Wednesday, January 13, 2021

The Latimer Bailey House - 243 West 14th Street

 



Andrew Norwood, who was described by Valentine's Manual of New York as a "solid and substantial" citizen,  recognized the investment potential of real estate along West 14th Street in the mid-1840's.  As sumptuous homes rose around the rim of the newly completed Union Square in 1845, its refined residential tone spread east and west along 14th Street.  In 1845 Norwood began construction on the first of three abutting houses at Nos. 159, 161 and 163 West 14th Street.   All three would be completed by 1847.  Norwood moved his family into the middle house and by early 1853 had sold No. 163 (renumbered 243 in 1868) to Latimer Bailey.

Described as a "first-class" dwelling, the 25-foot wide brick-fronted house was a blend of Italianate and Greek Revival styles.  A wide brownstone stoop led to the entrance above the high English basement.  The floor-to-ceiling parlor windows were fronted by a cast iron balcony.  

Latimer Bailey was a drygoods merchant and importer whose business was located at No. 54 Pine Street.    His wife was the former Augusta Keese.  Along with their son, John K., they shared the 17-room house their daughter's family.  Eliza Ann Keese Bailey was married to Robert M. McJimsey, a partner in the brokerage firm of Jackson & McJimsey.  They had four small children, Emma, Silliman, Snyder and Lucetta.  Another child, Robert, Jr. was born in 1855. 

The large family depended on a staff of several servants.  Augusta was seeking to fill two of those positions in April 1856 when she advertised:

Wanted--Two colored women; one as cook, the other as chambermaid.  Good reference required.  Apply at 163 West 14th st.

The outbreak of Civil War--known in the North at the time as the War of the Rebellion--caused upheaval in lives throughout the city and within the Bailey house, as well.  Robert McJimsey was a member of the National Guard's Seventh Regiment, known popularly as the "Silk Stocking Regiment" because its members came from some of the city's wealthiest families.  On June 9, 1861, the New York Herald reported, "A new branch of the service is being organized by a number of experienced members of the Seventh regiment, National Guard, under the names of the Clinton Voltigeurs and Clinton Rifles."  Among those preparing to march off to war was Lt. Robert McJimsey.

Like all well-to-do families, the Bailey-McJimsey family spent the summer months away from the city.  Augusta's staff at the country home was noticeably trimmed down, as evidenced in her advertisement in 1861:

Wanted--A Protestant Woman, as cook and washer and ironer in a private family, a short distance in the country; must be a good baker and understand the dairy.  A girl of 14 to 20 years of age, in same family, as chambermaid.

Although the family would continue to live in the 14th Street house through 1865, in 1862 Latimer Bailey transferred title of the property to his unmarried sister, Eliza T. Bailey.  She never moved in, however.  By the time her brother's family moved out, several of the opulent homes along West 14th Street were already being operated as upscale boarding houses.  Eliza leased No. 243 to Rose Hann, the widow of Roseby Hann, who used it for that purpose in 1866.

The refinement and status of boarding houses were reflected in the number of residents--the fewer the boarders the more exclusive.  In 1866 the tenants enjoyed an entire floor.  Two advertisements appeared that year, one offering the "delightful second floor," furnished or unfurnished, with "first class Board."  The other read: "To Let--With Board, a Parlor Floor, three rooms deep, furnished or unfurnished; private table if desired."

The mention of "private table" was significant, meaning that Rose was willing to serve the parlor floor boarders in their rooms, should they prefer not to sit with the other boarders in the common dining room in the lower level.

Among her boarders in 1867 were attorney Henry Brodhead and his widowed mother, Emily, and banker John D. Bolles.   The Brodheads would remain through 1871.

In 1872 Rose's boarders were the family of clothing merchant James Oliphant; Henry Berkele, a dealer in guns; and iron merchant Andrew J. Campbell.  Oliphant's adult son, William J., was a tailor and worked in his father's business.  Rose Hann leased the house until the spring of 1873.

By the late 1870's widow Mary A. Raymond was the landlady of the boarding house.  Among her boarders in 1879 were Henry J. Parks and John O. Phair, both of whom were clerks, a position with a broad meaning that ranged from highly-paid bank employees to office workers.  That year she made significant renovations to the basement level by installing a commercial space.  Upon its completion she leased it to E. C. Houghton's piano store.

Among the boarders in 1897 was the well-to-do widow Elizabeth Kley and her granddaughter, 13-year old Elise Steele.  The New York Journal said Elizabeth "fairly dotes on her," and described the girl as "unusually well developed for her age, and very pretty."  When Elise disappeared on March 28, Elizabeth thought she knew why.  She told a reporter that the girl "ran away from home because she didn't like the convent where she was going to school."

Detectives searched for a month with no leads.  And that was because Elise's disappearance went beyond any dissatisfaction with her school.  She had been "lured away" and taken aboard a steamship, the Trave, to England in steerage.  

Elisa was deemed "unusually well developed."  New York Journal & Advertiser, June 27, 1897 (copyright expired)

Once in London Elise was left on her own, with no money.  Luckily she had the presence of mind to go to Low's Exchange and inquire about Jessie Lindsay, a friend of her grandmother's whose husband's business was in London.  On April 25 Elizabeth received a letter from Mrs. Lindsay notifying her that she had Elise, who "was poorly clad and had no money."

Jessie Lindsay embarked on a previously unexpected voyage to America with Elise in tow.  On June 27, 1897 the New York Journal and Advertiser reported "Yesterday Elise arrived here on the American liner Paris in the care of Mrs. Lindsay...and was taken to her grandmother's house."  When Elizabeth asked her who had induced her to leave, the girl replied "Well, you've got me back; isn't that enough?"  The newspaper said she "obstinately refused to tell her grandmother...who had given her the money to purchase a ticket to Europe."

Three decades earlier, on the night of November 10, 1865, a group of dockworkers had formed a club in the back room of George Topf's saloon at Hudson and West 10th Streets.  Calling itself the Topf Club, its motto was "Bend, but Never Break."  Over the years the name became corrupted to the Tough Club.

Eliza T. Bailey died in 1907, leaving No. 243 to her nephew, Charles Bailey.   In December 1910 he sold the house to the Tough Club which announced "the building will be remodeled into an up-to-date club house."

The Tough Club had never been political.  A few years later, in 1915, an original member, Simpson Sharp, told a reporter "We organized for purely social purposes, and it was the pride of our members to keep the club sturdy and clean in word and deed."  

The club had festive traditions.  On Washington's Birthday the members enjoyed a dinner, preceded the night before by a ball, and another on Thanksgiving Day.  A summer "chowder" was held each year at College Point, in Queens.  And once a month between October and April a dinner was held, featuring the club's renowned clam chowder, the recipe of which was safely guarded.

The men supported the families in the gritty neighborhood near the docks.  The club paid $250 to the families of each deceased member within 48 hours of his death.  Additionally, it maintained a large plot in a Cedar Grove cemetery for members whose families could not pay for graves.

But the most notable event was the annual children's Christmas party.  The Sun said "Jew and gentile boy and girl gather for the big Christmas function held each year--to eat ice cream and cake in the clubrooms and drink all the lemonade in the world and receive from Jimmie Dunnell as they pass out of the door a big box that holds a doll which is as pink and white as a live English girl; or, if you're a boy, a football or a ketchin' glove."

Although the Tough Club had no intention of discontinuing the half-century old tradition, its pending move to 14th Street was devastating to the Greenwich Village children.  On December 19, 1910 The Sun reported that "woe spread through the district yesterday when somebody came out of the Tough Club's basement...and started the story that the Tough Club has bought a house away up town at 243 West Fourteenth street, scarcely in the Village at all, and is going to remodel the house and live there henceforth."

The move, said the article, would come just before Christmas.  "It was a blow to the little boys and girls who had counted on the pink and white dolls and the reg'lar league baseballs."  Spirits were restored, however, when Jimmie Dunnell promised that that year's party would still be held in the old clubhouse.

The renovations of the building did not come until May 1912.  The Tough Club hired architect William S. Boyd to make $8,000 (about $218,000 today) in extensive alterations.  The Sun reported on May 14 that "The entire interior is to undergo changes."  It was most likely at this time that the center openings of the upper floors were shortened and a stucco-type material applied over the brick.

By the club's 50th anniversary in November 1915 its 350 members--originally longshoremen--were from all walks of Greenwich Village life.  But its traditions were still revered.  On November 11, 1915 The New York Times noted, "One of the occasions on which there is sure to be a large gathering of the club is on the second Saturday of every month, when the huge chowder pot in the basement is filled with such delicacies, including two bottles of choice wine, as go into the making of a Tough Club clam chowder."  Ninety gallons were produced each month so that members with could take a pailful to their families at home.

Rather amazingly, as West 14th Street continued to change, the Tough Club held on.  New York Magazine journalist Bob Drury wrote in its May 10, 1993 issue, "To walk into the Tough Club, one of the oldest nonprofit private clubs in the city, is to revisit a time when the gears of New York were oiled by whiskey...A visitor half expects to spot former members Fiorello La Guardia, Gene Tunney, and Jimmy Walker--the first perusing the funnies, the second shadowboxing, and the last with a flapper on each arm, knocking back a dram of Irish whiskey."  

Drury reminisced on the varied backgrounds of the club's members over the decades--"captains of industry, professional athletes, labor leaders, journalists and countless civil servants."  But at the time of his article, things were looking bleak for the venerable club.  Membership had dwindled from 860 in 1958 to 17.

Bartender and member Frank Scavone (front) and some of the aging members in the barroom.  New York Magazine, May 10, 1993

In 1998 the upper floors were converted to three apartments.  Shortly afterward the end of the line came for the Tough Club, which had been relegated to the former storefront space.  On August 25, 2002 The New York Times reported that Erica Miller and Nathan Foreman were transforming the old club space "into a contemporary American restaurant called Kloe."

The pair removed the old woodwork.  On one section a poem was painted in gold Old English lettering on dark red mahogany:

Never are ill spent the hours
Laid out in harmless merriment
With mirth and laughter
Let old wrinkles come

Eight decades of Tough Club members had read those words over their glasses of whiskey.


Today a Cajun restaurant, Hot n' Juicy Crawfish, operates from the old storefront.  The Tough Club is mostly forgotten, but the Latimer Bailey house still maintains much of its domestic appearance from a more elegant West 14th Street of nearly 170 years ago.

photographs by the author

Tuesday, January 12, 2021

The 1896 Theodore K. Pembrook House - 31 West 69th Street

 


Henry F. Cook acted as developer, architect and contractor in constructing speculative houses in the late 19th century.  In 1895 he embarked on an ambitious project of eight rowhouses on the north side of West 69th Street between Central Park West and Columbus Avenue.

Cook designed his row in the Renaissance Revival style, arranging the dwellings in an off balance A-B-B-C-C-D-E-F configuration.  The mirror-image "C" houses, Nos. 31 and 33, were "of Long Meadow stone and coral brick," as described by The Record & Guide.  Side-by-side dog-legged stoops rose to the balcony-topped entrances.  Rounded bays rose from the basement level through the second floor, terminating in balustraded balconies.  Grouped windows at the top floor sat atop an intermediate cornice, their interior piers decorated with Renaissance-inspired carvings.

On January 2, 1896 The Real Estate Record & Guide reported that No. 31, "one of the handsome row recently completed by Henry F. Cook," had been sold to Theodore K. Pembrook for about $75,000.  (The price would translate to about $2.3 million today.)

Pembrook was a partner in the wholesale dry goods firm of Sweetser, Pembrook  & Co.  He was also a director in the New York Casualty Co. and the Traders' Fire Insurance Co.  Sweetser, Pembrook & Co. was organized in 1868 and by now was described by King's Handbook of New York as "among the most prominent of the dry-goods firms of America."

Pembrook's social status was reflected in his several club members, including the Colonial, the New York Athletic Club, and the Merchant's and the Manhattan Clubs.  He and his wife, the former Bertha Patience Woodruff, had two daughters, Bertha Woodruff and Sara Isabelle.


Mirror images, Nos. 31 and 33 shared a balcony created by the creative hoods above the entrances (now windows).  

The Pembrooks enjoyed an extended stay in Lakewood, New Jersey for the 1897 Thanksgiving holiday.  On November 28 the New-York Daily Tribune noted "Theodore K. Pembrook and William B. Dowd, of New-York, are out for quail these days, with good results.  Their record for four days is eighty-six birds, and on Tuesday they brought in thirty-four quail and two woodcock."  In a separate article the newspaper reported "Mrs. William A. Pembrook is visiting her son, Theodore K. Pembrook, a New-Yorker, who is here for a long stay."

Interestingly, in addition to being a businessman and huntsman, Pembrook had an artistic side.  He had an art studio on West 68th Street and owned the Lyceum Theatre in Elizabeth, New Jersey.  

But things were about to fall apart for the Pembrooks.  On April 10, 1900 The New York Times reported on a judgment against "Theodore K. Pembrook, the artist," for $6,344 (nearly $200,000 today).  In his hearing, Pembrook has said "that there was another judgment against him held by his father's estate for about $8,000."    He claimed he owned no real estate, saying he "did own the property at 31 West Sixty-ninth Street, but it had been foreclosed and sold."  (That was not exactly true.)

In November Pembrook sold the Lyceum Theatre.  He had already transferred his interest in Sweetser, Pembrook & Co. to his mother.  The Pembrooks managed to stay on in No. 31 until August 1903 when Theodore leased the house which he had earlier insisted was not his to Frederick M. Strauss and his wife Julie.  Two years later, on October 5, 1905, Pembrook sold the 22-foot wide house to his tenants.  

Strauss was a member of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.  The couple's son, Walter C., was a freshman at Harvard, and son John Francis was an attorney in the law firm of Strauss & Hedges.  More notably, he was a recognized photographer.

Known sometimes simply as J. F. Strauss, he was a co-founder with Alfred Stieglitz in 1902 of the Photo-Secession.  He worked as an associate editor for Camera Work, a quarterly founded by Stieglitz.  The magazine featured a photogravure by Strauss, The Bridge, a haunting shot of the Brooklyn Bridge at night.

J. F. Strauss's The Bridge was taken in 1903.  from the collection of the Minneapolis Institute of Art

While living in the 69th Street house J. F. Strauss exhibited his works at impressive venues like the Corcoran Gallery of Art in Washington, the Carnegie Institute in Pittsburgh and the National Arts Club in New York.

Around 1911 the Strausses shared the house with Ernest A. Cardozo.  A widow, the well-to-do attorney had graduated from Columbia University in 1899 and was a member of the Sons of the American Revolution.  He was financially comfortable enough to own a Pierce Arrow automobile.

It appears that John Francis left the family home in 1913.  On December 7, 1912 The Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported that he had purchased Larchmont Manor, the former George Croker estate in Larchmont, New York.  The price he paid would equal just over $2 million today.

Ernest Cardozo was still living with the family in June 1919 when he married Mary Ellen Katon of Cincinnati.  In reporting on the wedding The New York Times mentioned that he also owned a summer home at Allenhurst, New Jersey.

The split, shared stoop was intact when this photo was taken around 1941.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

The Strauss family left the 69th Street house shortly after that.  In 1938 it was being operated as "furnished rooms," and in 1947 a renovation converted it to two apartments per floor.  Sadly, the stoop--so integral to Henry F. Cook's design--was removed, the entrance converted to a window, and a new, unattractive doorway installed in the former basement level.

Among the first residents was opera singer Dino Yannopoulos.  He was no doubt thrilled to receive a letter from the Metropolitan Opera Association dated March 2, 1949 which said in part, "It is the intention of the management to offer you a contract for the season 1949-50."

Other than replacement windows, the tragic loss of the stoop, and an air conditioner projecting through a hole gouged in the brickwork of the top floor, Henry F. Cook's handsome design is essentially intact.

photographs by the author

Monday, January 11, 2021

The Lost Henry Delafield House -- 77th Street and Avenue A


 

from Valentine's Manual of the City of New York, 1862 


In 1677 the Governor of the Province of New York, Sir Edmond Andros, granted 46 acres of land far north of the city to Abraham Shotwell.  Known as the Saw Kill Farm it spread from approximately what is 76th Street today to 81st Street, and from west of First Avenue at its westernmost point to the East River.

In 1684 the farm was acquired by William Cox, whose widow, Sarah, married Captain William Kidd.  According to The New York Times centuries later in 1921, "Her brother, Samuel Bradley, Jr., joined Captain Kidd in his voyage of adventure in 1695, which terminated in their being hanged as pirates."  Before the two left New York, Captain Kidd and Bradley transferred their share of the farm to Sarah's father, Captain Samuel Bradley, Sr.

By the mid-18th century the "farm" had was one of several elegant summer estates that dotted the district.  Its location near the river provided respite from the insufferable heat and odors of the city.  At some point in the 18th century a handsome two-story and attic Georgian style home was erected which would have been the scene of dances, dinners and teas for neighbors like the Gracie, Schermerhorn, Winthrop, King, and Wilkes families.

The irregular borders of the estate were possibly dictated by the topography centuries before the area would be graded.  from An Introduction to The History of Dentistry in America, Volume II, 1948


It may have been Mary Ellis (who changed the name of the property to Sans Souci) who erected the house.  After she sold it to Dr. John Baker in 1790 for 3,600 pounds, he renamed it Baker's Retreat.

Baker was nearly-arrived in Manhattan, having established a sterling reputation as a dentist in Philadelphia.  He was about 60 years old at the time and it appears that he relocated to retire, as no advertisements for his services appear in New York papers.  

Five years later, on September 20, 1796, apparently aware that death was looming, he made out his will.  He died four days later.  He left his extensive properties, including Baker's Retreat, the house downtown, and real estate in "Great Britain, the Island of Jamaica, the State of Virginia, the State of Pennsylvania...or elsewhere" to his wife, Mary."   Perhaps concerned that the weight of managing such a vast estate would be too much, he instructed that she "advise in all difficulty with my friends," John Delafield, Thomas Jones, and John Bannister.

Four of the Baker servants were slaves.  But it appears that Baker treated them as indentured servants rather than property.  Dr. Bernhard Wolf Weinberger, in his An Introduction to the History of Dentistry in America, wrote:

In the will of September 20, he expressed a desire that his wife retain all of his negro servants, but "in any case they were not to be sold as slaves."  If certain of them were still on the farm after the death of his wife, Mary, "James was to receive a dollar per week, and Dinah one-half dollar per week during their natural lives."

He further instructed that $400 be put aside following Mary's death "that my four negro servants, James and Dinah and John and Mary and their children shall have a living support and maintenance off and from my said farm during their respective lives."

John Delafield, with whom Baker posthumously instructed his wife to consult, was a close friend.  His country estate, Sunswick, was located across the river, within sight of the Baker estate.  In his 1907 Historic Homes and Institutions, historian William S. Pelletreau explained "As countrymen by birth, the family of Dr. Baker and that of John Delafield became intimate.  Dr. Baker appointed Mr. Delafield the executor of his will, and dying childless, bequeathed, subject to the life of his wife, who died in 1831, his country place, first to Henry Delafield."


The John Delafield summer estate, Sunswick, was directly across the East River from Baker's Retreat.  Historic Homes and Institutions, 1907 (copyright expired)

Henry and William Delafield were twins, burn at Sunswick on July 19, 1792.  The two, according to Pelletreau, "resembled each other so closely that only intimate friends could distinguish one from the other."  They were partners in the shipping firm of Henry & William Delafield--their merchant ships sailing to England, China, South America and the West Indies.

A bachelor, Henry at first considered simply leasing the property.  On February 26, 1831 an advertisement in The Evening Post read:

To Let or Lease--The Country Seat and Farm of the subscriber on the East River, five miles from the city.  The House is large and commodious, and is well calculated for a large family, boarding house, or school.  The Farm consists of 45 acres tillable land, and has coach house, stable, barn and other out houses.  The whole will be put in good repair and possession given immediately.  The House and Farm will be let separately or together.  For terms apply to
                                    Henry Delafield, No. 88 Front st.

He changed his mind at some point and spent considerable time in the summer months here.   He renamed the estate Hurlgate, the name originally applied to the East River.  It was a corruption of the Dutch Helle Gadt.   

A hint of the beautiful gardens that surrounded the house can be gleaned from a report on the exhibits at the Fair of the American Institute which opened on October 18, 1845.  Among the listing in The Brooklyn Evening Star were "two baskets of Dahlias; two bouquets of Roses" grown by William Armstrong, "gardener to Henry Delafield, Hurlgate."

Within a decade of the exhibition the city was creeping nearer and nearer to Henry's estate.  On October 9, 1854 he appeared before the Common Council proceedings to petition "against opening and paving Seventy-eighth-street," as reported in The New York Times.

The Delafield brothers.  Henry is at the far right.  Historic Homes and Institutions, 1907 (copyright expired)

No doubt to the surprise of everyone, the 73-year old bachelor married on February 9, 1865.  The wedding took place in the house of his brother, Joseph, at No. 475 Fifth Avenue.  His bride was Mary Parish Monson, the daughter of Judge Levinus Monson.  She was 27-years old.

The days of summering at Hurlgate had passed by now.  The newlyweds went to Saratoga that summer season.  Henry had earlier leased the estate to the New York Protestant Episcopal Public School at an annual rent of $1,500 (a significant $50,700 per year today).

The townhouse of Henry and Mary Delafield was at No. 269 Fifth Avenue.  It was there that a baby girl, Mary Frances Henrietta, was born on June 9, 1869.  Her mother died a year later in the mansion, on May 16, 1870 at the age of 32.

Of the seven children of John Delafield, only three were still alive in 1875.  Then, remarkably, Edward died on February 13, Joseph on the 14th, and Henry Delafield died on February 15.  The three brothers were interred in the family vault in a single ceremony on February 16.

Henry's will bequeathed Hurlgate to the Trinity Church School.  It was shortly divided into building plots, the mansion demolished, and the property sold off.

Saturday, January 9, 2021

The 1856 James and Euphemia Russell House - 208 West 11th Street

 

The floor-to-ceiling parlor windows may well have originally been fronted by a cast iron balcony.

Builder and contractor Elisha Bloomer erected significant structures like the University of the City of New York building on Washington Square.   In 1856 he completed a row of four Italianate homes on Hammond Street, between Seventh Avenue and Waverly Place.   The brownstone fronted residences were 18-feet wide and rose three stories above English basements.  Molded lintels and sills sitting upon minute brackets enhanced the openings.  A single bracketed cornice unified the row.

No. 5 Hammond (renumbered 208 West 11th Street around 1865) was originally shared by two residents and, most likely, their families.  Elisha Bloomer was an accountant on Murray Street before going into the jewelry business in 1860.  Walter D. Stewart ran a shoe and boot business at No. 14 Warren Street.

In 1864 the house became home to James and Euphemia Russell.  Russell operated a brewery on Greenwich Avenue.  He seems to have surreptitiously branched into the liquor trade in 1868.  The New York Evening Express reported on June 3 that a "condemnation" had been filed after "Eighteen barrels of distilled spirits [were] found at 208 West Eleventh street."

The couple suffered tragedy on June 15, 1870 when their three month old daughter, Elizabeth, died.  The door of No. 208 was hung with black crepe and the infant's funeral was held in the parlor the following afternoon.

Around 1876 the Russells moved to Westchester County, but retained possession of No. 208 which was now operated as a boarding house.  On June 4 that year an advertisement offered "A pleasant front room, hot and cold water, gas and bath, elegantly furnished; house and neighborhood first class; rent $6 per week."  The weekly rent would be equal to around $148 today.

Over the next decade respectable boarders like Frank B. West, who worked as a clerk in a downtown office, came and went.  In 1882 two musicians, brothers Carl and Edward Hermann, gave lessons from their rooms.

Edward Hermann was a violinist and Carl a pianist.  Carl was his brother's accompanist during concerts.  Such was the case on January 22, 1883 when Edward gave a concert in Steinway Hall.  It was received by a cringe-worthy review.

The critic of Music and Drama said the audience who heard Edward play Beethoven's Violin Concerto "are deserving of special sympathy, as a more deplorable performance can hardly be conceived.  Mr. Hermann has no tone, cannot play in tune, and lacks the slightest trace of anything like intelligence."  As if that were not scathing enough, the critic continued "As for breadth of style, sentiment, or perception of the composer's meaning, they were all qualities conspicuous by their absence, in his puerile attempt to struggle through this noble work.  His other efforts were equally bad."  It noted briefly "Mr. Carl Hermann contributed some specimens of pianism."

Mrs. Harriet Goble ran the boarding house in the 1890's.  Among her most notable boarders was Robert Mayhew, described by The New York Times as the 8th Ward's "most celebrated resident."  The old man had been a familiar character in Greenwich Village for more than 25 years.  The New York Times said "Year after year he wore the same gray linen duster and the same straw hat, Winter and Summer alike.  He invariably carried a cane, and his long red nose was as much a source of interest and attraction to the children as was the pocketful of candy and oranges with which he was always supplied."

Mayhew never worked, instead relying on a clever scheme.  Knowing that obstructing the sidewalk with merchandise or unlicensed stands was illegal, he would confront shop owners and threaten to call an officer.  But then he would offer to "fix the matter up with the authorities" for a fee.  Most often the merchant agreed and "Mayhew thus lived easily and comfortably," according to the newspaper.

Robert Mayhew enjoyed the reputation of being the greatest liar in the neighborhood.  His various stories included having two sisters who were so tall no one would marry them, and having an aunt in England who was 108 years old.  He also claimed to be the son of Admiral Bruce of the English navy and a lineal descendant of Robert the Bruce, King of Scotland.  According to his story he was born Robert Mayhew Barrymore Bruce on August 19, 1800.  At the age of 9 he "gave great offense to his father and was beaten by him."  His father "discarded and disowned him" and forbade him from using the family name.

In November 1891 Mayhew caught a cold.  His sickness worsened and he was taken to St. Luke's Hospital where he died on January 5.  Amazingly, documents found in his room in the West 11th Street house supported his unbelievable story about his life, including papers drawn up in preparation for a suit in the English Courts to recover property inherited by the other children of his father.

Harriet Goble took in a new boarder in July 1896.  Margaret J. Seiley was 50 years old and the widow of a former officer in the English army.   She received his pension of $75 per month, or about $2,360 today.

Interestingly, Seily was the name of her first husband who, according to a friend, "ran off with another woman two years ago."  She then married Major Fitzjohn, who died not long afterward.  The Sun opined "She apparently assumed her first husband's name because she was still fond of him."  The two kept up a regular correspondence.  

Four months after Margaret moved in, on November 11, Harriet discovered her dead in her room, having committed suicide by inhaling lighting gas.  The Utica Semi-Weekly Herald reported "There were two motives for her act.  One was that she was approaching total blindness and the other was her separation from her two sons, who recently went abroad to accept positions offered them in Russia."  The Sun assumed that she would leave her property to "her sister, a Mrs. Gilmore, who lives in this city, it is supposed."

But she did not.  On November 13 The New York Times ran an article entitled "Suicide Slights Relative" which reported that Margaret had left her entire estate to a 45 year old clerk who worked in the office of her attorney.  It was unclear how large her estate would be, however bank books showed that she had at least nearly a quarter of a million dollars, in today's money.

In 1909 the estate of James Russell sold No. 208.  It was still home to respectable boarders like the Rev. John C. Newman.  But by the World War I years, a few less upstanding residents lived here.  Among them was John Collins who was arrested for violating the New New York State "Loafer Law" in July 1918.

The law demanded that every "able-bodied male between the ages of eighteen and fifty years" who was not serving in the military be engaged in some sort of "lawful, useful and recognized" occupation until the end of the war.  On July 11 The Sun reported "the first three men sentence to jail as loafers under the new State law which requires folk who will not fight to work were arraigned yesterday."  Among them was John Collins.  The 35-year old was sentenced to three months in the workhouse.

The life of another tenant, Martin Seller, came to an abrupt end on March 13, 1919.  The New-York Tribune reported he was "found dead in a hallway of a negro tenement at 246 West Sixty-second Street."  The responding ambulance surgeon "said death was due to strangulation."  The article noted "In the same block two negro murders occurred within two weeks."

The following year No. 208 was sold.  During the Depression years it was home to several Italian-American families.  In 1936 the Federal Government's Special Committee on Un-American Activities listed tenants Amaryllis Nicol, Ernestine Cocito and Michael Maccario as "workers for the Communist Party ticket."

By 1941 the house had lost its Victorian detailing.  via the NYC Dept of Records & Information Services

At some point the stoop was removed and the entrance moved to the former basement level.  In an effort to give the building a more modern appeal, the molded lintels of the windows and former doorway were shaved flat.


A renovation completed in 2002 resulted in two duplex apartments and brought back the mid-19th century appearance.  The stoop was refabricated and the lost architectural elements were replaced with applaudable approximations of the originals.

photographs by the author

Friday, January 8, 2021

The Adolph and Lillian Pavenstadt House - 10 East 64th Street


An idea of the original appearance of No. 10 can be gotten from the glimpse of No. 12, to the left.

In 1878 the architectural firm of D. & J. Jardine designed a row of four high-stooped houses on East 64th Street, just east of Central Park, for Edward Kilpatrick.   The neo-Grec design of the 20-foot wide homes was the latest in domestic fashion.

No. 10 was purchased by Isaac Meinhard and his wife, the former Amelia Rosenheim.  Meinhard was born in Burghashlach, Germany in 1836 and immigrated to Savannah, Georgia with his family in 1860.  He and his brother Henry opened a wholesale dry goods firm, Meinhard Brothers & Co., there.  Following the end of the Civil War he brought his family to New York.

Isaac and Amelia had four children: Henry, Alice, Minnie and Leo.  The family's name only occasionally appeared in society columns, mostly in reference to their trips abroad.  Significant exceptions were the marriages of their daughters, Alice in 1886 and Minnie in 1894.  Both were married in upscale ceremonies at Delmonico's.  As had been the case with her sister's wedding, following Minnie's "a reception dinner and ball followed," as reported by the New-York Daily Tribune.

In June 1898 Meinhard sold the house to William P. and Adelaide C. Hardenbergh.  The Sun reported the price paid was "about $40,000," or just over $1.25 million today.

Hardenbergh was a vice-president of the New Jersey Zinc Company.  He and Adelaide had two children, William, Jr., and Sara.  Their country home was in Bernardsville, New Jersey.

It was there, in St. Bernard's Church, that Sara was married to Hugh J. Chishold, Jr. on June 25, 1910.  The Sun romantically reported, "It was at a country wedding that Mr. and Mrs. Hugh J. Chisholm Jr. were married."  The reception was held in the Hardenbergh house.  The Sun noted that William "has just bought the Marion Story place at Westchester," as well.

Adelaide appeared in society pages as she hosted receptions and other entertainments.  An example was on December 8, 1920, when, as reported by The New York Times, she "entertained with a dinner and dancing at her residence."

By the time of that event the brownstone house was more than three decades old and decidedly out of architectural fashion.  But that would change when the Hardenberghs sold it to newlyweds Adolph and Lillian M. Pavenstadt in July 1922.  The following month the Real Estate Record & Builders' Guide reported that the Pavenstadts had hired architect Donn Barber to make $35,000 worth of alterations to the residence.  (The cost would translate to about $534,000 today.)

While renovations got underway the Pavenstadts went to Europe.  On November 5 the New York Herald reported "on their return [they] will occupy their new home at 10 East Sixty-fourth street."  

The house to which the couple returned looked nothing like the one they had purchased.  Barber had stripped off the brownstone front and stoop, pulled the façade to the property line, and produced a limestone-faced Adamesque style mansion unlike anything in the district.  A broad, grilled entrance sat within the rusticated base.  The two-story midsection was dominated by double-height, free-standing columns.  The grouped openings of the fourth floor sat below a triangular pediment which fronted the slate mansard level.



The Pavenstadts had been married in 1921, just months before buying No. 10.  The Washington D.C. newspaper The Evening Star noted, "Mrs. Pavenstedt is remembered in Washington as the Baroness von Sternberg, wife of the late former ambassador of Germany."  Her former husband, Baron Hermann Speck von Sternburg, died in 1908.  Born in America as Lillian Langham, Adolph was now her second German-born husband.  

An expatriate banker, Pevenstadt had been an advisor to Count Johann von Bernstorff during World War I.  Both drew governmental suspicion when Pavenstadt negotiated a deal between von Bernstorff and an infamous spy, Bolo Pacha.  $1,700,000 was passed to Pacha who was to use it bribe the French press to start a propaganda campaign.  Although Pavenstadt swore he did not know the intended use of the money, in January 1918 he was detained on Ellis Island for the duration of the war.  

The couple now immersed themselves in Manhattan society.  On February 21, 1927 The New York Sun reported, for instance, "Mr. and Mrs. Adolf J. Pavenstedt will give a dinner this evening at their home, 10 East Sixty-fourth street, and take their guests to the opera." 

Lillian's sister, Ivy, had married Count de Faramond de Lafajole of France in 1904.  The two couples traveled back and forth across the Atlantic for extended visits.  On November 23, 1934, for instance, The New York Sun, reported "The Countess de Faramond de Lafojole, from Paris, has joined Mrs. Adolph J. Pavenstedt at 10 East Sixty-fourth street."  And on October 17, 1936 the newspaper reported that the Pavenstedts had returned from Europe, adding that "Count and Countess de Framond de Lafajole and their youngest son, Vicomte Jack de Faramond de Lafajole, are due from France soon to join Mr. and Mrs. Pavenstedt."

Receptions and dinners slowed at No. 10 East 64th Street by the early 1940's.  A somewhat catty article in the Albany Times-Union on February 21, 1941 began, "Mrs. Henry S. Redmond and Mrs. Adolf Pavenstedt are two formerly prominent hostesses of whom one hears little these days."  The writer noted that "Both ladies still possess sizeable fortunes and dwell in the grand manner," but continued "Mrs. Pavenstedt has followed in Mrs. Redmond's footsteps--I suspect both ladies with years creeping upon them, have wearied of the very thing that once was the Alpha and Omega of their existence."

By 1947 the mansion was home to Arthur T. and Alice M. Ford.  It received a high-profile owner in 1992 when it was purchased by Ivana Trump, former wife of Donald Trump, for $2.5 million.  

She raised the ire of her neighbors in 1994 by installing gilded lamps on either side of the entrance and erecting a "large burgundy canopy," as described by The New York Times on March 27.  The commercial-looking canopy did not escape the notice of the Landmarks Preservation Commission, either, which slapped her with violations.

Art dealer and neighbor Pat Kery told Times reporter Marvine Howe, "what strikes me more than the canopy is all that gold glitter and red flocked wallpaper in the lobby, which really lights up the block."

Ivanna Trump's canopy and façade-mounted lighting fixtures quickly came down.  photograph by William E. Sauro/The New York Times.

The house was the venue of Ivana Trump's launch of her "Ivana Living Legend Wine Collection" on October 18, 2011.

Ivana Trump and her daughter, Ivanka, at the launch of the wine collection within the house.  Black Tie Magazine, October 22, 2011

As it did in 1922, Donn Barber's striking remake of the 1879 brownstone stands out along the upscale block, unlike anything in the neighborhood.



photographs by the author

Thursday, January 7, 2021

D. & J. Jardine's 1875 Cast Iron 678 Broadway


 

In 1836 attorney Samuel Alfred Foot began construction on his sumptuous 28-foot wide home at No. 678 Broadway.  The project consumed him and he wrote it "has occupied too many of my thoughts, and too large a portion of my time.  A wise man will never build a house."  When the residence was completed the following year, Foot and his family (he and his second wife, Jane Campbell, would have 14 children) filled it with furniture custom made by Duncan Phyfe.

The neighborhood was filled with similar homes of New York's wealthiest citizens at the time.  But by the years preceding the Civil War those homeowners had moved northward, fleeing the encroachment of commerce.  Their once-elegant homes were either converted for business purposes or razed.

The Foot house survived until 1874 when it was demolished by developer Thomas A. Davies.  He hired the architectural team of brothers David and John Jardine to design a modern loft and store building.  Five stories tall, it was completed the following year, an exuberant cast iron take on  Renaissance Revival.  Each of the floors above the storefront were treated essentially the same with garlands of flowers dripping from the piers that separated the deep-set windows.  Decorative shells sat atop each of the fifth floor openings, above which was the ornate cornice.


Among the earliest tenants was T. Hillyer & Co., woolens merchants.  Only two years after moving in the firm was the target of worried industry gossip.  On September 27, 1877 the New York Daily Herald reported "A rumor was current yesterday that the firm of J. Hillyer & Co., jobbers in fine woollens [sic] at No. 678 Broadway, had suspended.  Upon inquiry at their office it was stated that the firm was financially embarrassed, but they did not call it exactly a suspension."  Nevertheless, the admission of "financial embarrassment" signaled a serious problem, and, indeed, six months later on March 14, 1878 The New York Times reported on the firm's bankruptcy.

Much more successful was the book store of Charles T. Dillingham.  On May 16, 1877 The Buffalo Commercial said, "Mr. Dillingham is known as one of the most enterprising of the wholesale booksellers of New-York."  The store also sold framed artwork and heliotypes, an early form of photography.

The Evening Post, November 26, 1880 (copyright expired)

Rufus Waterhouse moved his men's furnishings business into three floors of the building in 1878, after having originally opened at No. 563 Broadway two years earlier.  In January 1882 Clothier and Furnisher announced "A number of improvements have been made at the saleroom, 678 Broadway, and the place now assumes a more cheerful appearance.  More display room has been added, thus enabling customers to view the handsome stock to aa better advantage."

In its April 1882 issue, the same periodical reported, "Rufus Waterhouse, importer and manufacturer of men's fine furnishing goods at 678 Broadway, is showing one of the most select stocks of novelties in gloves, hosiery, suspenders and and neckwear ever brought to this market."


Clothier & Furnisher, January 1882 (copyright expired)

In 1884 Waterhouse employed about 100 workers in his factory and salesroom.  That year New York's Leading Industries gave him a supreme compliment, saying "The manufacture of gents' furnishing goods is a business peculiarly adapted to persons of culture and elegant tastes."  It described the Rufus Waterhouse shops as "very spacious and convenient...admirably arranged and equipped with every facility and appliance for the prosecution of business."

In the meantime, Charles T. Dillingham continued to operate from the address.  Three days before Christmas in 1886 it touted its literary calendars for the coming year, including the Tennyson Calendar and the Dickens Calendar.  Of the latter it said, "Last year we made the finest and prettiest calendar ever made in America--so they say--with a bit from Dickens for every day in the year, besides the daily picture-panel.  This year we make it Entirely New, both pictures and bits."

In 1890 the ground floor and basement were home to the H. C. Kroh window shades store.  On the night of April 25 Patrolman Schneider was passing by and heard suspicious noises coming from the basement.  He rapped his nightstick on the pavement to summon help.  Officers Cooney, Wesell and Clune responded.

The New York Times reported "It was decided that the proper way to enter the building was through the coal hole.  Patrolman Schneider tried it and got as far as his shoulders.  They were too broad to let him pass and he was pulled out.  Patrolman Clune got as far through as the third button on his waistcoat and there he stuck.  Patrolman Wesell could only get down to the second button and Patrolman Cooney could not do as well as that."  

The article continued to say the "fat quartet" felt that dieting would take too long," and "finally a combination of the thinnest patrolman and a very large transom solved the difficulty, and an entrance to the building was effected.  In the basement was found a discharged clerk of Mr. Kroh's named Dinsmore.  He looked very sleepy, having had to wait a long time for the officers to come and arrest him, and as he seemed to have no business there he was taken to the station and locked up."

As had been the case with J. Hillyer & Co. years earlier, the shirt manufacturing firm of Stern & Co. was struggling financially in 1894.  Finally, on October 24 the firm declared bankruptcy.  The following day, as reported in The Sun, "Policemen Smith and Ryer pulled the body of L. S. Stern out of the Central park lake...Despondency over financial embarrassments is though to have led Mr. Stern to suicide."

Thomas E. Davies retained ownership of the property for more than two decades, selling it in December 1897 for $130,000--about $4.13 million in today's money.  Rufus Waterhouse was still in the building, now employing 25 men, 175 women and 50 females under 21-years-old who worked 54 hours per week.  The firm remained here at least through 1903.

Joining them in the building in the first years of the 20th century were wholesale milliners Coumbe & Kaiser; Julius Sauer, manufacturer of artificial flowers and other millinery trimmings; men's furnishers McIlwaine Knight & Co.; and men's hosiery and underwear firm Heilmann, Loth & Feist.

Mens Wear, November 22, 1905 (copyright expired)

Directly behind the building is a narrow passageway left over from the days when residents like Edward Foot had private stables in the rear of their homes.  It is still known as Shinbone Alley and was the scene of what The Sun said "is destined to go down in history as the battle royal of Shinbone alley."

The importing firm of Adolph Strauss & Co. was one the ground floor of No. 678 Broadway when on the night of June 15, 1917 it was targeted by two Brooklyn burglars.  The Sun said they "entered and looted" the Strauss & Co. store of "trinkets, cutlery and ladies' wear."  But the young men had been noticed by Father Philip McGrath who was standing outside his rectory on Lafayette Street.

He alerted a policeman familiar to him, Robert Murphy, and the two men followed the suspects.  When Murphy asked the pair what they were up to they suddenly they pounced upon the policeman and the priest.  The Sun reported that Joseph Donegan, the 23-year old who struck out at Father McGrath, was unaware that the priest had taught boxing to longshoremen and others at the Catholic Seamen's Mission for years.

A melee ensued with the thieves getting the worse of it, until they both pulled out weapons.  Donegan threatened Father McGrath with a hatchet and John Price pulled a sharp chisel on Officer Murphy.  That tactic did not go well for them, either.  The Sun reported that when backup arrived at the dark Shinbone Alley, "Father McGrath was in the vanguard with an ear in one hand and the weapon made famous by another father--the Father of His Country--in the other.  With the substitution of a chisel for a hatchet, Patrolman Murphy was similarly acquired."  

John Price accused McGrath of having planted the stolen goods on him.  At the station house an officer said "You had your nerve to pull that stuff about the priest framin' you wit' the beads," to which Price answered "Aw, how'd I know he was a priest?  He didn't hit like one!"

In 1927 the York Building Company, Inc. made renovations to the building, resulting in a store on the first floor and factory space above.  In the 1940's it was home to the General Refrigerators Corp. which got into serious trouble with the Government during World War II.  On February 14, 1945 the Daily News reported "General Refrigerators Corp., 678 Broadway, dealer in commercial and household refrigerators, has been suspended for six months, beginning today, for violation of limitation orders, the War Production Board said yesterday."

Herbst Brothers Seedsmen, Inc., seed merchants, had been located on Chambers Street for years before relocating into No. 678 in 1952.  In July 1959 the firm placed at ad in The Villager seeking:  "Women For Packing Seeds.  Seasonal work, $1 per hour.  Part time applicants considered."

The Noho neighborhood experienced a renaissance in the last quarter of the 20th century.  In the 1990's Gallery at 678 operated from the second floor space.  


Surviving elements of the 1875 storefront can still be seen today and the upper floors of D. & J. Jardine's handsome cast iron structure are beautifully intact.

photographs by the author