of land directly across from it to Isaac L. Rice for $225,000.  The lot carried the restriction that anything built here must “be a high class private dwelling house, not less than four stories, and designed for the use of one family only.”

The New York Times chimed in on the purchase noting that it “doubtless means the construction of a mansion that will be a fitting companion to the Clark residence on the opposite corner.”

Rice made a surprising choice of architects for his new residence, selecting Herts & Tallant, a firm that was making its mark as theater designers.  Rice was familiar with their abilities, however, having seen their renovations of the Harmonie Club–actually their first commission—of which he was a member.


The German-born Rice had wide interests.  While he made his fortune as legal counsel to railroad companies, most notably the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad, he recognized the potential in electrical inventions and founded the Electric Vehicle Co., the Electric Boat Co., and was president of the Electric Storage Battery Co.

Rice founded the magazine Forum.  It published insights, reviews and comments on political and literary issues.  He was, as well, highly regarded nation-wide as a proficient chess player, Rice invented an opening move known as the “Rice gambit.”

If Rice’s choice of architects was unexpected, it was not regrettable.  As plans were filed with the Department of Buildings in August 1900, The New York Times wrote “Isaac L.Rice will build one of the finest mansions in the city…The French villa style of architecture will be followed…The exterior will be of brick and granite, with marble trimmings.  In the centre of the structure an observatory tower will rise to a height of ninety-six feet above the curb.”

Deftly combining Neo-Georgian and Beaux-Arts styles, Herts & Tallant produced a red brick mansion trimmed in white marble, as The New York Times predicted.   Four stories tall, it was accessed on the Riverside Drive side through a dramatic stone arch that rose through the third floor.   Between the openings of the porte cochere a carved bas-relief depicted six children with symbols of the Liberal Arts–possibly portraits of the six Rice children.

The bowed porte cochere would later be mirrored in the elliptical bay on the opposite side -- photo by Alice Lum

The mansion was completed in 1903 and the Rices entertained sumptuously.  In keeping with their passionate interest in the arts, they held a dinner party for the French writer and lecturer M. Yves Guyot on December 27, 1904.

The luxurious mansion, named Villa Julia by Rice, and its beautiful setting, however, were not without problems.  Tugboats passing on the Hudson below disturbed Julia Barnett Rice with their incessant horns and whistles.  One purpose of the whistles was to summon crews from their late-night saloon visits.   The intrepid Mrs. Rice would not stand for it.

Julia Rice held an medical degree from the Women’s Medical College of the New York Infirmary, an unusual accomplishment for someone of her sex and social stature at the time.   In 1905 she rallied the neighbors in a campaign to regulate the whistle blowing.  Armed with petitions signed by hundreds of residents as well as the heads of several hospitals, she called upon Health Commissioner Darlington (claiming the noise “shattered nerves”), Police Commissioner McAdoo, Collector Stranahan, and other city officials.

The porte cochere sculpture possibly represents the Rice children -- photo by Alice Lum

The New York Times reported that ‘Mrs. Rice is prepared to lay the matter before Secretary Shaw of the Treasury Department if the city authorities find themselves powerless to remedy the matter.”

“Shattered nerves cannot be repaired,” she complained.  “No reasonable person objects to the orderly use of whistles on the river or to continuous whistling on foggy nights when there is danger of a collision.  However there is no justification for the almost continuous blowing of tugboat whistles every night, which makes sleep impossible for hours at a time.  It is a situation which rightly calls for protest, and the protest is not confined to the wealthy residents of Riverside Drive.”

photo by Alice Lum

The tugboat officers retaliated.  Each night a group of tugs would gather within range of Villa Julia, directing spotlights into the windows and blowing their steam whistles.  It only steeled Julia Rice in her mission.

By November 1906 she had won her battle.  “Unnecessary tooting” became a violation of the navigation laws.  But Julia Rice was not done yet.   Within a month she had organized the Society for the Suppression of Unnecessary Noise and lashed out against noise in the vicinity of hospitals.  “I have been informed that in some instances patients have been driven insane by these unnecessary noises,” she claimed.

Armed with a gramophone and recordings of street noise, she invited reporters into her library to listen to what The New York Times called “the whirr and bang of flat-wheeled surface cars, the shriek and rumble of the elevated expresses, the honk of the automobile, and the various discordant street cries, tooting of whistles, yell of street vendors, etc.”

Today’s quiet zones around hospitals owe their existence to the fervent struggles of Julia Rice.

In February 1906 Mrs. Rice hired a young servant girl, Hortense Uzac, who had just arrived in New York from her native France.  Three weeks after the maid had begun work, Julie Rice left her bedroom around 10:00 at night to attend to a reception downstairs.  She failed to lock the bedroom door.

Half an hour later she returned and noticed a ring that had been on her dresser was missing.  A few days later, as Detective Moran was questioning the servants one-by-one in the parlor, the girl bolted from the house and threw herself into the icy Hudson River.  She was pulled out and arrested for attempted suicide.  Juila Rice reacted with kindness and sympathy.

“There was no accusation of any sort against the Uzac  girl,” she insisted, “unless the police may charge her with attempting to take her life.”  The ring was found in a search of the house.  “Nothing else is missing and no accusations of any sort are made by us,” she said.

Isaac Rice, by 1907, was president of the Holland Torpedo Boat Company, a position that required him, along with Julia, to spend extended periods of time in Europe.  They decided to sell Villa Julia.

In December 1907 it was sold to cigarette manufacturer Solomon Schinasi for $600,000.  In reporting the sale, The New York Times noted “The Rice house, with its grounds, modeled after an Italian villa, has long been one of the show places along Riverside Drive.”

Schinasi, said The New York Times, “will occupy the house as soon as extensive alterations can be completed.”  The “extensive alterations” included an extension at the southeast corner and a semicircular bay.  Mansion architect C. P. H. Gilbert designed the renovations, melding them seamlessly with the Herts & Tallant architecture.

In 1912 Gilbert was brought back to design a new brick and marble wall around the property–the original having been ordered demolished as it extended beyond the property wall.  Gilbert mimicked the balustrades of the Soldiers and Sailors Memorial across the street, creating a harmonious flow.

Schinasi died in the house of heart disease on October 4, 1919.  Eight years later his son Leon added a garage and an additional story to the bay extension, all in keeping with the original architectural design.

Ruby Schinasi remained in the house after Leon’s death.  In 1935 the wealthy widow reported spending $30,000 annually on each of her two children, Solomon, then eight years old, and Betty, six.

Change came in 1954 when the yeshiva Chofetz Chaim acquired the mansion.  The building was a blessing and a curse to the cash-strapped religious school for Jewish children.   While the yeshiva attempted to maintain the structure, costs were always an issue.

So when, in 1980, a developer offered between $1.5 and $2 million for the property as the site of a 30-story tower-plaza building, good fortune seemed to shine on the school.  A battle between the school and preservationists quickly developed.  Facing the school across the battle lines were high-powered names like Jacqueline Onassis and Itzhak Perlman.  It would be one of the fiercest and most harrowing landmark battles in the city.

The Landmarks Preservation Commission was charged with proving that the mansion possessed special character, special historical or aesthetic interest, or value.”  Rabbi Feigelstock of the yeshiva didn’t think it did.  “By me, Isaac Rice is not anybody,” he said

Whether Rice was anybody or not, the house was determined to be a landmark and the yeshiva was stuck with it.

By 2005 it was becoming degraded.  Now home to Yeshiva Ketana, its decorative copper was falling away, the balustrade wall was cracked and deteriorating and neighbors complained regularly that Julia Rice’s Italian gardens were now a dust bowl, filling their homes with dirt on windy days.

The mansion remains in the hands of the yeshiva, which tries valiantly to keep the property in repair.  It is one of two surviving freestanding mansions on Riverside Drive and a lovely, if tattered reminder of better days.


  1. I moved to the block behind this building a few months ago and have been very interested in the back-story - this is more than I could have hoped for! Thank you - keep up your amazing research and work.

  2. Glad you enjoyed it. It's a great house with a very interesting history. And I defy anyone to find the subsequent alterations without knowing what they are beforehand.

  3. Great post! I loved the photo of the porte cochere sculpture. Those are the children. My grandfather is the youngest one, near the top. My grandmother took us by the house at the same time flyers were being distributed about getting landmark status for the building and grounds. The children were schooled at home and could study anything they wanted. The symbols represented what they were interested in at the time the sculpture was done.
    I found your post because I was looking for proof that Julia used a gramophone to record the tugboat noises. Where did you locate that information?

    1. According to a report in The New York Times, January 15, 1907, she used a graphophone to record all kinds of noises, and reproduced the sounds during the very first meeting of her Society; you can find the report on the website of the NYT, the heading of the article is: "Mrs. Rice put at head of anti-noise society".

    2. You may be interested in my chapter on the Rices and their lives in Making Noise: From Babel to the Big Bang and Beyond (NY: Zone and MIT, 2011) pp. 484-538, which covers in detail many of the things mentioned here. I would also be interested in talking with you. &60-436-7748. Hillel Schwartz

  4. What a fascinating bit of history you just provided! Thanks so much for your input.

    The information regarding the recorded tugboat sounds were from a contemporary newspaper article.

  5. Interesting! I work in the school, and I have always wondered about its history. I marvel at the detailing that I see throughout the building and in the classrooms. What lucky kids get to learn in classrooms with fireplaces and sweeping views of the Hudson River! A few things spark my interest on a regular basis: there is also a very old looking Otis elevator still in use, a dusty chandelier hanging down the center of the marble staircase in the main entryway, and some beautiful stained glass windows along the staircase between the second and third floors.
    Try to stop by one time to check it out - it's not a private residence, so they might let you in.

  6. Regarding the gardens - a few years ago, the Yeshiva renovated the garden area for the children to use as a playground. When I was a child in the school, we were prohibited to enter that area because it was not maintained and possibly dangerous, so I understand the complaints about "dust bowl" conditions. Today, however, no one is complaining.

  7. Very intriguing. Thanks for the update on the gardens. Now ... regarding a visit to those stained glass windows! I would love to see inside that wonderful house.

  8. Doubt I can be much help but my mother was Betti Schinasi. She shared a few fun memories of growing up there, sliding down the banisters, a sub-sub basement with secret tunnel passage leading to the home of a friend of the Rice's, fellow chess player. Ms. Rice may correct me but I believe Mom told me her mother, Ruby, had the street address changed from Riverside Drive to 89th St. to reduce pretension and, to help put away any "rich kid" teasing at school. Finally, a few years ago, I was visiting NYC with son and was seen taking pictures of the house from across the street. Not to alarm the elementary school teacher, I came by to introduce myself. After a short wait, I was graciously invited inside to tour the school and the building, every corner of it. While it shows the ravages of decades of use as a grade school, there remain historical remnants if you know where to look, down in the basement, etc., civil defense provisions, etc. That's about all I can offer. I thought I'd heard someone was to purchase the building, restore or repair it, and pay to relocate the school down the street to more appropriate facilities. Not sure what came of that.

    1. By chance I ran into property records containing the names Rubi and Betti Schinasi. If your interested Rubi was selling a property on W 215th on behalf of the minor Betti in 1934 to Marymount College. Now it's a Seventh Day Adventist's School

  9. Tom

    I have a photo/scan of this building from a early issue of Architectural Record; if you want I can send it to you.

    This is a great find for my research and work I's doing on my blog.

    If ok I would like to repost 1 or 2 of your picures on my blog

  10. Tom Rice, a descendant, wrote the following email and allowed me to post it for readers' information:

    My wife saw your very informative post about the Rice Mansion on Riverside Drive. I presume you have moved well beyond that blog to many other things, but I did want to mention that one of the six children (my great aunt), Dorothy Rice Sims (known as Polly), wrote a wonderful book about the children growing up in the city and in the house. It is called Curiouser and Curiouser. I loved it. And I saw a used copy on Amazon for $17. (I can't part with mine.)

    Best regards,

    Tom Rice

    1. Tom,
      My grandmother was Marjorie Rice, (known as Lolly ). She was the youngest daughter, next to youngest sibling. I have a journal she kept on a trip through Europe and Asia. She refers to her brother Tom as "Baby". Lolly was 12 when she wrote the journal. It is clear that your grandfather was doted upon by his mother and four older sisters.

  11. I can't fathom how anyone could be dull (or blinded) so moch as to propose destroying such a beautiful structure.

  12. Clips of the movie Evergreen was filmed in the front garden of the Rice mansion. I was teaching there at the time and it was fascinating to see the gardens brought back to their original look, as well as to see the people from the film milling about in the proper attire of the time. I would love to see photos of the way the rooms looked before the building became a school. I think my classroom was a mini ballroom. The attic was also beautiful and filled with many windows and sunlight.

  13. I used to work at Kateri residente a block away and sit down on my lunch break in front of the Julia Villa and dream that one day would be my house. I wonder in today's dollars what price would have the Rice mansion if it were on sale and if the Yeshiva people would be interested in selling it. Not that I have the money but to dream is costless.

  14. Anyone know who carved the children on the Porte cochere? I’m curious. Thanks.

    1. the name of the sculptor is a mystery as the artist's name was never recorded at the time. There are various thoughts on who executed it, but not are confirmed.