|photograph by the author|
Thirteen years later, in 1841, Blauvelt added to his holdings by building a two-and-a-half story home at No. 120 Charles Street. Its architect took inspiration from both the Federal and newer Greek Revival styles. The 22-foot wide house was trimmed in brownstone. Its doorway above the stone stoop was slightly off balance with the upper floor openings This was because of the horsewalk that nestled up to the stoop. Essentially a tunnel that provided access to the rear yard, it was most likely used by the occupants of both 118 and 120.
If Blauvelt initially leased the house to a single family, it was being operated as a boarding house by the early 1850's. Among the respectable residents in 1854 was Mary Jane Davis, a teacher in the Primary Department of Public School No. 3, at the corner of Hudson and Grove Streets. Because she earned $125 that year, or about $3,760 today, she most likely could afford only a single room.
An advertisement in The New York Herald on May 31, 1856 offered "Three rooms, in a small, genteel house, with gas, &c., to a man and wife, or family of two persons. The rent will be $12.50 per month." That was one-tenth of Mary Jane Davis's annual income.
Although the advertisement described the house as "genteel," several of its boarders continued to manage on meager incomes. George Wilkinson lived here in 1865. He was a cartman and volunteered as a firefighter, or "laddie," at the Columbian Hook & Ladder Company, No. 14 nearby at No. 96 Charles Street.
The boarding house was being leased and operated by Charles M. Turner, and his wife Hilah in the early 1870's. Turner ran other rental incomes, as evidenced by his advertisement on June 15, 1873. "Country Board can be obtained on Long Island Sound, near the steamboat landing; splendid bathing, boating and fishing; terms reasonable."
Less than a month later the Turner's 24-year old son, Charles, Jr., died in the Charles Street house. His funeral was held on Staten Island two days later.
Among the Turners' boarders was policeman John F. Standish. He had been appointed to the newly-formed Metropolitan Police force on April 26, 1854. By 1876 while living here he was working with the Steamboat Squad, earning a comfortable $1,200 per year.
Also in the house that year was Henry Tunin. He had apparently befriended an elderly widow, Josephine A Colton. The New York Times described her as an "unfortunate woman," following her suicide on July 7, 1876. She left Tunin a silver cake basket and caster in her will "for his readiness and kindness in assisting me when requested."
No. 120 was owned by H. N. Camp at the time; but he fell behind on his mortgage payments in 1881. On January 14, 1882 the Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported that the house would be sold two days later in foreclosure auction. The winning bid of $5,310--equal to about $131,000 today--was placed by Charles P. Kuper.
Officer John Standish was still among Kuper's boarders. He retired in 1884 and in 1886 was living on his pension of $600; about half of his former salary. It may have been his reduced income that prompted him to move to New Jersey within a few years.
Charles I. Stewart acquired both No. 120 and its skinny next door neighbor, No. 118, around 1928. He leased both in March 1929, The New York Times noting "The buildings are being renovated for studio apartments.
Architect Clive Wing's renovations included cutting an entrance above the horsewalk of No. 120 and installing a wide stoop to provide access to both buildings.
|A double-wide stoop provided access to both buildings. photo via NYC Department of Records|
In 1969 another renovation joined Nos. 118 and 120 internally. The stoop of No. 118 was removed and its entrance bricked up. Unfortunately, the owners and architects did not make an effort to match the brick nor to restore the entrance.