Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Former Proskurover Zion Congregation - 431 East 6th Street


photograph by Carole Teller

In 1851, the family of Joseph Oehrlein lived in the newly completed flat house at 90 Sixth Street.  (The address would undergo several changes--it would be renumbered 90 Sixth Street in 1851, to 431 Sixth Street in 1868, and by the turn of the century the "East" would be added to the address.)  Like the other flat (or apartment) buildings long the block, it was likely designed in the Italianate style.

Joseph Oehrlein listed his profession variously as musician, singer and teacher of music.  He and his wife had at least one son, Joseph Jr.  Also living in the building in 1851 were Adam Lofferholz, a locksmith; police officer Luke Usher; and the family of carpenter Abraham Seaton.

The Musical Review & World July 30, 1864 (copyright expired)

The Oehrlein family remained here at least through 1864, by which time Joseph Jr. was working as a clerk.    

Around 1867, Valentine Kaemmerer moved his family into the building and converted the ground floor to a German meeting hall named Beethoven Hall.  The Beethoven Maennerchor, a singing group, was organized on August 16, 1859 and had 75 members, many of whom "are well-trained singers," according to the New York Herald.  Other men's singing groups also met here.  On May 17, 1869, The New York World reported on the city's various "German vocal societies."  The long list explained "what they are called and where they meet."  On the list was the Rheinischer Saengerbund, which met at "Beethoven Hall, 431 Sixth street, Saturdays."  Another group on the list was the Uhlandbund, "in honor of a German poet Uhland," said the article.  It met at 431 Sixth Street on Mondays and Thursdays. 

Kaemmerer also provided entertainment to the public.  On April 25, 1869, the New York Herald reported on the "principal places of summer resort for our German population."  In addition to the music or beer halls, however, there were "places equally inviting, because of their cheapness and because they contribute to enhance social enjoyment."  Listed among the latter grouping was "Kaemmerer's Beethoven Hall, No. 431 Sixth street." 

On June 28, 1870, the New York Herald reported, "A stranger passing through the east side of the city yesterday, from Houston street to Tenth, and from Second avenue to Avenue B, would have thought that it was a grand holiday.  The streets were crowded with Germans, and every window on the route had a German and American flag floating in the breeze."

The event was the cornerstone laying of a new Beethoven Hall.  "A multitude of Germans had assembled at 431 Sixth street, when, at about 2 o'clock, Sheriff James O'Brien arrived and received a hearty welcome from the members of the Maennerchor."  A procession wound through the East Village streets to the site.

Following the completion of the new Beethoven Hall, newspapers referred  to 431 East Sixth Street as "Little Beethoven Hall" or "Kaemmerer's Beethoven Hall."  With the musical groups gone, the hall became a popular venue for political meetings. 

As early as the fall of 1886, Charles Dudenhausen was the hall's proprietor.  It was the meeting place of the Joe Hooker Post, a veteran group.  On November 7, the New York Dispatch reported, "A pound party and hop will be given at Dudenhausen's Beethoven Hall, No. 431 Sixth street, on next Saturday evening, by the comrades of Jose Hooker Post."  The article noted, "Comrade Jos. Nohles's Band will furnish the music."  (A "pound party" was a gathering to which each attendee or couple brought a pound of foodstuffs like coffee, sugar, flour and such.  The staples were then distributed among the needy in the community.  A "hop" was a dance.)

The hall continued to host political meetings.  On January 11, 1894, The New York Sun reported that a meeting of "anti-Patterson Republicans" had met "at Little Beethoven Hall, 431 Sixth street."  The article described the group as "anti-machine Republicans."

Over the coming decades, the changing demographics of the neighborhood were reflected in the activities here.  By 1905, the Magyar Roosevelt Club, a Hungarian Republican club, held its meetings here.  On March 17, 1906, the group unveiled a portrait of President Theodore Roosevelt.  The New-York Tribune reported, "The portrait, half length, was painted by Julius Tammasy, a young Hungarian artist, who recently came to the country."

Major change came in 1927.  On February 5, the Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported that architect Philip Bardes had completed plans to renovate 431 East 6th Street to "a four-story brick store, synagogue and residence...for the Center of Prosgurever [sic] Zion Congregation."  The alterations would cost the congregation the equivalent of $371,000 in 2026.

The Proskurover Zion Congregation was founded in 1900 by 20 young immigrants from Proskurov in western Ukraine.  Bardes stripped off the facade and replaced it with Flemish bond beige brick.  His vaguely neo-Classic design included arched openings at the first and second floors.  The tympana of first floor windows were inscribed with Magen Davids, and between the French windows of the second floor were stone tablets carved with menorahs.  A stone plaque above the doorway was inscribed in English and Hebrew, "Center of the Proskurover Zion Congregation."  Atop the brick-and-stone parapet was a rod-supported Magen David.

image via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

The New York Times was not especially complimentary to the synagogue in its article on May 5, 1958.  "A proud and once warlike people honored their dead yesterday in a dingy hall on East Sixth Street.  Members of the Cossack community met to honor cavalry men who fell in battle with Bolshevik forces."  The article noted, "The day was chosen because on May 4, 1918, regiments of Don Cossacks under General of Cavalry Peter Popoff captured Novocherkassk, the capital of the State of the Army of the Don, from the Communists."

At some point in the third quarter of the century, the Proskurover Zion Congregation quietly left 431 East 6th Street.  On December 30, 2015, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported that Rabbi Michael Strassfeld had been researching the congregation.  The article said he, "has been unable to gather any more details about the congregation (when did it shut its doors?)."

What is certain is that in 1988 the building was converted to loft residents by a group of artists.  An art gallery was installed in the cellar.  There were now two apartments on the first floor and one each on the upper stories.  In the process, the Magen Davids were filled in on the first floor and the menorahs shaved off on the second.  The Star of David above the parapet was, as well, removed.  Oddly enough, the panel above the entranceway was not erased.

photograph by Carole Teller

Among the early residents was photographer William Wegman.  Born in 1943, he was perhaps best known for his compositions of posed dogs in various costumes.

William Wegman and two of his dogs in front of a few of his works.  from the collection of the Library of Congress.

In 2015, Peter Kohn, described by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency as "a veteran construction supervisor," inspected a vacant six-story office building on the Upper West Side.  In the basement, his flashlight illuminated a pair of large tablets leaning against the wall.  The marble slabs were engraved with Yiddish lettering.  Hoping to prevent their ending up in a landfill, Kohn took photographs and looked for someone who could identify them.  The newspaper reported, "They were from the Proskurover Zion Congregation, a long-defunct congregation in the East Village."

The translated inscriptions revealed that they were "mostly lists of names of members of, and contributors to, the shul and its women's auxiliary," said the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.  They were entrusted to Rabbi Michael Strassford.  The article explained that the retired leader was "best known as an author of the series of 'Jewish Catalog' do-it-yourself guides to Jewish life in the 1970s [and who] collects such artifacts."

The menorahs were shaved off the panels flanking the second floor window.  photograph by Carole Teller

The grossly unsympathetic replacement windows, entrance door and painting of the first floor masonry are regrettable.  Nevertheless, its rescue by the 1988 group of artists is laudable.

many thanks to artist Carole Teller for suggesting this post

No comments:

Post a Comment