Saturday, November 21, 2026

The 1845 George D. Phelps House - 35 West Eighth Street



In 1845, Zebedee Cook, Jr. erected a high-end home at 107 Clinton Place (renumbered 35 West Eighth Street around 1890).  Cook almost assuredly used the same builder as his neighbor, J. B. Herrick, whose nearly identical house next door at 105 had been completed three years earlier.    

A stone stoop led to the entrance above the English basement.  Three full floors were capped by a squat attic level, typical of the Greek Revival style, and a simple wooden cornice ran along the roofline.  

Cook sold 107 Clinton Place to George D. Phelps and his wife, H. Augusta Ayres.  The president of the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad Company, Phelps was as much involved in charities as he was in business.  He served as a trustee for the Asylum for Friendless Boys, was a manager of the Protestant Half Orphan Asylum, and a manager of the Demilt Dispensary.  Augusta was his third wife, his two previous wives having died in 1831 and 1844.

The Phelpses' residency was surprisingly short-lived.  In marketing the house, Phelps gave a detailed description in his advertisement in the New York Morning Courier in 1856:

For Sale--The superior built house, No. 107 Clinton Place, finished a few years since, by G. D. Phelps for his own use.  The house is 25 by about 50, 3-story and attic, and a 2-story enclosed piazza, finished for a library.  The drawing-rooms are in beautiful order, and of the style of 10 or 12 years since, viz:--2 Rooms deep, mahogany sliding doors: plated furniture, &c, &c.  The house has gas, water, furnace, &c., and ready for occupancy at 5 days' notice.  To a party wishing what is now difficult, that is to say a most comfortable house, thoroughly and completely built, and not three rooms deep--this one will be likely to suit.

The new buyer operated the residence as a high-end boarding house, not uncommon in the tony neighborhood.  An advertisement in the New-York Times on December 5, 1857 offered, "Very desirable and well furnished front rooms (parlor and bedroom) on third floor can be had, with board, in this convenient and pleasant location, if applied for immediately.  Dinner at 6."

The exclusivity of boarding houses was reflected in the number of residents--the fewer the more upscale.  It appears that the proprietor, Virginia Simonet (whose husband, Louis, was an optician), accepted only about two or three at a time.  Among the first boarders were Ellen M. Russell, the widow of Captain Francis S. K. Russell, and her adult son, Edwin, here in 1857, and Dr. Von Moschzisker, who practiced from his rooms in 1860 and '61.

An advertisement in the July 14, 1860 issue of Harper's Weekly read, "'Deafness and Its Fatal Effects on the Brain and Speech,' will shortly be published by Dr. Von Moschzisker, oculist and aurist, now practising his new system or restoring the sight and hearing at 107 Clinton Place, New York."  And an advertisement in the New York Herald the following month touted "his newly invented ear vaporizer which restores the hearing in the most obstinate cases as well as stops the noise in the head."

Ellen Russell and Edwin Russell left the boarding house following Ellen's marriage to John Walton on October 17, 1858.  A daughter, also named Ellen, was born about a year later.  But what the New York Herald called "some private difficulties" soon arose.  Ellen sued her husband when he refused to give her an accounting of "moneys alleged to have been loaned to him from her separate estate."  The amount was "near $5,000," according to the newspaper.  (The loan would convert to a substantial $202,000 in 2026.)  Walton denied his wife had ever loaned him any money.

On July 2, 1860 the New York Herald reported, "A double murder was perpetrated in Eighteenth street on Saturday night, near Third avenue.  Mr. John Walton, a wealthy distiller...was shot down in cold blood, and with evident premeditation, and died in a few hours of his wounds."  The "flying murderer" was chased a few blocks by several pedestrians.  The culprit turned and fired, fatally wounding John W. Matthews.  Four days after the article, Mayor Fernando Wood offered a $500 reward for the capture of the culprit.

Suspicion soon turned to Ellen Walton and her son, Edwin Russell.  At least one witness testified that Edwin owned two pistols.  In court on December 23, 1861, Ellen was asked, "Did you not tell your son Edwin that you would give him $2,000 if he would shoot Mr. Walton?"  She denied it, as she did the next question, "Did you not go out with him to shoot Mr. Walton?"

Under intense questioning, however, Ellen crumbled.  On the stand she said Edwin committed the murder because, "he said my name had been disgraced in the newspapers in connection with the bill of separation with Mr. Walton."  Ellen blamed it on Edwin's drug use, saying he took laudanum, adding, "I told him that the Walton family had scandalized me; they had told Mr. Field that I had danced before the servants naked."

Ellen's moving tale and emotional testimony swayed the all-male jury.  She was released.  But, considering the circumstances of Walton's death, it took Ellen until October 1863 to receive her share of his estate.  

The boarding house had been taken over by Mary L. Humphreys at the time.  Never married, she died in the house at the age of 67 on August 23, 1868.

Franklin A. Thurston sold 107 Clinton Place to Daniel P. Ingraham on September 1, 1873 for $24,500.  The price would be equal around $680,000 in today's dollars.  Like his predecessor, Ingraham purchased the property as an investment and it continued to be operated as a boarding house, now run by Marriett (known as Mary) E. O'Brien.

Mary's boarders were a bit less refined that those of a decade earlier.  In June 1874, she took in a newly-arrived couple from Providence, Rhode Island.  Julia Ann Sweet found a job in Knight's saloon at Hudson and Broome Street.  Only two weeks later, The Sun ran the headline, "A Young Wife Kidnapped / The Astonishing Story that is Told by Mrs. Julia Ann Sweet."

According to Julia, when she returned from work late Saturday night, June 27, she was "unable to obtain admission at her lodgings without arousing all the inmates of the house."  So she went to a hotel and spent the night.  The next morning she went to the home of a cook employed at Knight's and had a cup of coffee.  Julia said the coffee was drugged, she fell into a "profound sleep," and did not wake up until Monday morning.  She related that she found herself "in a room at 198 South Fifth avenue with a colored ruffian who threatened to kill her if she made any outcry."

Julia, described by The Sun as "an attractive woman about twenty-five years of age," claimed that her kidnapper disguised her in clothing found in the room, and took her to a house on Watts Street, "where she was kept under the influence of narcotics until night."  The apparent nightmare stretched on for a week when, according to Julia, her kidnapper released her "on promise that she should not tell anyone what had occurred" under the threat of being shot.  Immediately upon returning to their Clinton Place rooms, Julia told her husband her terrifying story.  He, of course, went to the police.

Officers went to the Watts Street address where they arrested Gabriel Smith.  It appears that Julia's "extraordinary" story fell apart in court.  On July 2, the New York Evening Express reported, "Gabriel Smith, charged with kidnapping Mrs. Julia Ann Sweet, of 107 Clinton place...was to-day discharged by Justice Wandell."

Boarding with Mary O'Brien in 1876 was John Trouilh, who ran a billiard parlor, and Leon Bejoues, who listed his profession as "liquors."  Both men operated from 679 Broadway.  Sarah Bernhardt (not the famous actress with the same name), who lived here in 1884, typified the decreasing respectability of the tenants.

At 2:00 on the morning of August 7 that year, Sarah was arrested by policeman George Noll, charged with disorderly conduct.  The officer reported that "she was at Varick and Canal Streets with a drunken man, who appeared to have money."  Suspecting that she intended to rob the man, Noll ordered her to move along.  She refused, became "abusive," and was taken to jail.

Sarah's story, was much deeper and more tragic.  The New York Times said, "Of late she has been too well known in the streets."  Until 1881 she was known as Elia Gluckmeyer, the wife of well-to-do bookkeeper Adolph Gluckmeyer.  He lost his job with Dunn, Barlow & Co. that year and they "separated after much bickering," according to The New York Times.  Gluckmeyer refused to support his wife.  While Sarah claimed that she made a living as a seamstress, she was sent to the penitentiary in 1883 for stealing clothes.

Ironically, it appears that Sarah had not intended to rob the man.  He turned out to be James Cox, who also lived at 107 Clinton Place.  When he tried to intervene, he, too, was arrested and fined $5.

Harry M. Wright and his wife, Kitty, appeared in newspapers for even worse reasons in 1886.  They were arrested on January 5 for "having abducted and detained from her home Minnie Baker, otherwise known as Minnie Vancaryzeele, the 13-year-old stepdaughter of Louis Vancaryzeele," according to The New York Times.  

According to Kitty, she had found Minnie crying on 14th Street.  "She told me she had no home to go to, and as she was wet and hungry I took her home with me and gave her food and shelter for the night."  Minnie's story was only slightly different, saying "the woman's husband gave her some hot whiskey to drink and afterward went to sleep."

A New-York Tribune reporter described 107 Clinton Place as containing "a number of separate rooms which are let furnished for light housekeeping."  He interviewed the landlady who defended the Wrights, saying "So far as I am able to judge, [Kitty] is a respectable woman.  Mrs. Wright and her husband take their meals outside or have them sent to their rooms.  I have never seen either of them under the influence of liquor."  Happily for the couple, the case against them was dismissed.

Such was not the case with another boarder, Edward Lombard.  On August 7, 1886 The New York Times reported that he "was sent to Sing Sing Prison for four years...yesterday, for stabbing James Kehoe, a janitor of a flat at No. 75 South Fifth-avenue, during a quarrel two weeks ago."

As late as 1940, 33 (right) and 35 West Eighth Street retained much of their early 19th century appearance.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

By the last decade of the 19th century, West 8th Street had become intensely commercial.  Around 1895, the stoop was removed from 35 West Eighth Street and two-story commercial space installed.  In 1896, Bernard Kahn operated his upholstery business, B. Kahn & Co. here, likely on the ground floor.  The other space was shared by Joseph Laguttuta's shoe store and Peter J. Petersen's leggings shop.  The three businesses would remain through the turn of the century.

Following World War I, the Chelsea Bookshop was at 35 West 8th Street.  It remained until 1930, when the commercial space was converted for a restaurant.   Another renovation would come six years later.  The building was sold in October 1936 to Morris Luskin, president of the newly-formed 35 West Eighty Street Corporation.  The New York Sun noted, "The building will be altered by Mr. Luskin, with the first two floors developed for business and the upper three floors with apartments."  The remodeling resulted in two apartments each on the upper floors.

The two-story commercial space was leased to Ohio-based Richard W. Kasse Company.  On February 28, 1937, The New York Times reported that the store's opening "will mark the entry of an old Cleveland concern into the New York field."  The firm, which manufactured bakery products and candies, had ambitious plans.  "Within the next two or three months," said officials, "the firm will open about thirty retail units in Manhattan and the Bronx."

The second half of the century saw a diverse stream of commercial tenants.  In the early 1960's, the Michael Malce shop was here, described by The New York Times in July 1962 as "one of the most intriguing gift shops in town."  The following decade saw Mamie's Ice Cream Parlor here.

Following the turn of the century, Cachaca, a jazz club, occupied the ground floor.  A quick succession of clubs followed, culminating in 2021 with the opening of the cocktail bar Mace.



While the lower two floors have been heavily altered and the upper facade covered with a stucco-like material, the 1845 domestic personality of the Phelps house is still evident.

photographs by the author

No comments:

Post a Comment