Friday, July 7, 2023

The 1893 Munroe Smith House - 635 West 115th Street

 


In 1896 Columbia University left its collection of Midtown buildings for a new campus in the remote Morningside Heights district.  The move created problems for fraternities and academic clubs, which had costly clubhouses downtown, and for faculty and staff.  Two Columbia professors, however, were far ahead of the game.

In 1891 Francis M. Burdick and Munroe Smith acquired two 25-foot-wide plots on the undeveloped block of West 115th Street, between Riverside Drive and Broadway.  The site was just one block west of the proposed campus.  The educators hired architect Henry Otis Chapman to design mirror-image houses at 633 and 635 West 115th Street.  Construction began in 1892 and was completed the following year.  

The handsome Colonial Revival style houses were faced in yellow brick and trimmed in terra cotta.  The design was dominated by the striking Federal-style arched doorways with leaded and stained glass sidelights and exquisite fanlights.  Each of the four stories was defined by a terra cotta bandcourse.  The houses shared a delicate dentiled cornice.


Edmund Munroe Smith, who went professionally by Munroe Smith, moved his family into 635 West 115th Street.  He and his wife, the former Emma Gertrude Huidekoper, had one daughter, Gertrude Munroe, who was two years old at the time.

Munroe Smith from the collection of the Columbia University Archives.

Smith was a very well-educated man.  He graduated from Amherst Collect in 1874, earned his law degree from Columbia Law School in 1877, re-enrolled in Amherst in 1879, and received his J.U.D. from the University of Gรถttingen in 1880.  That year he was hired at Columbia University as an instructor in history and Roman law.  When he and his family moved into the 115th Street house, he was a full professor of Roman law and comparative jurisprudence.

The Smiths' large house afforded them the ability to take in other Columbia educators.  By 1906 Dr. Henry Rogers Seager, a professor of political economy, lived with the family.  Born in Kiev, Russia, he earned his Ph.D at the University of Michigan in 1890.  Both he and Munroe Smith were members of the Century Association, the membership of which was composed of authors, artists, and "amateurs of letters and fine arts."  

Henry Rogers Seager, from the collection of the Library of Congress

Another Columbia professor, John Bates Clark, and his wife, the former Myra A. Smith (no relation to their landlord), were listed here by 1909.  Born in Providence, Rhode Island in 1847, Clark taught economics.  His controversial views about capitalism had softened by the time he boarded with the Smiths.  Early on he had been a critic of capitalism, favoring instead German Socialism.  His views eventually evolved to make him a leading proponent of capitalism.

All three men wrote extensively.  They were the authors of academic books, articles and monographs in their respective areas.

The professors would have to find alternative lodging in 1910.  The Smiths moved out in 1910, and an advertisement in the New York Herald on October 2 offered the unfurnished house for rent.  It touted "11 rooms, 3 baths, immediate possession, refined residential section."

The house became home to Edward Purcell Slevin, his wife, the former Josephine Mary Hecker, and their daughter Elizabeth.  The couple's country home, East Clive, was in West Orange.  Another daughter, Paula, had been married on January 11 that year to Stephen Valentine Farrelly.

Only months after moving into 635 West 115th Street, Josephine died on March 15, 1911.  Edward remained in the house for years.

Then, on October 6, 1921, the New York Herald announced that "the Catholics of Columbia University" had purchased 635 West 115th Street "for occupancy as the Newman Club, an organization of Catholic students, who will occupy it after extensive alterations are completed."  The article added, "The present plans embody an assembly hall, committee meeting rooms, space for informal dances and other features, besides a library and reading room."

A chapel was installed in the basement level, where mass was said every day and twice on Sundays.  On the parlor floor was a "large comfortable reception room" where lectures were sometimes given, as well as social events.  The reading room and library were on the second floor.  Father H. F. Riley of the Paulist Fathers, the club's chaplain, resided in the house.

On April 7, 1922, the Columbia Alumni News reported on the opening of Newman Hall.  The article noted, "An inspection of the newly opened club house was made under the guidance of Father Riley, the resident Chaplain."  The Handbook to Catholic Historic New York City explained in 1927:

Newman Hall is the center for Catholic students.  The Newman Club of Columbia University was established in 1902.  Its headquarters at No. 635 West 115th Street is a meeting place for the members of the Newman Club in and around New York City.

The Newman Club remained until the early Depression years, selling the property to Armic Restaurant, Inc., which leased it.  Living here in 1938 was John M. Kelly, chief supervisor in the Department of Markets.  Kelly had been a city employee since 1920.  Two years later, Angelina Geminiani was leasing the house.  Living with her were her 17-year-old daughter, Regina, and two boarders, John and Eleanor Morgan.

The house in 1941 appeared little different than it does today.  image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

In 1946 Columbia University purchased the former Smith house.  It became the center of the school's Modern China Research Project in 1958.  Professor Howard L. Boorman, its director, said that year, "One phase of this project is to compile a biographic dictionary of Chinese personalities as a basic reference tool to enable scholars to fill more readily the research gap for the transition period between 1911 and 1949."  The Modern China Research Project was still here as late as 1967.

Trouble came to Columbia University in the spring of 1972 when anti-war protestors shut down the campus.  On May 4, 1972, The New York Times reported, "Black and Latin students continued their occupation of Lewisohn Hall and an off-campus brownstone at 635 West 115th Street, which is owned by the university."  Over a week later, on May 13, the newspaper reported that the house had been "voluntarily vacated by the black and Latin students."

On the same day, the N.Y. Amsterdam News reported, "The University President has also agreed to an extension of the CEEP Program through 1974 and to provide the university facilities at 635 West 115th for the exclusive use of the CEEP Program."  That project, the Community Educational Exchange Program, "provides compensatory education for Harlem residents," as explained by The New York Times.

Later the building became home to the university's Office of Environmental Stewardship.  Appropriately, in November 2007 it was one of two Columbia buildings to receive a "green roof."  Nilda Mesa, Director of Environmental Stewardship explained in December that year, "Grass and plants growing on green roofs take in carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and turn it into oxygen, helping cool temperatures in the hottest months and cleaning the air supply."


While its fraternal twin next door has been slightly altered, 635 West 115th Street is remarkably intact, including its wonderful 1893 doorway.

 photographs by the author
LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog

Thursday, July 6, 2023

The Fourth Avenue Studio - 337-341 Park Avenue South


 
In the early 1870's, Allen B. Miller & Brother's carriage auction house operated from the southeast corner of Fourth Avenue and 25th Street.  At the time, the concept of "studio buildings" was gaining popularity in the city, sparked by James Boorman Johnston's far-sighted 1858 Tenth Street Studios Building.  Studio buildings provided both living and working space for artists.

Owners Robert and Ogden Goelet demolished the old building in 1875 and erected the Fourth Avenue Studio.  Four stories tall, it was faced in red brick and trimmed in in stone.  While essentially neo-Grec in design, it retained elements of the Italianate style, notably in the elliptically arched openings.  Large floor-to-ceiling windows on the second and third floors of the 25th Street elevation flooded those studios with northern light, so important to artists.  Three entrances--one to the upper floors and two to the commercial spaces--were framed in stone and flanked by polished columns.

King's Views of Ne York, 1893 (copyright expired)

The Fourth Street Studio quickly filled.  On October 4, 1876, the New York Herald announced, "Sam Colman has returned and put up his quarters in the new Studio Building on Fourth avenue.  He was joined by other artists within two months.  On January 2, 1877, the New York Herald reported, "[George] Smillie has taken up his quarters in the new Fourth avenue studio building and is at work on landscape and cattle subjects."  The article reiterated, "Colman, who has returned from his wanderings, has on his easel a painting of Durham Cathedral, perched away upon a high hill, with a placid sheet of water seen in the foreground.  He has also taken up his quarters in the fourth avenue studio."  Both Colman and Smillie were primarily landscape artists.  

Colman was a founder of the American Water Color Society and was its first president.  He was close friends with Louis Comfort Tiffany, who had studied with Colman in the 1860s.  The two would later collaborate on interior design.  It was possibly their close relationship that influenced Louis Tiffany's choosing the building next door at 333-335 Park Avenue for his Tiffany Glass Company's headquarters in 1887.

Colman's Storm King on the Hudson.  from the collection of the Smithsonian American Art Museum.

George Smillie came from an artistic family.  His father, under whom he studied, was artist James Smillie, and his brother James David Smillie was also an artist.  George Smillie's landscapes were often set along the New England coast.

Other original tenants were painters Agnes Dean Abbatt, Elizabeth H. Remington, and sculptor Charles Calverley.  

Primarily a still life painter of flowers, Elizabeth H. Remington painted The Two Kings--Corn and Cotton in the Fourth Street Studio building in 1876.  from the collection of Bernard Baruch

Born in Albany in 1833, Calverley had dropped out of school at the age of 13 to support his family after his father died.  He found a job with stonecutter John Dixon who paid him $1 a week to clean out his stoves and make fires.  Beginning in 1853 he apprenticed with sculptor Erastus Dow Palmer, and by the time he moved into the Fourth Street Studio was a member of the National Academy of Design.  

On April 26, 1888, The Albany Evening Journal reported that a committee of Albany gentlemen "proceeded to New York last evening for the purpose of formally accepting the clay model of Mr. Calverley's statue of Robert Burns to be erected in Washington Park...If the clay model is satisfactory, the statue will be cast immediately and unveiled in Washington park on Aug. 30."  It was, indeed, satisfactory and the Burns statue in Albany became his most famous piece.  A bust based on that work was commissioned by Andrew Carnegie for the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1891.

In 1879, Appleton's Dictionary of New York and Vicinity commented, "There is quite a large colony of artists in New York, and for their accommodation several buildings have been fitted up for studio purposes."  It noted that among the buildings "devoted exclusive to artists is the 'Fourth Avenue Studio Building,' cor. of 4th av. and 25th st.  This was erected very recently, and is fitted up for studio purposes almost exclusively."

Among the tenants in the early 1880s were painters Robert Ward Van Boskerck, Albert Fitch Bellows, Ernest Longfellow, and Sarah Rhodes Macknight.  By 1886, all three of the Smillies--James, James David, and George--occupied studios in the building.

Artist J. Wells Champney and his wife, the former Elizabeth Williams, lived here by 1882 when The Evening Telegram notified other socialites on November 16, "Mrs. G. W. Champney is at home on Wednesdays at her studio rooms, No. 337 Fourth avenue."  Elizabeth entertained routinely in the studio/apartment.  On December 7, 1890, for instance, The Press reported, "Yesterday Mr. and Mrs. J. Wells Champney gave a tea at their residence, No. 337 Fourth avenue."

In the meantime, by 1884 one of the ground floor commercial spaces was home to Charles Lurch's piano store.  That year New York's Great Industries said, "he keeps in his warerooms only the best made instruments, carefully selected by him from among our leading manufacturers...He occupies a fine large store, centrally located, and carries a splendid stock of new instruments of all kinds and styles."

The 1890s saw studios occupied by Frank B. Carpenter, John du Fais, Frederick Wilson, and architect Charles E. Thain.  On September 7, 1893, a reporter from The Press visited the studio of Frank B. Carpenter "carrying to the well known artist news of the death of Hamilton Fish."  The article said, "Mr. Carpenter was putting the finishing touches on a copy of his 'Arbitration' painting, the original of which was presented to Queen Victoria two years ago by Mrs. William W. Carson of Newburg and now hangs in Windsor Castle."

The news was especially meaningful to Carpenter.  Hamilton Fish occupied a prominent place in the Arbitration painting, which depicted the 1871 Treaty of Washington between the United States and Great Britain.  He and Carpenter had spent much time in repeated sittings and interviews, and the two came to know one another well.

At the turn of the century, Tiffany & Company expanded its showrooms into the ground floor.

Famed artist William Merritt Chase took space in the building in 1908.  In her 1917 biography The Life and Art of William Merritt Chase, Katharine Metcalf Roof wrote:

The Fourth Avenue Studio was even more spacious than the Tenth Street place.  Partitions were taken down until a connecting chain of four rooms remained, two of which were extremely large.  Somewhat overcrowded, yet without seeming actually cluttered because of their size, these rooms were beautiful in tone and color.  Rich draperies, Spanish, Italian, Chinese, and Japanese embroideries were in evidence on all sides.  Pictures of his own and of other painters, including a few old masters, stood about or were hung on the walls.  Beautiful old furniture, including some rare Spanish pieces, bits of porcelain, brass, copper, Japanese carvings; miscellaneous objets d'art, Italian, French, Dutch, Spanish, and Oriental, were set each in the exactly right place--for the taste that can enjoy such multitudinous ornament!

It would not be long, however, before non-artistic tenants moved into the Fourth Avenue Studio Building.  More modern studio buildings that were being erected uptown, many of them on the Upper West Side, lured artists away.  In 1905 Tiffany & Company moved uptown and the ground floor of 337-341 Fourth Avenue became home to the Fifth Avenue Auction Rooms, which would remain into the 1920s.  The Hartley Silk Mfg. Co. operated from an upper floor space by 1915, and the Atlas Knitting Co. was here in 1918, supplying underwear to the U.S. Army.

By 1921 it appears that Isabel L. Whitney was the last artist in the building.  She would remain at least until 1925.  Among the other tenants was Alfred Littauer & Co., manufacturers and wholesalers of surgical instruments.  The firm occupied space until the Depression years.  Appropriately, in 1939 the American Artists League, Inc. rented space in the building.  

In 1959 Fourth Avenue was renamed Park Avenue South.  By then the distinguished history of the building was mostly forgotten.  Somewhat fittingly, in the early 1970s art returned to the building in the form of the L A L Photo Gallery, which staged exhibitions of the works of photographers.


The ground floor space where Tiffany & Company once exhibited stained glass windows and other masterful works is today home to a bank branch.

photographs by the author
LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog

Wednesday, July 5, 2023

The 1881 Frank C. Markham House - 155 East 71st Street

 



James R. Breen and Alfred G. Nason started their partnership as "carpenters."  By the early 1870s they had become full-fledged contractors.  Both men became wealthy and influential (Nason was a friend of Presidents Ulysses Grant and Theodore Roosevelt).  Among the structures built by Breen & Nason would be Grant's Tomb.

There were rare instances when the partners acted as their own developers and architects.  They started one such project on April 1, 1881 when they purchased the old 40-foot-wide wooden house at 155-157 East 71st Street from Thomas D. Stetson for $15,500 (around $425,000 in 2023).  The price reflected the increasing development in the Lenox Hill district.

Before the end of the year Breen & Nason had completed two upscale, mirror-image houses.  An advertisement on Christmas Day 1881 read:

An elegant new four-story and basement house, No. 155 East 71st-st., just completed by Breen & Nason, No,. 341 East 59th-st.; cabinet finish, mirrors &c.; house open daily.

The 20-foot-wide residence was designed in the neo-Grec style.  At four stories tall, the high-stooped house and its fraternal twin towered over their neighbors.  Breen & Nason's use of spandrel panels below and above each window emphasized the geometry of the neo-Grec style.

Frank Chauncey Markham purchased 155 East 71st Street in April 1882, paying the equivalent of $807,000 today.  A stockbroker, he and his wife, the former Louisa Hill, had two daughters, Mary Louise and Helen Taylor.

The family moved into the new house just in time for Mary Louise's introduction to society.  As was often the case, a wedding quickly followed.  On June 15, 1884 the Buffalo Courier reported on her marriage to Charles Townsend in St. James Church.  A reception followed in the Markham house.  "The bridal party received before a large mirror, which was festooned with bands of  roses of all colors," said the article.  "The floral decoration in all the reception rooms and halls were noticeably effective.  The newel-post in the main hallway supported a huge vase of regal flowers."  The article said that after the last of the guests left, the bride and groom "disappeared for parts unmentioned."

The Markhams left the East 71st Street house not long afterward.  It became home to Herrman and Eveline Schiffer.   Eveline was the daughter of Minna and Samuel Schiffer, and whether she and Herrman were related before marriage is unclear.

On June 1, 1888, Herrman and Alfred Schiffer became partners with Isaias Meyer in the silk manufacturing firm Pelgram & Meyer.  They filled the position of Meyer's deceased partner, Charles R. Pelgram.

Eveline Schiffer fell ill early in 1889 and died in the house on March 19.  Her funeral was held in the drawing room on March 22.

No. 155 East 71st Street next became home to Dr. Andrew J. McCosh, who purchased it on June 22, 1903.  Born in Belfast, Ireland in 1858, he was the son of Dr. James McCosh,  who had become president of Princeton University in the family's new homeland.  Not surprisingly, McCosh attended Princeton, before earning his medical degree from the Columbia's College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1880.

By the time Dr. McCosh purchased 155 East 71st Street, he was considered to be one of the leading surgeons of the country, and was a professor of clinical surgery at Columbia University.  He was the author of several medical books, including Remarks on Spinal Surgery, Four Cases of Brain Surgery, and Surgical Intervention in Benign Gastric Lesions."

Andrew McCosh's residency would be short.  He sold the house in February 1905 to Francis G. Lloyd, the president of Brooks Brothers.  It does not appear that the Lloyds ever lived in the residence, but rented it.  Lloyd hired the architectural firm of Trowbridge & Livingston to make interior updates and install new windows in 1907.

Lloyd's tenants by 1910 were the family of merchant Gustavus Owen Winston.  The wealthy young man was just 27-years-old at the time.  His and his wife, the former Margaret Dey, had three sons, four-year-old John Lloyd; Owen Lloyd, who was 3; and little Francis Lloyd, just one year old.  Also living with the family was Gustavus's brother, 19-year-old Eric S. Winston.  Their father Gustavus S. Winston, had died in 1899 and their mother was now remarried.

The Winston family had five live-in servants: three Irish maids who ranged in age from 16 to 25, a French-born servant who was most likely Margaret's lady's maid or possibly the children's nursemaid, and 17-year-old William Zangl, who was born in Austria.

Eric S. Winston was attending Harvard at the time.  He graduated in 1912 and two years later his engagement to Maud Arden Kennedy was announced.

The well-dressed and well-to-do Eric and Maud Winston at the New York Horse Show not long after their marriage.  from the collection of the Library of Congress.

The Winstons left 155 East 71st Street in 1914.  Francis G. Lloyd leased the house next to Clendening J. Ryan, son of millionaire Thomas Fortune Ryan, and then to Thomas Frothingham.

In 1919 he sold the house to stockbroker Richard Lewis Morris and his wife, the former Caroline Whitney Fellowes.  Morris was the son of Stuyvesant Fish Morris and Ellen James Van Buren and was descended from Lewis Morris, a signer of the Declaration of Independence.  He and Caroline had two children, Cornelia Fellowes, born in 1909, and Richard Jr., born in 1917.  Their summer home, The Three Chimneys, was in Southampton.

In 1925 the Morrises hired architect Auguste Noel to modernize their brownstone house.  He removed the stoop and moved the entrance to the former English basement level, just below grade.  He enlarged the openings at what was now the third floor, connecting them with a single lintel.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

Cornelia was introduced to society at a dinner dance at the Park Lane on December 1, 1928.  Saying she was "well known to the younger set of the Hamptons," the Standard Union noted that Cornelia "spent last year in France at L'Ermitage, Versailles."

Unlike many debutantes, Cornelia seems to have been in no hurry to marry.  It was not until April 28, 1933, that the New York Evening Post reported, "Descendants of families prominent in the early history of the United States are being married this afternoon when Miss Cornelia Fellowes Morris becomes the bride of Mr. Malcolm Graham Field."  Coincidentally, the wedding took place in St. James Church, where Mary Louise Markham had been married half a century earlier.  A reception following in the East 71st Street house.

As was the case with all wealthy families, the society pages followed the Morrises' movements.  On May 4, 1934, for instance, The New York Sun reported that Richard and Caroline "will be among the New Yorkers attending the Kentucky Derby on Saturday.  They are motoring to Louisville, stopping en route at Washington, Arlington, Charlottesville and White Sulphur Springs."

Richard Lewis Morris died at the age of 79 on July 4, 1954.  He and Caroline had been gone from 155 East 71st Street for several years at the time.  In 1953 the house was converted to a triplex apartment in the lower part, with one apartment each on the upper two stories.  



The configuration lasted until 1967 when the basement level was converted to an office, with a duplex on the first and second floors, and one apartment each on the third and fourth.  The top two floors were combined to a duplex apartment in 1988.

photographs by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Tuesday, July 4, 2023

Advent Lutheran Church - 2504 Broadway



On February 28, 1900, John O. Baker sold the vacant plot at the northeast corner of Broadway and 93rd Street to the Evangelical Lutheran Church of the Advent for $54,000.  Just over four months later, on June 19, architect William A. Potter filed plans for a “one story brick and limestone church” which would cost $70,000, bringing the total outlay to more than 4.1 million in 2023 dollars.  In reporting on the filing, the New-York Tribune noted, “The congregation, of which the Rev. Dr. C. F. Krotel is pastor, now worships in the hall of the West Side Republican Club, Broadway, near Eighty-fourth-st.”
 
The son of New York Bishop Alonzo Potter and brother of Bishop Henry Codman Potter, William A. Potter had served as a Supervising Architect of the United States Treasury from 1874 to 1877.  Now, instead of Government buildings, he was better known for churches and the numerous buildings he designed for Princeton University.
 
For this project, Potter turned to what the Lutheran League Review called “a style of modern English Gothic.”  It was the architect’s personal, somewhat truncated take on English Collegiate Gothic.  Faced in red and black brick and trimmed in Indiana limestone, the Broadway elevation stressed verticality with full-height stone piers and a soaring Gothic window.  The stained-glass windows, as well as the ceramic alter mosaic, were executed by Tiffany Studios.
 
Potter's office released this frame-worthy rendering a year before the building was completed.  American Architect & Building News, June 23, 1900.

The Evangelical Lutheran Church of the Advent was only three years old, organized by Rev. George Frederick Krotel in 1897.  This was the second congregation he founded.  In 1868, he had organized the English Evangelical Lutheran Church of the Holy Trinity.  By the time the Church of the Advent moved into its “fine new building,” as described by the Lutheran League Review, Rev. Krotel had “built up a flourishing congregation on the upper west side.”
 
The church was consecrated on April 14, 1901.  In reporting on the upcoming event, The New York Times mentioned, “One of the women members of the congregation has contracted with a well-known organ builder to put in a fine new organ as a memorial, and this is to be ready on May 1.”  Tiffany Studios received the commission to decorate the front pipes of the instrument, as well.
 
The intricate mosaics behind the altar were executed by Tiffany Studios.

The architectural critic of The Sun was somewhat tepid in his assessment of the new structure, calling it “one of the most recent examples of a comparatively inexpensive city church.”  He said, “although there is no spire, the suggestion of corner towers adds to the churchliness of the structure.  One excellent feature of the plan of this building is that it harmonizes with surrounding structures.”
 
On May 17, 1907, six years after his church was completed, the Rev. Dr. George Frederick Krotel died of a stroke at the age of 82.  In reporting his death, The Sun called him “one of the best known Evangelical Lutheran clergymen in the State.”  So beloved was he by his congregation, that nearly two decades later, on May 17, 1926, The New York Times reported, “The Krotel Centenary was observed yesterday at the Evangelical Lutheran church of the Advent.”  Rev. A. Steimle compared Krotel “to the Gospel of St. John, v. 31: ‘He was a burning and a shining light.’”  In his remarks, Steimle said, “A more fruitful life I do not know.  His influence is still felt among us.” 

Indeed, ten years later on December 27, 1936, a memorial service for Rev. Krotel was included in the program of the church's 40th anniversary ceremonies.
 
The congregation received a colorful pastor in 1956 in Rev. John Garcia Gensel.  Always a devotee of jazz music, when he first arrived in New York City he took a course on the influence of jazz on modern culture at the New School for Social Research.  On March 27, 1965 the Recorder-Gazette said, “This led to doing field work at various clubs.  Wearing his clerical collar and drinking cokes, he was not at first accepted by the musicians, but finally one by one they came to him for help and his ministry took hold.”  The New York Times explained, “as word got around about the hip minister, more and more musicians would come to him with personal and spiritual problems.”  Eventually the Lutheran Board of American Missions allowed Rev. Gensel to devote half his time to ministering to the jazz community and the other half to his church duties.  An assistant pastor was supplied to pick up any slack.
 
Jazz music was often—in fact, almost always—a part of the services at the Advent Lutheran Church.  But a particular funeral outshone any other event.  Famous jazz composer, pianist and arranger Tadd Dameron died on March 8, 1965 and his funeral was held three days later.  The New York Times began its reporting on the services saying, “The Benny Golson Jazz Quintet played ‘The Squirrel’ yesterday at a funeral in the Advent Lutheran Church at Broadway and 93d Street.  It was one of the late Tadd Dameron’s favorites and his friends said he would have loved it.”
 
About 150 musicians, “all well-known in the world of jazz,” were in attendance.  The article said that Rev. Gensel “let the music speak for itself—and for Tadd.  There was one hymn, ‘Nearer My God to Thee,’ but the Golson Quintet carried the burden of the service.”
 
In 1977 Rev. Gensel was relocated to St. Peter’s Lutheran Church in Midtown, where he continued his “jazz ministry.”  But that did not end jazz music at Advent Lutheran Church.
 
On November 24, 1983, The New York Times reported on the Thanksgiving dinner the church had supplied to 350 men and women from welfare hotels.  “At 7 A.M. a battalion of 27 cooks and servers began arriving in the cramped basement kitchen, with its eight-burner stove.  Martha Sickles…brought her jazz records.”  As a matter of fact, the annual feast had been founded by jazz musician Billy Moore.
 
Feeding several hundred people a proper Thanksgiving meal required much help.  Set decorator and costume designer Lynn Tonnessen, said the article, “spent two nights baking 35 pumpkin and apple pies.  There were 33 turkeys including the first one ever prepared by Art Fried, a Legal Aid lawyer.”  Eight of those turkeys were prepared by Mayor Ed Koch’s chef, Mitchell London, who also turned out 500 chocolate chip and oatmeal cookies.
 
Music continues to be a mainstay within the congregation.  An especially notable musical event was “Moondog Rising,” in October 2007.  The two-day music festival paid homage to the late Moondog, a long-haired, bearded blind man who had worn a handmade Viking helmet and cloak.  The New York Times recalled, “he regularly stationed himself at Sixth Avenue and 54th Street, which cops and cabbies knew as Moondog’s Corner.  Dispensing his poetry, politics, sheet music and recordings…he was sought out over the years by beats, hippies and foreign tourists, but also by the media and celebrities.”  Moondog Rising included “music by Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, Ives, Carter and Kirchner, all playing second fiddle to the classical works of Moondog,” said The New York Times.
 


Classical co-existed the jazz and off-beat music as well.  In 2019 the church presented its Music Mondays series, including, for instance, a pairing of violinist Jennifer Koh and bass-baritone Davone Tines “in music that ranges from Bach and Beethoven to Julia Wolfe and Missy Mazzoli to a hymn and a Korean lullaby.”
 
In 2007 the congregation began an ongoing $1 million fund-raising project to restore the Tiffany Studios windows.
 

photographs by the author
LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog

Monday, July 3, 2023

The Lost Rehearsal Club -- 45-47 West 53rd Street

 

Aspiring actresses, dancers and singers pose on the stoop of the Rehearsal Club.  image via The Daily Mail.

In 1878 real estate developer Jacob B. Tallman completed a row of high-end homes on the north side of 53rd Street, between Fifth and Sixth Avenues.  Their neo-Grec design was on the cutting edge of domestic architectural taste.  Four stories tall and 21-feet-wide, the high-stooped residences were intended for well-heeled families.

In April, Tallman sold 45 West 53rd Street to Jessie Baldwin, and No. 47 to Charles H. Lowerre.  The families paid $22,500 for the homes, or about $630,000 in 2023.  Before long both homes were resold--45 West 53rd Street to Jeannettie Anderson Giles and 47 to Robert Carter.

Jeannettie A. Giles was the wealthy widow of John S. Giles.  Living with her were her three daughters, Jessie Louise, Florence and Margaret.  Her next door neighbor, Robert Carter, was the head of the publishing firm Carter & Brothers.  He and his wife Jane had four adult children, Robert, Peter, Rev. Thomas Carter, and Anne, who had married Rev. Israel Williams Cochran in 1868.

The first of the Giles daughters to marry was Jessie Louise.  Her wedding to Cuyler Van Vechten was held in St. Bartholomew's Church on November 19, 1884.  Guests came to the 45 West 53rd Street afterward, the New-York Tribune  mentioning, "The parlors were profusely decorated with palms and flowering plants."

Anne and Israel Cochran were living in Mendhan, New Jersey at the time.  Rev. Cochran was pastor of the First Presbyterian Church there.  In 1885 the family (the Cochrans had 11 children) went "to Minnesota for the benefit of his health," according to the New-York Tribune.  But the 44-year-old pastor was seriously ill.  The newspaper said, "it was not until they found he was beyond recovery that his congregation agreed to accept his resignation."

Rev. I. Williams Cochran and Anna Carter Cochran.  (original source unknown)

No. 47 West 53rd Street suddenly became more crowded.  The Cochran family moved in with Anna's parents.  Rev. Cochran died there on February 15, 1887, and his funeral was held in the drawing room two days later.

The would soon be another funeral in the house.  Jane Carter died at the family's summer home in Centerport, Long Island on July 19.  Her funeral was held here on July 21.

Robert Carter died at the age of 82 on December 27, 1889.  His estate sold 47 West 53rd Street to Dr. William Warner Hoppin, Jr. the following May for the equivalent of $1.3 million in 2023.  The well-educated Hoppin had graduated from Brown University in 1861, from the College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1864, and from Columbia Law School in 1869.  He was one of the Secretaries of the 1861 Peace Conference in Washington, and during the Civil War he served as an Assistant Surgeon.

He and his wife, the former Katharine Beekman, had five children.  The family would remain in the house for decades, and it would be the venue of social events like debutante entertainments and wedding receptions.  The Hoppins were still here in 1922 when son Beekman Hoppin gave a lavish dinner at Pierre's for Mrs. Willard D. Straight on May 5.

In the meantime, following Jeannettie Giles's death, 45 West 53rd Street was sold at auction on April 14, 1909.  It was purchased by Dr. Pearce Bailey, a well-known alienist (or what today is known as a psychiatrist).  He initially leased it to Frederick Kingsbury Bull, a broker who had graduated from Yale University three years earlier.

Bull brought unwanted publicity to the block in March 1911 after neighbors complained to police that he was appearing nude in a rear window and making "Adamlike poses."  Police watched the house from a rear window on 54th Street "for half an hour and what they saw induced them to get the warrant," reported The Sun.  Despite the scandal, Bailey renewed Bull's lease in 1916.

Pearce Bailey served in World War I with the rank of colonel with the Army Medical Corps.  He was later awarded the Distinguished Service Medal for his work.  After the war, he moved into 45 West 53rd Street.  He died of pneumonia in the house on February 11, 1922 at the age of 57.  In reporting his death, The New York Times called him, "one of the best known neurologists in America" and recalled that he "arranged the psychiatric tests used in the draft armies during the war to weed out the unfit."

Nine years earlier, Mary Harriss Hall, an Episcopalian deaconess, had founded the Rehearsal Club.  It provided affordable and safe housing to aspiring actresses, dancers and singers who hoped for success in the theater.  In 1926, the club acquired 45 and 47 West 53rd Street with significant help from John D. Rockefeller, Jr.  The houses were modernized and remodeled to accommodate its new purpose.  The stoop of 45 West 53rd Street was removed and the neo-Grec lintels of both shaved off. 

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

The Broadway community helped the club get on its feet in its new home.  On November 8, 1926, The New York Times reported, "Proceeds from the performance of 'Oh, Kay' at the Imperial Theatre on Dec. 1 will be devoted to the work of the Rehearsal Club, 47 West Fifty-third Street.  Miss Gertrude Lawrence appears in the play, which opens tonight."  The article explained, "the Rehearsal Club is a home for young women of the theatrical profession.  It has been necessary to enlarge the quarters."

The fame of the Rehearsal Club was such that it inspired the 1936 play Stage Door by Edna Ferber and George S. Kaufman.  Interestingly, Margaret Sullavan, who starred in it, was living in the Rehearsal Club when the play opened.

Among the residents during the war years was actress and singer Phyllis Jeanne Creore.  Decades later, on April 7, 2013, Corey Kilgannon of The New York Times recalled, "Every Friday evening over NBC radio airwaves--or short-wave overseas--homesick troops during World War II were told to 'drop in at the canteen' for comforting chat and songs by a pretty, young actress named Phyllis Jeanne Creore."  She opened every program saying, "Here is your Canteen girl, Phyllis Jeanne," and then sang the self-written song "This is My Wish."  Jeanne told Kilgannon that among the other actresses living in the Rehearsal Club at the time were Lucille Ball, Katharine Hepburn, and Ginger Rogers.

A depiction of the club in the Saturday Evening Post on September 20, 1947 noted "Waiting list: endless."  from the collection of the New York Public Library

In 1954 Carol Burnett moved into the club.  In his 1988 biography of Burnett, Laughing Till It Hurts, J. Randy Tarborrelli noted, "Former residents included Jo Van Fleet, Martha Scott, Shirley Booth, and Jayne and Audrey Meadows."  He wrote:

The fifty or so girls living there when Carol moved in were a lively bunch; all seemed to be in a perpetual state of frenzy, preparing for "the big audition" and poring over trade publications daily in search of "the big break."  Carol was totally and happily absorbed in this new environment in no time; these people had dreams, they had goals.  Now, if they only had jobs...

In 1978, Evan Robertson of The New York Times described the Rehearsal Club as a "safe, friendly place where everybody has the same ambitions you do.  They show you the ropes, for $55 a week you've got room and two good meals a day and you're within walking distance of every casting director and agent in town."  At the time of the article, however, the club was seriously threatened.

A court ruling in December revoked the club's tax-exempt status, resulting in an annual real estate tax of about $30,000 per year.  The club's attorney, Isaac Sherman, called it a "financial disaster."  In reporting on the situation on December 14, 1978, The New York Times added to the long list of former celebrity residents with names including Martha Scott, Phyllis Thaxter, Sandy Duncan, and Ruth Hussey.

A few weeks later, on January 25, 1979, The New York Times announced the the Rehearsal Club's board "will close the club in June rather than fight the city over the loss of its property-tax exemption."  Ironically, a revival of Stage Door--the play based on the club--was in rehearsals at the time.

The two venerable rowhouses-turned-residential club were purchased by the American Folk Art Museum, which had operated from rented space next door.  The buildings were eventually demolished for the new museum building designed by Tod Williams and Billie Tsien, which opened in 2001.

As a footnote, the Rehearsal Club was reincarnated in 2003 within the former Webster Apartments on West 34th Street.

LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog

Saturday, July 1, 2023

The James McComb House - 64 Horatio Street

 



When former British Major Horatio Gates learned of the outbreak of war in 1775, he left his Virginia plantation, Traveller's Rest, to fight for the patriot forces.  In 1790, he and his wife, Mary Valens, relocated to Manhattan.  In honor of his service in the Revolution, a street in Greenwich Village was named for him--Horatio Street.

As Greenwich Village expanded in the early decades of the 19th century, surrounding farmland was rapidly developed.  In 1844 a local builder, Abraham Demarest purchased five empty lots at 58 through 66 Horatio Street from two cartmen, Cornelius Ackerman and Peter Van Natter.  (They had bought them from the Ireland family just months or weeks earlier.)  Demarest erected five identical, brick-faced homes on the plots.

Intended for middle-class families, their Greek Revival design featured handsome entrances with three-paneled sidelights and transoms.  Simple brownstone lintels crowned the windows and orderly dentil molding ran below the cornices.

By 1854, 64 Horatio Street was run by Ann Redway as a boarding house.  The widow of Maturin Redway, who had died in December 1847, she was born Ann Martin in New Jersey in 1795.  Her select boarders were professionals, like Abraham W. Martin, who was listed as an "agent" at Pier 15 on the North River (today's Hudson River); and James Boden, who operated a railing, or ironworks, business on Eighth Avenue.

There was no doubt a commotion within the house on the morning of August 15, 1856.  The New York Herald reported, "Between 11 and 12 o'clock on Friday forenoon, a quilt took fire from a furnace on the back piazza of [the] house No. 64 Horatio street, occupied by Mrs. Radley [sic]."  The article said that the flames spread to the piazza (the wooden extension or porch), "but were soon extinguished before much damage was done."  The newspaper placed the damages at "probably $3," or around $100 in 2023 terms.

In 1860, the house was offered for sale, the advertisement noting, "The house is in good order and is supplied with gas and Croton."  Both amenities were modern conveniences.  Not all New York City homes were lighted by gas in the pre-Civil War years, and "Croton" meant that it had running water.  (The term referred to the Croton Reservoir on the site of today's New York Public Library, opened in 1842.)

The house became home to Albert Anderson and his family.  Anderson's occupation was listed as a carman, however his ability to purchase a modest house suggests he owned a delivery operation rather than simply driving a dray.  

The family took in one or two boarders at a time.  Living with them in 1863 was a young man named F. Gayner.  His residency was cut short when he was drafted into the Union Army on March 16, 1865.  (Happily for Gayner, General Robert E. Lee surrendered at Appomattox Court House just over three weeks later.)

An interesting boarder at the time was Jacob C. Banta, his wife Sarah, and their six-year-old daughter, Lillie.  Born around  1832, Banta was a pioneer in the professional photography business.  His studio was at 328 Bleecker Street, where he created posed "cabinet cards." 

Banta shot this cabinet card later in his career. image via cabinetcardgallery.com

Anderson and his family left 64 Horatio Street in 1866.  It was home to another carman, Simon Doremus for two years.  He also volunteered with the Columbian Hook & Ladder Company No. 14 at 96 Charles Street.

The house was purchased by James P. McComb around 1869.  A produce merchant, he and his wife, Elizabeth, had a 14-year-old son, William A.  Six years after the family moved in, on November 20, 1875, Elizabeth died at the age of 39.  In a somewhat surprising breach of tradition, her funeral was not held in the Horatio Street house, but in the Thirteenth Street Presbyterian Church.

By then, James McComb had become involved in real estate development, as well.  In November 1877, for instance, he hired architect J. M. Dunn to design a three-story brick tenement in Harlem; and in April 1880 constructed a two-story brick warehouse on Washington Street.

McComb had a boarder in 1880, E. H. Fullerton.  He became a hero of sorts on Friday afternoon, April 30 that year.  Fullerton was seated on the Bleecker Street streetcar next to E. P. Fritz.  The men noticed a suspicious looking passenger next to Mary M. Barr, a widow.  They concluded he might possibly be a pickpocket.  The New York Times reported, "When the man left the car, Mr. Fullerton asked Mrs. Barr if she had lost anything.  She missed her pocket-book, which contained $18.76."  Fullerton bolted from the streetcar and alerted a police officer, who overtook Isidore Mauger.  He still had Mrs. Barr's purse in his clutches.

William A. McComb died at the age of 28 on March 19, 1882.  Unlike his mother's, his funeral was held in 64 Horatio Street.

It was around this time that James P. McComb remarried.  His new wife became involved in his real estate business.  When J. M. Dunn filed plans for another tenement building in Harlem in March 1887, it was Mrs. J. P. McComb who was listed as owner of record. 

The McCombs sold 64 Horatio Street on December 4, 1889 to Robert Fash, a real estate agent for $8,350, or about $254,000 today.  He leased it to a succession of tenants over the next years.

Following the Stock Market crash, the aversion to capitalism held by many liberal-thinking citizens increased.  The collective or cooperative housing concept, formed in the 1920s, spread, and in 1932 it reached 64 Horatio Street.

A group of young people including 18-year-old David Jenkins, Muriel Reiker, and Gittel Poznoski Steed leased two floors of the house for $60 per month.  Jenkins described it later as a "collective," meaning the tenants pooled their financial resources.  

Steed was a successful model for the Art Students' League and a dancer.  Her father was a Yiddish scholar, according to Jenkins.  The artistic tone of Greenwich Village was reflected in Jenkin's recalling in 1988:

Gittel particularly introduced me to a lot of the artists.  Raphael Soyer, whom I met there, and [Yasuo] Kuniyoshi, who was a famous Japanese painter.  Arnold Blanche, and later on Doris Lee, one of the famous women painters.  Louis Spieker, who was a famous painter, whose paintings still hang at the Whitney and places like that.  I also met this guy, V. O. [sic] Matthiessen , who was a literary critic at Harvard, who was gay and later killed himself.  Then I also met some of the poets: Horace Gregory, Kenneth Little.

Soon, both Steed and Jenkins joined the Young Communist League, and the Horatio Street house was the scene of meetings and other gatherings.  On May 26, 1934, for instance, The Daily Worker, a Communist newspaper, reported that there would be a "house party" at 64 Horatio Street that night "for $1,000 drive of the Workers School."  For 15 cents admission, the revelers would enjoy "dancing, games, refreshments."  Another house party was held to benefit a labor group on September 7 that year.

The house was purchased by Henry Brant in 1953.  Four years later it was converted to two duplex apartments.  The configuration that lasted until 1997, when the venerable house was returned to a single family home.  

photograph by the author
LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog