Friday, November 20, 2026

The Much Altered David J. Ely House - 32 West 37th Street


 photograph by Carole Teller

David Josiah Ely had lived a robust life by the time he arrived in New York City in 1869.  Born in 1828 in upstate New York, he started out as a boatman, The Columbia Republic recalling decades later that he "sailed up and down the Hudson on sloops and schooners."  Then, at the onset of the Gold Rush in 1849, "he was one of the Argonauts who left for the Pacific coast to dig for the yellow metal," said the article.

In 1855, he married Charlotte B. Comfort.  He continued as a sailor, serving on the steamer Thomas Powell, a government mail and hospital boat.  When the couple moved to New York City, Ely purchased the Commercial, a well-known restaurant on Front Street.

It was likely Ely's prospecting in the West that afforded him and Charlotte to live the comfortable lifestyle of the merchant class.  They purchased the 25-foot-wide, four-story-and-basement townhouse at 32 West 37th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues in 1869.  Erected around two years earlier, it was faced in brownstone and its high stone stoop, corniced windows, and handsome cast metal terminal cornice were typical of other high-end, Italianate-style residences in the fashionable neighborhood.

Charlotte Berry Comfort was born in May 1830.  She and David had two children when they moved into 32 West 37th Street: James Victor, born in 1856, and Henry de Forrest, born in 1864.  Two others would be born in the house.  Charlotte Bulkley arrived in 1870 and George Day in 1875.  Sadly, those two would not survive to adulthood.  George died at three years old in 1878 and Charlotte died the following year at the age of nine.

Like other wives of her financial and social class, Charlotte threw herself into charitable causes.  The same year they arrived in New York, she became a member of the ladies' association of The Shepherd's Fold, which was organized "to support orphans and other friendless children."  And by 1875 she was treasurer of the New York Medical College for Women (of which her husband was a trustee).

Affluent families closed up their townhouses and spent the summer months at their country homes.  Husbands, like David Ely, who had to oversee their businesses, would move into their clubs and visit on the weekends.  The summer social season had already begun on June 10, 1873, but Charlotte Ely and the children were still in Manhattan.  The advertisement she placed that morning may explain the delay:

Wanted--A first class cook, well recommended, to go to the country for about three months; proving satisfactory would insure a permanent place on return to the city; Protestant preferred.

Around 1880, the Ely family relocated to Hudson County, New York.  The West 37th Street house became home to Peter Moller Jr. and his wife, the former Ann E. Platt.  Ann was "a member of an old New York family," as described by The New York Times.  The couple had two children, Edwin Clarence and Adelina.

Born in England in 1834, Peter was brought to the United States by his father in 1837.  The elder Moller co-founded the Havemeyer & Moller sugar refining company.  He was described by The New York Times later as "a pioneer in the sugar refining business in this country."  The Moller mansion sat at 319 Fifth Avenue. 

The younger Peter Moller eventually became head of the Moller Sugar Refining Company.  He had been retired for a few years when he and Ann purchased 32 West 37th Street.  

The Mollers' domestic staff included a laundress, cook, maid, and governess, a valet (or butler) and ladies' maid.  Interestingly, rather than a waitress (the polished servant, almost always a woman, who served in the dining room and parlor), the Mollers seem to have always had a "waiting man."

Because the Moller family always spent their summers abroad, many on their staff scrambled to find new positions each spring.  An advertisement in May 1888 read: "A young colored man as waiter in private family; is single; willing and obliging; city or country; can be seen with first class references from his last employer, 32 West 37th st. (present employer's)."  Exactly two years later, on May 8, 1890, Ann advertised: "By a lady, place for her waiter man.  A young Swede, whom she can recommend very highly; careful with china and glass; neat, competent and very obliging.  Call at 32 West 37th this morning."

It was Peter Moller's close friendship with King George I of Greece that prompted the family's summer sojourns.  The New York Times explained that Peter  was "an intimate friend of the King of Greece...Mr. Moller spent much of his time in the company of the King while visiting Aix le Bains, Savole, each Summer."

Society columns closely followed the Mollers' movements.  On April 17, 1902, for instance, The New York Times reported, "Among the dinners given last evening was one of twenty covers by Mr. and Mrs. Peter Moller, 32 West Thirty-seventh Street."  Five months later, on September 21, the newspaper reported, "Mr. and Mrs. Peter Moller, Miss Moller, and Edward Clarence Moller, sail early in October, after a few weeks in London.  They have been as usual at Aix les Bains this Summer."  And on December 12, The New York Times announced, "Mr. and Mrs. Peter Moller, who arrived from Europe a fortnight ago, have opened their residence at 32 West Thirty-seventh Street for the season."

Ann Moller was involved in a frightening accident on April 4, 1905.  The New York Times reported, "Her brougham and a Wells Fargo express wagon were the chief vehicles in the mix-up caused by a runaway express horse, although there were others."  It appears that the express horse, named "Ole Billie," was spooked by an automobile on Sixth Avenue.  He crashed the wagon into a streetcar, "shaking out a trail of express packages behind him," then crashed into Ann Moller's brougham (a one-horse, closed carriage).  One of the glass windows was shattered and a wheel was "wrenched."  The article said, "Mrs. Moller, who is an elderly woman, was bruised and shocked, but she was able to walk home."

In May 1907, Peter became ill.  His condition rapidly worsened into pneumonia and he died a week later on May 16.  His funeral was held in the Church of the Transfiguration on the 20th.

Ann and Adelina remained at 32 West 37th Street for a few years.  But commerce was quickly engulfing the once refined neighborhood.  The women moved into a suite in the Ritz-Carlton as early as 1917.

On March 23, 1918, The Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported that De Rosa & Pereira had filed plans for altering 32 West 37th Street "into a dwelling and store."  Two years later, on April 17, 1920, the New York Herald announced that the Peter Moller estate had sold the property to Scully Brothers Company.  The article said the firm "will alter and occupy the premises."

The alterations removed the stoop and installed a commercial space on the ground floor, now home to the Scully Brothers Company, a high-end leather goods firm founded in 1906.  The former parlor level became its showroom.  During World War I, the firm had produced flight jackets and helmets for pilots.  The upper floors was converted to apartments, the Department of Buildings warning, "not more than 2 families cooking independently on premises."

By 1927, the commercial space was occupied by an off-shoot of Scully Brothers Company, Scully Hats, Inc.  The varied tenant list at the time included Leonette Aveduke, a 21-year-old teacher; Mr. and Mrs. E. T. Meyers; Rex Adams, a "scenario writer," on the third floor;  25-year-old Madeline Mass, who lived on the same floor; designer Ray Walmar; Jean Murray, who worked as a manicurist; art student Harrison H. Hendricks; and 42-year-old portrait and landscape painter Charles W. Svensson.

Svensson was the uncle of actress Gloria Swanson.  The New York Times said the movie star "visited him several times and sat for him" here.  

Charles W. Svensson was likely living at 32 West 37th Street in 1924 when he painted After the Bath.  (private collection.)

At 6:00 on the morning of May 1, 1927, Rex Adams left his apartment for a walk.  At the head of the stairs he encountered a "billow of smoke."  The building had no fire escapes and the stairway was blocked.  He shouted to the other tenants, then rushed into his bedroom where he jerked the sheets from his bed and knotted them into a rope.  In the meantime, Madeline Mass had entered his apartment.  "You'll have to slide down.  It's your only chance."  Madeline was afraid the sheets would fail, so Adams climbed down first.  She followed, but became exhausted after two floors and dropped one floor to the ground.  She was not seriously injured.

Three policemen (all of whom were injured) rushed into the building.  They helped Mr. and Mrs. Meyers get to the fire escape on the adjoining building.  Jean Murray and Ray Walmar were rescued from a third-floor window by firefighters from Hook and Ladder Company 24.  Harrison Hendricks climbed down the firetruck ladder unaided.

Both Leonette Aveduke and Charles Svensson occupied top floor apartments.  Trapped, Leonette forced open Svensson's door and "climbed out on a ledge" from his window.  The New York Times reported, "She crawled to the corner of the building and then jumped to the fire-escape of the three-story building adjoining."  Grimly, the young teacher had had to pass the body of Charles Svensson in rescuing herself.  The New York Times reported that he, "had apparently opened in inner door of his apartment...and was overcome by smoke.  His body had fallen across the threshold."

As early as 1938, Hermann Bryner's Swiss restaurant occupied the second floor, while Harry Dence's hosiery shop was at sidewalk level.

Hermann Bryner's Swiss restaurant was on the second floor when this photograph was taken in 1940.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services.

In 1954, the Hideway restaurant opened here.  On October 20, The New York Times food critic described, "The Thirty-seventh Street Hideway is really hidden away--up a flight of dusty carpeted stairs at 32 West Thirty-seventh Street."  She noted, "The establishment is one of the few in the neighborhood that offers dishes with an Italian and French accent."

New York Magazine, March 14, 1994

In reviewing the restaurant a decade later, Craig Claiborn mentioned, "The Hideaway, said to have been patronized in former years by John Barrymore, is a study in red and shadows with flocked wallpaper, a large chandelier and a smokey mirror."  Readers took the mention of the famous actor and ran with it.  For decades later, newspaper articles would refer to 32 West 37th Street as the former home of John Barrymore.

In 1980, the Hideaway took over the ground floor as well, expanding from a restaurant to a supper club.  On May 10, 1980, critic Howard Thompson explained, "A new dining area has been added on the main floor of the midblock structure where young John Barrymore once lived."  The second floor, called the Red Blazer, now offered live entertainment.

Nearly half a century after it opened, the Hideaway was supplanted by Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse, the second location of its namesake on West 45th Street, which opened in 1926.  On January 1, 2003, The New York Times reported that the owners had "just completed a multimillion-dollar renovation of the former Hideaway."  The article said, "Its location, a town house that was a former home of John Barrymore's, features a back room on the second floor with a spectacular working fireplace and stained glass skylight."  Included in the renovations was a new two-story storefront.  Its chocolate-colored stucco mimics brownstone and scrolled brackets echo the mid-19th century cornice.

many thanks to artist Carole Teller for suggesting this post

No comments:

Post a Comment