Monday, November 16, 2026

The Lost Steinway & Sons Factory - Park Avenue and 52nd Street


Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)

Heinrich Engellhardt Steinweg invented a small piano for his son in 1834, using a combination of German and English construction methods.  It drew attention of musicians and sparked a massive change in his family's lives.  Upon arriving in New York in 1850, Steinweg anglicized his name to Henry Engelhardt Steinway.  In March 1853, he and sons Charles and Henry Jr. established Steinway & Sons in "a curiously small edifice in Varick-street," according to The New York Times later.  The workrooms turned out one instrument a week.  Henry's grandson, William (son of Henry Jr.) was admitted to the firm in 1856.

William Steinway was highly involved in the German music association, the Liederkranz Society.  Equally active in the group was architect Louis Burger (both men would be elected president).  It was likely that this close relationship resulted in Burger's being commissioned to design a new Steinway & Sons factory uptown.

At the time of William's joining the firm, the firm had exploded in business.  With a reputation of creating high-quality instruments, Steinway & Son was emerging as a world-class piano maker.  The chosen site for the factory was the block of Fourth Avenue (later Park Avenue) and Lexington Avenue, and from 52nd to 53rd Streets.  Ground was broken in 1859 and construction completed the following year.  On September 1, 1860, The New York Times remarked, "The cost of the building and ground is about $150,000."  The figure would translate to about $6 million in 2026.

Burger created an inverted L-shaped building in the Italianate style.  Four and five stories tall, the Fourth Avenue front was divided into nine three-bay wide sections.  Eight were identical, their rows of repeated elliptically arched windows capped with hefty brick lintels.  The central section relieved the monotony, rising above the roofline with a gable outlined with arched, brick corbels.  Here the openings were fully arched and two decorative balconies added flair.

Cartographer William Parris's 1862 Fire Insurance Map shows the original L-shaped footprint.  Notice the Steinway lumber yards across East 53rd Street.  (copyright expired)

In the rear yard were outbuildings, like the four drying houses where "about 240,000 feet of lumber [are] constantly under the process of kiln-drying," reported Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper on September 22, 1860.  

Part of the basement was devoted to "all the iron-work, places and bars, drilling-machines, japanning works, and the rosewood veneers."  

Workers busy in the finishing department where the empty cabinets still sit on sawhorses.  Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)

Other departments included planers, case-makers, a varnishing room ("where every case remains from three to four months, to be thoroughly varnished," according to The New York Times), the sounding-board floor, and a floor where "the instruments are strung, the action and key-boards fitted in, and the tops, legs, and lyres adjusted and put on."  There were also a department for finishing and polishing, and a salesroom.   

Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper deemed the new factory "magnificent" and reported on a particular innovation, the "telltale clocks."  Placed at the far ends of the building, the two clocks tested "the trustworthiness of the night watchman."  The clocks were connected to stations throughout the building, "and if they are not touched at certain intervals the watcher has neglected his rounds, and the tale is recorded on the faces of the dials," said the article.

The factory communicated with the Steinway salesroom on Walter Street by a private, short-distance telegraph.  (The distance would be shortened in 1863 when Steinway & Sons erected its new building at 109 East 14th Street.)

Smart carriages with well-dressed visitors arrive to the factory's opening on August 31, 1860.  from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

Steinway & Sons opened its new factory on August 31, 1860.  The New York Times reported, There was a large and very respectable number of visiters [sic] present."  Musicians were on hand to demonstrate the various pianos.

Visitors to the opening listen to a pianist demonstrating a Steinway grand piano.  Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, September 22, 1860 (copyright expired)


The New York Times reported on September 1, 1860 that the 350 skilled craftsmen "turn out about thirty square and five grand pianos every week" from the new factory.  But within only three years, the facility was inadequate.  On May 10, 1864, according to The New York Times, Steinway & Sons simultaneously opened its new East 14th Street showroom and "an additional wing to their factory."  Now, said the article, it forms "three sides of a square" and noted, "They employ many hundred hands, and use all the labor-saving machinery that has yet been discovered by themselves or others, to expedite the various processes."  Steinway & Sons was now, said The New York Times, "the largest piano-forte makers in the world."

The new wing extended along East 52nd Street. Valentine's Manual of Old New York, 1919 (copyright expired) 

Always innovating, in 1878 Steinway & Sons introduced its Parlor Grand.  At six-feet long, it was 12-inches shorter than a regulation grand piano.  On December 23, the New-York Express reported, "This new style, lately introduced, has created a genuine sensation in musical circles at home and abroad, and the demand is so large that the Steinways cannot promptly supply enough of them."  The article noted in an exhausting run-on sentence:

Steinway & Sons are the only manufacturers who make every part and particle used in the construction of a piano, from the iron plate of a grand piano to the smallest hitch-pin for the strings, in their own factory, which is now conceded to be not only the most perfectly-arranged, but by far the most extensive establishment of its kind in existence, supplying these standard pianos to all parts of the civilized world.

The Steinway factory was a strictly non-union establishment.  Its highly-skilled craftsmen were well-treated.  Nevertheless, other labor groups targeted the factory during their own strikes.  In June 1872, for instance, the furniture-maker union went on strike, headed by the "Eight Hour Men," who demanded that work days be reduced from ten to eight hours.  On June 13, things got ugly.  The New-York Tribune reported that "between 200 and 300 strikers surrounded the factory," noting that, "The crowd was largely composed of men who did not represent the piano-forte trade."  The newspaper added, "as there was a rumored intention to destroy the building, the police of the Nineteenth Precinct were called out."

In 1882, a strike that did involve the Steinway workers took place, and its cause was surprising.  The New-York Tribune explained, "They were not dissatisfied with their wages; but they did not like one of the bookkeepers."  The workers demanded that the bookkeeper be fired.  When that did not happen, a group of employers walked out.  

On November 21, the New-York Tribune reported, "This was nine weeks ago, in nice, pleasant weather, when idleness was delightful."  Steinway & Sons retained its bookkeeper but fired the strikers.  Now, said the article, "finally the cold weather has forced the strikers to beg for work.  The bookkeeper is not discharged.  They have gained nothing.  What is worse, they probably have learned nothing."  The workers were given their jobs back, but the newspaper was distinctly unsympathetic.  "This was clearly a case where the men should have been kept out in the cold."

In the meantime, on June 22, 1875, the New-York Tribune reported on the progress of the "sinking" of the Fourth Avenue railroad tracks.  The locomotives that ran down the middle of the avenue had belched smoke and cinders and made the thoroughfare undesirable for residential use.  "The work of sinking the track was begun in the Fall of 1872," said the article.  Now, "the first train to run all the way from the Grand Central Depot to the Harlem River upon the sunken tracks" had taken place two days earlier.  The "improvement" would greatly affect the Steinway & Sons factory location.

On December 2, 1904, the New-York Tribune reported on a rumor that the New-York Central Railroad had purchased the factory property "for the purpose of carrying out its plans for bettering the Grand Central Station" neighborhood.  Charles H. Steinway replied that the factory had stood "for the last fifty years, and I think it is likely to be on the site for fifty more years."

But on June 13, 1909, The Sun remarked, "Since the locomotive was banished from the New York Central tunnel a number of costly private dwellings have been erected in the avenue and many more will of course be built there."  The article reported that E. Clifford Potter had purchased the Steinway factory property.  "When the new owner obtains possession next year the block will no doubt be cut up into sites for private dwellings or elevator apartment houses," said the article.

Steinway & Sons erected a sprawling facility in Long Island City.  On November 19, 1910, The New York Times reported that the firm had vacated the Park Avenue site and E. Clifford Potter would "devote the entire plot to one or more large apartment houses."  The massive Montana apartment building, known as "the House of Millionaires," according to The Edison Monthly in October 1919, replaced the factory.  (It survived until 1954, replaced by the Seagram Building.)

photo by Wurts Bros, from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

No comments:

Post a Comment