The 1890 George W. Blakeslee House - 157 West 93rd Street

 

image via apartments.com

W. P. Anderson was both a builder and architect, responsible for structures like the 1881 H. H. Hunnewell Building on Beaver Street.  In 1890, he added "developer" to his resume by erecting two rows of high-stooped houses along West 93rd and West 94th Street between Columbus and Amsterdam Avenues.  A mixture of the Renaissance Revival and Queen Anne styles, each was just 18-feet wide and rose three stories above an English basement.

The six houses on West 93rd Street--from 149 through 157--cost Anderson $12,000 each to construct (about $427,000 in 2025).  The basement and parlor levels of 157 West 93rd Street were faced in planar sandstone banded with undressed stone courses.  Peaked eyebrows hovered over the elliptically arched parlor openings.  The upper floors were clad in red brick and trimmed in buff-colored sandstone.  The grouped second-floor windows sat within a stone frame that included a prominent entablature and cornice.  Their transoms, the center of which was arched, were filled with colorful stained glass.  The arched openings of the floor above were grouped within a triptych-like stone frame with sharp peaks.  A complex pediment sat atop the cornice.

Striped canvas awnings protected interior fabrics from damaging sunlight and reduced heat during summer months.  image courtesy of Lynne Miller.

Anderson advertised the newly-completed houses in November 1890, using a confusing dearth of punctuation:

Between 9th and 10th Aves., very handsome 3-story butler pantry extension basement and cellar fancy fronts private dwellings.

No. 157 was sold on November 28 to real estate developer George R. Dunn for $17,848.  The price would translate to about $635,000 today.  Like W. P. Anderson, he was involved in the rapidly developing Upper West Side.  While living here in October 1892, for instance, he hired architect George Keister to design a five-story apartment building at the corner of Amsterdam Avenue and 77th Street.

In 1893, Dunn leased 157 West 93rd Street to Walter A. Reilly and his wife, who had two children.  According to the New York Herald, Reilly had inherited "nearly $109,000," from the estate of his father, Charles V. Reilly, in 1890.  (The figure would translate to nearly $4 million today.)

Unfortunately for the family, Reilly suffered from a gambling addiction.  On May 8, 1893, the New York Herald explained that of his substantial inheritance, "at least $83,000 has been squandered at cards in the last three years."  In an attempt to cover the shortfall, Walter wrote a $3,500 check to Dr. Patrick J. Lynch, his father-in-law, from the bank account of his father's estate.  He forged the signature of Walter D. Burke, the executor of the estate, on the check. Reilly then cashed it at the Madison Square Bank.

It did not take long for the bank to discover the forgery.  Charged with "robbing his father's estate," as reported by The Norfolk Weekly Landmark, Walter Reilly fled the city with detectives hot on his trail.  On May 5, 1893, the Washington, D.C. The Evening Star reported, "A dispatch from Richmond, Va., advised Inspector McLaughlin, chief of detectives of New York, yesterday of the arrest in that city of Walter A. Reilly, charged with forgery."  Calling Reilly, "a well dressed young man of 27," The San Diego Sun reported that he had confessed.  He consented to return to New York without the formality of extradition.  In reporting Reilly's arrest, the New York Herald mentioned, "His wife and two children live at No. 157 West Ninety-third street."

Not surprisingly, the Reillys' residency soon ended.  In April 1894, Dunn advertised the house for sale.  "Only $8,000 needed, price $18,000; three story and basement high stoop, 157 West 93d st., between Columbus and Amsterdam avs."  The house underwent a rapid-fire change of ownership until October 1898 when it was purchased by James D. De Milt (sometimes spelled Demilt).

Born on Grand Street in June 1824, De Milt came from "a prominent family in old New York, noted for the public spirit and philanthropy," according to School magazine.  A relative, Elizabeth De Milt, founded the De Milt Dispensary and bequeathed $5,000 to the Society Library in 1850.

A widower (his wife, Mary Coulter, died in 1864), De Milt retired from the public school system in 1895.  As a boy, he attended Public School No. 4 on Rivington Street.  Unconceivable today, he "became a teacher at thirteen under the old monitor system."  He remained at P. S. No. 4 for decades as the neighborhood around it changed.  On January 25, 1900, School commented,

In his early life the neighborhood of the school was a well-known American section of the city.  With the foreign influx of late years, Mr. De Milt made a long and strenuous effort to correct the pronunciation and prevent the corruption of local American names in that vicinity.  Old "Goerck" st., which became commonly known as "Garrick" st., he instanced as a special example of this corruption.

On May 27, 1887, De Milt's 50th anniversary of teaching at P.S. No. 4 was celebrated there.  By then, he held the position of principal and by the time he moved into 157 West 93rd Street, his daughter, Hannah W. De Milt was a teacher there.  

The New York Times reported on January 20, 1900, "James D. De Milt died from apoplexy yesterday morning at his home at 157 West Ninety-third Street."  (The term referred to a stroke or cerebral hemorrhage.)  The article noted that the 75-year-old "retired four years ago after fifty-eight years' continuous service as a teacher in the public schools."

Anderson's row was a variation on a theme, the interior layouts no doubt identical.  No. 157 is at the far right.  from the collection of the New York Public Library.

The estate sold 157 West 93rd Street at auction on March 18, 1902.  It was purchased by George B. McEntyre.  He moved in with his father, P. B. McEntyre.  They were partners in the contracting firm P. B. McEntyre & Son.  Interestingly, on March 28, The New York Times reported, "George B. McEntyre, who bought 157 West Ninety-third Street at auction a few days ago, has purchased the adjoining house, 159, from the Citizens' Savings Bank."

P. B. McEntyre's other son, James T., had followed a much different career path.  He entered the Grand Seminary in Montreal and was ordained in 1884.  When his father and brother moved into the 93rd Street house, he was pastor of St. Theresa's Church on Rutgers Street.  Father McEntyre would be elevated to monsignor and president of St. Joseph's Catholic Seminary in Yonkers.

P. B. McEntyre died in the house on September 29, 1906.  His funeral was held in the nearby Church of the Holy Name on October 1.  

Before the end of the year, George McEntyre sold the house to Dr. George W. Blakeslee.  He converted part of the basement level to his dental office.  On January 23, 1910, he advertised, "Young girl wanted, dentist office, and make herself generally useful. 157 West 93d."

On May 11, 1921, Blakeslee and his wife advertised for a replacement servant.  "Houseworker--Two in family; sleep out, good cook."  The distinction "sleep out" meant that the successful candidate would not be living with the Blakeslees.

The couple sold 157 West 93rd Street to the Houghton Company in January 1930.  In reporting the sale, The New York Evening Post remarked, "Dr. Blakeslee owned and occupied the premises for twenty-five years."  The following day, the Houghton Company sold the house to Pilar O. Domingo (who sometimes used the name James).  On March 7, The Sun reported that Domingo had resold it to the Miltown Realty Corporation.

In 1941 the parapet and stained glass survived.  image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

When Gil Brandsen purchased 157 West 93rd Street in the 1960s, it was most likely being operated as a rooming house.  A renovation completed in 1970 resulted in one apartment per floor.  Although the stained glass transoms have been removed and the parapet eliminated, the external appearance of W. P. Anderson's 1890 design is greatly intact.

many thanks to Lynne Miller for requesting this post.