Wednesday, July 13, 2022

The James McCreery House - 325 East 14th Street

 


Born in Ireland in 1826, James McCreery arrived in the United States when he was about 20 years old, settling first in Baltimore.  He relocated to New York City to join the drygoods firm of Upson, Pierson & Lake on Broadway.  In 1851 he married Fanny Maria Crawford and the couple moved into the fine house at 173 East 14th Street (renumbered 325 in 1868), between First and Second Avenues. 

It was one of a recently-erected row of 23-foot-wide, Greek Revival homes.  A high stoop rose above the English basement to the entrance.  Here the architect gave pilasters highly unusual Egyptian lotus capitals decorated with carved anthemia.   The influence of the Italianate style was reflected in the stoop ironwork, the floor-to-ceiling parlor windows, and the ornate bracketed cornice.

Heavily weathered today, the Egyptian capitals were highly unexpected.

Interestingly, McCreery's brother, John, moved briefly into the house with the newlyweds.  John was a partner in the McCreery & Goulding drygoods firm at 18 John Street.  He was no longer listed at the 14th Street address by 1853.

James and Fanny would have four sons: James Crawford, born in 1853; Andrew born in 1857; Robert Samuel, who arrived in 1860; and William John, born three years later.  Just before William John's birth, the family moved to 15 Washington Place, across the street from Cornelius Vanderbilt I.  McCreery had risen within Upson, Pierson & Lake following the retirement of Upson.  By 1867 he would take control of the firm, changing its name to McCreery & Co. and becoming one of the city's wealthiest businessmen.

James McCreery, image via Notable New Yorkers 1869-1899 (copyright expired)

McCreery rented the 14th Street house, advertising in the New York Herald on April 16, 1862:

East Fourteenth Street--To rent, the three story and attic brown stone, high stoop House 173 East Fourteenth street, between First and Second avenues, 23-1/2 feet front, to a private family only.

The James Brady family lived here in the 1860's, and while McCreery's ad stressed "private family only," it did not prohibit the taking in of a boarder, as was common.   From 1864 through 1869 Frederick Sackett Hanford rented a room while he attended Columbia University.  The young man's home was in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio.

Following Brady's death at the age of 69 in January 1870, 325 East 14th Street became home to the Thomas Le Claire family.  Sharing the house was Le Claire's sister-in-law, Margaret Dean, as well as her adult daughter, Frances, son-in-law, Washington L. Jaques, and their children.  

The year 1872 would be a traumatic one for the family.  On June 25, Frances and Washington's eight-month-old son George Brower Jaques died.  Their youngest child, his little casket sat in the parlor until his funeral two days later.  And then, only three months later, Margaret Dean died at the age of 63 "after a lingering illness," according to The New York Sun.   

There would be a third funeral in the house three years later.  Thomas Le Claire contracted Bright's disease, a kidney condition known today as nephritis.  He died at the age of 58 on June 25, 1875 and his funeral was held in the house on the 27th.

By now 14th Street had become the center of Manhattan's theater district.  Catherine Charles, the widow of John Charles, was a close friend of the McCreerys.  Catherine purchased 325 East 14th Street and began operating it as a "theatrical boarding house."

Among her more tragic boarders was William Carleton who took a room in 1884.  An Irish-born actor, author, and playwright, he had been known as the Great Carleton.   The New York Herald noted, "Not many years ago he was quite a favorite before the footlights, earned a handsome salary, and was hailed with delight on the 'Square' as a good fellow, because he spent his earnings freely and indiscriminately."

But when he rented his room from Catherine, he had not worked in two years.   He made some money by writing songs and plays, and received help from the Actors' Fund Association.  The New York Herald explained his fall, saying "But by and by there came a change.  William sought the wine cup too frequently and neglected his business...His clothes began to look shabby, his appearance changed and people on the square no longer pressed forward to welcome the comedian and playwright."

He lived over a year in the 14th Street house where, according to the newspaper, Catherine Charles "by words and kindness, endeavored to make things pleasant for the actor.  She said he was always so gentlemanly in his manner and so cheerful in disposition that no one could fail to like him."  Carleton's continued drinking prompted the Actors' Fund to cease supporting him, and living in a boarding house became too costly.  He left in May 1885 to take a furnished room a block away at 316 East 14th Street.

Carleton became ill early in August 1885.  The New York Herald said that Catherine and one of her boarders, a Mrs. Chandler, "brought the sick scion many nourishments.  They saw that he wanted for nothing during his illness, and when he was able to get about again, he was profuse in his thanks."  But the once-proud thespian and writer was broken.  And on August 19, 1885 the Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported that the odor of gas in the rooming house was traced to Carleton's room.  "When the door was forced open he was found dead, lying across the bed."

Catherine's boarders in the 1890's included opera house proprietor Wallace H. Frisbie, Irish comedian Edward J. Heffernan, Eva Marshal (described by the New York Herald as "the high kicking soubrette"), vocalist Charles Burt, and actor Charles DeForrest and his actress wife Vera.

On December 19, 1899, the New York Morning Telegraph reported, "It takes something pretty strong to make the average boarders in a theatrical house complain, but there were many present in court to make all sorts of charges against [Charles] DeForrest, who, by all accounts, had left the place looking like a Kansas ranch after a friendly call from an ably built cyclone."

Vera testified that her husband had come home drunk "and terrorized the boarding house by smashing furniture, bombarding doors with crockery, and otherwise making life a horrible reality for all concerned."  When Policeman Fletcher started up the stairs, "he met a wash basin sailing down in his direction and ducked his head in time to avoid a collision."  DeForrest barricaded himself in his room while "along the hallways actors and actresses stuck their heads out to note the progress of the storm.  Broken crockery and pieces of chairs were strewn along the hall."  

DeForrest was arrested, but only after a struggle.  The article said, "Charles was not a thing of beauty when arraigned.  His head and face had been battered until his countenance resembled that upon a copper cent after a train had passed over it."   Referring to Officer Fletcher, he complained to the judge, "There was no reason why he should have assaulted me."  The magistrate promised, "I am going to inquire into that," but in the meantime he held the actor in $500 bail.

Two boarders who were most definitely not involved in the theater arrived on April 3, 1902.  Signing in as Mr. and Mrs. Harry Place, the couple were in reality Harry Alonzo Longabaugh, known to authorities as the outlaw and member of Butch Cassidy's "Wild Bunch," Sundance Kid, and his wife, Etta Place.  By now, the aging Catherine Charles had help from her niece in running the house, and at least two biographies of the Sundance Kid refer to 325 East 14th Street as "Mrs. Thompson's."  The couple remained only until July 10, 1902 when they sailed to South America on the steamer Honorius.

The Sundance Kid and Etta Place posed for his photograph at DeYoung's Studio at 857 Broadway while staying here.


As she had done with William Carleton, Catherine maintained close relationships with many of her boarders.  Jerry Clayton was one of those.  A partner in the Stanton-Olifan Trio, well known to vaudeville audiences, he enlisted in the Army in 1917.  When he was killed in action on September 3, 1918, the Government listed his next of kin as Catherine Charles.

One of Catherine's longest-lasting boarders was Frank J. Hurley, a vaudeville acrobat who went by the stage name Frank Rossi.  He moved in around 1892 and as the decades passed, began helping his aging landlady.  It was a kindness that did not escape the appreciation of Catherine Charles.  

On May 16, 1922 she rewrote her will.  Interestingly, it was witnessed by J. A. McCreery, presumably the grandson of James McCreery.  The will gave her entire estate to Frank Hurley, "in recognition of his helpful assistance to me in carrying on the business of the house and in attending to my personal wants while I was in suffering health."  After having run the boarding house for more than four decades, Catherine died on June 28, 1922.

Around 1932 the basement level was converted to an Italian restaurant, Lido Dell' East.

The Daily Worker, October 26, 1932.

A renovation in 1954 resulted in six furnished rooms per floor in the upper stories.  At the time the Spanish restaurant Il Faro had operated on West 14th Street since 1927.  In 1968, The Underground Gourmet reported, "Il Faro has moved eastward to somewhat fancier quarters at 325 East 14th Street, but prices and menu remain virtually unchanged."

Il Faro eventually moved west again, to 823 Greenwich Street.  By 1993 the restaurant space was home to the Filipino restaurant, Manila Garden.  The New York Times food critic Elaine Louie said of it on October 5, 1994, "Napkins are linen, flowers are fresh, and drinks aren't soda pop."


That same year the upper portion of the house was converted to apartments, one per floor.  Around the turn of the century the Crocodile Lounge moved into the restaurant space.  Today, of the long row of homes, the McCreery house is the best preserved.  With little imagination the passerby can imagine its well-dressed occupants alighting from their carriage before the stoop.

photographs by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Tuesday, July 12, 2022

Henry Anderson's 1896 316 West 82nd Street

 


Frederick Haas was busy constructing apartment, or flat, buildings in the 1880's, many of them on the Upper West Side.  In 1895 he hired architect Henry Anderson to design another, on the south side of West 82nd Street, between West End Avenue and Riverside Drive.  It was a neighborhood quickly filling with private homes of the well-to-do.

Completed the following year, 316 West 82 Street was five stories tall and accommodated six families.  Anderson designed the 25-foot-wide structure in the Renaissance Revival style.  The entrance, above a short stoop, was set to the side, under a portico with Scamozzi columns.  The upper floors were clad in yellow Roman brick and trimmed in limestone.  The  paneled piers that flanked the second floor windows and the long frieze at this level were intricately carved.  The top floor strayed from the theme below.  Its windows were fully arched with prominent scrolled keystones, and decorative carved rosettes and plaques decorated the brickwork.



An advertisement for an apartment described, "eight rooms and bath, all large, light and handsomely decorated; everything modern and attractive."  They filled with affluent residents, including its owner, Frederick Haas, and his wife.

Among the initial tenants were George Alden Sanford, a lay assistant with the West End College Church; piano manufacturer Charles Alonzo Wessell and his wife; and Hutchins Hapgood, who worked for the Commercial Advertiser.

Perhaps the most celebrated tenant at the time was George William Warren.  Born in 1826, he was an organist and world-renowned hymnist.  In 1870, after working for several prestigious congregations, he was made organist for St. Thomas's Church on Fifth Avenue.  When he retired in 1900, he was made organist emeritus.

Musical Courier noted, "Mr. Warren came from Pilgrim stock, his ancestor, Richard Warren, having come over on the Mayflower.  Another ancestor, William Warren, was wounded at the Battle of Bunker Hill."  Among the well-known hymns he composed were the National Hymn, or God of Our Fathers; and Rock of Ages, Cleft for Me.

Warren suffered a stroke in March 1902.  It was followed by another a few days later, and he died in his apartment on March 16.  The New York Times commented, "It is said of Dr. Warren that no one on the United States' list of organists and church music composers was better known than he both here and broad."

Also living here were the family of Congressman John Henry Ketcham.  He and his wife, Augusta, had two grown sons, Henry B. and Charles B., and a daughter, Ethel B. Ketcham.  Henry was an attorney and Charles was a broker.  Although Henry was married and lived with his wife and children on East 58th Street, during the summer when they were away, he would stay here when in town.

Like all upscale apartment buildings, 316 West 82nd Street had hallboys--young uniformed men who were on hand to run errands, bring mail, deliver messages, and such.  On September 30, 1903 a new hallboy, 18-year-old Harry Smith (or Miller--he used two surnames) was hired.  What Frederick Haas may not have known in hiring him, was that he had just spent several years in the House of Refuge, sent there by his mother for stealing from her.

Two days later Augusta was alone in the apartment.  Her husband had taken Ethel to Nantucket, Henry had left that morning to be with his family in Massachusetts, and Charles, too, was in the country.  She started out to do shopping at around 10:30.  As she left the building, she told the hallboy that she expected her sister and she would be home by 11:00.  Harry Smith saw an opportunity.

But Augusta was not gone an hour.  She returned half an hour later.  The Poughkeepsie newspaper, The Evening Enterprise, said, "When she opened the door she saw that the furniture had been moved about and that the drawers of a bureau were pulled out.  As she walked toward a closet, looking about her all the time for an explanation of what she saw, the new hallboy spring from the closet and made straight for her.  He held a piece of lead pipe in his uplifted right hand."

Harry Smith hit the 60-year-old woman over the head, then hit her again on the shoulder, breaking her collarbone.  Augusta later said she pleaded, "Don't kill me, Harry.  I can't do anything to hurt you."

Instead, Harry grabbed her by the throat and strangled her.  When she lost consciousness he removed her collarette (a sort of necktie), tied it tightly around her throat, "and left Mrs. Ketcham for dead," said the Brooklyn Daily Eagle.  Harry made off with $5 in cash and Augusta's $50 gold watch.  He left the apartment door slightly open in his escape.  It caught the attention of a neighbor later, who discovered Augusta unconscious on the floor.

A devout Christian Scientist, Augusta "forbade those people in the house either to send for a physician or to notify her family, every member of which was out of town at the time," said The Evening Enterprise.  She walked, unaided to the Christian Science Church.  When she returned, despite having a broken collarbone and bruised face, "she assured everybody that she was in excellent condition."

A general alarm was sent out to find her assailant.  But finding him would not end in his imprisonment.  The Evening Enterprise noted, "Mrs. Ketcham, it is said, told the police that even if the hallboy was arrested, she would refuse to make any complaint against him."

In 1911 William Stephen Devery had already had a remarkable career.  In 1878 he was appointed to the police force.  A favorite of Tammany Hall, especially of leader Richard Cocker, Devery rose in the ranks quickly.  Although convicted of bribery and extortion in February 1897, he was promoted to inspector the following year, to Deputy Chief on February 14, 1898, and to Chief of Police on June 30, 1898.  Known best as "Big Bill," he was forced out by Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt's reforms.  He sold his opulent West End Avenue mansion and left town--for a while.

William "Big Bill" Devery.  (original source unknown)

On August 11, 1911 the Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported, "'Big Bill' Devery found that he could not resist the call of the city," and had "reconsidered his decision."  The article said "He has bought the five-story apartment house at 316 West Eighty-second street.  It is said that he will occupy one of the suites himself, and that another will be the home of his daughter, Mrs. Fink."  (Devery's 19-year-old daughter, Anna, had eloped with Edward Fink in 1903.)

In the summer of 1919 teenaged sisters Kay and Joan Boyle, who lived in Cincinnati, moved temporarily into the apartment of their aunt, Madge Boyle, here.  Kay took a summer course in architectural drawing, and then in September enrolled in the New York School of Fine and Applied Art (later Parsons School of Fine and Applied Arts).  Meanwhile, Joan was studying fashion design.  Kay Boyle would go on to become a novelist, short story writer, political activist and winner of the O. Henry Award.

The residents of 316 West 82nd Street were gradually becoming less affluent.  Madge Boyle, for instance, worked in a department store.  Meta Schumann's apartment doubled as her studio in 1923.  The pianist accompanied professional vocalists and taught piano from her apartment.

True change would come after the building was sold to Lily Weiner in 1938.  She converted the building, where entertainments like debutante teas had been held a few decades earlier, to an SRO with 40 rooms.

That configuration lasted until a renovation completed in 1970 resulted in two apartments per floor.  They were remodeled again in 1986 by architect and developer Joseph H. Gardner.

And while the facade could stand a gentle cleaning, other than replacement windows little has outwardly changed since it opened in 1896.

photographs by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Monday, July 11, 2022

The Lost Ascension Memorial Church - 245-249 West 43rd Street

 

from the collection of the New-York Historical Society

The congregation of the Church of the Ascension, on Fifth Avenue and 10th Street, was fashionable and affluent.  But their privileged status did not blind them to the needs of the less fortunate.  In a sermon delivered on December 23, 1934, Rev. Donald B. Aldrich recalled:

From 1859 on, a flood of immigration swelled New York City with four hundred thousand additional people.  These newcomers lived in shacks and tenements unspeakable in squalor and poverty.  It was for them that the congregation purchased and cleared a block at 43rd Street and Ninth Avenue, and erected model tenements there, at a cost of $43,000.  As a center of center of worship, recreation and help for these people, the Ascension Memorial Chapel, costing $10,000, was built among them and administered by the congregation of this church.

Aldrich had one detail slightly wrong.  The mission was originally called the Chapel of the Shepherd's Flock.  The original rector was Daniel Thom, replaced in 1870 by Reverend John Floyd Steen, who would remain with the impoverished members for decades.  The were fifty members in the congregation at the time.

In 1894 the mission chapel became an independent church, now named the Ascension Memorial Church.  The congregation celebrated Steen's 25th anniversary on March 3 the following.  The Sun reported that Bishop Henry C. Potter had overseen the "special services."  Steen's outreach to the immigrants who had had little exposure to religion was reflected in the last line of the article.  "Forty persons were confirmed, a number of them being of mature years."

Just weeks earlier, Reverend Steen had begun seeking a larger building for his congregation.  On February 8, 1895, The Churchman explained, "This church has for many years been greatly inconvenienced by the limited accommodations of its present building.  The completion of the twenty-fifth year of the present pastorate is deemed a most opportune time for the purchase of a new site where better conditions of growth may reasonably be expected."

A "Guarantee Fund" was established to finance the project.  The Churchman announced, "A fair for the benefit of the Guarantee Fund of the Ascension Memorial church, West Forty-third street, will be held in the Healey Building, Broadway and Forty-second street, during the days from Feb. 20 to Feb. 23 of this week."

Rev. Steen moved quickly.  In its April 1895 issue, The Arrow reported, "He has purchased the Methodist Meeting house on West 43d Street, and will convert it into a church."  In fact, the congregation did not yet have the money to purchase the building at 245-249 West 43rd Street between Seventh and Eighth Avenue.  It would rent it for three years before buying the property in February 1898. 

The vintage, free-standing brick building was a block to the east of the former chapel.  Its classic Greek Revival design included full-height pilasters and a triangular pediment.  

The congregation renovate the interiors.  On December 9, 1900 Bishop Potter was back for the annual memorial service.  In his remarks to the congregation, he mentioned the renovations:

I wish also to congratulate you upon the success achieved in the recent improvements of this building...I don't know whether you know it, but this building has some of the older virtues--including an old-fashioned gallery.  I am glad you did not take out the gallery.  Too many of our new churches have no gallery, and are so lengthened out that worship is an act of faith in a sense not originally intended.  You have also done well not to have the building smeared all over with the hideous polychrome that is so common nowadays, and for using instead a simply unity of tint.  You have now one of the most dignified church edifices in New York.

Later that year the church received a generous gift.  Prominent merchant and art collection George A. Hearn presented Ascension Memorial five old master paintings in memory of his daughter, Grace Arnold Hearn Wheeler.  On December 23, The New York Times noted, "This gift makes Ascension Memorial Church one of the richest in the city in precious works of art."

The article said art connoisseurs would pick out Hans Memling's Madonna and Child as "the most interesting and valuable of them," adding, "Work by Memlinc [sic] is so rare as to be seen in few even of the national collections outside of Belgium."  The painting had been valued at $50,000 (about $1.6 million today).

The other Renaissance period paintings were Jan Gossaert's Descent from the Cross (the artist lived from 1470 to 1532); Christ Mourning Over Jerusalem, by Benvenuto Tisio, a painter known as Garofalo; Frederigo Barocci's Flight into Egypt; and Bronzino's Madonna and Child.

The neighborhood around the Ascension Memorial Church was transforming into the center of Manhattan's theater district by now.  The church earned the nickname the Little Brick Church in Times Square and gradually the occupants of the pews included more and more musicians, actors and chorus girls.

In reporting on Rev. Steen's 40th anniversary on February 19, 1910, The Living Church recalled, "There were shade trees lining the curbs of what has now come to be the theatre district, and many fine old buildings with old-fashioned columns were still standing in the new parish."  Reverend Steen personally commented on the change in 1911, saying "I have now, as regular churchgoers, many chorus girls.  Some of them have been regular attendants for many years.  I like the theatrical people very much."

His affection for the "theater people" resulted in his offering church spaces for meetings.  A report on the annual meeting of the White Rats Actors' Union and Associated Actresses in The New York Clipper on July 4, 1917 noted, "More than one hundred members of the organization attended the gathering, which was held in the Sunday School room of the Ascension Memorial Church at 251 West Forty-third Street, as the White Rats have had no quarters since the loss of their club house last April."

Amazingly, John F. Steen celebrated his 50th year in the pulpit at Ascension Memorial church in February 1920.  The Sun noted, "Dr. Steen has solemnized 2,221 weddings, and has baptized more than 5,000 children."  Later The New York Times would remark that when he took the position, "Farmers drove in to church from the outlying acres to the north," and noted, "Dr. Steen was so young that one or two of his parishioners objected to his baptizing their babies, on the ground that he was only a boy."

Rev. John Floyd Steen would live to the age of 93, dying on March 29, 1938.  He had seen the Little Brick Church in Times Square demolished eight years earlier.  The New York Times expanded its Annex building onto the site, the construction of which was completed on January 7, 1932.

no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Saturday, July 9, 2022

The Benno Neuberger House - 55 East 74th Street

 


In 1898 the prolific real estate developer Jeremiah C. Lyons began construction on a row of eight five-story dwellings on East 74th Street between Park and Madison Avenues.  His architects, Buchman & Deisler, design them in two balanced groupings of four--A-B-B-A and C-B-B-C.  Among the C models was 55 East 74th, a dignified neo-Renaissance style residence faced in limestone.

Above a short stoop, the entrance sat within a handsome portico upheld by Scamozzi columns.  The pierced balcony railing at the second floor flowed into the continuous balustrade along the row.  An arched, cartouche-filled pediment sat above the center door at this level.  The bowed facade ended at the third floor, providing a stone railed balcony to the fourth.

Construction would be completed in spring of 1899, but Benno Neuberger did not wait that long.  On February 9, 1899 The Sun reported that he had purchased 55 East 74th Street "in course of construction."



Neuberger was born in Bremen, Germany in 1866 and came to New York in 1881.  He was the senior member of the tobacco firm of E. Rosenwald & Brother.  Highly involved with Jewish charities, he was the president of the Hebrew Orphan Asylum, as well.  He and his wife, the former Stella Mayer, had two children, Florence Edna and Harry Hobson.  Moving in with the family was Stella's widowed mother, Fredricka Mayer.

Like their neighbors, the Neubergers filled the house with costly furnishings and decorations.  An inventory listed "an Aubusson tapestry suite of five pieces," an Aubusson tapestry fire screen, and Eduardo Leon Garrido's modern painting The Masque Ball, appraised at $8,000 by today's conversion.  Neuberger's German roots may have prompted him to buy a Benz automobile rather than an American-made vehicle.  It cost him $2,000, the equivalent of $53,400 in today's money.


from Empire State Notables, 1914 (copyright expired)

On January 4, 1911 Fredericka Mayer died at the age of 70.  Her funeral was held in the drawing room the following day.  That summer the family sailed for Germany, where Florence first met Ehrich Hecht, a well-to-do young agent for a Berlin exporting firm.  A romance was sparked.

The family was back in Germany in 1914.  Benno Neuberger was ill and sought "the cure" in Konigstein.  Not surprisingly, it seems that Ehrich Hecht was a regular caller on Florence.  But the trip ended tragically, with Neuberger dying of pneumonia there on July 6, 1914 at the age of 48.  He left an estate valued at $1,357,982--or about $36.3 million today.

The funeral and burial was held in Germany.  The family narrowly escaped being trapped abroad when, less than two weeks later on July 28, World War I erupted.  

Once back home, Harry joined the Tenth Field Artillery to fight against the country his father had so dearly loved.  He was sent to the French front in 1918 where he would receive what the New York Herald called, "his baptism of fire at Chateau-Thierry."  Harry performed valiantly during the harrowing battle.  The New York Herald reported, "He continued to assist in the evacuation of the wounded even after being gassed," and noted grimly, "Of his regiment only three more men are left.  All the others were either killed, wounded or detached."

New York Herald, February 25, 1919 (copyright expired)

On February 24, 1919 Harry was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross for heroism overseas.

Just months after peace was declared, Florence resumed her romance with Ehrich.  Anti-German sentiments still ran high in America, a fact that, perhaps, resulted in their marriage being quietly held in the East 74th Street house on October 25, 1919.  The New York Times commented that the groom was "said to be the first German subject to arrive here since the war."  The article noted, "Mr. Hecht was employed in the German War Office during the hostilities, but it was said that he intends becoming an American citizen if permitted to do so."

In April 1920, Harry Neuberger sold the house to the Stevenson C. Scott family.  Born in Edinburgh, Scotland in 1864, Scott was the son of a portrait painter.  He came to the United States in 1893, and was now a respected art critic and the president of Scott & Fowles, art dealers.  He was an authority on 18th century English painting and, according to The Saratogian, "possessed a comprehensive knowledge of modern and classical art."

He and his wife, the former Marie Power, had one daughter, Marie.   The family was followed by the society columns as they sailed to Europe, or summered in Saratoga Springs, New York.  Understandably, the home of the man who sold paintings to wealthy collectors and institutions like the Metropolitan Museum of Art filled his home with valuable artwork.  In 1939 he traveled to London where he created "a mild sensation" in art circles, according to The Saratogian, "when he paid $30,000 at Christies for Whistler's famous painting, At the Piano."  It was the highest price ever paid for a Whistler at the time.

Scott paid the equivalent of $560,000 in today's money for At the Piano.  from the collection of The Taft Museum, Cincinnati.

In January 1945, Stevenson Scott injured his hip when he suffered a fall in the East 74th Street house.  The family went to the fashionable Gideon Putnam resort in Saratoga Springs for his convalescence.   He died there nine months later, on October 8 at the age of 81.

The East 74th Street house was soon purchased by Dr. Otto  Burchard and his wife Berta.  The couple remained here until selling it in December 1951.  The New York Times noted that the buyer intended to remodel it into "apartments of four rooms each."  That plan was never carried through.

At the time, former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt was living at 211 East 62nd Street.  She had met Dr. David Gurewitsch in 1944 and the two became extremely close, platonic friends, often traveling together.  When Gurewitsch married Edna Perkel in 1958, the deep friendship increased by one.  According to Shannon Butler in her Roosevelt Homes of the Hudson Valley: Hyde Park and Beyond, Eleanor "soon treated Edna as an additional companion, and they traveled all over the world and formed a tight bond of friendship."

Dr. David Gurewitsch and Eleanor Roosevelt outside the Kremlin.  from the Everett Collection

Butler explains, "It was Edna who mentioned the possibility of the three sharing a townhouse together that would give Eleanor more room to work and David space to see patients."  In 1959 the three purchased 55 East 74th Street, with Eleanor taking the lower three floors and the Gurewitsches living on the top two.  While they lived separately, the Gurewitsches would often dine with Eleanor.

Living with a diplomat had its challenges.   According to The Wall Street Journal writer Katherine Clarke, "One day in 1960, Edna Gurewitsch got a call from former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt suggesting she get to their shared townhome early: Soviet statesman Nikita Khruschev, in town to address the U.N. General Assembly, was swinging by."

Less than three years after moving in, Eleanor Roosevelt went to Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center on September 26, 1962 for what the public was told was "a routine checkup."  But, the Utica Press later noted, "Actually she had suffered a lung infection and anemia.  When her illness failed to yield [to] hospital treatment, she was discharged to her Manhattan apartment at 55 East 74th Street on October 18."

The modestly furnished room in which Eleanor Roosevelt died.  from the collection of the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library and Museum

The First Lady "gradually faded," according to the article, until she died at 6:15 on the evening of November 6, 1962.

In 1964 an auction of Eleanor Roosevelt's personal items was held at Hammer Galleries.  The New York Times reported, "The collection comes from Mrs. Roosevelt's residences at 55 East 74th Street and the Val-Kill Cottage on the Roosevelt estate at Hyde Park, N.Y."  While many of the items were valuable antiques, like the 1750 George III melon-shaped silver pitcher, and the American Sheraton-style mahogany breakfront, a surprising number of the First Lady's furnishings were modest.  The New York Times diplomatically said, "In every case, though the furniture in the collection may have what is known as age, the articles are not period pieces."

David Gurewitsch died in 1974 and by 1976 Edna was operating the Gurewitsch Gallery from the house.  In April that year she staged an exhibition of sculptures by George Rickey here. 

She remained at 55 East 74th Street until 1999, when she sold it to Credit Suisse executive Vikram Gandhi and his wife, Meera, the founder of the Giving Back Foundation.   The nonprofit raises funds for education and to fight global poverty.  Through her works, Meera Gandhi, like Eleanor Roosevelt, would host prominent guests like Hillary Clinton in the house.  In 2000, the Gandhis made major renovations to the interior, eliminating Buchman & Deisler's 1899 architectural elements.


In the fall of 2021, with her children grown, Meera Gandhi sold 55 East 74th Street for $13.5 million.  In reporting the sale,
The New York Times noted, "It has around 8,500 square feet of interior space and features terraces on the roof and fifth floor and a rear garden.  There are also six bedrooms, five full bathrooms and two half baths."

photograph by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Friday, July 8, 2022

The Abrahams Magazine Service Bldg - 56 East 13th Street

 


In the spring of 1898, the end was near for the 25-foot-wide Italianate brownstone at 56 East 13th Street.  Once home to Civil War veteran Jeremiah T. Hallett, it would soon become a victim of progress.  On April 9 the Real Estate Record & Guide reported that architect Otto C. Von Schoen was "preparing plans for an 8-story fireproof store and loft building" on the site for Frederick A. Boeckeler.  The article placed the cost of construction at $130,000, or just under $4.2 million in today's money.

Von Schoen's four-part, Beaux Arts design was meant to dazzle.  Two polished granite pilasters with carved stone Ionic capitals flanked the storefront.  The two-story second section was dominated by a full-width balcony supported by robust brackets.  Atop its balustraded railing sat seated lions holding shields.  Von Schoen gave the four-story third section interest by creating a grid-like pattern, relieved only by the splayed lintels and keystones of the seventh floor openings.  The eighth floor sat atop a prominent intermediate cornice.  Intricate brackets with wreaths and swags upheld the now-lost cornice.



The building filled with apparel manufacturers, like A. Famberg & Co., makers of cloaks.  A fire in its space on May 19, 1901 caused the loss of the equivalent of $31,400 in today's money.  The "fireproof" quality of the construction touted in Von Schoen's plans was proved, however, and the blaze did not spread beyond the Famberg & Co. premises.

All the other tenants of the building that year were cloak and suit makers except R. Goldstein & Co., which manufactured waists--a tailored blouse that was the most popular piece of women's attire in the nation.  The employees of each firm worked a grueling 53 hours per week in uncomfortable conditions.  The largest firm was Hyman & Brown, which employed 4 men, 50 women and one girl under 16.

A succession of garment manufacturers would operate from 56 East 13th Street, including Sol Ehrlich, known in the industry as the Persian Lamb King.  His firm was here by 1909.

The ground floor store was home to Hein Photo Supply Co. in 1915, perhaps the first hint that the garment district was moving northward.  Nevertheless, apparel firms continued to occupy 56 East 13th Street through the Depression years.  One of the last, the American Specialty Leather Company, signed a lease in January 1930.

Change came in 1954 when the Abrahams Magazine Service and the A. M. S. Reprint Company (or AMS Press, Inc.) took over the building.  The printing portion of the vast business republished out-of-print books.  On October 25, 1964, for instance, The New York Times reported that the Columbia University Press had sold the reprint rights "to what is regarded as its second most important series, the English Institute Annuals and Essays."  The article noted that AMS Press, Inc. would be publishing the 13 hardcover volumes the following year.

The Abrahams Magazine Service archived hundreds of thousands of periodicals, some dating back to the 19th century.  In the days before digitization and even microfilm, its massive library of magazines and other publications was priceless.

But the days of microfilm and digitation did come, and the usefulness of the paper periodicals faded.  When owner Gabriel Hornstein was faced with a significant rent increase in 2000, he opted to move the business to Brooklyn.  And in preparation for the move, massive numbers of vintage periodicals were carted away for disposal.


On March 25, 2001, Sherri Day wrote in The New York Times, "By the time the gigantic spring cleaning ends in about two weeks, more than 300,000 publications, many dating to the 1800's, will have been discarded...Each night, the workers push out old United States Postal Service carts filled with popular magazines like Fortune and Vogue, scientific and medical journals, and periodicals on subjects ranging from Slavic literature to psychedelic drugs."

Hornstein stressed that "nothing rare is being thrown out," and noted, "What I'm really agonizing over are things like Scribner's Harper's; they are wonderful American publications."

The curbside carts awaiting pickup drew nighttime treasure hunters, like used book store operators.  Day wrote, "Some bring vans and luggage racks to cart away their loot."  She tried to interview Isaac Kosman, who answered, "I can't talk because I'm so busy digging.  I've got to concentrate on the task at hand."  He did pause long enough to tell her that "his most treasured find was a well-kept Vogue magazine.  He kept the year of publication to himself.  And, he said, he'll be back."


With its tenant of half a century gone, the building was renovated to luxury housing--one sprawling condominium per floor.  The young women who toiled over sewing machines in the lofts could not envision the lifestyles being enjoyed there now.  Sadly, the terminal cornice was lost at some point and a glaringly white coat of paint obscures Von Schoen's 1898 details.  But overall the building survives wonderfully intact.

photograph by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Thursday, July 7, 2022

The 1889 Church of the Ascension Parish House - 12 West 11th Street

 

photo by the author

In 1843, two years after construction of the Janes Renwick-designed Church of the Ascension was completed at Fifth Avenue and West 10th Street, trustees turned their attention to a school building.  A plot was acquired half a block away, at 12 West 11th Street, where refined homes of New York's upper class were being built.  Completed in 1844, the four-story school building included a chapel and an office for the assistant minister.  Over the next decades the school would count among its students some of the most recognizable surnames in Manhattan society--like Rhinelander, Astor and De Peyster.

The interior of the church was substantially redesigned in 1885 by Stanford White (including a pulpit designed by another McKim, Mead & White partner, Charles F. McKim).   Three years later, on June 16, 1888, the Real Estate Record & Guide reported that McKim, Mead & White had filed plans to convert the school building into a "four-story brick and stone parish house."  The American Architect & Building News placed the cost at $27,000--about $758,000 today.

Completed in 1889, the Parish House was faced in yellow Roman brick and trimmed in limestone.  A three-story bay to the side of the entrance encased a staircase, its upward progression inside reflected in the stepped loophole windows on the outside.  McKim, Mead & White carried on the Northern Renaissance and ecclesiastical motif with intricate leaded windows throughout, including the transoms of the charming dormers of the slate-shingled roof.

The Parish House bustled with activity.  The Church Choral Society met and rehearsed here, The Churchman reporting on March 8, 1890 that J. Pierpont Morgan had been elected its president a week earlier.  At the same time The Association for the Relief of the Industrious Poor operated from the building.   The 1890 New York Charities Directory said it "furnishes sewing to poor women, and sells the garments made, at the Parish House.  And that year the registry office for the Girls' Friendly Society for America, organized in 1875, was here.  Its goal was to help "and to encourage purity of life, duty to parents, faithfulness to employers, and thrift."

In fact, on February 17, 1901, The New York Press said the Parish House "is the home of many interesting activities.  Here 135 volunteer workers have given their services in connection with the Parish House alone, where twenty different organizations have been accustomed to use its rooms."  The article mentioned, "The parish sewing room, the press room, where the Boys' Department turns out beautiful work, the Junior Brotherhood of St. Andrew, the Mother's meeting and many other items of work have their headquarters here."

At the turn of the last century, the rector of the Church of the Ascension was Reverend Percy Stickney Grant.  He accompanied Bishop Henry C. Potter on an extended trip abroad in 1899, and on April 19, 1900 The Hempstead Sentinel reported that they were welcomed home "from their trip around the world" with a lavish reception in the Parish House.   It was, no doubt, a bit awkward for at least three people in the room.

The newspaper said, "Mr. and Mrs. Perry Belmont are members of the church and Mr. Belmont was on the reception committee."  The wealthy couple had shocked high society in 1897 when it became known that Jessie Robbins Sloane, who was at the time the wife of Henry T. Sloane, was having an extra-marital affair with Belmont.  Six hours after the Sloanes divorced on April 28, 1899, Jessie and Perry were married in Connecticut.  Now, in reporting on the reception, The New York Sun wrote, "It will be remembered that at the time of the marriage of Mr. Belmont, whose wife was Mrs. Henry T. Sloane, Bishop Potter preached a sermon against the marriage of divorced persons."

In the spring of 1919 a modern art exhibition of "paintings by distinguished contemporary artists including John [Singer] Sargent," as described by the New-York Tribune, was held in the Parish House.  It was followed by a summer exhibition of  "work by the younger generation of painters."  The New-York Tribune said, "There is an even sprinkling of portraits, landscapes, marines and still life.

Rev. Percy S. Grant was progressive in his political and social views.  In fact, years later in reporting his death in February 1927, The New York Times would call him "a militant liberal in the Protestant Episcopal Church."  His socialistic viewpoints would sometimes clash with those of the wardens and vestrymen, as well as the Bishop, himself.

Grant's opinions came out in his sermons and in the discussion groups held in the Parish House assembly room.   On January 7, 1911, for instance, The New York Press reported that the topics of his sermons the following day would be "The Needs of the Coal Miner" and "Wanted, Social Shock-Absorbers."  The article noted, "The service will be followed by the People's Forum in the parish house," during which Benjamin C. Maran would speak on "The Real Rulers of New York."  (The Day Book explained that the People's Forum "is designed to be to the working class movement in all its branches what the Sunday school is to organized religion.")

The People's Forum continued to meet in the Parish House for years, a situation that boiled over in January 1920.  Bishop Charles Sumner Burch requested a report from the vestrymen of the Church of the Ascension regarding Grant's activities.  He had recently decried deportation from the pulpit, and on Christmas Day 1919 the People's Forum met in the Parish House before marching up Fifth Avenue in what was called The Amnesty Parade for political prisoners.

On January 23, 1920, Rev. Grant received a stern letter from Bishop Burch.   In it, reported the New York Herald, "he solemnly protest[ed] against the use of the consecrated building as a meeting place for a forum to which speakers who not infrequently are men 'who do not believe in God, who professedly are opposed to the government,' are invited."

Rev. Grant was equally stern in his response.  "What position would a church be put in that refused the request of highly intelligent young women and young men to come together on Christmas morning in one of its halls, in order that they might sing the gospel of Christmas Day--'Peace on earth, good will toward men'--not only to the ear, in the tunes of the actual Christmas carols, which they did, but to the eye, in specific appeal on behalf of given cases demanding pace and good will at present before the public."

Even after Rev. Grant's death in 1927, social awareness and concern continued to play out in the Parish House.  On June 27, 1942, The New York Age reported, "The first of a series of discussion meetings entitled 'Social Facts for Church People' will be held at the Parish Hall of the Church of the Ascension...under the sponsorship of the Provincial Committee of the Church League for Industrial Democracy."

The tradition of art exhibitions within the Parish House that had started in 1919 was continued in April 1956 with what The New York Times called an "exhibition of traditional and present-day religious art."  The critic was tepid in his review, saying "For example, an abstract painting here by Minna Citron, a perfectly good example of its kind, is given a semi-religious title when any other kind of title would have done as well.  It will stimulate neither those who come to scoff nor those who remain to pray."

Since it opened in 1889, the Parish House was a venue of lectures and a century later tradition continued.  On April 2, 1975, for instance, famed architectural preservationist, historian and author Margot Gayle lectured here on "Cast-Iron Architecture In and Around the Village."

photo by Beyond My Ken

After more than 130 years, the exterior of McKim, Mead & White's handsome Parish House is essentially unchanged.  It continues to serve the varied activities of the Church of the Ascension.

no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com