The Thatcher M. Adams Mansion - No. 63 East 79th Street

photograph by the author

The son of a well-respected minister, Thatcher Magoun Adams grew up in comfortable surroundings.  By the time he attended New York University in the 1850s his family was living at No 46 West 22^nd Street.  Adams would choose a house nearby, at No. 15 West 17^th Street, following his marriage in the 1860s.

Thatcher and Frances Charlotte Adams had one son, Thatcher, Jr.; and they adopted two twin girls, Lillian Marie and Marion Marie, who were born on March 6, 1874.  (Marion would die at the age of 18 of appendicitis while traveling with her sister in Europe).   By now Thatcher M. Adams was a partner in the prominent legal firm Anderson, Adams & Young.  And his refined residential 17^th Street block was gradually changing as Sixth Avenue, just steps away, became the city’s foremost shopping district—later known as the Ladies’ Mile.

In the meantime the Upper East Side was seeing rapid development.  On East 79^th Street, between Madison and Park Avenues, speculative brownstone-fronted rowhouses had appeared in the 1860s.  Intended for comfortable middle class families, the two homes at Nos. 63 and 65 East 79^th Street were each a mere 13-feet wide.  Their owners were respectable, such as well-known Dr. Frank Van Fleet who lived in No. 63 at the turn of the century.

But, like Thatcher Adams’s neighborhood, the 79^th Street area was changing by now.  Old brownstones along the blocks off Central Park were being remodeled or razed to be replaced with modern mansions as New York’s wealthy migrated uptown.  On January 25, 1902 The Real Estate Record & Guide reported that Adams had “bought two 4-sty dwellings, Nos. 63 and 65 East 79^th st…which he will tear down and erect upon the site a new dwelling in their place.”

Adams commissioned the architectural firm of Adams & Warren to design the mansion.  Completed in 1903 at a cost of $35,000, its chaste brick and limestone façade echoed the English rowhouses of London’s Mayfair.  An Ionic portico sheltered the offset entrance and provided a balcony to the parlor floor.  A second balcony refused at this level flexed its individuality, bowing out from the French windows unlike its flat counterpart.  A stone course below the fourth floor, stone window framings of the central openings, and splayed lintels above the fourth floor windows provided reserved ornamentation.  Above a substantial stone balustrade two hooded dormers fronted the mansard roof.

 

The slim proportions of the original properties is evidenced by the narrow two-bay-wide houses on either side of the new mansion.  photo by Irving Underhill from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York

Like many wealthy Manhattanites, Adams filled his mansion with a fine art collection.  His was known for its 18^th century British portraits and old masters.  On the walls of the 79^th Street house were paintings that included, as later described in the New-York Tribune, “some excellent Venetian scenes by Canaletto, a superb ‘Portrait of a Cavalier,’ by Nicolas Maes, and a fascinating little Milanese fragment, an ‘Infant Christ and St. John,’ attributed to Marco d’Oggiono.”

The family summered in fashionable Lenox, Massachusetts where their Colonial Revival mansion, Sundrum House, was the scene of glittering entertainments.  While in Manhattan, Frances and Thatcher involved themselves in philanthropic endeavors. Thatcher served on the boards of medical institutions and became President of the New York Institute for the Instruction of the Deaf, Dumb and Blind, and a governor of the Woman’s Hospital.  His long list of exclusive club memberships included the Union Club, the Knickerbocker, the Metropolitan, the Lenox Club and the Downtown Association.

The family's summer home, Sundrum House, was designed by Roth & Tilden in 1888 for Frederick T. Frelinghuysen, Secretary of the Treasury under Chester A. Arthur.  photo via Lenox History

On Wednesday, October 13, 1909 Frances died in Sundrum House.  Wealthy in her own right, her will reflected her charitable interests.  She left $50,000 to the Society for the Relief of Half Orphans and Destitute Children, in memory of Marion; and $20,000 to the Children’s Aid Society.   Thatcher M. Adams received $200,000 of his wife’s estate--in the neighborhood of $5.4 million today.

The will exposed an earlier family rift, which Frances later forgave.  The New York Times reported “Mrs. Adams states in the will that she has omitted to provide for her nephew, Arden M. Robbins, on account of his conduct in connection with the sale of section 32 in Chicago.”  But only five months before her death, she amended the will.  In the codicil she said she had “determined to forget and forgive” and desired “to leave only pleasant memories.”

Thatcher Adams continued on in the 79^th Street mansion and at Sundrum House.  Following his mourning period he resumed the entertainments for which the Lenox estate was so well known.   On July 24, 1913, for instance, The Sun noted that “Dr. and Mrs. W. Holland Wilmer of Washington have arrived [at Lenox] to visit Thatcher M. Adams” and that “Mr. Adams will entertain at dinner to-morrow for his guests.”

Adams died in the 79^th Street house at the age of 81 on Saturday, May 10, 1919.  Within five months the mansion was sold by his estate to Henry W. de Forest for $175,000.  In reporting on the sale, The Sun noted “The residence is one of the best in the Park avenue section…On the east is the handsome residence of George L. Rives and to the west is the home of John H. Iselin.”  The article went on to say “Other residents of the neighborhood are Catherine C. D. Rogers, Emma L. Wooley and I. N. Phelps Stokes, the architect.”

An attorney, Henry Wheeler de Forest was highly involved with railroads and banking.  Like Adams, he engaged himself with hospital work, becoming a governor of the New York Hospital and a trustee of the Presbyterian Hospital.

Henry and his wife, the former Julia Gilman Hoyes, had two daughters, Julia Marie and Alice.  They maintained a summer estate in Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island, named Nethermuir.  The family would barely return to New York that season and move into their new 79^th Street home in time for daughter Julia’s introduction to society.  The mansion was the scene of teas and receptions as 1919 drew to a close.

Five years later, on December 27, 1924, guests would gather here following Julia’s Grace Church wedding to Beverly Duer.   The New York Times mentioned that “Following their wedding trip Mr. and Mrs. Duer plan to make their home in the city, spending their Summers on Long Island.”

On October 29, 1928 The Times reported that “Mr. and Mrs. Henry W. de Forest and Miss Alice de Forest” would return to New York the following day on the Olympic.  “They passed the Summer in England,” said the article.  It would be the last summer season Alice would spend with her parents.

Four days later Alice’s engagement to Francis Minturn Sedgwick was announced.  The wedding took place on Wednesday, May 8, 1929 in Grace Church.  The Times reported the marriage “will link families that have long been prominent in the affairs of New York.”   The social importance of the event was evidenced by the family names that made up Alice’s wedding party.  “For bridesmaids she has chosen her cousin, Miss Carlotte Noyes and the Misses Marie Iselin, Priscilla Choate, Mary Trimble, Barbara Babcock, Eleanor Pratt, Marie Parish, Helen de L. Kountze and Winifrew Loew.”

Henry W. de Forest died in Nethermuir on May 29, 1938.  Julia would not stay on in the 79^th Street house for long; selling it in an all-cash deal to Frederick V. Fields in May 1940.  The future of the mansion as a private home was about to end.

Fields quickly resold the 20-room residence two months later.  The New York Times, on July 8, reported “the new owners are planning to remodel the structure at once with ten apartments ranging from one-and-one-half to five-room suites.”

Instead, they, too, rapidly turned it over.  It was sold on September 11 that year, and again in May 1945.  This time No. 63 received its delayed renovation, resulting in two upscale apartments per story with a doctor’s office on the ground floor. 

Perhaps the most celebrated residents were the family of architect Lawrence Grant White, principal in McKim, Mead & White and son of Stanford White.   The Whites were living here in 1955 when they announced the engagement of daughter Ann Octavia White to Harold Edgar Buttrick.  Following in the footsteps of her father and grandfather, Ann was currently studying architecture at Harvard University, as was her finance.

“Larry” White was more than an architect.  He was the author of Sketches and Designs by Stanford White, published in 1920 and his translation of Dante’s Divine Comedy into blank verse, published in 1948, had taken him 25 years to complete.  The Whites were still living in the 79^th Street apartment when Lawrence died in their St. James, Long Island, country home at the age of 68 on September 8, 1956.

The floor-to-ceiling paneling of the former library survives.  photo Curbed New York

The Adams mansion still contains the two apartments per floor as it did in 1946.  Happily, much of the Adams & Warren interiors survive.  Outside, the house is virtually unchanged since the Adams family moved in in 1903.

The 1907 Anson McCook Beard House -- No. 47 E. 68th Street

photo by Alice Lum

At high noon on April 3, 1902, New York attorney Anson McCook Beard was in the St. Paul mansion of James J. Hill, President of the Great Northern Railway and Northern Securities Company.  Beard was about to marry Hill’s daughter, Ruth.

The headline in the New York Times society pages that day remarked “Well-Known Capitalist’s Daughter Is Bride of New Yorker”   It was one of the first hints that Anson McCook Beard would forever play second-stage to his powerful father-in-law.

It was what The Times called a “quiet wedding” with only 130 guests, officiated by the St. Paul Archbishop.    As he had done for his eldest daughter, James Hill allowed Ruth to select a painting from “his splendid gallery.”  The newspaper added that “The bride, among other presents, received $250,000 in bonds from her father for pin money.”  J. P. Morgan added to the pile by giving Ruth a solid gold salver.

There would be no long European tour for the couple’s honeymoon.  Instead they went directly to North Oaks, the summer estate of James Hill near St. Paul.    Although there were distinct advantages to marrying into the Hill family, Beard doubtlessly realized he had a task ahead of him in keeping up with his bride’s daddy.

He brought his new wife back to New York City and before long plans were underway for an appropriate residence.  Beard purchased the brownstone rowhouse at No. 47 East 68^th Street in what was rapidly developing into a block of impressive mansions.   One-by-one the respectable but outdated homes of the 1870s were being altered or replaced by fashionable residences for the city’s upper class.  Beard intended his new home, just steps from Fifth Avenue and Central Park, to reflect his (and his wife’s) social and financial status.

The family ate in a Colonial-style dining room, watched over by a moose head -- photo collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The brownstone was razed in 1906 and construction began on the new mansion.  Designed by Adams & Warren, it would be a six-story Italian Renaissance showplace.   The house was completed in 1907 and, as was the customary among the upper classes, the title was in Ruth Beard’s name.  Three shallow stone steps led to the rusticated entrance under a handsome stone balcony that stretched nearly the width of the structure.  Deep, hefty pediments surmounted the second floor windows.  The top floor, in the steep mansard roof, sat behind a stone balustrade supported by a bracketed cornice.

The newly-completed house is flanked by still-surviving brownstones -- photo collection of the Museum of the City of New York

 The Beards settled in to the new mansion with their two children, Anson McCook Jr. and Mary, and became, as The New York Times would remark “well known in the social life of the city.”   The successful lawyer provided his family with summer estates in Tuxedo Park and Southampton.    He had been one of the leading athletes in his Yale class, and it was reflected in his choice of exclusive men’s clubs.   In addition to his membership in the Down Town club, a private men’s luncheon club, he was a member of the Racquet and Tennis Club and the Metropolitan Riding Club.

Ruth Beard's music room reflected the contemporary interest in Colonial Revival -- photo collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The advent of the Great Depression could not stop the elaborate preparations for the debut of daughter Mary Hill Beard in 1929.  The big night came on August 11 when the Beard’s presented their daughter with a dinner and dance at the Beach Club in Southampton.    It was a lavish affair with a extensive guest list peppered with society names like Belmont, Havemeyer, Carnegie, Whitney and Dodge.

Within weeks, however, the mood at the Beard Southampton estate grew less festive as Anson McCook Beard suffered “a stroke of apoplexy.”   He seemed briefly to improve and on September 8 The New York Times gave hope, still managing to put James J. Hill in the forefront.  “Anson Beard, son-in-law of the late James J. Hill, builder of the Great Northern Railroad, is recovering at his home here after a serious illness, Mrs. Beard said today.”

The East 68th Street Conservatory -- photo collection of the Museum of the City of New York

The recovery was not to be.  Anson Beard was moved to his Tuxedo Park house where the 55-year old attorney died at 3:00 in the afternoon on November 9, 1929.  His obituary the following day made clear note of his father-in-law.

The widowed Ruth Hill Beard returned with her children to East 68^th Street and observed the expected 12 months of mourning.  That being out of the way she announced her engagement, on December 30, 1930—exactly one year and 21 days after her husband’s death—to the fabulously wealthy Pierre Lorillard.   “The engagement is of wide interest, as it concerns families of much prominence here and in Tuxedo Park, where Mrs. Beard has a villa,” said The New York Times.  Lorillard’s father, incidentally, had founded that community.

Guest filed through the iron-grilled doors for the wedding of Ruth Beard to Pierre Lorillard --photo by Alice Lum

The wedding took place in the house on East 68^th Street less than two months later, on February 3.  The house was decorated “with palms, smilax and Spring flowers,” noted The Times and the choir from the Church of St. Paul the Apostle provided the music.  “During the ceremony they hummed a thirteenth-century hymn,” said the newspaper.   The couple honeymooned in Palm Beach.

Daughter Mary married Frederick C. Havemeyer II, and in March 1934 young Anson Beard became engaged to Rosanne Hoar.   In announcing the betrothal, The New York Times made particular note that “He is a grandson of the late James J. Hill, founder of the Great Northern Railroad.”  Even now, Anson McCook Beard could not get his proper recognition.

The second-story stair hall -- photo collection of the Museum of the City of New York

With the children grown and married Ruth Hill Beard Lorillard sold the house in which she had lived for nearly three decades.  It remained a private home until 1955 when the National Municipal League, Inc. purchased and renovated it for offices.   The organization, founded in 1894, was intended to unite reform groups in order to unseat corrupt local governments.

Somewhat surprisingly for a mid-20^th century renovation, architect James E. Casale preserved most of the architectural detailing.  The paneling of the 18-foot high library and ballroom survived, as did the six-foot high mantels in both rooms.  In order to preserve the exquisite plastered ceilings, drop ceilings were installed.

photo by Alice Lum

Then in 1988 Dr. Samuel Mandel purchased No. 47 East 68^th Street and reconverted it to residential purposes.   Mandel installed his dermatology office in the basement and transformed Ruth Beard’s mansion into two apartments—the first three floors became the home of the doctor and his wife, Annette; and the top two were now a luxurious rental duplex with two terraces.

Ten years later the doctor retired and rented the former medical offices to Keith de Lellis who established his vintage photography gallery here.    When Lellis left the space in 2006, Mandel put the house on the market for $26.8 million.   The 20-room mansion was reduced in price to $24, before Dr. Mandel finally accepted the surprisingly low offer of $19 million from 43-year old Carlos Aljandro Perz Davila.

The new owner began a one-year restoration and renovation.    Preservation architectural firm Preserv cleaned and repaired the stone façade, restored the wrought and cast iron decoration, and replaced the copper two-story mansard cladding.

A workman from Preserv replaces the copper cladding on the mansard level -- http://www.preservinc.com/47-east-68th-st.aspx#

Inside the 12,400 square foot mansion, designer Peter Marino created three condominium apartments.  Marino had already worked on the restoration of the Palazzo Sernagiotto in Venice and Britain’s Ascott House.   The designer promised that “the rooms are large, the ceilings are high, and there’s very ornate original detail—which will be kept.”

The house at No. 47 East 68^th Street, home to the daughter of a railroad baron and wife of a less-famous attorney, is remarkably preserved—a page from an elegant and lost period along this block.

photo by Alice Lum