Showing posts with label west 43rd street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label west 43rd street. Show all posts

Friday, May 22, 2026

The 1891 Hotel Renaissance (Columbia Club) - 4 West 43rd Street

 

photo by Anthony Bellov

Even as he and Bruce Price were designing part of David H. King Jr.'s ambitious "King's Model Houses" in Harlem, Clarence S. Luce was working on another project for the developer--an upscale residential hotel in Midtown.  As the Renaissance Hotel neared completion on August 16, 1891, The New York Times called it, "an ornament to the city" and described it as, "magnificent."

The article began saying, "One of the handsomest and most interesting buildings in the city is the new Hotel Renaissance, in West Forty-third Street, near Fifth Avenue."  The journalist described the style as "a type of the Renaissance with pronounced American interpretations."  Anticipating skyscraper technology, Luce employed an iron skeleton "and hollow terra-cotta brick, strong and light."  The article said the foundations were "like the grave of a tavern keeper's wife, 'both wide and deep.'"  

Luce faced the two-story rusticated base with marble, "calculated to reflect the general renaissance style."  It was dominated by the Caen marble entrance, designed as a double-height porch with paired columns.  

photo by Anthony Bellov

The four-story midsection was faced in tan brick and trimmed in limestone.  The windows of the fifth floor imitated Renaissance balconies, with stone balustrades and engaged columns that upheld arched, shell-filled pediments.  Extravagantly decorated terra cotta panels separated the top floor openings, and a stone balustrade sat upon the overhanging cornice.

Guests entered into a "round arched vestibule" wainscoted in "marble in beautiful tints," as described by The New York Times, and the walls were frescoed.  On either side were the reception room and a cafe, "both of them large and handsomely-decorated saloons [i.e., rooms]."  The vestibule led to the "main hall" and the courtyard, around which the principal ground floor rooms were arranged.  The courtyard featured a fountain surrounded with "growing flowers and tropical plants."  The result, said the writer, was "an effect similar to the interiors of the most celebrated structures of this class in Florence, Paris, and Madrid."  Interior balconies at the second floor were available to all residents from which to enjoy the courtyard's afternoon and evening music.

Residential hotels differed from apartment buildings in that the suites did not have kitchens.  Guests, who signed months- or years-long leases, ate in a large communal dining room, similar to an elegant restaurant.  All the amenities of a transient hotel (like maid service, for instances) were provided by the management.

Also on the ground floor were four private dining rooms, two each on either side of the courtyard.  "From the Florentine galleries that separate the private dining rooms from the court yard, the main dining room in the back of the building is reached," said the article.  The reporter deemed it, "one of the handsomest dining halls in the country."  Engulfing the entire 125-foot width of the building, it was visually broken up by "mural arches" that gave the impression of three rooms "thrown into one."  The Times said, "The ornamentation of this room is in the highest form of the frescoer's art."  (The article mentioned that King had hired "one of the best chefs of Paris.")

The walls of the first floor rooms were decorated with hand-decorated Louis XV-style panels.  The private dining room walls, however, were covered in silk and the furnishings were "in the style of the empire."  The motif was carried into the two oval elevators, which were "finished in gold and Vernis Martin, with painted panels and Louis XV decorations."

The New York Times, October 6, 1891 (copyright expired)

Each of the apartments looked onto the courtyard.  The New York Times explained, "Each suite is entered from the hall through a private vestibule, thus insuring perfect privacy for all."

The Hotel Renaissance opened on October 1, 1891.  It was patronized by some of Manhattan's wealthiest citizens, either as their permanent city residence or during the winter season.  Among them were James and Sarah Roosevelt and their son, Franklin.  In her Franklin and Eleanor, An Extraordinary Marriage, Hazel Rowley writes:

Franklin and his parents (accompanied by servants and tutors) spent time in New York City, where they had an apartment at the Renaissance Hotel, on West Forty-third Street.

C. Grayson Martin purchased the Hotel Renaissance following David H. King Jr.'s death in April 1916.  He quickly swapped it with George N. and Julius Black for the X. Y. Ranch in Colorado.  On January 17, 1917, The New York Sun said the 5,000-acre X. Y. Ranch was "one of the best known ranches in the West."  The value of the Hotel Renaissance was estimated at $1 million, or about $24.5 million in 2026.

The Black brothers closed the Hotel Renaissance and leased the property to the Columbia University Club, which had been located at Gramercy Park for more than a decade.  The club hired architects Henry F. Hornbostel, Kenneth MacKenzie Murchison, and Alger C. Gildersleeve to convert the hotel to a clubhouse.  

A year and "more than $100,000" later, almost to the day, The New York Times reported on January 27, 1918 that the renovations were completed and the opening would be celebrated by a dinner on February 7.  It said the architects had "transformed it into one of the best-equipped clubs in the Forty-second Street club centre."  

The New York Herald explained that the upper floors now contained 104 rooms "for members who wish to live at the club."  There were also exercising rooms, baths, and four squash courts on the roof.  The "immense dining room," said the article, which was designed by Hornbostel, "is in simple white stone, with great light brackets in silver and a frieze that includes some paintings of scenes of the Columbia campus as it is to-day and was in the days of Hamilton."  (The frieze was executed by muralist James M. Hewlett.)  Also on the ground floor were "lunch rooms and private dining rooms," according to the New York Herald.  A large library on the second floor could also be used for meetings.

photo by Anthony Bellov

College life throughout America was disrupted by the country's entry into World War I.  On April 5, 1918, a service flag was raised above the clubhouse and on November 10 that year, the university's president, Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler and Major Herbert C. Earnshaw, Commandant of the Students' Army Training Camp, spoke here.  "The war activities of the college will be the subject," announced The New York Times.

Shortly after the end of the war another issue--Prohibition--would rock the organization.  On the "first bone-dry prohibition day," as worded by The New York Times, an announcement informed members "that afternoon tea will now be a feature of the club's gayeties."  The article then reported on a serious side effect of the law's enactment.  "Prohibition...has also made it necessary to practically double the annual dues."

Prohibition crippled the finances of hotels, clubs and restaurants.  The condition was no doubt a major factor in the club's decision to alter the ground floor to provide additional income.  On October 1, 1922, the New York Herald reported, "The Columbia University Club will install stores in the club property...All but 25 of the 125 feet of frontage of their building will be changed on the grade floor into business use."  The practical renovation unfortunately greatly decimated Luce's Italian palazzo design.

Over the years, the Columbia University Club was home to distinguished alumni.  Among them were prominent architect Henry Rutgers Marshall; poet, novelist and editor Henry Morton Robinson; and retired Brigadier General Rodney Hamilton Smith.

One of the most colorful residents was William Cullen Bryant Kemp, described on the Columbia campus as the "perpetual student."  As a young man, Kemp was attending Columbia when his uncle left him $2,500 a year "as long as he remained at school."  (The income would equal about $50,000 a year today.)  He took the wording seriously and earned his first degree, a Bachelor of Arts, in 1868.  He continued to matriculate at Columbia, earning a list of degrees that included A.M.,  M.D.,  LL.M., LL.B, Ph.D., C.E., E.E., Mechanical Engineering, Pharmaceutical Engineering, and a B.S.  Kemp was living here on February 3, 1929 when he died at the age of 79.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

In 1922, although Prohibition was still in effect, the Columbia University Club hired Irish-born Michael J. Dunne as its head bartender (presumably dispensing sodas, iced tea and such).  Although his only education was from an Irish primary school, he was a voracious reader.  The New York Times remarked that he, "could converse on a variety of topics with the many men of distinction who patronized his bar."

The members called Dunne "Serjeant," the title bestowed only on the highest class of barristers in England.  In 1960, author Henry Morton Robinson presided over a "large gathering in the club," as described by The New York Times, during which Dunne received the degree of D.D.L.," Doctor of Delectable Libations, and a scroll.

The following year, Dunn visited his birthplace, Engfield, County Meath, Ireland.  On his trip he became ill.  He made it back home before dying at the age of 71 on August 15, 1961.  He had held his position at the club for 39 years.

On February 13, 1973, the club's board of governors voted unanimously to sell the 43rd Street building.  John Reeves, the group's president, explained that the maintenance "had become too expensive for the needs of the 1,500 members."  The club moved into the Princeton Club at 15 West 43rd Street.

The former Columbia University Club building sat vacant for slightly more than two years before a buyer was found.  On May 7, 1975, The New York Times reported, "The Rev. Sun Myung Moon's Unification Church has purchased the former Columbia University Club building at 4 West 43d Street for use as its American headquarters."  The church had paid $1.2 million (about $7 million today) for the property.  A spokesperson said, "the upper floors would be used to house about 50 staff members and their families.

photo by Anthony Bellov

The Holy Spirit Association-Unification of World Christianity continues to use the building for its headquarters.  It, additionally, offers rental offices to non-profit organizations, and large spaces for events.

many thanks to historian Anthony Bellov for suggesting this post

Thursday, February 9, 2023

The 1883 Narragansett Flat - 435 West 43rd Street

 


As early as 1869, the family of Charles P. Allaire occupied the three-story brownstone at 435 West 43rd Street.  Charles was a butcher with a stand in the Clinton Market.  Interestingly, when the family sold their home to Margaret Niebuhr in 1882, they relocated to 437 West 43rd Street, just two houses away.

Margaret was the wife of Henry P. Niebuhr, a partner in the Niebuhr Brothers construction company which would erect a replacement building on the site.  The 25-foot-wide house was demolished and in June 1882 architect W. Scott West filed plans for a five-story flat to cost $16,000 (about $437,000 in 2023).  It was Margaret who held the purse strings in the couple's real estate development projects.  She later testified that the lot was "purchased out of her own funds" and the Narragansett Flat was "part of her own private estate, in which neither her husband" nor his partner had any "right, title or interest."

West's Queen Anne design was an spirited presence among its somber brownstone neighbors.  Faced in red brick and liberally trimmed in carved stone, the Narragansett was the last word in 1880s architectural taste.  



Two shops occupied the basement level on either side of the stoop.  The entrance sat below a robust hood supported by polished granite columns.  A foliate carved panel above the center windows of the second floor served as the base to a slightly projecting section crowned by lacy ironwork at the third.  Panels of terra cotta Queen Anne tiles, incised lintel carvings, and a metal cornice support by paired brackets created a visual cornucopia.

There were two apartments per floor, each with five rooms and a bath.  An advertisement for the "new and elegant Narragansett" urged, "must be seen to appreciate."  Calling the neighborhood "first-class," it boasted "modern improvements."  Those would have included indoor plumbing and, most likely, steam heat.

Victorian ironwork was often removed during the 20th century, but this exquisite example survives beautifully.

Among the initial residents was Dr. A. D. Gaillard.  It appears he came up with a guileful marketing scheme in 1886.  The New York Dispatch invited readers to send in questions, like "what is pumice stone?", which were answered in its "Notes and Queries" column.  On April 18 that year the newspaper replied to "A Five Years' Reader" saying, "We know of no better physician for the trouble from which you suffer than Dr. D. A. Gaillard, No. 435 West Forty-third street."  There was almost assuredly a monetary exchange between the doctor and the newspaper.  And "A Five Years' Reader" was most likely the doctor, himself.

The residents of the Narragansett Flat barely escaped with their lives at 5:00 on the morning of December 1, 1887.  The Hudson Register reported that a fire broke out in the tailor shop in the basement "and spread so rapidly that the eight families living in it were driven from the house before they could save any of their property."

On the third floor was the Jacobs family.  Mrs. Jacobs grabbed their three-year-0ld son and ran down the staircase with him.  The article said, "Her husband followed, leaving behind him their oldest child, Joseph, five years old, who was burned to death.  Mr. Jacobs afterward said that in his excitement he forgot the boy."  When the inferno was finally extinguished, the building had been gutted, with damages estimated at $588,000 in 2023 dollars.  

After the repairs were made, Mary Jane Smith was hired as housekeeper and given one of the first floor apartments.  She remarked in court later, "The house is fully improved, [with] all improvements."  Rents in 1887 ranged from $23 to $28 per month--about $825 for the most expensive.

A young couple named Duffy lived here in 1908.  They were married in 1900 when Lillian Duffy was 16 years old.  Now, at the age of 24, she had developed an obsessive attraction to theatrical agent Morris Gest.  According to him, Lillian "has a hardworking husband who is devoted to her."

Her husband's devotion notwithstanding, in February 1908 Morris Gest filed a complaint against her for what today would be termed stalking.  He told the magistrate that she "had followed him for three years."  And he used the term "followed" in its literal sense.

Just weeks after filing his complaint and while still on probation, Lillian trailed Gest "for hours" along Broadway.  He had had a luncheon appointment with actor and playwright George M. Cohan that day at the Knickerbocker Hotel.  As he approached the door, Lillian suddenly appeared.  He escaped by rushing into an elevator.  But, according to The New York Press on March 2, "she afterward followed him to his office building and to other places until he caused her arrest."  In court Lillian's probation officer, Miss McQuade, told the magistrate that she "thought the woman ought to be sent to Bellevue for examination as to her sanity."

Although the Narragansett Flat sat squarely within the notorious Hell's Kitchen neighborhood, its tenants appear to have been, for the most part, respectable and hard working.  Living here in 1918 was Charles D. Donohue, who ran on the Democratic ticket that year for Assemblyman.

The unpainted stone trim can be seen in this 1941 photograph.  The Allaire house, which the Narragansett Flat replaced, looked much like the houses on either side.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

On December 1, 1934 Sarah Keenan moved into an apartment.  Interestingly, her rent was $28 per month--the same amount that tenants had paid in 1887.  As part of her lease, the superintendent agreed to install a clothes line and pulley next to the rear fire escape outside her apartment.  The convenience would nearly end tragically six years later.

On the morning of October 4, 1940, Sarah was hanging laundry.  The superintendent had removed a section of fire escape railing so she could do so.  As she leaned out, clipping wet garments to the line, it broke and Sarah plummeted with it to the concrete pavement below.  Although she suffered a broken leg and abrasions, her injuries could have been significantly worse.


The building was renovated in 2015, however there are still just two apartments per floor.  It may have been at that time that the brownstone trim was painted white.  As it was in 1883, the Narragansett is a scene stealer along the block.

photographs by the author
LaptrinhX.com has no authorization to reuse the content of this blog

Friday, January 27, 2023

The 1888 Holy Cross School - 332-336 West 43rd Street

 



The parish of the Church of the Holy Cross was established in 1852.  The original church structure on West 42nd Street between Eighth and Ninth Avenues was destroyed by lightning in 1867.  It was replaced by a Romanesque Revival structure designed by Henry Engelbert which survives.  

Directly behind the church on West 43rd Street was the Chapel of the Shepherd's Flock.  In 1887 it was razed to make way for the Holy Cross School.  Architect L. J. O'Connor's plans, filed in August, called for a five-story brick school building to cost $60,000--about $1.13 million in 2023.

O'Connor saved the parish money with his sparse use of stone.  The decorations of his Romanesque Revival structure were executed mostly in terra cotta--like the pronounced eyebrows over the arched windows and foliate intermediate cornices--and in brick, as in the handsome corbel table below the cornice.  Rough cut granite made its appearance in the bandcourses above and below the second floor and the entablatures over the two entrances which labeled them "boys" and "girls."


Gender-specific entrances were obligatory in Catholic schools.  Note the elaborate Romanesque carvings on either side of the doorways.

The construction of the relatively costly building came only after substantial fund-raising.  The parish of the Church of the Holy Cross, which sat within the bleak Hell's Kitchen neighborhood, was a poor one.  Despite the crime and poverty around them (and perhaps partly due to the strict, no-nonsense methods of the nun teachers), the students' names rarely appeared in newspapers for serious misbehavior.

The assembly room of Holy Cross School often served the community as a meeting place.  Locals, many of them newly-arrived from Ireland, crowded in on September 20, 1914 to hear Member of Parliament Richard McGhee (known popularly as Dick McGhee) speak on the Home Rule Bill he had introduced.  In reporting on the speech, the New-York Tribune titled its article "Says Ireland Is Free."  It quoted him saying, "The Irish people have no quarrel now with the British democracy.  The fight is over and a thing of memory only."  (As it turned out, he was being optimistic.  And when home rule was finally legislated in 1921, it merely triggered the Irish Civil War.)

A Holy Cross School success story was William Meehan.  Born in 1886, he saw the stage as his route out of poverty.  After he graduated he went into acting, debuting at the Casino Theatre in The Runaways in 1903.  The Irish immigrant boy became a success, appearing with his wife Violet Pearl for eight years before his untimely death in 1920 at the age of 34.

At the time of Meehan's death, the Hell's Kitchen neighborhood had not improved.  Greek immigrant Louis Sidoris and his wife lived in the district that year.  He was brutally abusive to his wife, who finally left him in 1920.  The 25-year-old woman temporarily moved in with her friend Mrs. Peter Segalas, who lived directly across from the school.  The New York Herald explained the arrangement would enable her to earn enough month to "be able to go back to her folks in Greece and be independent of the husband whose brutalities, she said, had forced her to leave." 

She was peeling potatoes for lunch on March 17, 1921 when Louis Sidoris burst into the apartment.  He pleaded for her to return to him.  When she refused, he said, "There is only one thing to do then," and pulled out a revolver.  He fired all six rounds, three of them hitting his wife.  Too shocked to move, Mrs. Segalas watched him grab the knife his wife had been using.  The newspaper reported, "He rushed through the apartment to a mirror in the parlor, slashed his throat and jumped to the street, three flights below."

The children of Holy Cross School, out of class for lunchtime, witnessed the body crash to the sidewalk.  They notified a nun who sent word to Monsignor Francis P. Duffy, rector of the church, who arrived to give last rites.

O'Connor's intricate terra cotta detailing includes masks, each of them slight different, between the smaller arches of the fifth floor.

While almost all of Manhattan buildings were electrified by the Great Depression, that was not necessarily the case with Hell's Kitchen tenements.  On October 23, 1929 "several hundred pupils of Holy Cross Parochial School, let by the Rev. Francis P. Duffy," as reported by The New York Times, joined in the funeral procession for six of their classmates.  The article said, "The procession of seven hearses, one gray and six white, attracted much attention as it moved through the streets."  Walter Cavanagh, a widower, and six of his seven children had died of gas asphyxiation in their apartment at 544 West 56th Street.  The children ranged from eight to eleven years old.

The Holy Cross students, many of whom had meager Christmases and Thanksgivings in their tenement homes, were not forgotten by businessmen and socialites during the holidays.  On December 23, 1937, The New York Sun reported, "Milk replaced Manhattans and Martinis as the favored drink at the Game Cock Restaurant...yesterday afternoon.  Jack Stutz, proprietor of the Game Cock, was host at his third annual Christmas party for about 200 under-privileged children of the Holy Cross Roman Catholic School."  The children, aged five to twelve, were entertained by actor Bert Lytell and "the Yippe Boys, currently appearing in the Broadway production 'Red, Hot and Blue.'"  After a turkey dinner, the children received "candy, books, gift stockings and dolls."

A sudden announcement from the New York Roman Catholic Diocese in January 2011 enraged many of the parents of Holy Cross students.  The New York Times reported that the school was being merged with the Sacred Heart of Jesus School on West 52nd Street, and the 43rd Street building closed.  The diocese explained that the Sacred Heart building "has the larger capacity" and was in better condition.

Parents complained of being "blindsided."  A parent writing to The New York Times in response said in part, "I find the use of the word 'merger' insulting as it is not a merger at all, but a closing."  Another said with caustic sarcasm, "Will the new name for the combined schools be called, 'Cross Your Heart'?"

In 2013 the building became home to the the private De La Salle Academy.  Founded in the 19th century as a co-educational Roman Catholic school, today the 6th through 8th grade institution focuses on "academically talented, economically less advantaged children of diverse backgrounds," according to its website.


After 135 years, L. J. O'Connor's imposing educational fortress is little changed, a commanding reminder of a far different period in Hell's Kitchen.

photographs by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Monday, January 16, 2023

The Lost Rector's Restaurant - 1508-1510 Broadway

 

Massive electric letters spelled out RECTORS within the over-sized parapet.  King's Views of New York City, 1903 (copyright expired)

Charles Rector recognized a niche in 1884 Chicago, hundreds of miles away from an ocean--oysters.  Well-heeled Chicagoans who traveled to New York, Philadelphia and Boston enjoyed that staple of American cuisine.  Those cities were filled with oyster restaurants and oyster bars, and socialites' tableware included decorated oyster plates.  That year he opened Rector's Oyster House to immediate an immense success.

On February 23, 1899, the Portland [Maine] Express reported that Rector had introduced another East Coast delicacy to his Midwestern menu.  "Many of our citizens who have visited Chicago are aware of Rector's mammoth restaurant devoted almost entirely to fish...Mr. Rector asserts that he is the second man in this country to serve broiled live lobsters."  The article mentioned, "Rector has just established a branch house in New York at Broadway and 43d street."

Charles E. Rector had partnered with Carl G. Essner in the new venture.  They took over a recently constructed building on Longacre Square (renamed Times Square in 1904), an area that was rapidly transforming from a carriage making center to Manhattan's theatrical district.  Designed by William Strom, the building was commissioned by restauranteur Jack Dunstan, who for some reason backed out of the project.  Its two-story design straddled the Beaux Arts and Renaissance Revival styles.  

The rusticated brick ground floor featured fluted Scamozzi columns and an impressive metal-and-glass entrance below a large second-floor arch fronted by a massive winged griffin, the restaurant's symbol.  Patrons entered through a revolving door, reportedly the first in New York City.  The openings of the second level wore Renaissance pediments, their formality balanced by delicate carved garlands.  Large electrically-lit letters filled the spaces within the story-tall pediment upheld by paired columns and capped by stone urns.  

Rector's immediately claimed a place among the upscale eateries like Delmonico's and Sherry's.  Its arrival made such an impact on society that within months, it was so recognized that it appeared in a new play, Around New York in Eighty Minutes.  On November 7, 1899, The World reported, "The opening scene was the outside of Rector's restaurant.  Then, after a moment, the front disappeared and the gay crowds within were revealed."

A 1940 revival of the play resurrected the old set.  (original source unknown)

The Longacre Square location drew not only socialites, but figures from the theatrical and sports fields.  Among the latter was boxer James J. Jeffries, who was named heavyweight champion of the world the same year Rector's opened.  On November 22, 1899, The Buffalo Times reported, "It was 2 A. M. when Jim Jeffries and a friend dropped into Rector's restaurant on Longacre Square.  Three men and three women were at a table.  Two of the men were matching bills."  They caught Jeffries' eye because one of them was a friend.

The affluence of the Rector's restaurant patrons was evidenced in the pair's amusement.  "Matching bills" was an informal gambling game.  The article said, "The bigger man was always the loser.  First he lost a $100 bill, then a $1,000 bill, and finally $500 in five crisp bills...The loser of the $1,600 went over to Jeffries, shook hands and laughed with him."

"Who is he?" Jeffries asked.

"Why, don't you know?  That's---Oh, but never mind.  I can't recall his name."

The good sport had lost the equivalent of $54,000 in 2023 money.

Only months after their restaurant opened, Carl Essner changed his mind.  The New-York Tribune reported, "He expressed a wish to withdraw from the firm, and finally Mr. Rector purchased his stock for what he paid for it, and the two parted amicably."  He was replaced by Charles Rector's son, George, who had been trained in exclusive Parisian restaurants and awarded a medal from La Société des Cuisiniers de Paris.

Rector's Restaurant played a significant part in the Thaw-White murder trial in 1907.  On February 25, 1907, attorney James Jerome questioned Evelyn Nesbit Thaw on the stand, "When did you first meet Thaw?"  

She replied, "I think it was either in December, 1901, or January 1902."

"Where?"

"At Rector's Restaurant, at a dinner given by Mr. Thaw.  It was after a matinee, and the dinner lasted about an hour.  I was accompanied by another girl."

Stanford White's chauffeur, John Burns, testified that in February 1905 (prior to Nesbit's marriage to Thaw) he had driven the two to her home from Rector's, and again in September that year (following the wedding) he drove them from the restaurant to her hotel.

On February 21, Evelyn testified that she, Harry Thaw, and another couple had spent Christmas Eve 1903 at the restaurant.  She became indignant when attorney James Jerome asked, "Didn't you have to be helped out of Rector's at 4 o'clock in the morning because you had drunk so much wine?"

Decades before the concept of credit cards, even well-heeled patrons sometimes found themself short of funds when the bill arrived.  Such was the case in 1907 when August Bonoit, "after ordering, eating and enjoying a sumptuous Christmas dinner," as worded by the New-York Tribune, was unable to pay his $12 check (just under $400 in 2023).  The management's Christmas spirit was not sufficient to brush the matter off and Bonoit was arrested.  He was also charged with stiffing a cabman, Seward Meltzer.  The magistrate was short on holiday warmth, as well.  "I don't mind you defrauding Rector's," he said, "because I think they can stand a little loss, but I am going to punish you for defrauding this cabman."

After attending the theater on November 13, 1908, broker Cyril Hatch took his party of eight to Rector's.  They enjoyed themselves until 5:30 in the morning, when the waiter presented a check for $35.20 (just over $1,000 today).  Hatch told the waiter he "had been in the habit of charging items to his account."  The waiter, however, insisted on payment.

Hatch's fury prompted the waiter to "withdraw," and the broker attempted to leave the restaurant.  But the doors had already been locked.  When head waiter Charles Decermeaux attempted to intervene, Hatch struck him.  The following day The New York Times headlined an article "Broker Hatch Locked Up."

The restaurant building was vised between taller structures at the time of the Cyril Hatch incident.  image from the collection of the New York Public Library.

The waiter's insistence on having the bill paid in cash may have been prompted by an incident the previous month.  William M. Schwenker, Jr., described by the New-York Tribune as "the son of a millionaire dealer in brewers' supplies," was married to actress Mae Murray in September 1908, and hosted an extravagant wedding breakfast at Rector's that cost the equivalent of $18,000 today.  Seven months later, on April 10, 1909, the New-York Tribune wrote, "The restaurant man has been trying ever since to get his money."

On June 5, 1909 The Sun reported that Charles E. Rector had hired architect John Russell Pope to design a 12-story hotel at the southeast corner of Broadway and 44th Street, "replacing the present Rector restaurant."  The project spurted along, with Pope being replaced by Chicago architects D. H. Burnham & Co.  Finally, on February 1, 1910 Charles E. Rector assembled a party of ten in a private room in Rector's "to celebrate the launching of the new Rector enterprise," according to the Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide.  The article noted that the contract for demolishing the old building and erecting the new one had been signed.

D. H. Burnham & Co. released a rendering of the proposed structure in 1910.  Record & Guide, February 19, 1910 (copyright expired)

The replacement building was demolished to make way for 1500 Broadway, designed by Leo Kornblath and completed in 1972..

no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Friday, January 6, 2023

The Michael Schweyer House - 461 West 43rd Street

 



In 1843 Michael Schweyer was described by the New York Daily Express as a "German porter-house keeper at 11 Frankfort Street."  It was around that time that a row of handsome brownstone-fronted homes were built along the north side of West 43rd Street, between Ninth and Tenth Avenues.  

The houses sat on land that was originally part of John Leake Norton's extensive farm, 70 acres of which had been purchased by John Jacob Astor I and William Cutting prior to 1807 in anticipation of the city's expanding this far north.  The neighborhood that would become known as Hell's Kitchen would be blighted with shanties, taverns and crime following the Civil War, but for now it was still respectable.

Like its identical neighbors along the row, 461 West 43rd Street was 25-feet-wide and three stories tall above an English basement.  The arched entrance was originally capped by a pediment upon scrolled brackets, and the windows wore molded lintels.

In 1868 Michael Schweyer purchased 461 West 43rd Street.  The move was convenient, since he had recently established A. & E. Schweyer, a malt manufacturing business, three blocks away at 530 Tenth Avenue.  His partners in the venture were his sons, Edward and Adolph.

Also living in the 43rd Street house with Michael and his wife, Margaretha, was Adolph, the younger of the two sons.  (Edward and his wife moved to 467 West 43rd Street, just three houses away.)  The population of 461 West 43rd Street increased by one on May 16, 1871 following Adolph's wedding.  Anna M. Schweyer moved into the house with her new husband's family.  It was around this time that a stylish Second Empire style mansard was added, greatly increasing the interior square footage.

Michael and his sons were Masons, all members of the Copestone Lodge.  The affluence of the extended family was evidenced when they attended the lodge's annual ball on February 14, 1872.  The New York Evening Express noted that "prominent among the ladies" were Edward's and Adolph's wives.  "Mrs. Edward Schweyer [wore] dark brown silk, powdered hair, emeralds; Mrs. Adolph Schwyer, dark blue silk, en train, trimmed with heavy overlaps of white point lace, white illusion overskirt."

Tragically, Adolph's and Anna's lives together would be short.  On June 20, 1874, Anna died at the age of 30.  Her funeral was held in the parlor two days later.

There would be two more funerals in the Schweyer house before the decade was out.  Michael died at the age of 74 on November 29, 1876, and Adolph died "suddenly" at 43 years old on April 26, 1879.  Margaretha moved in with Edward's family soon after Adolph's funeral.

John E. Hasler briefly leased 461 West 43rd Street.  It next became home to the family of James F. Wiley.  The parlor was again the scene of a funeral after the Wiley's four-year-old son, Leroy Filkins, died here on May 31, 1883.

Although much of the detailing has been lost, the original Italianate entrance doors survive.

William B. Lundie, the superintendent of the 42nd Street Station of the Consolidated Gas Company of New York, next occupied the house.  A Civil War veteran, he had been discharged after being wounded in action on March 1, 1863, but the determined 21-year-old soldier re-enlisted on February 14, 1864, serving in Co. B., 1st Battalion.  Wounded again, he was discharged from the U. S. Army General Hospital in Newark on July 20, 1865.  He died in the West 43rd Street house at the age of 47 on Christmas Day, 1890.

The house became home to Jacob Loewer and his family.  He and his brother, George, were members with their father, Valentin Löwer, in the Valentin Loewer Brewing Co., which he founded in 1869.  As had been the case with Michael Schweyer, Loewer most likely chose 461 West 43rd Street because it was convenient to the brewery on West 41st Street.

The brewery was nearly lost on the night of October 18, 1893.  A massive blaze broke out in the wall paper factory of William S. Campbell on the same block.  The New York Herald wrote, "The fiercest fire this city has seen in many years swept away one-third of the block bounded by Tenth avenue, Forty-first and Forty-second streets last evening."  

Next to Campbell's factory was a brick tenement he also owned.  In the basement was a saloon owned by Jacob Loewer's uncle, Jacob Johannes.  He lived in one of the apartments with his wife and seven children.  Behind the factory was a building occupied by William Schwager, the foreman in Loewer's brewery, his wife and nine children.

The New York Herald said, "From Nos. 530 to 540 West Forty-first street is the Valentin Loewer brewery, a handsome and costly structure of brick and granite, while on the opposite side are the brewery stables."  There were 60 horses housed in that building.  "Mr. Loewer arrived with a score of employés.  In a trice all the horses were taken out and were shortly scattered for the night in various stables in Eleventh Avenue."

The brewery, remarkably, escaped the conflagration.  Jacob Johannes and William Schwager were not so lucky.  In the basement of Johannes's saloon were barrels of whiskey, which exploded one-by-one, adding to the inferno that consumed the building.  The New York Herald reported that the structure in which the Schwagers lived was totally destroyed.  "Young Mr. Jacob Loewer took the Schwager family to his home, No. 461 West Forty-third street."

In 1896 Dr. William Angus White leased the house.  Born in Canada in 1873, he had graduated from the University of the City of New York Medical Department in 1896.  The bachelor doctor established his practice in the house.  

image from Universities and Their Sons, 1903 (copyright expired)

On December 27, 1900, White married Mary Mosetta Jones.  The couple soon welcomed a daughter, Mary Mildred.  (Mary would graduate from Barnard College  in 1924 and go on to teach English and biology.)  Although the Hell's Kitchen neighborhood was, for the most part, one of tenements and poverty by now, the Whites were financially comfortable.  In 1914 the doctor owned an Overland automobile.

White would live and practice from the residence for decades.  After having leased it for three decades, he purchased the house in May 1924.

His office was the scene of a tragic occurrence on December 21, the following year.  The New York Evening Post reported that while 65-year-old Peter McFarlin was sitting in the waiting room, he "collapsed and died from heart disease."

Dr. William A. White died of a cerebral hemorrhage at the age of 76 on July 10, 1933.  In 1935, 461 West 43rd Street became the home and office of Dr. Graham L. Bennett.  It was most likely Bennett who modernized the facade by stripping off most of the Victorian detailing.


image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Dr. Bennett had received his medical degree from Cornell University and, like White, would live and practice from the house for years.  He was still listed at the address as late as 1953.

Astonishingly, the house remained a single-family home until a renovation completed in 1978 resulted in a duplex apartment in the basement and parlor floors (with a doctor's office in the lower portion), one apartment each on the second and third floors, and two on the fourth.


photographs by the author
no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com

Monday, July 11, 2022

The Lost Ascension Memorial Church - 245-249 West 43rd Street

 

from the collection of the New-York Historical Society

The congregation of the Church of the Ascension, on Fifth Avenue and 10th Street, was fashionable and affluent.  But their privileged status did not blind them to the needs of the less fortunate.  In a sermon delivered on December 23, 1934, Rev. Donald B. Aldrich recalled:

From 1859 on, a flood of immigration swelled New York City with four hundred thousand additional people.  These newcomers lived in shacks and tenements unspeakable in squalor and poverty.  It was for them that the congregation purchased and cleared a block at 43rd Street and Ninth Avenue, and erected model tenements there, at a cost of $43,000.  As a center of center of worship, recreation and help for these people, the Ascension Memorial Chapel, costing $10,000, was built among them and administered by the congregation of this church.

Aldrich had one detail slightly wrong.  The mission was originally called the Chapel of the Shepherd's Flock.  The original rector was Daniel Thom, replaced in 1870 by Reverend John Floyd Steen, who would remain with the impoverished members for decades.  The were fifty members in the congregation at the time.

In 1894 the mission chapel became an independent church, now named the Ascension Memorial Church.  The congregation celebrated Steen's 25th anniversary on March 3 the following.  The Sun reported that Bishop Henry C. Potter had overseen the "special services."  Steen's outreach to the immigrants who had had little exposure to religion was reflected in the last line of the article.  "Forty persons were confirmed, a number of them being of mature years."

Just weeks earlier, Reverend Steen had begun seeking a larger building for his congregation.  On February 8, 1895, The Churchman explained, "This church has for many years been greatly inconvenienced by the limited accommodations of its present building.  The completion of the twenty-fifth year of the present pastorate is deemed a most opportune time for the purchase of a new site where better conditions of growth may reasonably be expected."

A "Guarantee Fund" was established to finance the project.  The Churchman announced, "A fair for the benefit of the Guarantee Fund of the Ascension Memorial church, West Forty-third street, will be held in the Healey Building, Broadway and Forty-second street, during the days from Feb. 20 to Feb. 23 of this week."

Rev. Steen moved quickly.  In its April 1895 issue, The Arrow reported, "He has purchased the Methodist Meeting house on West 43d Street, and will convert it into a church."  In fact, the congregation did not yet have the money to purchase the building at 245-249 West 43rd Street between Seventh and Eighth Avenue.  It would rent it for three years before buying the property in February 1898. 

The vintage, free-standing brick building was a block to the east of the former chapel.  Its classic Greek Revival design included full-height pilasters and a triangular pediment.  

The congregation renovate the interiors.  On December 9, 1900 Bishop Potter was back for the annual memorial service.  In his remarks to the congregation, he mentioned the renovations:

I wish also to congratulate you upon the success achieved in the recent improvements of this building...I don't know whether you know it, but this building has some of the older virtues--including an old-fashioned gallery.  I am glad you did not take out the gallery.  Too many of our new churches have no gallery, and are so lengthened out that worship is an act of faith in a sense not originally intended.  You have also done well not to have the building smeared all over with the hideous polychrome that is so common nowadays, and for using instead a simply unity of tint.  You have now one of the most dignified church edifices in New York.

Later that year the church received a generous gift.  Prominent merchant and art collection George A. Hearn presented Ascension Memorial five old master paintings in memory of his daughter, Grace Arnold Hearn Wheeler.  On December 23, The New York Times noted, "This gift makes Ascension Memorial Church one of the richest in the city in precious works of art."

The article said art connoisseurs would pick out Hans Memling's Madonna and Child as "the most interesting and valuable of them," adding, "Work by Memlinc [sic] is so rare as to be seen in few even of the national collections outside of Belgium."  The painting had been valued at $50,000 (about $1.6 million today).

The other Renaissance period paintings were Jan Gossaert's Descent from the Cross (the artist lived from 1470 to 1532); Christ Mourning Over Jerusalem, by Benvenuto Tisio, a painter known as Garofalo; Frederigo Barocci's Flight into Egypt; and Bronzino's Madonna and Child.

The neighborhood around the Ascension Memorial Church was transforming into the center of Manhattan's theater district by now.  The church earned the nickname the Little Brick Church in Times Square and gradually the occupants of the pews included more and more musicians, actors and chorus girls.

In reporting on Rev. Steen's 40th anniversary on February 19, 1910, The Living Church recalled, "There were shade trees lining the curbs of what has now come to be the theatre district, and many fine old buildings with old-fashioned columns were still standing in the new parish."  Reverend Steen personally commented on the change in 1911, saying "I have now, as regular churchgoers, many chorus girls.  Some of them have been regular attendants for many years.  I like the theatrical people very much."

His affection for the "theater people" resulted in his offering church spaces for meetings.  A report on the annual meeting of the White Rats Actors' Union and Associated Actresses in The New York Clipper on July 4, 1917 noted, "More than one hundred members of the organization attended the gathering, which was held in the Sunday School room of the Ascension Memorial Church at 251 West Forty-third Street, as the White Rats have had no quarters since the loss of their club house last April."

Amazingly, John F. Steen celebrated his 50th year in the pulpit at Ascension Memorial church in February 1920.  The Sun noted, "Dr. Steen has solemnized 2,221 weddings, and has baptized more than 5,000 children."  Later The New York Times would remark that when he took the position, "Farmers drove in to church from the outlying acres to the north," and noted, "Dr. Steen was so young that one or two of his parishioners objected to his baptizing their babies, on the ground that he was only a boy."

Rev. John Floyd Steen would live to the age of 93, dying on March 29, 1938.  He had seen the Little Brick Church in Times Square demolished eight years earlier.  The New York Times expanded its Annex building onto the site, the construction of which was completed on January 7, 1932.

no permission to reuse the content of this blog has been granted to LaptrinhX.com