Saturday, January 8, 2011

Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church -- 5th Avenue and 55th Street


On December 19, 1808 a small congregation formed The Cedar Street Presbyterian Church on Cedar Street near William Street.  As the city grew northward the church moved to Duane Street in 1836 and, in 1852, again to Fifth Avenue and 19th Street.  Finally, in 1875 the church, now known as the Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church, moved for its final time to the corner of Fifth Avenue and 55th Street.

The land was purchased for $350,000 and, surrounded by brownstone mansions along “Millionaires Row,” the new church would cost an amazing $1 million.

While the new St. Patrick’s Cathedral four blocks to the south and St. Thomas Episcopal just two blocks away utilized the traditional Gothic cruciform layout; architect Carl Pfeiffer designed an interior revolutionary for its time.  There were no right angles, no soaring stone pillars.  Instead Pfeiffer produced a ship-like open space with a ribbed 60-foot ceiling and unobstructed views from every perspective. The carved woodwork was of polished ash. The New York Times called the interior, capable of seating 2,000 worshippers, “early English.”


photo museumplanet.com

The brownstone exterior was purely Gothic Revival.  The two main entrances, on Fifth Avenue and below the corner tower on 55th Street, mimicked the Gothic arches of the 49 traceried windows and belfry openings. The main steeple, also executed in brownstone, rose 300 feet above Fifth Avenue.  Copper-clad fleches to the north gave an exceptionally picturesque touch; however they were as much utilitarian than simply attractive.

photo nycago.org

In the third quarter of the 19th century, long before air conditioning or central heating, worshippers suffered intolerable heat in the summer and cold in the winter.  Pfeiffer solved the problem with an ingenious system of air movement.

In the basement he had installed 9,000 feet of steam pipes directly below the floor of the sanctuary. The two fleches acted as airshafts, outfitted with a iron fan seven feet in diameter which ran at 220 revolutions per minute. When the shafts sucked the air out of the sanctuary, the warmed air from the basement was pulled through the holes in the floorboard, heating the room (and, more importantly, the feet of the parishioners!).

Likewise, in the summer, the fan would pull 30,000 cubic feet of air out of the church every minute, completely renewing the air every fifteen minutes and providing a constant movement of otherwise stale, hot air.

Behind the sanctuary was a chapel, 75 feet by 45 feet, a lecture room, a large hall and rooms for the minister, trustees, sexton and classrooms and a roomy library.


The chapel of Fifth Avenue Presbyterian -- photo nycago.org

Through the immediate and aggressive sale of pews, the structure was paid for within only two years.  “The pews,” reported The New York Times on May 23, 1875, “were appraised in such a way as to provide for the extinction of the debt, and for the annual expenses of the church organization. These prices ranged from three hundred dollars each to six thousand dollars, according to location…”

While the purchaser received a perpetual title to his pew, he was then liable for an annual assessment of six per cent on the cost price.

The church realized almost immediately that, based on its popularity, it might have nearly doubled its physical size. Under the Reverend Dr. John Henry Jowett in the first quarter of the 20th century, upwards of 1,000 hopeful worshippers would have to be turned away on a Sunday morning.

The church's work was proactive and altruistic. In 1867 it established the first Bible class in the city for women, resulting in lines outside the church awaiting admittance. By 1907 it was supporting two missions, a large settlement house, numerous educational, charitable and relief agencies and employed 57 clergymen and paid workers globally to carry out its missionary and charity work. The church was instrumental in the establishment of the Princeton Theological Seminary and the New York Presbyterian Hospital.


Fifth Avenue Presbyterian in 1917, decorated to honor British, French, Italian, Japanese and Russian War Commissions

A riot was narrowly avoided when, in 1920, ministers from Belfast were invited to speak, representing the Protestant churches of Ireland. Sinn Feine members, the Irish Republicans, massed outside the church on Fifth Avenue hollering “Hurray for the Irish Republic!”

During 2000 and 2001, as an outward demonstration of its concern for the less fortunate, Fifth Avenue Presbyterian established a policy of allowing the homeless to sleep on the steps of the church. Although there is a shelter in the basement, it was limited to ten men. The pastor, one Sunday, remarked to the congregations that “these homeless friends are part of our ministry…Outside on our signboard there’s a sign that says ‘This is God’s House, All Are Welcome.’ All are welcome, and we mean it.”

When, in December 2001, the city evacuated the homeless from the steps, the church filed suit, charging that the city was in violation of the United States Constitution. The church won.

In the 1990's, after a five-year study, a major renovation project was undertaken that included the formation of a new Christian Education Center in the formerly unused space below the sanctuary, installation of air conditioning and fire proofing. Today Fifth Avenue Presbyterian remains essentially unchanged, down to the gas brackets and reflectors still in place.

Friday, January 7, 2011

Hidden, Winding Gay Street in Greenwich Village

photo by Alice Lum
In Greenwich Village a curving little street, one block long, winds it way from Christopher Street to Waverly Place; lined with tiny Federal houses on one side and later, Greek Revival buildings on the other.
1894 print showing the Jefferson Market Courthouse in background -- NYPL Collection
Wouter van Twiller built a brewery here in the 17th Century, one that was long gone by the time the tiny, narrow street was laid out in the early years of the 19th Century. On April 23, 1827, the first documented mention of Gay Street appeared in the Common Council minutes which told of a complaint made by a health inspector against A. S. Pell’s privy.

As the refined Greek Revival homes on Washington Square nearby began rising in the 1830s, Gay Street was widened, in 1833, demolishing the 1820s period houses on the west side. Working-class Greek Revival homes replaced them with stables behind that served the wealthy homeowners of Washington Square.

Mrs. Patton of 276 West 29th Street was brought to No. 12 Gay on August of 1855.  After disembarking from an 8th Avenue trolley car with a baby in her arms, she had been knocked down and run over by a heavy express wagon. Mrs. Patton threw her baby out of harm’s way, but her body was run over by two of the wheels. Policeman Carpenter escorted the woman to her sister’s home on Gay Street. The Times reported that “During the excitement the driver of the wagon made his escape.”


The little house at No. 12 Gay Street with Flemish bond brickwork and surviving Federal entrance details and ironwork where Mrs. Patton was brought in 1855, where Mayor Walker's girlfriend lived and where Howdy Doody was created - photo Atomische.com
On August 28, 1869 a fire broke out on the stable of Henry Lairs behind No. 10 Gay Street reportedly doing $1000 worth of damage. The little houses sat essentially unnoticed on the arcane street, Joseph E. Walsh living at No. 18 when he signed the Woman’s Suffrage petition in 1894 and Anastasia Mullen living at No. 14 Gay Street in 1906.
Nos. 14, where Ruth McKenna wrote "My Sister Eileen," and 16 Gay Street in 1937 -- photo by Bernice Abbott

Throughout the 19th Century and into the early parts of the 20th, the picturesque street was home, mainly, to black residents and on May 10, 1903 The New York Times reported that “A couple of colored artists, Messrs. E. Hawkins and S. O. Collins of 11 Gay Street announce an exhibition of their work at that address from May 11 to 15. They call themselves modestly enough art students, not artists.”

Yet despite its hidden location and plebian roots, Gay Street became the setting for many New York happenings. In the mid-1920s playboy mayor Jimmy Walker leased an apartment for his mistress, Ziegfeld Follies showgirl Betty Compton in No. 12, where Mrs. Patton had been taken in 1855. Later puppeteer Frank Parris lived here, where created his Howdy Doody character.

Next door, in the 1827 house at No. 14, author Ruth McKenney shared the basement apartment with her sister Eileen in 1935. Details of their life on Gay Street were integral to her novel “My Sister Eileen.” A few days before the subsequent Broadway play of the same name opened in 1940, Eileen and her new husband were killed in an automobile accident. The grieving Ruth never saw her play.

In the same apartment on Christmas Day, 2003, community activist David Ryan was killed by a fire.

While Ruth and Eileen McKenney were living two doors away, author Mary McCarthy took up residence in No. 18 in 1936.

Later, across the street, at No. 13, controversial self-described “radical lawyer” William Kunstler lived. Kunstler became famous for his defense of the “Chicago Seven” and later for such divisive clients as the Black Panther Party, the Weather Underground Organization, Jack Ruby and the 1993 World Trade Center bombers.

Nos. 19 through 7 Gay Street in 1940
No. 13 also gave Gay Street its first movie appearance as the principal location in the 1934 A Night to Remember. Al Pacino was arrested at No. 17 in the 1993 Carlito’s Way and in 1996 Sheryl Crow’s video for “A Change Would Do You Good” was shot on Gay Street.

The secretive little bent street is one of New York's quaintest and least known spots.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

The 1908 Felix Warburg Mansion -- 1109 Fifth Avenue

photo by Gryffindor

At the turn of the 20th century in New York City, wealthy Jewish families–the Guggenheims, the Kahns, the Loebs among them–trod carefully among their Christian contemporaries.  According to Kate Simon in her Fifth Avenue, A Very Social History, the unspoken rule was, “live and comport yourself at the height of respectability so that ‘they’ might have no handle for criticism.”

When Jacob Schiff’s son-in-law, Felix Warburg, began planning his grand French Gothic palace on the corner of Fifth Avenue and 92nd Street, a block from Andrew Carnegie’s mansion, Schiff reportedly objected.  Fearing that the ostentatious style would spur anti-Semitic criticism, he urged Warburg to build in the more restrained Italian Renaissance style.  Felix and Frieda Warburg, however, resisted.

Felix and Frieda had admired the Francois I style mansion of Isaac and Mary Fletcher at 2 East 79th Street designed by C. P. H. Gilbert in 1898.  The couple commissioned Gilbert to design a similar, larger and grander residence on a plot purchased from Perry Belmont.  Following the couple's general design direction, Gilbert drew inspiration from the Hotel de Cluny in Paris.  Begun in 1907 and completed a year later, the mansion dripped with Gothic moldings and boasted ogee-arched windows, steep slate mansard roofs and crocketed gables, tall chimneys and foliate borders, tracery and copper cresting.  Unusual in Fifth Avenue mansions, a 50-foot side lawn fronted the avenue.

According to Kate Simon, as construction progressed Jacob Schiff’s “gesture of protest was to turn his head away when he passed the growing house on one of his constitutionals.”

The Warburg mansion in 1925 - from the collection of the New York Public Library

The Warburgs’ limestone chateau featured a grand entrance hall with an impressive staircase.  On the first floor were a small gallery for the collection of early German and Italian woodcuts and Rembrandt etchings, and the kitchens and pantries.  The second floor held a music room overlooking Fifth Avenue.  It held an Aeolian pipe organ and housed some of the Warburgs’ art collection–tapestries, illuminated manuscripts and sculptures.  A stained glass conservatory housed a Botticelli while an adjoining room displayed a Madonna and Child by Raphael and antique Italian paintings.  The formal dining room, hung with medieval tapestries, was also on this floor.

Above were the family rooms: the principal bedrooms, Frieda’s boudoir and dressing room, and joint sitting rooms for the parents.  The fourth floor housed the five children’s bedrooms and the fifth held guest bedrooms and a squash court.

A contemporary account said the home was, “elaborately fitted out with fine marble work and woodwork which helped to form a fit setting for the extensive and costly decorations, tapestries, furniture and statuary gathered by the banker and his wife from all parts of the world.”

Although, according to Edward M. M. Warburg, “Father used to say [if] had he had any idea what kind of family he was going to have he never would have built so formal a house.”  Felix reveled in his children.  He played squash with them, invented bicycle polo, and sang Gilbert and Sullivan tunes to them in German.  He told his wife, “Your children may be spoiled, mine are fun.”

And, indeed, the children had fun. A train wound its way throughout the children’s bedrooms and Mrs. Walburg’s china bowl in the entrance hall, meant for receiving calling cards, was a perfect target for spitting contests from the staircase landing above.

There were 13 servants living in the house including a nurse and an engineer (who tendered the boiler, furnace and such).

One-by-one the children married and left.  In 1937, Felix died, leaving a legacy of generous philanthropy.  Frieda stayed on in the house, sharing it with the family of Max Warburg who were driven from Germany by the Hitler regime.

Things were changing on upper Fifth Avenue at the time.  On May 3, 1940, Frieda Warburg leased a duplex suite that engulfed two full floors in the apartment building at 1070 Fifth Avenue.  Property taxes on the house, totaling $665,000 a year, coupled with operational expenses and maintenance made sustaining the building impractical.  Within a year, she emptied the house, donating the bulk of the rare artwork and furnishings to museums, libraries and universities.

Three years later Frieda donated the house to the Jewish Theological Seminary for its Jewish Museum, which opened to the public in 1947.  In 1963, the side yard was replaced by a new wing.


Although the museum opposed landmark designation in 1970, it lost its battle in 1981 when the property was given landmark status.  In 1988, designs for an annex by Kevin Roche were approved and the astonishingly seamless addition was completed in 1993, which author Andrew S. Dolkart called “expertly replicated.”

In its designation report, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission commented that the “mansion itself is a tangible reminder of one facet of Jewish life in American history, and as such is one of the museum’s most important treasures.”

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Our Lady of Pompeii Church -- Carmine and Bleecker Streets


photo by Jim Henderson

The Greek Revival Third Universalist Church had stood at 214 Bleecker Street for 36 years when, in 1898, the congregation of Our Lady of Pompeii made it their home.  The fledgling parish had been founded six years earlier by the Reverend Pietro Bandini of the Missionaries of St. Charles–the Scalabrinians.

The area of Greenwich Village where the church settled was quickly becoming an enclave of Italian immigrants and Our Lady of Pompeii offered services in their native language.  It was here that Mother Frances Xavier Cabrini, America’s first saint, taught for a period.

In 1900, the dynamic and charismatic pastor Reverend Antonio Demo took charge of the congregation.  The 30-year-old priest, who was born in Lazzaretto di Bassano, Italy, became a noted personality and a force within the Italian-American community.

In 1923, the city notified Father Demo that the church sat squarely in the path of the intended extension of Sixth Avenue.  Through eminent domain scores of structures including the Church of Our Lady of Pompeii were condemned and scheduled for demolition.

Father Demo went into action.  Organizing the parish into committees, he spearheaded the project of purchasing land and building a new church, rectory and school.  The priest personally chose the esteemed architect Matthew W. Del Gaudio to design the structure.

The buildings at 17 through 25 Carmine Street, at the corner of Bleecker Street, were purchased and demolished and in 1926 ground was broken.

A tragedy occurred during construction on New Year's Day 1928.  Three-year-old Zita Triglia of 23 Leroy Street was killed instantly when a 10-foot beam fell from the scaffold of the steeple at noon that day, knocking the toddler from her father’s arms.  Construction was completed nine months later and on October 8, 1928 Cardinal Joseph Hayes officiated in the solemn mass dedicating the new church.  The service was attended by more than 2,000 worshippers.

image via Wurts Bros. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.


Del Gaudio’s imposing edifice, costing over $1 million, was designed in the Italian Renaissance style.  The limestone Carmine Street façade gives way to beige brick along the Bleecker Street side.  The classical elements–immense Corinthian columns and pilasters, a closed pediment over the entrance and stately stone balustrades along the roofline–combine to create a stately presence.  The three-story campanile at the corner, topped by a copper dome and cross, has been variously termed “dominating” and “majestic” to being criticized for creating an overall "lopsided” effect.  The architect lavished the interior with frescoes and murals and highly polished marble columns.

Father Antonio Demo continued to serve his mainly Italian congregation until 1935.  A year later, he died and in 1941 the empty triangular plot of land created when Sixth Avenue was extended was named Father Demo Square in his honor.


photo nyc-architecture.com

Today Our Lady of Pompeii continues as an active, thriving parish.  Although the once exclusively Italian congregation now is now a harmonious mix, one mass is still conducted in Italian every Sunday.

photo by Alice Lum


Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Clairvoyance and Murder - No. 8 Jane Street


The sleepy Village of Greenwich quickly developed as residents of New York City fled the yellow fever epidemics of 1819 and 1822. Here merchant Leonard DeKlyn purchased a stretch of land facing the lane that led to the Jayne farm.

After DeKlyn’s death his family had three modest brick homes built on the plot in 1843. The three identical structures, built as investment properties, were most likely the product of a builder using style books. Transitional in style, they flirt with the then-trendy Greek Revival while clinging to the obsolete Federal style.

Included in the row was No. 8 and, like the others, it boasted three stories of red Flemish bond brick over a brownstone English basement. Brownstone lentils and a denil-molded cornice, a handsome and dignified entrance with narrow sidelights and a generous overlight, and a wide brownstone stoop with cast iron banisters lent a refined air to the comfortable residence.

The roomy house on quiet Jane Street was intended for a working class family, such as that of Arthur Harley who was living here in 1881 when, while passing the construction site at 70 Beekman Street, was hit in the head by a screw-wrench dropped from a workman on a scaffold above. The unfortunate Harley suffered a resultant skull fracture.

By 1889 No. 8 Jane was a boarding house, run by Mrs. Eliza Murray. One of Mrs. Murray’s boarders was Mrs. Matilda Peck. Originally from the South, Mrs. Peck was a clairvoyant who conducted business as Madame Mantell. Upon her sudden death in her room here at the age of 50, The New York Times called her “intelligent and well-educated…and was looked upon by Spiritualists as a remarkable medium.”

Unwelcomed notoriety came to No. 8 Jane when, on May 24, 1895, boarder George Meehan assaulted another tenant. The Times noted that “Meehan was addicted to the use of liquor, and, while under its influence, was abusing his wife.” When sixty-five year old Elvin O. Buck attempted to intervene, Meehan, a coal dealer, turned on him.

Buck was kicked and beaten and one of his eyes gouged out. New Yorkers followed the story for weeks as new details developed. When doctors at St. Vincent’s hospital explained to the old man that he would not recover, he requested to be allowed to die at home, at No. 8 Jane Street. Soon after being returned to his room, he died. Meehan was held on $1000 bail.

In a tragic postscript to the story, Mrs. Meehan left No. 8 Jane and took a room at 235 W. 17th Street, paying $1.50 rent for the first week up front. Before the week was up, an intoxicated 20-year old Mary O’Brien, another boarder, knocked on Jennie Meehan’s door at 1:00 am holding a lighted coal oil lamp, requesting more coal oil. When Jennie refused, Mrs. O’Brien (who was acting in “a surly manner”) erupted with “a torrent of oaths” and threw the lighted lamp at Jennie Meehan.

The lamp exploded, setting Jennie Meehan and subsequently the entire room ablaze. Not only was she horribly burned, but she inhaled the flames. Jennie Meehan died five hours later.

Annie S. Baumann owned the boarding house at No. 8 Jane in 1899 when delivery man Clarence Hoyt resided there. That winter, on February 7, Hoyt was inside a building when his team of horses bolted down 6th Avenue. The wagon struck a trolley car, righted itself and struck another between 17th and 18th Street, breaking several of the car’s windows and frightening the passengers. Hoyt’s wagon was demolished against the pillar of the elevated railroad. No horses were injured in the telling of this story.

Two years later in 1901 Annie Baumann sold the building to John Fox and, with few changes, the house continued throughout the 20th Century as rental units. In 2010, the 3200-square foot house, a charming pre-Civil War survivor, sold for $4.3 million.

Monday, January 3, 2011

St. George Greek Orthodox Church - 307 W. 54th Street

Photo by stgeorgenyc.org

When Mayor Hugh J. Grant founded the Narragansett Club (a Tammany Hall-based Democratic political organization), an upper west side headquarters/clubhouse was necessary.  Land was purchased at 307 W. 54th Street and a Romanesque Revival-style building with Queen Anne touches was erected on the lot.  For the two-story, red brick-faced structure over an English basement, architect H. J. Grant added a pressed-metal cornice board, terra cotta ornamentation and bold numerals below the eave announcing the construction date, 1886.  Construction of the building cost $15,000, or just over $400,000 today.

Three years later on January 6, 1889, the group threw a celebration of its third anniversary.  Mayor Grant was in attendance as was “every Tammany man of consequence.”  The New York Times reported, “They were entertained with songs, instrumental music, exhibitions of ventriloquial skill, and speeches.”  Senator Irving Ives concocted an apparently strong punch for the event.  “Everybody had a good time,” said The Times,” but those who looked least at the seductive punch bowl feel the better to-day.”

In addition to its occasional celebrations, the clubhouse was the site of conventions and nominations of candidates for the 14th Congressional District.  On October 5, 1896, John Quincy Adams, who was “related to the well-known Massachusetts family of that name,” was unanimously nominated here.

Almost 20 years to the day after building their clubhouse, on January 5, 1906, the Tammany club sold it to the New Amsterdam Council of the Knights of Columbus.  The heavily-Irish group, which promised to make “extensive alterations to the property,” renamed it The New Amsterdam Building.

With the Knights of Columbus came evenings of serious discussion and debate.  Irish-born James P. Conway, a student of Irish literature, attempted to defend John Millington Synge’s play The Playboy of the Western World here on January 24, 1912.  The Knights, many of whom had participated in the riots following the play’s debut in New York, jeered him for an hour.  Michael Conway, a former member of Parliament, countered Conway and was carried by the crowd from the stage in triumph.



In March of 1912, the Reverend Terence J. Shealy discussed the ills of Socialism, and on January 15, 1913 Mayor William Jay Gaynor addressed the group regarding new issues in the city: subway construction, elevation of the freight train tracks on Tenth Avenue (known today as the High Line), and the lengthening the Hudson River piers to accommodate the newer, larger ships.

By the spring of 1915, the building was the home of the Century Road Club Association.  A cycling club, it not only participated in bicycle races but used the clubhouse for dances and “amateur night” talent contents.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

It was during the Great Depression that the building became an “old calendar” Greek Orthodox Church–“one of a group of churches that split off from the mainline church over a dispute regarding adoption of the western calendar,” according to Father James W. Kordaris, of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America.  At this time, it was also home to the Hellenic Centre.  In December 1933, a one-man show by Alexander Sideris exhibited oils and water colors of still lifes, portraits, florals, and Greek villages and coast vistas.




photo by firstthings.com

In the early 1950s, the church came under the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America and today the little building remains so.  Saint George Greek Orthodox Church conducts services in Greek and English in a space encrusted with murals and icons.  Were it not for the flat ceiling, the visitor might never suspect that the building was not originally intended as a church.  An exquisite iconostasis dominates the space.  Under the floor mat in the foyer, according to Father Kordaris, the Knights of Columbus monogram "KC" survives in the tilework.

Little has changed to the façade since 1886 other than the cross on the eaves and the stained glass window that replaces the original.  The little building whose “joyous ornament is still evident,” according to the AIA Guide to New York City, is a delightful surprise on West 54th Street.

Saturday, January 1, 2011

The House that Minnie Young Built - 19 East 54th Street


19 East 54th Street on September 1, 1900

When Albert and Minnie young married around 1875, things looked good for the couple. Albert was a successful stockbroker and Minnie had amassed a fortune of her own in Virginia after the Civil War. Together they raised three sons and a daughter in a succession of fine homes.

Tragedy struck when in 1895 Albert died and then, only four years later, son Albert M., aged 25 years old, passed away unexpectedly.

The year that her son died, 1899, plans for filed for a new house at 19 East 54th Street. Minnie commissioned Hiss & Weekes to design her home. Possibly owing to her status of a mourning widow and mother, she dispensed with the architectural ornament currently stylish in grand residences of the neighborhood.  Rather than marble or limestone, Mrs. Young’s mansion was granite. The Italian Renaissance palazzo, overall, was dignified rather than exuberant.

Minnie Young’s home spoke restraint.

The interior was less so. Coffered ceilings, oak paneled stairways and a stained glass conservatory reflected the wealth of the owner. In 1900 Minnie moved in with her sister, Johanna “Jennie” Arents, and her son, George. Nine servants also lived in the house including a “hallman” named Pleasant Read. Other help included the cook, kitchen maid, parlor maid, laundress, and butler.

Minnie owned thoroughbred racing horses and a year after moving into No. 19 won four ribbons in the Millbrook Horse Show. Seven years later in 1907, her daughter, Mrs. A. E. Dieterich, caused scandal by running off to Paris with Harry Benchley, Alfred Vanderbilt’s horse buyer. Minnie steamed off to France with her son, George Louis, booking rooms at the Hotel Ritz and going almost immediately to her daughter’s rooms in “a hotel little frequented by Americans.”

The New York Times reported that “When she left the Hotel Ritz…it was with the expressed determination of bringing her daughter back with her.”

Minnie’s expressed determination was to no avail and a year later she steamed back into New York harbor without her daughter.

Later that year Minnie and her sister lost over $1 million when the investment firm of A.O. Brown & Co., of which Minnie’s son Lewis Ginter Young, was a partner, failed. The women, whom The Times said “had been liberally provided for by their father, who was prominent in the American Tobacco Company,” were “apparently not in the least ruffled by the ordeal.”

By the time World War I was over, the neighborhood where Minnie lived was no longer home to Rockefellers and Vanderbilts. The chateaux and palazzos of the great 5th Avenue families were being demolished or converted to retail space as their owners fled uptown. In 1920 Minnie Young followed suit. Moving to Park Avenue, Minnie leased her home to Lady Duff Gordon who did business as "Lucille." Lucille was a dressmaker to the wealthy and famous. It took Lucille a year to complete her renovations, including installing show windows in the first floor.  She opened in 1921, paying Minnie a monthly rent on the 21-year lease of around $50,000.

It wasn’t a good move for Lucille.

The next year, on March 21, 1922, The Times announced that Lucille was in receivership after an involuntary bankruptcy. Lucille’s attorney, Harry Bandler explained that the “embarrassment of the company” had been caused in part because “the company was obliged to move to its new quarters at 19 East Fifty-fourth Street during the year, which required the tieing up of a considerable amount of its capital in the improvements which were made in the new quarters.”

Adventure-loving antiques trader Arthur S. Vernay took over the house and it was from here that he sold to William Randolph Hearst the historic Elizabethan great chamber of Gilling Castle from Yorkshire, England. On April 6, 1933 Vernay bought the house, selling and exhibiting both the wonderful and the rare until he closed his gallery on October 20, 1940.

Minnie Young’s house was next home to the English-Speaking Union for several decades. A non-political organization it was conceived to foster global friendship and understanding among English-speaking peoples.

In 1962 the house became the salon of a celebrity hairdresser. Like Lucille, Kenneth used only one name. Here clients like Jacqueline Kennedy came to be beautified and here on May 16, 1989 fire ravaged the back portion of the house. The house sat, its interiors soot covered and rubble-filled, for over a year before renovation began.

Today Minnie Young’s dignified home at No. 19 East 54th Street is home to Interaudi Bank. While the exterior is pristine and preserved, the elegant interiors, except for traces here and there that managed to survive modernization and commercialization, are essentially gone.



 
 
photo Interaudi Bank