Showing posts sorted by date for query Master Apartment. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Master Apartment. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Emery Roth's 1930 300 West 23rd Street

 

In 1750, Captain Thomas Clarke and his wife Mary purchased 94 acres of land north of the city as the site of their country estate, Chelsea.  The property passed to the Clarkes' grandson, Clement Clarke Moore, who began selling and renting building plots around 1818.  In 1845, he rented the southwest corner of Eighth Avenue and 23rd Street for 21 years at a yearly rental of $560.  The 21-year leases continued and in 1908, the Moore Estate leased the corner at $9,350 per year.  When that term expired on April 30, 1929, it signaled the end of the decades-long tradition of leasing the corner.  The Moore Estate sold the property to the newly formed 8th Av. & 23d St. Corporation.

James P. Eadie, who negotiated the sale, told The New York Times that the buyers would erect "a twenty-story apartment house to cost about $1,250,000."  The syndicate hired one of the best-known apartment building architects of the time, Emery Roth.  Construction was completed in 1930.  Roth had designed a monolithic, Art Deco-style structure that dwarfed the buildings in the neighborhood.  Faced in beige brick, Roth accentuated the six-bay-wide central midsection by filling the spandrels on both elevations with projecting, vertically stacked brick.  The sections rose three stories above the setbacks of the upper portion and terminated in Art Deco-style brick ornaments.  An impressive water tower housing dominated the penthouse level and gave the upper section an Oz-like atmosphere.

P. L. Sperr captured this image on December 26, 1936.  from the collection of the New York Public Library.

Apartments contained one to three rooms, "all of which are equipped for full housekeeping," according to the 1930 realtors' brochure.  "Full housekeeping" meant that each apartment had a kitchen.  The brochure boasted that they were "equipped with modern range, silent refrigerators and all-metal cupboards and ideally planned for quick and labor-saving cooking."  The building was outfitted with the last word in technology: a radio connection.  "In addition to the usual outlets for lamps, and other electric service, every apartment is provided with an outlet which connects directly with your aerial on the roof," boasted the brochure.

The 1930 brochure depicted the lobby saying, "The Main Entrance is a spacious hall, tastefully furnished.  Here, there is always a man in attendance to announce your visitors, to accept mail and packages for you and to help promote your comfort."  (copyright expired)


The apartments filled with middle-class professionals, like Dr. Edward Pravener, an initial tenant.  Prohibition and the Great Depression made the 1930s a period of gangsters, speakeasies, and crime.  Dr. Edward Pravener walked innocently into the nearby London Chemists drugstore just after midnight on February 7, 1932 and became an unwitting witness of a Hollywood-style rubout.

Gangster bootlegger and murderer Vincent "Mad Dog" Coll lived in The Broadmoor, across 23rd Street from No. 300.  He came into the pharmacy and entered a phonebooth.  The next morning,  The Bristol [Virginia] News Bulletin began an article saying, "Young Vincent Coll who was poison with a pistol and most feared of the Gotham 'guns,' got his load of lead in a telephone booth at 12:45 a.m. today.  A machine gunner chopped him down cooly [sic] and deliberately in a West 23rd Street drugstore."

Dr. Pravaner, the other two customers and the two clerks, were interrogated by detectives.  They all said, "that the slayer had carried out his deadly program as coolly and efficiently as if it had been carefully rehearsed," reported by The New York Times.  

The 1930 Real Estate Brochure depicted a typical floorplan.  (copyright expired)

Another initial resident was William Rhodes, a newspaper photographer.  In December 1934, he sublet his second-floor apartment to a young couple, Leslie Drew and his wife, the former Alice Potts.  Drew was a salesman for a publishing firm and he was suffering a serious condition that required surgery.  The couple, however, did not have the money to pay for the procedure.

At around noon on February 19, 1935, employees of the building smelled gas and called the Consolidated Gas Company to find the leak.  The fumes were strongest on the lower floors, so the building's superintendent, Frank Masefield, took the two gas company men to the basement.  At 2:00, there was a massive explosion.  "As tenants ran out excitedly, the three went to the inner court," said The New York Times, "They saw that the windows of Apartment 2C had been blown out."

On the apartment door, Alice Drew had posted a note for her husband:

Do not enter alone, I beg of you, especially with a lighted cigarette.  I am more afraid of life than death.  You frightened me in the theatre last evening, you looked so sick.  If you did not have my responsibility you could afford to get well.  I am an expensive luxury.  Lovingly, Alice

The three men pushed their way into the apartment and found the 32-year-old Alice "dead in the middle of a fire which was burning her clothes and the furniture," said The New York Times.  "Six jets on the gas range were turned on."  (Hopefully William Rhodes had insisted on a security deposit.)

Among the other residents at the time of the tragedy were Joseph F. Faulhaber and his wife, the former Eva Sarfaty.  Born in Cleveland, Joseph studied at the Case School of Applied Science and from 1910 to 1917 was associated with the Commercial and Industrial Corporation of America, described as "business doctors."  He was now the president of the Finance and Development Corporation and of the Quick Alarm Fire Detector Corporation.


Attorney Thomas F. Noonan, who lived here as early as 1936, was a widower.  Born in 1877, he was a life-long Chelsea resident. He graduated from St. Francis Xavier College in 1897 and received his M. A. degree from the same institution the next year.  He received his law degree from Columbia Law School in 1900, and was elected a justice of the Municipal Court in 1909.

On the afternoon of December 20, 1936, Noonan was presiding at a trial when a court officer whispered to him that Governor Herbert H. Lehman was on the telephone.  Noonan went to his chambers "and Governor Lehman informed him by telephone that he had been appointed a Supreme Court Justice," reported The New York Times.

In stark contrast to the respected jurist was Allan Coulter.  The 20-year-old moved in following his discharge from the U.S. Navy in December 1945.  He had been a radio technician on the aircraft carrier Lexington, during which time he acquired technical skills.  He used them to form a teenaged safe-cracking gang.  Two of his cohorts were 16 years old and the other was 17.  

Coulter's scheme utilized two-way radios that warned those on the inside of a building of approaching police.  Within three months, the youthful gang committed "seventy-five burglaries, including forty-two safe 'jobs,'" reported The New York Times on May 8, 1946.  It was the group's lavish spending that tipped off detectives.  The article said they squandered  the "$15,000 loot on girls, night clubs and parties on a grand scale."

They were arrested in February 1946.  Investigators searched Coulter's apartment here and found the walkie-talkie sets that he had "improved," and burglar tools.  "There was also a device on which the 'master mind' was at work: an infra-red ray gadget that would have furnished the gang 'invisible' light for their burglaries."  Coulter was convicted on a lesser charge of "having burglar's tools in his possession."

Somewhat surprisingly, Allan Coulter was "put on probation until 1957," reported The New York Times.  Three years later, in May 1949, he and four other men were arrested "with a 'walkie-talkie' device, after an alleged attempt to break into the safes of the New York Giants Baseball Club and the Personal Finance Company," reported The New York Times.  On May 6, a "laboratory of crime" was discovered in Coulter's apartment.  The Safe and Loft Squad discovered "between $35,000 and $40,000 worth of electrical equipment, radar devices, chemicals and books."  District Attorney Paul F. Reilly described Coulter as "the brains of the outfit," saying he had a "scientific mind" and was "a radar expert."  Coulter was convicted and sentenced to seven-to-fourteen years in prison.

A rendering of the building appeared on the cover of the 1930 realtor brochure. (copyright expired)

Gangster Joseph "Socks" Lanza lived here starting in 1953.  He was described by The New York Times as the "racketeer-czar of the Fulton Fish Market."  Born in 1900, he founded the Fulton Market Watchmen and Patrol Association at the age of 20.  His thugs charged fishermen, ship owners, peddlers and trucking companies "union license fees" and "protection" money.  In the 1920s, Lanza's organization was taking in the equivalent of $900,000 in 2026.

Lanza was sentenced to prison for labor extortion in 1943.  When he was released on parole in 1953, he moved into 300 West 23rd Street.  At 10:30 on the evening of February 5, 1957, Lanza was arrested in his apartment.  He was charged with violating his parole "by allegedly associating with gamblers and a woman believed to have been involved in the narcotics traffic and spending much more than he earned as a clerk in a hardware store," explained The New York Times.  The well-connected mobster, however, was soon back home.

Commissioner James R. Stone resigned under fire in April 1957 after he dismissed the parole violations against Lanza.  Governor W. Averell Harriman demanded an investigation to find out "why Lanza, a convicted extortionist and formerly a power in Tammany politics on the Lower East Side," had been released.  Joseph Lanza was returned to prison until 1960.  He died from cancer on October 10, 1968.

Among Lanza's neighbors in the building were Charles H. Farrell, his wife Mary, and son John H.  Charles Farrell was born in 1894 and served in the U.S. Army in World War I.  He became a court clerk assigned to the Chief Magistrate's Office in 1925, and was the Democratic leader of the Third Assembly District South.  John H. Farrell followed his father's political bent.  On February 14, 1957 he was elected to the State Senate.

Unmarried Elizabeth Thomson moved into 300 West 23rd Street in 1944.  The 96-year-old was still living here in December 1983 when she fell ill and temporarily moved in with her niece, Elizabeth DeKovessey in Englewood, New Jersey.  While she was gone, the building began the conversion to cooperatives.  Although she had continued to pay her rent, in July 1984, Elizabeth Thomson received an eviction notice.

A spokesman for the property owner told The New York Times, "We don't want to play the part of the heavy here, but no one bothered to contact us that Miss Thomson would be returning."  Elizabeth DeKovessey refuted that assertion, saying they had told the landlord she would return, "but chose to press the eviction since reissue of the apartment as a cooperative would command a higher price."  It appears that the negative publicity caused the management to change its mind and Elizabeth Thomson's eviction was rescinded.


Emery Roth's hulking Art Deco structure remains a prominent landmark on the intersection of Eighth Avenue and 23rd Street.

photographs by the author

Saturday, October 24, 2026

The Charles F. and Maude Watson Mansion - 34 East 69th Street

 

Prolific real estate developer Anthony Mowbray erected two brownstone-faced homes at 32 and 34 East 69th Street between Park and Madison Avenues in 1880.  Designed by Lamb & Wheeler in a marriage of neo-Grec and Queen Anne styles, they were 20-feet wide and four stories tall above high English basements.

34 East 69th Street would originally have been very similar to its next-door-neighbor at 32 E. 69th Street.  from the collection of the New York Public Library

Politician John Kelly and his wife, Ann Theresa Mullen, purchased 34 East 69th Street.  Born in 1822, Kelly entered politics in 1840 and served as a New York Representative in Congress from 1855 to 1858.  He was elected Sheriff of New York County in 1859 and in 1871 turned his focus to fighting the corruption of the notorious Tweed Ring.  By 1874, Kelly controlled Tammany Hall and earned his nickname, "Honest John."

John Kelly, from the collection of the Library of Congress

Ann was Kelly's second wife.  His first, Mary Ann McIllhargy, died on July 17, 1866, and within five years their three children had perished.  He and Ann (who was the niece of New York Cardinal John McCloskey) had a son, John Jerome, and a daughter, Josephine.

Kelly, the most powerful force in New York City politics, suffered a blow in 1884.  In his 1917 The History of Tammany Hall, Gustuvus Myers writes:

Kelly broke down with nervous and physical prostration after the Presidential campaign of 1884.  Grover Cleveland's election, which falsified his predictions, deeply disappointed him.  He kept to his house, No. 34 East Sixty-ninth street, but still issued his orders to the Tammany organization.

His condition was well publicized.  On February 14, 1885, The New York Times reported that Kelly had spent a few days as a guest of Nathaniel Jarvis, Jr. in Far Rockaway.  Now back home, the article said "it was announced that he was greatly improved in health, and had not been in better spirits for several weeks."

New Yorkers no doubt realized things were more serious that November.  The day after the elections, the New-York Tribune reported, "John Kelly remained all day yesterday at his home, No. 34 East Sixty-ninth-st.  It was stated that he was too ill to go out of the house."

By the following year, according to Gustuvus Meyers, "he could not sleep except by the use of opiates."  Around 1:30 on the morning of May 30, 1886, Mary Ann sent for a priest.  Two more came at around 10:00 to administer last rites.  On June 2, The Sun reported, "John Kelly, the Tammany chieftain, whose name is as familiar to the country as the President's, died yesterday afternoon at a little about 3 o'clock."  John Kelly's funeral was held in St. Patrick's Cathedral on June 5.

Kelly had left the East 69th Street house in equal shares to Mary Ann and Josephine, who was still unmarried.  Following their period of bereavement, the women again entertained.  Those gatherings often reflected the Kellys' deep Catholic faith.  On December 16, 1894, for instance, the New-York Tribune wrote, "One of the pleasant dinners of the week was given by Mrs. John Kelly for Monsignor Satolli, at her home, No. 34 East Sixty-ninth-st., on Monday.  The decorations were in white and purple, the Papal and the Delegate's colors."  (Monsignor Francesco Satolli was the first Apostolic Delegate to the United States.)

Mary Ann and Josephine remained here until August 1928 when 34 East 69th Street was sold to stockbroker Charles Frederic Watson Jr.  Somewhat ironically, seven months later, on March 25, 1929, Mary Ann Kelly died.

In reporting the sale on August 3, 1928 The New York Times had remarked that during the decades that the Kelly family occupied the house, "the block was improved with fine residences."  Charles and Maude Watson followed suite by hiring architect A. Wallace McCrea to remodel the outdated brownstone.  

He stripped off the outer wall and pulled the facade to the property line.  McCrea gave the mansion a tripartite, neo-French Classic marble facade.  Above the rusticated base, the windows of the piano nobile were fully arched, while the upper openings were segmentally arched.  McCrea even executed the terminal cornice in marble.

The renovation caused a stark contrast to its once fraternal twin next door.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

As work on the house progressed, the Watsons lived in a sumptuous apartment in Mayfair House at 610 Park Avenue.  Then, on November 2, 1929, The New York Times reported, "Mr. and Mrs. Charles F. Watson Jr. have left Mayfair House for 34 East Sixty-ninth Street."

Both Charles Frederic Watson Jr. and his wife, the former Maude V. Burnside, came from privileged backgrounds.  They were married in St. Thomas's Church on January 26, 1924.  The New York Times said that Charles was "descended from the Campbell and Argyle families of Scotland."  On her maternal side, Maude was a descendant of Roger Sherman, signer of the Declaration of Independence.

Charles was born in Orange, New Jersey and educated in private schools.  He became a member of the New York Stock Exchange in 1906, but was, perhaps, better known for his athletic skills at the time.  He was a championship amateur tennis player.  Now, he and Maude maintained a home in London where they spent several months every year.

As early as 1938, the Watsons's butler was John Evert Andren.  The butler was the most trusted member of a family's domestic staff and were entrusted with all the keys and combinations for silver safes.  On January 17, 1939, Andren was arrested "as a suspect" in the theft of some of the Watsons' silver.  Although he claimed innocence, he was carrying "monogrammed silverware worth more than $500" at the time of his arrest.  (The value would translate to more than $11,000 in 2026.)

Charles Frederic Watson Jr. died at the age of 71 on April 19, 1954.   Maude sold 34 East 69th Street on November 1, 1956 to Harold G. and Irene R. Lacks.  The couple's marriage dissolved and the house was auctioned as part of the divorce proceedings in February 1969.  It was purchased for the equivalent of $3 million today by the Government of Iran.  On February 28, The New York Times reported, "The house will be the residence of Iran's consul general, Parviz Sepahbodi."

photograph by Gottscho-Schleisner, Inc. from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

On February 11, 1979, revolutionary, armed forces overthrew the Iranian Government.  The U.S. State Department took over Iranian properties, including 34 East 69th Street in April 1980.  Six months later, on October 14, The New York Times reported that the State Department had leased the building to the French Designer Showhouse.  The Decorator Showcase continued to be held here through 2000.

In 2001, the Richard L. Feigen & Co. gallery opened in three floors of 34 East 69th Street.  Founded in Chicago in 1957, the gallery "handles work by such important artsists as German Expressionist Max Beckmann and Surrealist master Henri Rousseau," according to the 2016 ART + NYC.

David Zwirner's gallery took over the space in 2017.  Art dealer Adler Beatty occupied the fourth floor.  When Zwirner closed his East 69th Street location in July 2026, artnet recalled, "The Zwirner on East 69th Street hosted about three-dozen exhibitions for canonical figures like Yayoi Kusama, Bill Traylor, and Dan Flavin."


With the gallery gone, the future of the landmarked marble mansion is unclear.

photographs by the author

Saturday, September 26, 2026

The Howard and Frances Poillon Mansion - 174 East 80th Street

 

In 1873, Mary Barter, a widow, lived with her adult daughter, Ellen, in the newly-completed "double flat" at 174 East 80th Street just west of Third Avenue.  Ellen C. Barter was a teacher in the primary department of School No. 33 on East 66th Street.  There were two apartments per floor in the building and the Barters' neighbors were respectable and working class, like Peter Dunigan, who worked as a carpenter.

The Edward Haas family lived here in 1877.  Haas was a policeman and his daughter was a music teacher.  For some reason, the young woman left New York headed to Ocean Grove, New Jersey on January 31 that year in what the New-York Tribune described as a "furious northeast gale."  She boarded a New-Jersey Central Railroad train that left New York  at 5:15.  Because of the dangerous weather conditions, the conductor and engineer were told to run the train "carefully as far as South Amboy."  

When they arrived at Red Bank, "the conductor of the train received orders to go to Long Branch, and stop the train there," reported the New-York Tribune.  Miss Haas and the other four passengers were enraged and "insisted on being taken to Ocean Grove."  After an hour's delay, the train continued.  At Deal Beach, the conductor and head brakeman got off and walked the track for 300 yards.  They returned and reported that the track seemed safe as far as they had gone.  The New-York Tribune reported, "The train had scarcely moved a hundred yards when the track gave way and the engine toppled over into the Great Pond, carrying the head brakeman, the engineer, and fireman."

The engine plunged into the water, pulling the baggage car behind it.  The baggage master "jumped for his life."  Tragically, one passenger, 24-year-old Dr. Laird, had moved forward into the baggage car and was killed.  The sole passenger car remained on the tracks.  The three male passengers helped rescue the engineer and fireman and the baggage master "plunged into the pond and dived under the wreck of the engine," looking for the brakeman.  He was finally found alive, trapped under the fire-box of the engine.  The New-York Tribune explained, "This was two hours or more after the accident."

The article said, "The passengers, one of whom was Miss Haas...then walked back to Deal Beach.  The lady was taken care of there, and a conveyance was obtained to convey the other passengers to Ocean Grove."

On April 15, 1920, The New York Times reported that Harriet A. Reinig had sold "the four-story flat" to Eugene Klapp, who "will make substantial alterations."  Instead, a year later on June 27, 1921, the New-York Tribune noted, "Howard Poillen [sic] is the new owner of the flat at 174 East Eightieth Street."

Born in 1879, engineer Howard Andrews Poillon graduated from Columbia University School of Mines in 1901.  He married Frances Wright in 1914 and the couple had three children, Cornelius III, Jeanne, and Peter.  The family's country home was in Westhampton Beach, Long Island.

Howard Andrews Poillon (original source unknown)

Poillon had prospected for gold in Alaska for ten years before co-founding Poillon & Poirier in 1913.  He was a vice president of Research Corporation, Consolidated Asbestos, Ltd., Federal Asbestos Co., D. M. Steindler Holding Co., and president of Crescent Lorraine Mining Co.  He was also a director in several other corporations.

The Poillons hired the architectural firm of Ford, Butler & Soliver to convert the vintage apartment building into a private home.  Although designated by the Department of Buildings as a single family dwelling, the Poillons rented out the upper two floors.  On September 17, 1922, they advertised in The New York Times:

An unusual duplex apartment.  174 East 80th St.--10 rooms, three baths, automatic elevator, two open fireplaces, living room 16x23.6, dining room 14.6x19; use of laundry in basement; occupancy Oct. 1.  Howard Poillon 42 Broadway.

The building likely looked similar to the one on the right in this 1940 tax photograph.  image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

The ad was answered by three siblings: Catherine, Margaret and Henry Stanton Leverich.  They were the children of the late Edward Leverich and the former Annie Frederica Schuchardt, who died in 1886 and 1918, respectively.  Henry was a real estate operator.  The New York Times described the siblings as descendants "of Colonial families identified with Rhode Island and New York."  They traced their paternal roots to the Rev. William Leverich, a Puritan clergyman who arrived in Rhode Island in 1634, and on their mother's side, according to The New York Times, from "the Remsen, Rutgers and de Peyster families of New Amsterdam."

The Leverich sisters moved within polite society.  On November 18, 1923, for instance, The New York Times reported, "Miss Margaret D. Leverich, of 174 East Eightieth Street will give a large luncheon on Wednesday, Dec. 5, at the Colony Club for Miss Margarette S. Delafield."

Calling him the "well known club man of New York city," on February 22, 1924 the Otsego Farmer reported that Henry Stanton Leverich would be married in Cooperstown, New York the next day to Jessie Reid Birdsall.  The New York Evening Telegram remarked, "Mr. Leverich was graduated from Yale in 1901 and is a member of the Union and Turf and Field clubs."  Following their honeymoon "through Italy, France, Belgium and England," according to the Otsego Farmer, "they will make their home at No. 174 East 80th Street."

Also moving into the upper floors was Jessie Reid Birdsall's daughter from her previous marriage, Gertrude Carlton Reid Birdsall.  On August 1, 1926, Town & Country reported on her engagement to William Richard Galt Duane.  The article noted that she "is a graduate of St. Agnes School, Albany, and has been studying in New York and Paris."

In 1927, Howard Andrews Poillon was promoted to president of Research Corporation in 1927.  The firm was described by The New York Times as, "an engineering foundation organized to transact business for the advancement of science."

Frances, in the meantime, kept herself busy within society.  On June 27, 1929, for instance, the Standard Union reported on the happenings at the Westhampton Country Club.  "The women's golf tournament for the Tombstone Competition was held yesterday," said the article.  "Mrs. Howard Poilon [sic] of 174 East Eightieth street, Manhattan, is chairman of the women's golf committee."

Jeanne Poillon attended the private Brearley School and graduated from Rosemary Hall in Greenwich, Connecticut in June 1938.  In March 1939, her parents hosted a tea to announce her engagement to Wellington Vandeveer.

When America entered World War II, Cornelius and Peter Poillon joined the U.S. Army and were deployed to Europe.  Jeanne's husband also enlisted.  Vandeveer joined the United States Naval Reserves.  With her husband fighting abroad, Jeanne and her two young daughters, Pamela and Judith, moved back into 174 East 80th Street with her parents.  The family was at the Westhampton Beach house on September 5, 1944, when Jeanne, who was 25 years old, died "presumably of Rocky Mountain fever," according to The New York Times.

In 1944, Howard Poillon suffered a debilitating stroke.  It necessitated his stepping down from the presidency of Research Corporation.  In 1948, he was admitted to the Westchester branch of New York Hospital in White Plains.  He remained there until his death on January 20, 1954.  

No. 174 East 80th Street next became home to the Morton Fearey family.   Born in New York City in 1913, Fearey was a graduate of Yale University and the Yale Law School.  Now a partner in the law firm of Davis, Polk, Wardwell, he had served as a naval aviator in World War II.  He and his wife, the former Mary Senior, had two sons, Morton Jr. and John, and a daughter, Mary.  The family's country home was in Edgartown, Massachusetts.

Mary's dizzying debut to society included a dinner dance in the Colony Club on December 26, 1956.  The New York Times remarked that she "attended the Grosvenor Ball in the Plaza last month and the Debutante Cotillion and Christmas Ball in the Waldorf-Astoria last Friday.  She also will attend the Mayfair Assembly in the Pierre New Year's Eve."

The social spotlight turned to Morton Jr. in 1964 when he was married to Beverly Ann McMonagle on February 8.  The ceremony as performed by the Right Rev. William Appleton, "retired Bishop of Western Massachusetts and granduncle of the bridegroom," as reported by The New York Times.

Two years before Morton Fearey's death in 1988, the couple sold 174 East 80th.  Their former residence was converted to offices.


It became home to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation, the Association of Art Museum Curators & AAMC Foundation, and The New York Preservation Archives Project.  

photographs by the author

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

The Skinny 144 First Avenue

 
photograph by Anthony Bellov

In the 1830s, the eastern blockfront of First Avenue between Eighth and Ninth Streets was lined with low Federal-style store-and-house buildings.  Change would soon come as throngs of immigrants inundated the neighborhood.  Private homes were converted to rooming houses and vintage buildings on the avenues were replaced with tenements and stores.  Around 1851, a row of Greek Revival store-and-flat buildings was erected at 142 through 148 First Avenue.

The buildings were faced in red running bond brick above the storefronts.  Their Greek Revival design included featureless brownstone lintels and wooden corbeled cornices.  No. 144 First Avenue was just 16-feet wide.  As early as 1852, Mary McGuinness, a widow, lived here, working as a seamstress.  She may have operated the upper floors as a boarding house.  Living here at the same time were Edward McGorren, a real estate agent, and carpenter James Robinson.

At the same time, Gaius H. Nash operated his pharmacy in the store.  He had a short commute to work, since he lived in the new building next door at 146 First Avenue.  (He and his family would move above the store around 1857.)  After working for Nash for several years, an employee became disgruntled by his lack of advancement in 1854.  In June he advertised:

To Druggists--The Advertiser having had eight years experience in the compounding of medicine, is anxious to obtain a clerk's situation.  Best city Reference.  Apply at Dr. Nash's store, 144 First avenue, for two days.

Calling the proprietor "Dr. Nash" was a stretch.  It would not be until around 1859 the he closed his drugstore here and enrolled in the New York University School of Medicine.  He would earn his title "doctor" in 1864.

Sharing the upper floors with the Nash family in 1856 were  a young Irish-born couple, John J. and Margaret Ahern (John worked as a clerk); the extended Ramsey family; and policeman Charles McMillen.  

Margaret Ahern, "formerly of the city of Cork, Ireland," as reported by The New York Sun, died in her rooms here on November 28, 1856 at the age of 18.  Her funeral was held in the couple's rooms.

There would be another funeral in the building within a few months.  The Samuel Ramsey family, who would remain at least through 1865, crowded into an apartment.  They included adult sons James (an engineer) and Robert, and the latter's wife, Margaret, and their three-year-old son, John.  On May 1, 1857, little John succumbed to "congestion of the brain," as described by the New York Herald.  His funeral was held here on June 2.

Joanna Regiersky opened a jewelry store in the former pharmacy space in 1859.  On January 31, 1860, she took two $1,000 St. Louis and Iron Mountain Railroad Company bonds to Jacob Little & Co. on Wall Street to have them cashed.  The New York Times reported, "but as it was after banking hours, she was requested to call the next day."  In fact, the astute clerk was stalling.  He recognized the bonds as having been stolen from the home of Alexander H. Nones two months earlier.  When Joanna returned, an officer was waiting for her.

As it turned out, the burglar (who also took $400 worth of jewelry) was Joanna Regiersky's brother-in-law, Julius Werner.  She told the officer that he had promised her $100 if she successfully cashed the bonds.  Joanna was ordered to send him a message saying that he was needed to "attend the business."  When he arrived, he and Joanna were arrested.  

The incident apparently ended Joanna Regiersky's jewelry shop.  The space became the barbershop of Franz Haberstroh.  (He would alternatively spell his first name Frank and Francis.)

John Wille, a tailor, not only occupied an apartment here by 1868, he owned the building.  Also living here that year was Charles A. Cappa, a musician.  In June 1868, Wille sold the structure to Franz Haberstroh.

Haberstroh did not retain ownership for very long.  By 1872, he closed his barbershop and sold 144 First Avenue to Michael Klopf and his wife, Anna M. H. Klopf.  The couple had three children, Henry, Katie and Lizzie.  Michael opened his "stoves" store in the ground floor space.  It may have been Klopf who slightly updated the appearance of the building by having cast metal cornices added to the lintels.

Michael Klopf died in 1900.  The store space became home to Paul Limbach's "butter and egg" store.  The entrepreneur struggled in business.  On November 9, 1904, the New York Produce Review and American Creamery reported that Paul Limbach's business had failed.  He, nevertheless, rallied and on March 28, 1906, The City Record reported that he had been given a license "to sell milk at No. 144 First avenue."  Only four months later, on July 31, The New York Times reported that he had declared bankruptcy.

While the simple blocks and wooden fascia board were typical of the Greek Revival style, the full-height of the top floor and the slightly-molded cornice showed the emerging Italianate style.  photograph by Anthony Bellov

Rutilio Colorosso, a coal dealer, his wife and six children arrived from Italy in 1892 and moved into 144 First Avenue in 1900.  In the summer of 1911, he opened a second coal store at 406 East 9th Street.  The Italian community was plagued by a terroristic group called La Mano Nera, or the Black Hand, at the time.  The Italian-American group used violence, including assassinations and bombings, to extort money from well-to-do Italians.  On September 11, 1911, The Evening World reported, "Outward evidence of prosperity, manifested by the opening of a new place of business for the sale of coal, wood, ice and cheap wine has brought upon Rutilio Colorosso the unwelcome attention of Black Hand extortioners."

Within four weeks of opening the new store, Colorosso received two Black Hand letters, each demanding $1,000.  They warned him that "he and his family would be blown to pieces in their home unless he paid the money," reported The New York Times.  Colorosso dismissed the letters until the night of September 4.

At 10:30, janitor David Leper locked the street door.  About an hour later, residents of the top floor heard someone walking on the roof.  Minutes later, a massive explosion shattered the doors "of every flat in the four stories of the building," reported The New York Times.  Plaster from the ceilings fell upon sleeping tenants.  The bomb had been placed directly in front of the Colorossos' door.  Where the door had been there was now a four-foot wide hole in the floor.  The article said, "In every room in the house debris crumbled from the ceilings to a depth of several inches."  The Colorossos' 15-year-old son, Joseph, "was thrown out of his bed against the opposite wall."  Happily, he was not hurt.

Two days later, The New York Times reported on the arrest of Giuseppe Costabile, "a shrewd, narrow-eyed Italian," for the bombing.  The article said, "the police believe they have caught the chief and master-mind of a gang of blackmailers who have set most of the thirteen bomb explosions reported in the last month."  If Costabile was, indeed, the bomber, his arrest did not deter the determined extortionists.

That same day, Colorosso received another letter and the following week, on the morning of September 11, a second bomb was discovered in the building.  The Evening World said, "The explosive was dynamite, properly equipped with a detonating cap.  Only two inches of the twelve-inch fuse was burned.  Doubtless the fuse went out while the man who placed the bomb was running way."

The New-York Tribune reported, "The bomb, the police said, was unmistakably designed for Frank [sic] Colarusso [sic]."  The Evening World added, "The bomb found at Colorosso's floor this morning was of sufficient strength to have blown in the front of the building."

In 1940, the sheet metal cornices over the windows were deteriorating.  One of top floor examples had already fallen off.  via the NYC Dept of Records Information Services.

Most of the residents of 144 First Avenue continued to be Italian in the succeeding decades.  Salvatore Rezze and Charles Carnesi lived here in 1929.  On June 1 that year, the Daily Star reported that they had been arrested as part of a "counterfeiting gang."  Rezze, Carnesi, and Anthony Scarpello were arrested after a sharp-eyed taxi driver recognized the $5 bill they paid him was a fake.  Their capture led to "the seizure of the 'plant' where, it is believed, several hundred thousand dollars in bogus bills have been manufactured since the first of the year," said a Secret Service spokesperson.

By the Depression years, the store was home to the Italian American Grocery & Delicatessen.  At the end of Prohibition, Fortunato Liberto obtained a liquor license for the business.

The contemporary building next door, one-third wider than No. 144, received a replacement cornice at some point.  photograph by Anthony Bellov

Today a laundromat occupies the ground floor where a modern storefront and replacement entrance doors can be seen.  The Victorian window cornices are gone, but the vintage wooden terminal cornice survives.

many thanks to Anthony Bellov for suggesting this post.

Friday, August 28, 2026

Charles Mettam's 1870 506 La Guardia Place


image via loopnet.com


As early as 1845, a two-story brick house occupied the plot at 185 Laurens Street.  In the rear yard was a three-story brick house.  (It was an unexpected configuration since, normally, the larger house was at the front of the property.)  The address and the street name would be changed more than once in the coming decades.

Charles Golden owned the property in the post-Civil War years and the front house was home to Edwin Beyersdorf's lager-beer saloon.  At 10:00 on the morning of September 30, 1869, Beyersdorf was filling a cigar lighter on the counter from a "can of liquid gas," according to The New York Times.  The can ignited and the flames quickly engulfed the barroom.  The article noted, "The building, owned by M. [sic] Golden, is damaged about $800 and is insured for $4,000 in the Aetna."  (The amount of damage would translate to about $19,500 in 2026.)

One wonders if the fire was truly an accident or if Golden was in cahoots with his tenant to obtain the insurance money.  Two weeks before the fire, architect Charles Mettam had already filed plans for a "five-story brick store & tenement" on the site.  It is clear that Golden intended to replace the old structures, because at the time of Mettam's filing, the builder, James Clarke, had already been contracted.

Whether Golden was aware that Clarke was making shortcuts in the construction of the new building is impossible to know.  But a horrific accident took place on the job site.  The New-York Tribune reported, "a wrought-iron tension rod broke.  It was used to sustain the front wall...Having broken it let the entire wall down in to the cellar, and came near killing the master mason and a laborer."  An investigation revealed that the rod "was not of suitable form to sustain a great weight."

By the time construction of the building was completed in 1871, the block was known as South Fifth Avenue.  Mettam's Italianate design was typical of scores of store-and-apartment buildings being constructed throughout the city.  Faced in red brick above its cast iron storefront, the building's windows wore handsome molded stone lintels.  The cast metal cornice, likely chosen from a foundry's catalogue, featured foliate corbels, dentils and brackets. 

The building received a new address again in 1896--506 West Broadway.  Occupying the commercial space at the time was the United States Directory Publishing and Printing Company.  Among the upstairs tenants were the Mullin and Smith families.

Mary Mullin was an activist of sorts, at least for a woman of her time.  In 1896 she co-founded of the Woman's National Democratic League of the United States of America.  Its noble and floridly written purposes included: 

To denounce all forms of political corruption and unjust legislation and to aid and encourage the voters of the nation in their patriotic endeavors to maintain and perpetuate government of the people for the people and by the people.

The Smith apartment was burglarized by a trio of crooks early in 1897.  John Gartland, alias Corey; John Kelley, alias Frank Hazel, and Charles Walker, alias Stewart, were arrested on March 27 at 96 Barrow Street, described by the New York Herald as "a den of thieves."  Recent victims of burglaries, including Annie Smith, were summoned to Police Headquarters to identify any possible stolen items.  Annie "claimed a gold wedding ring," reported the New-York Tribune.

By the turn of the century, Gross & Horn, makers of shoe soles, occupied the ground floor.

Building Trades Association Bulletin, July 1901 (copyright expired)

In 1905, Ulric J. De Poli, described by the New York Herald as "a good looking young Italian," took an apartment here.  He operated his silk business from his apartment.  The nearly penniless immigrant posed as Louis Banta, "an Italian nobleman and a wealthy silk merchant," said the article.  Telling the owners of silk mills in New Jersey that he had $17,000 in the bank, he ordered bales of silk on credit and resold them to dry goods merchants.

The scheme collapsed on the morning of December 8, when De Poli "was nabbed at Bleecker street and West Broadway by Detective Sergeants Howard, Flannelly and Schoenick, who had a warrant for his arrest," as reported by the New York Herald.  The article explained that De Poli had been wanted "for fleecing several silk manufacturers out of goods valued at $20,933." 

Abolardo Cassi and his family arrived from Italy in 1906 and moved an apartment on the third floor of 506 West Broadway.  Like De Poli, he ran his business, of sorts, from his apartment.  On July 26, 1907, a man "hurried into the New York Custom House," and told officials that "he had found seven paintings by old masters, including Correggio and Titian, offered for sale by Abolardo Cassi...and that at the price asked he was sure they must have been smuggled into the country."

An art expert from the Appraiser's Office, a Customs inspector and a representative from the Custom House's legal department accompanied the man to Cassi's apartment.  Here Cassi showed them Titian's Rebecca at the Well; two canvases by Tintoretto, Hunting and Music; two works by Correggio, Abraham Dying and Joseph Recognizing His Brothers; The Holy Family by Cimaburg, and Massaccio's The Redeemer.  Cassi's asking prices ranged from $1,000 each for Hunting and The Redeemer to $15,000 for Rebecca at the Well.  The total amount of $32,000 would equal $1.1 million today.

Cassi explained that the paintings were "heirlooms of his family, which was at one time well-to-do in Italy," as reported by The New York Times.  He told the officials that he "had formerly been in prosperous circumstances, but that, meeting with reverses, he came to this country, bringing the paintings with him, as he did not wish to part with them."  Now in America, the Cassis' 17-year-old son was their main support.  But "since they arrived in this country," he explained, he "recently became insane and is now confined in the Manhattan State Hospital."

The art appraiser decided that the paintings were "very old, but were not considered originals."  Because there was no evidence that Cassi smuggled them into the country, the matter was dropped.  Whether the struggling immigrant was able to liquidate the copies is unclear.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Around the time of the Cassi investigation, 506 West Broadway was acquired by C. & M. Moriggia.  In 1911, they hired architect L. V. Spenaport to do $8,000 in renovations to convert the upper floors to commercial use.

Their ground floor tenant around the time was the Mariani Brothers, importers of Italian foods, operated by Filomena and Oreste Mariani.  On January 15, 1915, the New York Herald reported on the massive earthquake that destroyed 16 Italian towns, including Avezzano, and damaged 12 others.  An article said, "Mr. Oreste Mariani, who is a native of Vasto, near Avezzano, set to work early in the morning collecting funds at his place of business, No. 506 West Broadway, and turning them over to the Italian Red Cross Society.  The firm of Mariani Brothers headed the subscription list with $100."  The article continued:

Mr. Oreste Mariani sent a cable despatch [sic] to his brother, Mr. Humbert Mariani, in Naples, directing him to go to the stricken country, investigate conditions and to extend whatever immediate aid he could to the sufferers.  Mr. Mariani awaits a reply and expects to be accurately informed by one who was born and reared near Avezzano and still has nearly a dozen relatives in that region.

Less noble press about the Mariani Brothers came four months later.  The firm was fined $25 in April 1915, "for shipping whiskey into prohibition Vermont as 'groceries,'" reported The Larchmonter-Times.  

Among the upper floor tenants in 1912 were Axelrod & Sokel, manufacturers of boys' pants, and H. H. Upham & Co., sign makers.  The latter firm was established in 1863.  They would be joined in the building by 1915 by Edward Podesnick's electrical machinery shop.

Mariani Brothers remained in the building at least through 1919.  That year they advertised, "Correspondent wanted to take care of Italian and English correspondence; good typist; several years' experience with importers and small mail order; good salary."

But, initiated by Edward Podesnick, the building was mainly occupied by electrical firms in the 1920s.  Among them were the Shotwell Electric Co. and Neptune Battery Co., manufacturer of dry batteries.  The latter was renamed the Advance Battery Co. in 1923.

The building was a scene worthy of a cops-and-robbers movie in 1958.  In the early hours of February 8, Police Sergeant Thomas Gilligan and Patrolman John Dolan followed Kendall Brown, an ex-convict.  A passerby notified them that he had climbed the fire escape of 506 West Broadway to the roof.  The New York Post reported, "Gilligan, a six-footer weighing 200 pounds, was confronted on the roof by a man about his size wielding a switch-blade knife.  He disarmed the suspect in a struggle near the edge of the roof."

As the pair wrestled, Kendall tried repeatedly to shove Gilligan over the edge of the roof.  After breaking loose from the sergeant's hold, Kendall "scaled an eight-foot wall to the roof of an adjoining building," said the article.  Gilligan fired two shots and missed.  While Dolan waited below for the fugitive to emerge, Gilligan fired one more shot, hitting Kendall in the arm.  He was taken into custody.  The New York Post reported that Kendall had been arrested twice for robbery and spent a prison term that ended in 1953.

A renovation in 1962 resulted in a luncheonette on the ground floor, and one apartment-working space each on the upper floors. 

The street was renamed yet again in 1967, now known as La Guardia Place in honor of former Mayor Fiorello La Guardia.  

In 1980, Bruno Bakery occupied the ground floor.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

Around 1980, Bruno Bakery, a bakery-cafe, moved into the ground floor space.  In 1999, Biagio Settepani purchased the business, renaming it Pasticceria Bruno.  The pastry chef had started his career at the age of 13 in a small bakery in Brooklyn.  Settepani had previously been named one of the ten best pastry chefs in America and in 2006 he received the Northeastern Region's Pastry Chef of the year Award from the American Culinary Federation.

The popular bakery remained through 2016, when it was supplanted by Austrian restaurant Freud.  Two years later the name was changed to Bar Freud after, as reported by Florence Fabricant in The New York Times on February 27, 2018, "Freud has hit the bottle.  Or, rather, the cocktail hour."

The change was short-lived.  On August 6, 2019, The New York Times reported the opening of Bosie Tea Parlor a "well-appointed tea cafe" and French bistro.  The cafe remained until 2022 when Lord's opened.

On September 2 that year, Florence Fabricant wrote, "At Lord's contemporary English fare 'a long way from the bangers-and-mash of previous generations,' is how Patricia Howard and Ed Szymanski, the owners of Dame, describe what they have in store for this sibling."

Today each of the upper floors has one apartment and the commercial space is still home to Lord's.