Wednesday, January 6, 2021

The William Wright House - 248 West 22nd Street

 

The top floor was added in 2008.

William Wright was a builder and a manufacturer of corrugated metal roofing.  He and his wife, Mary Ann, had a son, William, Jr.  

The success of his businesses was reflected in their handsome 25-foot wide Greek Revival house at No. 176 West 22nd Street.  Faced in red brick and trimmed in brownstone, it was three stories tall above the high English basement.  The entrance sat within an earred surround crowned by a triangular pediment.  The parlor windows stretched to the floor, suggesting that they were originally fronted by a cast iron balcony.  A simple fascia board ran below the bracketed cornice.  Along the eastern side of the house a narrow passage, or horsewalk, provided access to the rear yard.

On November 28, 1852 an advertisement in the New Y0rk Herald touted the fireproof qualities of Wright's roofs:

Iron Roofs--The corrugated iron roofs are the lightest, cheapest, most handsome, and durable fire-proof roofs in the world, for dwelling and warehouses, railway termini, or all buildings worth saving from fire.  The cost of the roof may be gained in a short time on the insurance.  Manufactured by
                        Wm. Wright, 176 West Twenty-second street.

William Wright, Jr. embarked on a far different career.  He advertised his fertilizer in the May 4, 1854 issue of The Country Gentleman.  He promised farmers and gardeners that his Superphosphate of Lime cost "little more than one-half the price of guano" and its effects would last "for 5 or 6 years."  That, said the article, made it "the cheapest and best fertilizer known at the present day."

Later that year the Wrights' house was burglarized by an unexpected thief.  On October 9 The New York Times reported that a "young girl, of very respectable connections, named Emma Turner" had been arrested for "entering the house of Mrs. Mary Ann Wright, No. 176 West Twenty-second-street, and stealing a gold watch and other property."  She had made the mistake of falling for a bad boy.  The article said rather frankly, "Joseph Sands, a young man with whom she had been intimate, persuaded her to commit the theft.  He was arrested, but escaped from the officers."  Emma's brother put up her significant bond, equal to $15,700 today.

Wright sold the house to another builder, John Ludlum, around 1858.  Born in New Berry, Connecticut on February 7, 1810, Ludlum and his wife, the former Eleanor Wines, had four children.  

By the time son Henry Clay Ludlum married Mary Adaline Hills in 1869 the street had been renumbered, giving the house its new address of No. 248 West 22nd Street.  That year John transferred title to the house to Henry--but this was no wedding gift.  He charged his son $35,000 for the property, or around $677,000 today.

A game of real estate hot potato began in 1873 when Henry sold the house back to his father for the exact amount he had paid.  John then sold it to Morris S. Thompson on December 10 that year for $25,000--$10,000 less than he had just paid.  Thompson sold it to Eleanor Ludlum five days later for the same amount.  It is unclear exactly what the point of the complicated series of transfers was.

By 1876 the Ludlums had moved to Hempstead, Long Island and the 22nd Street house became home to attorney Philip Malone.  Sharing the house was his daughter, Margaret, and her husband Patrick Olwell.  (It appears that Malone's wife was deceased.)

Malone's comfortable financial situation was reflected in his real estate investments.  In April 1885, for instance, The American Architect and Building News reported that he was erecting two five-story apartment buildings at Nos. 409 and 411 West 16th Street at a cost of about $796,000 in today's money.

In the spring of 1889 Philip Malone contracted pneumonia.  He died in the house on March 29.  Interestingly, his funeral was not held in the house, as was customary, but at St. Columba's Church on West 25th Street.  His estate was executed by attorney Philip F. Olwell, Patrick's father.

Three years later there would be another family funeral in St. Columba's Church.  Patrick Olwell died on July 16, 1892 and his funeral was held there three days later.  Margaret's in-laws, Philip F. and Bridget Olwell, moved into the 22nd Street house with her.  

Bridget died there on October 7, 1899.  Two weeks later, while the family was still deep in grief, the house was burglarized.  The New York Times reported "Shortly after midnight of Oct. 22 a thief entered the home of Philip Olwell, at 248 West Twenty-second Street, and stole $500 worth of diamonds, a gold watch, &c."  It was a significant heist, worth nearly $16,000 today. 

Two months later another funeral at St. Columba's Church was interrupted by law enforcement.  Edward Flanagan was attending services for his aunt on December 1 when police entered the church and arrested the 28-year old.  They had been searching for the ex-con since the stolen Olwell goods turned up at pawn shops where Flanagan was identified.  After police "watched his accustomed haunts" with no success, they decided to nab him at the funeral.

The Olwell family remained in the house until 1906.  It was resold the following year to Maria S. Simpson who operated it as a boarding house.   Among her initial tenants was Mrs. Tessie Osraff.  On the night of September 20, 1907 Tessie was on 34th Street near Seventh Avenue when William W. Hart saw a man who appeared to be annoying her.  (Hart, incidentally, was among the best-known taxidermists in the country and had stuffed the P. T. Barnum's famous elephant, Jumbo.)

The New York Times reported that Hart "tried to interfere, but the man turned out to be Detective McManus, and after a struggle both Hart and the woman were arrested."  Exactly what Tessie Osraff was doing to cause her arrest was not reported.

The horsewalk to the side was protected by a wooden door around 1941.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

Writer John Dowling rented a room here during the World War I years.  Ardently patriotic, the 61-year old had served in the U.S. Cavalry and his son was currently a captain in the British Army.  He was arrested on the night of April 24, 1918 "for hauling down the British flag from Shakespeare's monument in Central Park," as reported by The New York Times.  Despite the fact that his son was serving in the British Army, Dowling pleaded to the judge that "he thought the flag was a Socialist flag."  He was fined the equivalent of $255 today.

The roomers were decidedly blue collar in the post war years.  Arthur Priest made his living by running a lunch wagon in 1922, for instance.  

Prohibition brought with it an unforeseen evil--deadly bootleg liquor.  James Brady purchased questionable whiskey in 1929.  On October 14 the Daily News reported that "acute alcoholism--with the possibility that poison liquor was the final cause of death" had claimed the 46-year old.  He "was found dead in the hallway of his home at 248 West 22d st."

Things had did not improved by the 1940's.  A retired steamfitter, 80-year old Charles B. Richmond had a furnished room here in 1941, as did 55-year old Wong Kee, who made his living as a dishwasher.  Kee, who had come to America in 1918 from China, was described by The New York Sun as "only 4 feet 10 inches tall and weighting 90 pounds."  He was arrested with the murder of the elderly man on July 1 that year.

The house was diminished by its late 19th and 20th century neighbors in 1935.  photo by Wurtz Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The New York Sun reported "Richmond was stabbed in the chest with an icepick and beaten over the head with a cleaver."   The article noted that old elderly victim "had half a dozen bankbooks with deposits totaling about $34,000."  It was a tempting motive, worth about $590,000 today.

Despite the location of the body in the hallway, according to the newspaper on October 29, Kee claimed that he and Richmond "had been drinking" and "Wong contended that Richmond had hit him over the head with a bunch of keys."  He pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to 7-1/2 years in prison.

In 1969 aspiring singer Judy Kreston purchased the house for $125,000, more in the neighborhood of $871,000 today.  There were two rental apartments on the upper floors, but the house was in dilapidated shape.  She told reporter Barbara Whitaker from The New York Times later "About the only thing that could be counted on was that, when it rained, the living and dining room floors would flood from the rear."

Little by little she and her husband, musician and arranger David Lahm, renovated the house.  The work stepped up when the cornice began to fall off in 1993.  Kreston recalled that a contractor who climbed a ladder to inspect the job.  He explained that he could not do the job--there was a bird nest in the cornice and "If I move the nest, the mother won't be able to find the baby."  Kreston took care of the pigeon nest and the work proceeded.


Significant changed came with the next owners.  A renovation completed in 2008 resulted in an additional (rather unattractive) floor and a total of two residential spaces.  The parlor windows have been shortened, the stoop removed, and the entrance moved to the former horsewalk.

On the market in 2021, it is touted as "non-landmarked" with renderings of a replacement buildings.

photographs by the author

Tuesday, January 5, 2021

The 1896 Charles A. Rich House - 257 West 91st Street

 

Rich simultaneously erected the house to the right.


Charles Alonzo Rich and Hugh Lamb established the architectural office of Lamb & Rich in 1880, with Rich as the main designer.  The team sometimes acted as its own developer--buying plots and designing the structures--cutting out the middleman and reaping increased profits.  In 1895 Rich began a project on his own by purchasing two vacant plots at Nos. 255 and 257 West 91st Street and designing upscale homes for the sites.  Both were in the currently popular neo-Georgian style, but each stood on its own architecturally.

At 50-feet wide, No. 257 would be twice the width of its neighbor.  Three stories tall above a basement level, it was faced in red brick and trimmed in limestone.  The entrance was recessed behind a columned portico, and splayed Georgian lintels graced the upper floor openings.  A striking, intricate stained glass fanlight crowned the parlor window.

The houses were completed in 1896 and Rich moved his family into No. 257.  He and his wife, the former Harriet Bradbury, had three daughters.  Their summer estate, The Studio, was at Bellport, Long Island.

The family remained in No. 257 until about 1904 when, interestingly enough, they moved into the smaller house next door.  The Riches retained ownership and leased No. 257, first to Mrs. F. C. Case, and then to Mrs. Henry Harmon Hendricks.  She was living in the house in the spring of 1908 when she issued invitations for the marriage of Alma Hendricks to Clarence Isaacs.

The following year the Riches got long-term tenants when William Knight signed the lease.  A member of the Produce Exchange, Knight's domestic affairs had been a sort of soap opera.  He and his wife had divorced in the beginning of the year and almost immediately both remarried.   Because his first wife was on her honeymoon, their two children, 1o-year old William, Jr. and 4-year old Kathlyn, moved into the West 91st Street house with their father and step-mother.

Their bags were barely unpacked when Knight was forced to bring the children into the court on March 18, 1909.  The New York Herald explained "The mother is on her honeymoon with Charles D. Orth...whom she married after her divorce from Mr. Knight a few weeks ago."  But before leaving, she left instructions that the children should be left with her aunt, Gertrude Murray King.   The article said "the father offered objections" to that proposal.

Other than that bump, the Knights' separation seems to have been quite amiable.  One letter showed that the new Mrs. Orth had released Knight from any obligation of alimony and another "from Mr. Knight [wished] his former wife happiness with her new husband."  The two had agreed on shared custody.

The new Mrs. Knight slipped easily into Upper West Side society.  She was was instrumental in organizing the bridge party held in the Plaza ballroom in April 1912 for the benefit of the Ely Club House for Young Women Students, for instance.  And when the Ely Club hosted a series of ten lectures at Delmonico's the following year, The Evening Post noted "Tickets for the series may be obtained from Mrs. William Knight, No. 257 West Ninety-first Street."

The Knight family got a new landlord in February 1919.  Charles Rich and Hugh Lamb had dissolved their partnership in 1899.  Rich was now partnered with Frederick Mathesius in the firm of Rich & Mathesius.  Harriet Rich continued to hold title to the side-by-side houses, but now gave her husband's partner a 21-year lease on the properties at an annual combined rent of $4,000 (just under $60,000 per year today).

Frederick Mathesius had other ideas for the houses.  At the end of the Knights' lease that fall, Charles Rich converted both houses to apartments.  He added a floor to No. 257 and remodeled the interiors to 15 non-housekeeping apartments.  The term meant that there were no kitchens and, in fact, the Department of Buildings noted "Cooking in more than two of the apartments will render this building liable to immediate vacation."

The tenants were professionals, like composer and conductor Louis Koemmenich and his wife.  On January 8, 1920 Musical Courier announced that he had moved his studios to the new address and noted "He will accept a limited number of pupils for score reading, orchestration and conducting."

Composer Louis Koemmenich and his wife were among the first residents of the newly-created apartments.  Daily News, August 21, 1922 (copyright expired)

Other initial residents included Ernest E. Arnold, a "stock salesman;" wood pulp merchant Folk Sundbland; and E. De Cernea, who had been made a Chevalier of the French Foreign Legion during World War I "for attacking a German submarine from an airplane."

Ernest E. Arnold got himself into serious trouble on May 17, 1921 when the 35-year old not only ignored the Prohibition laws, but got behind the wheel of his automobile while drunk.  The Evening World opined that "when he gets through explaining to the Traffic Court, [he] will have to face several irate chauffeurs and owners of vehicles damaged as he zigzagged up Broadway early in an auto which he drove himself."

There were two women and a man in his car when the adventure began.  Inebriated, he began banging into expensive automobiles prompting what the New York Evening Post called "A hurrying procession of fully two dozen automobiles, taxicabs, and buses" that rattled through the streets of upper Manhattan early to-day in pursuit of a fleeing automobile."  The chase had started at 90th Street and Broadway when Patrolman George Schmidt first saw Arnold driving erratically.

As Arnold sped ahead of the policeman, his car left "in its wake a line of upset traffic stanchions, scraped lamp-posts and damaged cars."  Behind Officer Schmidt was "a motley array of everything in the neighborhood that had four wheels and cylinders," said the New York Evening Post.

Somehow during the blocks-long chase Arnold was able to drop off his passengers, so when he was finally arrested at the corner of 81st Street and West End Avenue, he was alone in the car.  Dr. Bradoff of the Knickerbocker Hospital "gave one whiff and pronounced Arnold under the influence of contraband."

Louis Koemmenich took the position of orchestra leader of a road company of Aphrodite not long after moving into No. 257.  The Daily News noted that he was "once famed as musical director of the Oratorio Society" and this position "hurt his pride."  But "he found solace in the beautiful dancer," Vera Lehmann, who was among the cast.

In fact, the friendship became what Mrs. Koemmenich later described as a "strange infatuation."  In 1922 her husband of 35 years and the father of their three children was 55 years old and Vera was 22.  The Daily News said "His wife at first thought the friendship between the girl and her husband an innocent affair, but finally forbade Miss Lehmann to call at her home."

Vera Lehmann Daily News, August 21, 1922 (copyright expired)

The forced separation was too much for Vera and on August 20, 1922 she swallowed poison in her mother's dress shop.  Twelve hours later Koemmenich was found dead in his ground floor apartment from gas.  He left a note that read:

I have learned that Vera committed suicide.  This being a great loss to me, there is nothing else left for me to do.

The conductor's wife spoke to reporters later that evening.  "They were both foolish. But I do not blame the girl more than him," she said.  "I will not judge him."  She added, "I had my husband on a pedestal.  By not judging, may I can keep him there.  Isn't that the better way?"

Wesley Whitehouse brought some embarrassing press to the address on March 25, 1931 when the 20-year old and his 19 year old friend, Herbert Ramsdel were arrested at the Loew's State Theater on 45th Street and Broadway.  The New York Sun reported that the arrests were made "on the complaint of two usherettes" who said "the young men were trying to follow them into their dressing room."  They were bailed out by Ramsdel's father, motion picture director Leland Stanford Ramsdel.


The fanlight was intact when this photograph was taken around 1941.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

In 1957 the former Rich house was converted to a total of eleven apartments.  It was most likely at this time that the magnificent parlor floor fanlight was bricked up.

photograph by the author

Monday, January 4, 2021

The Lost Criterion Club - 683 Fifth Avenue

 

On either side of the club are the Charles H. Harkness house, on the corner of 54th St., and the home of Levi P. Morton to the right.  image via  Collins' 'Both Sides of Fifth Avenue'  1910 (copyright expired)

In January 1903 The Criterion Club purchased the former home of H. Victor Newcomb at No. 683 Fifth Avenue, just south of 54th Street.  It paid $250,000 for the property, or just under $7.5 million in today's money.  Despite the staggering price, the club had succeeded in major downward negotiations.  The New York Times reported "It is said to be valued at about $350,000."

At the time the Criterion Club was renting the mansion at the northwest corner of Fifth Avenue and 43rd Street.  It demolished the Newcomb house and in May the architectural firm of Lowinson & Eisendrath filed plans for a five-story "American basement building" on the 30-foot wide plot.  The Real Estate Record & Guide reported on the lavish plans.  "It is in the style of the French Renaissance.  The entrance is marked by a marble portico extending through two stories, each of the four supporting columns being of one solid piece of marble."

By the time construction was completed the structure had grown from five to six stories.  Its façade of red Roman brick was trimmed in marble and limestone.  There were two limestone balconies, one at the third and the other at the fifth floor.  The top floor took the form of a mansard faced in Spanish tiles.  Construction had cost the equivalent of just under $2.4 million today.

The Record & Guide called the interiors "elaborate."  Marble columns and wainscoting decorated the ground floor and the basement level.  There were reception rooms in the basement while the first floor held the "parlor, staircase foyer, café, and dining room."  On the second floor were the library and "various amusement rooms."  Those would include a card room, smoking room, and such.  The billiard rooms were located on the third floor and on the fourth were the gymnasium, Turkish bath and members' rooms.

Beautifully veined marble columns and wainscoting set the exclusive tone of the entrance hall.  The Architectural Record, February 1905 (copyright expired)

The Criterion Club was a prestigious Jewish men's club, lesser known than the Harmonie and the Progress Clubs.  As the sons of Manhattan millionaires grew to manhood, membership in at least one—but preferably several—of the exclusive men’s clubs was expected.  Passing the rigid selection process proved one's good breeding and social status, but most of all money.  None of those qualifications mattered much, however, if the candidate were Jewish.

Manhattan society was, for the most part, made up of Episcopalians with some ultra-wealthy Roman Catholics tolerated.  Despite the staggering wealth of some Jewish families, only a handful of Jews would manage to obtain memberships in the highly-exclusive Union or Metropolitan Club, for instance.  And so they established their own private club.

Members may have hoped that their lavish new home might deflect attention from the scandal the club had recently suffered.  On September 1, 1903 The Standard Union reported that the club had paid $1,880.17 in a case filed by the State Excise Commission.  It claimed that the Criterion Club had conducted a "'fake club,' permitting the premises to become the resort of disorderly persons, and selling liquors during the hours in which their sale is prohibited."

The Criterion Club was, by no means, a "fake club" nor were its members disorderly--especially in the sense that the word was used in 1903.  Nevertheless, the club was guilty of selling liquor on Sunday.

The bad press was unusual for the club, whose members came and went without drawing any attention.  While other upscale social clubs announced receptions, testimonial dinners and other events in the newspapers, the Criterion Club kept its activities private.  It rarely appeared in newspapers, most of which regularly ran a "club" column.

The Architectural Record, February 1905 (copyright expired)

An exception was Louis J. Weil, president of the Union Exchange National Bank of New York.  A bachelor, he lived in one of the upper floor "members' rooms."  Weil died on August 31, 1919.  When his will was read three months later, eyebrows were raised--especially those of his close family members.  He had left expected benefactions to charities--$5,000 to Mt. Sinai Hospital "to found a bed in memory of his father;" $1,000 each to the Children's Aid Society and the Hebrew Benevolent Society; and $500 each to the Montefiore Home for Chronic Invalids and the Home for Aged and Infirm Hebrews.  But one bequest caught the attention of The Sun, which reported, "Nellie J. Sexton...received $50,000, to be paid to her three months after the decedent's death."  The gift would be worth more than three-quarters of a million in today's dollars.  Nellie Sexton had to fight for her inheritance.  The family went to court in 1920, eventually overturning the terms of the will.

With the Fifth Avenue district becoming increasingly commercial, the Criterion Club left its handsome home in 1925.  On January 22, 1926 the New York Evening Post reported, "The Fifth Avenue Club, replacing the Criterion Club, opens its doors tomorrow night with 'The Fifth Avenue Follies," with Cecil Cunningham and her entertainers."

Impresario and showman Billy Rose had hired the architectural firm of Cohen & Siegel to transform the second floor to an upscale theater-restaurant.  The renovations cost him $50,000.  Rose had obtained major financial backing from Jewish millionaires--possibly Criterion Club members--including banker Maurice Wertheim and Samuel Untermyer.  

Patrons, dressed in evening wear, were charged $5 at the door (nearly $75 today) for an evening of Broadway-type entertainment.  In his 2018 book Not Bad for Delancey Street, The Rise of Bill Rose, Mark Cohen mentions, "An important introduction was to the jazz saxophonist Roger Wolfe Kahn, son of the millionaire banker Otto Kahn."

The venture was short-lived.  On November 26, 1926 The Yonkers Statesman announced, "Jane Gray's 'Club Caravan' that was such a success last year in the 'Village' has moved uptown to 683 Fifth Avenue on the site of the old Fifth Avenue Club."  The article said, "This rendezvous, probably one of the most attractive in Manhattan, boasts of two rooms rather than the conventional one.  In the smaller are a few tables and chairs and loads and loads of cushions.  It is here that couples stray after the show, and chat between cigarettes."

New York Evening Post, December 30, 1926.

The larger venue, said the article, included a dance floor.  It added, "another reason why this club is fast becoming the Mecca for night club habitués is is because of proximity to the theatre district.  There is a distinct air of refinement about the 'Club Caravan' that is sure of charm and Jerry's Caravan Orchestra renders music so contagious it is an inspiration even to the poorest dancer."

The club's popularity was not enough to outweigh the value of the property it sat on.  In 1927 the building was demolished, replaced by a 13-story office building designed by Frank E. Vitolo.  It was later joined internally with No. 683 Fifth Avenue and Vitolo's handsome façade remodeled to match its next-door-neighbor.

Erased today, the façade of the replacement building survived about 20 years.  photo by Arthur Vitols, from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York


Saturday, January 2, 2021

A Rich History of Immigrants- from Germans to Hispanics- 220 Avenue A

 


Around 1859 the four-story store and tenement was erected at No. 220 Avenue A, just south of East 14th Street.  There were two shops on the ground floor, separated by the residential entrance.  In the rear yard was a second, smaller building which was also held rented rooms.  

Between 1850 and 1859 nearly 1,000,000 Germans arrived in America and those who remained in New York mostly settled in this neighborhood--earning it the name Kleindeutchland, or Little Germany.  The tenants in No. 220 Avenue A most likely spoke only German.  In 1861 they included grocer Frederick Jung; George Graeff, a metal smith; Charles Weismann, a painter; Martin Wolf, who was a tailor; and the widow Margaret Bauman who seems to have been the landlady.

Frederick Jung's rooms were very convenient to his business, since he operated his grocery store downstairs.  The other space was a biergarten, the back room of which was sometimes used as a meeting place.  

At the time powerful newspapermen like Horace Greeley and political groups like the Free-Soil Party were pressuring Congress to enact a bill that would encourage intrepid citizens to settle in the West.  Such an act would present a great opportunity to immigrants.  On April 12, 1860 The New York Times reported on a meeting of the Working Men's Political Union.  It said, "A meeting of the Society which has assumed the above title was held last night in the German saloon, No. 220 Avenue A.  The object for which it has been ostensibly organized is the promotion of the movement in favor of the passage by Congress of a Homestead bill, securing the public lands in limited quantities to actual settlers...At a pretty late hour the meeting adjourned."

For three violent days in July 1863 New York City was terrorized by what would be known as the Draft Riots.   To augment troops fighting the Civil War, a new law had been enacted to draft men into the army.  But corrupt practitioners focused on the working class—primarily Irish immigrants—while the wealthy bought their way out of service.  What started as a protest against the draft quickly disintegrated into a bloody riot with mobs ransacking homes and businesses, murdering innocent blacks, and beating random civilians caught on the streets.

Following the restoration of order, citizens filed claims for the damages they suffered.  In August Margaret Bauman claimed $83.81, without specifying the exact losses.  It was a significant amount for the widow, about $1,760 by today's standards.

The Avenue A property was purchased by Otto Dietrich Hashagen and his son, Henry Otto, in 1876.  Otto, originally originally a shipbuilder by trade, came to America from Germany with his wife in 1844.  Henry Otto was born the following year.  Six more children would follow.

Hashagen not only moved his family into the building, but his saloon business, too.  Henry was, by now, a printer, but he helped in his father's saloon.  

Among Hashagen's tenants that year were Francis Briggs, a laborer; Julius Hanetsch who listed his occupation as "beer" and most likely worked in the saloon downstairs; and Michael Weiner was a peddler.  Living in the rear building were Henry Koepfel, who ran a candy store; George Kulenkamp, a carpenter, and his wife, Lucy; and another carpenter, Philip Rodenhausen.

Otto and Henry Hashagen made significant improvements to the building in 1878.  He hired architect J. T. O'Brien to add a fifth story and to alter the interior.  O'Brien placed an ambitious metal cornice on the completed structure and graced the openings with unusual cast iron keystones in the form of female portraits.

O'Brien saved Hashagen money by executing details, like the eyebrows over these openings, in brick.  But then gave them the added touch of the unusual cast iron keystones.


As had been the case with the previous saloon, Hashagen's back room doubled as a meeting space which he called Washington Hall.  It was often the venue of political gatherings, such as the meeting of the German Republicans on October 25, 1880, and the angry meeting of between 20 and 30 pawnbrokers on April 24, 1883 following the new law requiring pawnbrokers to pay a yearly license fee of $500, a crippling $13,000 in today's money.

Henry had married Caroline Steger in 1872.  She in childbirth in 1884, but the infant, whom he named Florence, lived.  The Daily Union said "she was left to the care of her father, Henry Hashagen, a saloon keeper at 220 Avenue A.  Naturally she was made much of."

Following Otto Hashagen's death in 1888, Henry became full owner of the Avenue A property.  

In the summer of 1889 Henry sent five-year old Florence to New Jersey to visit an uncle, "in the hope that the country air might do her good."  The Daily Union reported, "While there she made friends with a little spitz dog belonging to a neighbor.  One day, while they played together, the dog, with the meanness and viciousness which characterizes the whole breed, turned on the child and bit her."

Florence was taken to a hospital where the wound was cauterized.  It healed nicely and the incident was forgotten.  When Henry visited Florence a month later on Sunday, August 18 she was "well and comparatively robust."  The Daily Union said "She asked to remain there longer and was gladly indulged."

But when he returned the next Sunday, "she was in horrible convulsions.  On the Wednesday following she suddenly complained of feeling unwell and of difficulty in swallowing."  Henry brought the little girl home, where she only worsened.  The Daily Union said "She was parched with thirst, and the sight of water maddened her.  The very sound of water drawn through the tap in the house sent her into violent convulsions."

Because Henry had never been told about the dog bite, he couldn't give the doctor any information.  Finally, Dr. Veshlage questioned the uncle who remembered the incident.  Two other doctors were brought in, but the hydrophobia was too advanced.  The Union Daily reported "Her weak constitution was a mercy to her.  Heart failure intervened and saved her from the horrible extreme, symptoms of barking and biting."  Nevertheless, on September 1 the newspaper reported "In awful agony and paroxysm of pain, poor little Florence Hashagen, a tot of only 5 years of age, passed away to rest in this city late Friday night."

By 1890 the meeting room was being called Hashagen's Hall.  It was the scene of a Socialist meeting on March 1, 1890 to discuss the recent elections in Germany, and a "mass-meeting of street cleaners, hostlers and cartmen" to denounce the treatment of men employed by the Street Cleaning Department in February 1894, for instance.

By the turn of the century Hashagen's tenants included Irish immigrants.  One of them, Charles Manthey, attempted a heroic act on May 29, 1900 with tragic consequences.

John J. Schneible was a delivery driver for Rouen, Buehler & Son and on that afternoon his horse "took fright" on East 13th Street.   The New York Weekly Press reported "Schnieble was unable to control him, and there was great danger that some one would be hurt as the street was crowded with children."  Manthey saw the horse headed to a group of children.  He ran into the street and grabbed the bridle, but was lifted off his feet and dragged about 30 feet.  The article said "the enraged horse tossed him toward the curb.  Manthey fell on his head, and he was picked up dead."  He had suffered a broken neck.

On May 12 an announcement appeared in The New York Press of the auction of "the fixtures and furniture of [the] saloon" at 220 Avenue A.  Three years later the Hashagen estate sold the property, the New-York Tribune noting on March 24, 1906 that it "has not changed hands for about thirty years."

In 1912 a streetcar ran up the center of Avenue A.  The Fishman family lived in No. 220 that year.  Their son, Henry, who was four years old, darted into the street in front of the building on November 10 right into the path of an oncoming car.  The New York Press reported "The youngster ran into a trolley car and fell under the rear truck, and his leg was crushed above the ankle."  A policeman named Millen ran to the scene and saved the boy's life by using his club and a leather thong to fashion a tourniquet.  The Evening World reported "His left leg was so badly smashed that Dr. Grendy of Bellevue Hospital amputated it and then took the child to the hospital."


The cornice was intact when this photo was taken around 1941.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Tenant Harry Sidora was apparently supposed to be working in the East River dock neighborhood on the afternoon of August 6, 1931.  Instead he took a nap on the roof of the three-story building at No. 18 Corlears Street.  In his sleep, he rolled off.  The New York Sun reported, "the injuries he received in falling are regarded as serious."  The article added "he regained consciousness in Gouveneur Hospital and was able to identify himself."

When the building was sold by the Bank of New York in December 1940 it was described as "a five-story tenement for twenty families."   It was purchased in 1976 by Morris Malek, whom attorney Floyd Feldman, director of the Good Old Lower East Side housing agency described in 1981 as "the operator of some of the worst buildings I have ever seen."

Indeed, in the three years Malek owned No. 220 he was slapped with more than 100 violations including "no heat and hot water, leaks, broken walls, loose brick work and defective fire escapes," according to The Villager.  A fire in 1979 damaged the roof and resulted in the loss of J. T. O'Brien's 1878 cornice.  The Villager reported "According to one tenant, the fire was set by a junkie during a dispute with his wife in a top floor apartment."

The changing demographics of the East Village neighborhood were reflected not only in the new name Loisaida, but in the tenant list.  At the time 100 percent of the residents were Hispanic.

Gentrification of the neighborhood was already beginning when Malek sold No. 220 to John Carrese and Gaspar Mucaria.
According to The Villager, tenants reported "They told us to get out."  The residents, some of whom had been in the building more than two decades, were finally paid to give up their leases.  Brent Sharman, an organizer with the housing group Adopt-A-Building told The Villager he had hoped that they "would fight to remain there and get services restored," but "What can you do?  for the people who lived there $2,000, $5,000 is a lot of money."

With the building vacated, a renovation was begun.  Completed in 1983, it resulted in two apartments per floor in the front building and one per floor in the rear.


The building with its rich history is easily overlooked, but the cast iron faces staring out from above the windows are worth a pause.

photographs by the author

Friday, January 1, 2021

The 1915 Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr. House - 11 East 64th Street

 


Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr. was 17 years old when his parents moved into their sumptuous new mansion at No. 3 East 64th Street.  There were few young men in New York who could compete with his social status.  His mother was the former Caroline "Carrie" Schermerhorn Astor (daughter of William Backhouse and Caroline Schermerhorn Astor), and his father was banker and railroad mogul Marshall Orme Wilson.  His aunt had married Ogden Goelet, his uncle was John Jacob Astor IV, and other aunts had the married names of Roosevelt, Drayton, and Haig.

Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr. original source unknown

Following his graduation from Harvard, Wilson went into the banking business.  Then, in the summer of 1910, one of America's most eligible bachelors was off the market.  On June 10 The Washington Post reported "Society turned out in large numbers to attend the wedding of Miss Alice Borland to Marshall Orme Wilson, jr....The bride is the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. J. Nelson Borland, and the granddaughter of George Griswold Haven.  The bridegroom is the son of Mr. and Mrs. M. Orme Wilson, and the grandson of Mrs. Astor."

Three years later Wilson purchased and demolished the former Charles Steele house at No. 11 East 64th Street, steps away from his parents' home.  He hired the architectural firm of Trowbridge & Livingston to design a modern replacement mansion on the site.  On June 21, 1913 The Sun announced "The proposed dwelling, plans for which were filed yesterday...will be a five story fireproof structure, 29x80, with an extension, its façade being in limestone and brick.  It will cost $75,000."  That amount would translate to about $2 million today.

Construction on the limestone-faced residence would take two years.  The architects produced a sedate neo-French Classical style mansion that stressed sophistication over ornamentation.  The understated entrance within the rusticated base was decorated with only a scrolled keystone.  Three sets of graceful French doors at the second floor, or piano nobile, were fronted by stone balustrades and set within arches.  Intermediate cornices separated the two-story mid-section from the first and fourth floors.  The fifth floor took the form of a dormered mansard, set back behind a stone balustrade.

photo by Wurts Bros, from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The house was, of course, used only during the winter social season.  During the warmer months the couple made the rounds of fashionable "watering-holes."  On May 24, 1915, for instance, The New York Press announced, "Mr. and Mrs. Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr., will close their house, No. 11 East Sixty-fourth street, on Wednesday and go out to Bay Shore, L. I., where they have leased a place for the summer.  Mr. and Mrs. Wilson will pass part of August in Newport."  The couple had barely arrived back home that year when they left again to spend Thanksgiving with Wilson's sister and her family.  On November 23 The New York Press reported, "Mr. and Mrs. Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr...left last evening for the Greenbrier, at White Sulphur Springs, where they will spend Thanksgiving with Mrs. Ogden Goelet."

The mansion was shuttered in 1917 after the United States entered World War I.  Marshall joined the army and was sent to Washington D.C.  It would be a decisive moment in the lives of the Wilsons.    With peace achieved in 1919, the couple returned briefly to East 64th Street.  On April 6 the New York Herald reported that they "have returned from Washington and opened their house at No. 11 East Sixty-fourth street, which they closed two years ago."

The Wilsons' only child, Orme, was born in the mansion in August 1920.  In announcing the birth The Evening Telegram noted, "Mr. Wilson has recently been appointed to a secretaryship at the United States Embassy at Brussels and will leave for Europe in two weeks."

Marshall, Alice and the newborn sailed around September 15 and the following week the New York Herald reported that "Mr. and Mrs. G. N. Ormsby, who are at the Ritz-Carlton, have taken Mr. Wilson's house at 11 East Sixty-fourth street for the winter."

What initially was a one-season lease extended through the summer of 1923.  George Newell Armsby was the chairman of Curtiss-Wright and sat on the boards of numerous corporations.  His wife, the former Leonora Chestnut Wood, was the daughter of Colorado mining magnate Tingley Sylvanus Wood.  

Armsby's decision not to renew the lease on No. 11 no doubt had to do with worsening domestic problems.  A few months later Leonora would claim abandonment.  Her divorce, granted in San Francisco, earned her a $1 million settlement--more than 18 times that much in today's money.

The 64th Street mansion was briefly leased to millionaire Moses Taylor, and then, following a remodeling in the spring of 1924, to Standard Oil executive Henry Huddleston Rogers and his wife, the former Mary Benjamin.  Moving in with his parents was Henry H. Huddleston, Jr., but not his sister, Mary Millicent Abigail (who went by Millicent).  She was currently "away."

Her elopement to Austrian Count Ludwig von Salm-Hoogstraeten in January that year had enraged her parents (most notably her father).  The count had a title, but no money, and was almost twice Millicent's age.  Rogers immediately cut off his daughter's allowance.

Pregnant and without funds, Millicent was lured back to New York by her father--without the count.  It was not the end, but merely the beginning of the long drama.  On November 13, 1924 The New York Times reported that the count was considering a trip to America "for a reconciliation with his wife, if such a reconciliation is possible."  The article added, "It was said at the home of the mother of the Countess, Mrs. Henry H. Rogers, 11 East Sixty-fourth Street, that the count was not expected in New York."

As the count steamed toward New York the following year, Millicent took her baby boy to Palm Beach.  Her parents "did not care to comment on the Count's arrival," said The New York Times on December 3, 1925, and in Palm Beach Millicent told reporters, "I do not care to talk with the press."

The count was back in New York the following year, the Daily News reporting on November 26, 1926, "The Austrian nobleman came back to stay.  Or so he said."

Upon arriving he almost immediately telephoned the Rogers house.  The newspaper reported, "He wanted to see his golden-haired son, Peter, who is living with his mother.  Salm asked that the child's nurse be allowed to bring little Peter to his father's presence.  But Peter was having his Thanksgiving dinner in the Rogers's nursery.  Or something."

In April 1927 Millicent filed for divorce in Paris, her father offering Count Salm a $300,000 settlement.   Little Peter was left home with his grandfather while Mary accompanied her daughter to France.  Already the press was suggesting that Millicent had a second husband in the wings, but she underplayed that, telling a reporter "My future plans are indefinite.  I won't say that I will never marry again, at least, I have no one in mind now."

Millicent Rogers Salm, Daily News, April 5, 1927

In fact, she married Argentinian aristocrat Arturo Peralta-Ramos on November 8 that year.  This time her father approved, giving the couple a $500,000 trust fund (with the provision that the groom "lay no future claim" to the Rogers fortune, then estimated at about $40 million).

The wedding was "particularly quiet," as described by The Knickerbocker Press, due Millicent's grandfather, Dr. George Hilliard Benjamin, being gravely ill.  An eminent electrical scientist, he died two days later, early on the morning of November 10.  His funeral was held in the 64th Street mansion.

In the meantime Millicent's brother was living a much more low-profile existence.   He attended preparatory schools in the U.S. before entering Oxford University in 1924.  Upon his graduation he returned to begin his career as an electrical engineer.  

On July 28, 1928 Dr. William R. Lincoln of Cleveland, Ohio, announced the engagement of his daughter, Virginia, to Henry.  The New York Times reported "The engagement is one of the most important of the year and is of interest to society not only here and in Cleveland, but in Washington, D. C., and in Europe."

A month earlier a dramatic fracas had broken out in the 64th Street mansion.  On June 7 Henry Huddleston Rogers's valet, William Mackay, opened a clothes closet to find a burglar hiding inside.  Rogers kept a revolver in the bedroom (which was not loaded) and Mackay grabbed it, ordering Haywood Edwards "to precede him to the basement," as reported by The Daily Star.   They never made it that far before an out-and-out brawl broke out among the staff and the intruder.

"When they got downstairs, however, Edwards bolted.  Harry Caslow, the chauffeur; Charles Roth, the second man, and a maid servant struggled to hold him.  They were being bested in the scuffle but Patrolman Woods arrived in time to place the [burglar] under arrest."  Detectives believed him to be the "window-cleaning" burglar who had been entering the homes of the wealthy in the neighborhood.  Justice came quickly and on July 16 Edwards was sentenced to 10 years in Sing Sing prison.

As had been the case with the Armsbys, domestic bliss in the Rogers household began to deteriorate.  They left East 64th Street in 1928 before Mary filed for divorce in January 1929.

At the same time, Marshall Orme Wilson, Jr. was appointed Second Secretary of the American Embassy at Buenos Aires.  On October 9, 1928 the New York Evening Post reported, "During his leave of absence they will be in their home at 11 East Sixty-fourth Street."

In January 1929 the Wilsons leased the mansion to art dealer George Wildenstein and his family.  It was conveniently located to the Wildenstein Gallery at 19 east 64th Street, erected in 1931.

On June 3, 1946 the house was the scene of Miriam Wildenstein's wedding to Gerard R. Pereire, son of Jacques Pereire of Paris.  In reporting on the wedding, The New York Times mentioned that the bride's father "an art critic, is owner of one of the leading galleries in this city, Paris, London and Buenos Aires.  He is director of Gazette Des Beaux-Arts, editor and publisher of art magazines and books, and a Commander of the Legion of Honor."

George Wildenstein, Look Magazine, November 4, 1944

By the early 1960s, the family had purchased 11 East 64th Street from the Wilson family.  Daniel Wildenstein inherited the mansion following his father's death in 1963.  His son, Alec N. married Jocelyn Périsset in 1978 and the couple moved into the third floor.  Alec's brother, Guy and his wife, Kristina, lived on the fourth floor and the children of both couples had rooms on the fifth floor.

With drama that surpassed that of Millicent Rogers Salm, Alec and Jocelyn each filed for divorce in June 1997--but both refused to leave the mansion.  Things boiled over three months later.  On September 4 The New York Times reported "A prominent New York City art dealer was arrested early yesterday on charges of menacing his wife with a handgun."  Jocelyn had charged him with waving a loaded 9-millimeter pistol at her.  Although Wilderstein claimed he was defending himself from intruders, she succeeded at having an order of protection issued "that bars him from his home and orders him to stay away from his wife."

As part of the couple's divorce agreement in 1999 Jocelyn vacated the 64th Street house and Wildenstein moved back in.  He sold the mansion in 2008 for a reported $42.4 million to Oleg Deripaska, the Soviet-born aluminum tycoon and major GOP donor.

On October 8, 2018 the New York Post reported that, following sanctions imposed against Deripaska by the Treasury Department in April, authorities had "frozen his Upper East Side mansion, occupied by the ex-wife of his business partner Roman Abramovich."  The Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project added "Deripaska has lost billions after the US sanctioned him on alleged bribery, money laundering, murder and racketeering charges."

The report said "This might be a problem for Abramovich's ex-wife Dasha Zhukova, a Russian-American businesswoman, art collector, magazine editor, and philanthropist," who was occupying No. 11 East 64th Street.

Dasha Zhukova had become close friends with her former across-the-street neighbor, Ivanka Trump.  According to the New York Post, "While they were together, Zhukova and Abramovich travelled with Trump and Kusher to Russia, Croatia, Aspen and New York."



Despite having had more than its fair share of drama, the Wilson mansion continues to exude its architectural serenity after 115 years.

photographs by the author